Tag Archives: Foreign Litigation

Jiangxi trade-policy compliance rules & overseas rights channel

  • From 1 July 2026, Jiangxi’s “Implementation Rules for Trade-Policy Compliance” (23 articles) took effect.
    自2026年7月1日起,《江西省贸易政策合规工作实施细则》(共23条)正式施行。
  • The rules are the first to bring FDI-related policies into the compliance-assessment scope (goods, services, IP and FDI fully covered).
    该细则首次将涉外商投资政策纳入合规评估范围(货物、服务、知识产权、外资政策全覆盖)。
  • County- and city-level governments are made responsible (“who makes, who assesses”) for compliance self-review.
    首次压实市县两级合规主体责任,确立”谁制定、谁评估”原则。
  • Compliance assessment becomes a mandatory pre-procedure; non-compliant policies must be revised before issuance.
    首次将合规评估设为政策出台刚性前置程序,不合规政策须修改后方可出台。
  • A new overseas trade-barrier reporting and rights-protection channel is established (report → provincial commerce dept → MOFCOM).
    新增境外贸易壁垒上报维权通道(企业上报 → 省商务厅 → 商务部开展磋商)。
  • FIEs gain institutionalised national treatment and non-discrimination in Jiangxi’s policy-making.
    外资企业在江西政策制定中获得制度化的国民待遇与非歧视保障。

Jiangxi trade-policy compliance rules & overseas rights channel | 江西贸易政策合规细则与海外维权通道

Overview

From 1 July 2026, Jiangxi Province’s Implementation Rules for Trade-Policy Compliance (贸易政策合规工作实施细则) entered into force (23 articles, revised from a 2015 trial version and adopted at the 129th provincial executive meeting). The rules align Jiangxi’s trade policies — including those touching foreign investment — with WTO rules and China’s accession commitments, and add an overseas trade-barrier reporting and rights-protection channel for enterprises.

This article highlights what the rules mean for foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) operating or investing in Jiangxi.

Informational guidance only; the exact procedures are set by the Jiangxi commerce authorities, so verify with the competent department before acting.

Key innovations

Three “firsts”

  1. Broader compliance scope. For the first time, FDI-related policies are formally included in compliance assessment, achieving full coverage of goods, services, IP and FDI policies.
  2. Local-government responsibility. For the first time, city- and county-level governments are made responsible for compliance self-review under the principle of “who makes the policy, who assesses it” (谁制定、谁评估).
  3. Mandatory pre-procedure. For the first time, compliance assessment is a mandatory pre-step for policy issuance; policies found inconsistent with national-treatment or non-discrimination rules must be revised, with the adjustment explained in the approval materials.

Three new mechanisms

  1. Overseas trade-barrier channel. A reporting route for overseas unfair trade/investment measures: enterprises report → provincial commerce department → escalated to MOFCOM for consultation.
  2. Support system. Regular professional training and third-party/ university technical support for compliance work.
  3. Accountability. Supervision and accountability for units that skip compliance assessment and cause negative impact.

Implications for FIEs

  • National treatment institutionalised. FDI policies undergo full compliance review, embedding national-treatment and non-discrimination principles; FIEs may participate equally in government procurement and equipment-upgrade programmes.
  • Predictable environment. By screening out non-compliant clauses at the source, the rules aim to stabilise long-term foreign-investment expectations in Jiangxi.
  • Overseas protection. Jiangxi-based FIEs (and their groups) gain an official channel to surface overseas trade/investment barriers for provincial and central follow-up.

What to do next

  • If operating in Jiangxi, review whether local support or procurement policies treat FIEs equally; raise concerns through the compliance framework if not.
  • For Jiangxi groups facing overseas trade/investment barriers, use the new reporting channel via the provincial commerce department.
  • Track Jiangxi’s published compliance notices and training; engage early when local policies affect your sector.
  • Coordinate with your provincial commerce department contact for escalation to MOFCOM where needed.
  • Keep internal records of any discriminatory clauses encountered, as evidence for compliance review or overseas-rights cases.

Sources

  • 江西省商务厅(官方门户)— https://swt.jiangxi.gov.cn
  • 中国新闻网 — 《江西省贸易政策合规工作实施细则》正式实施 保障外商投资(2026-07-02 报道)
  • 江西省人民政府 — 第129次省政府常务会议审议通过《实施细则》(2026年)

Related reading

  • see also: Foreign-related dispute resolution: litigation vs arbitration / 涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁
  • see also: Stabilizing Foreign Investment Action Plan: 15 measures at a glance / 利用外资固稳促优行动方案:15条举措总览

江西贸易政策合规细则与海外维权通道

概述

自 2026年7月1日起,江西省《贸易政策合规工作实施细则》(共23条,在2015年试行版基础上修订,经第129次省政府常务会议审议通过)正式施行。细则将江西贸易政策(含涉及外资者)全面对接 WTO 规则与入世承诺,并为企业在海外设立贸易壁垒上报维权通道。

本文说明该细则对在赣经营或投资的外资企业(FIE)的意义。

本文仅为信息性指引;具体程序由江西省商务主管部门规定,行动前请向主管机关核实。

关键创新

三个首次

  1. 合规范围拓宽。 首次将涉外商投资政策正式纳入合规评估,实现货物、服务、知识产权、外资政策全覆盖。
  2. 属地责任压实。 首次压实市县级政府合规主体责任,确立”谁制定、谁评估”原则。
  3. 前置程序刚性化。 首次将合规评估设为政策出台刚性前置程序;与国民待遇、非歧视规则不一致的政策须修改,并在报批材料中说明调整情况。

三项新机制

  1. 海外贸易壁垒通道。 对境外不公平贸易/投资措施建立上报路径:企业上报 → 省商务厅 → 报送商务部开展磋商。
  2. 保障体系。 常态化专业培训,引入高校、第三方机构技术支撑。
  3. 监督问责。 对未开展合规评估、造成负面影响的单位依规问责。

对外资企业的意义

  • 国民待遇制度化。 涉外资政策全流程合规审查,将国民待遇、非歧视原则制度化;外资企业可平等参与政府采购、设备更新等。
  • 可预期环境。 从源头剔除不合规条款,稳定在赣外资长期投资预期。
  • 海外维权。 在赣外资企业(及其集团)获得官方渠道,反映海外贸易/投资壁垒,由省里及中央跟进。

下一步建议

  • 在赣经营者:审视地方支持或采购政策是否平等对待外资企业;若否,经合规框架提出异议。
  • 在赣集团遇海外贸易/投资壁垒:经省商务厅新上报通道反映。
  • 关注江西发布的合规通知与培训,地方政策影响本行业时尽早参与。
  • 必要时通过省商务厅对口联系,升级至商务部。
  • 留存遇到的歧视性条款作为合规审查或海外维权证据。

来源

  • 江西省商务厅(官方门户)— https://swt.jiangxi.gov.cn
  • 中国新闻网 — 《江西省贸易政策合规工作实施细则》正式实施 保障外商投资(2026-07-02 报道)
  • 江西省人民政府 — 第129次省政府常务会议审议通过《实施细则》(2026年)

相关阅读

  • see also: 涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁 / Foreign-related dispute resolution: litigation vs arbitration
  • see also: 利用外资固稳促优行动方案:15条举措总览 / Stabilizing Foreign Investment Action Plan: 15 measures at a glance

Foreign-related Dispute Resolution: Litigation vs. Arbitration

  • China offers two main routes for foreign-related disputes—litigation in Chinese courts and arbitration—and the choice shapes where, in what language, and how a result is enforced across borders.
    涉外争议有两条主路径——中国法院诉讼与仲裁——这一选择决定审理地点、语言及裁决如何跨境承认与执行。
  • Foreign-related civil and commercial cases are generally heard at intermediate court level or above; the SPC’s International Commercial Court (CICC, est. 2018) hears first-instance international disputes with “one-instance finality” for selected cases.
    涉外民商事案件一般由中级及以上法院审理;最高人民法院国际商事法庭(CICC,2018年设立)对相关一审国际商事纠纷实行”一审终审”。
  • Enforcing a foreign court judgment in China is harder than an award—there is no NY Convention equivalent, and only 35 of 39 judicial-assistance treaty partners cover judgment recognition and enforcement.
    在中国执行外国法院判决难于执行仲裁裁决——无类似《纽约公约》机制,39个司法协助条约伙伴中仅35个含判决承认与执行条款。
  • For treaty-less judgments China has moved toward a flexible “presumed reciprocity” standard (Nanning Statement, Kolmar, UK cases), systematized by the SPC’s 2021 Minutes.
    对无条约判决,中国已转向更灵活的”推定互惠”标准(南宁声明、高尔集团案、英国判决案),并由最高法2021年会议纪要系统化为审查框架。
  • Arbitration is usually the foreign-friendly default: a valid clause ousts the courts, allows an English/neutral seat, and awards are enforceable under the NY Convention (China a member since 1987).
    仲裁通常是涉外友好默认——有效条款排除法院管辖、可用英文与中性仲裁地,裁决依《纽约公约》(中国1987年加入)跨境执行。
  • For enforcement in China, apply to the intermediate court at the debtor’s domicile or asset location; rely on the NY Convention for foreign-seated awards.
    在中国境内执行须向债务人住所地或财产所在地中级人民法院申请;外国裁决依托《纽约公约》。

Foreign-related Dispute Resolution: Litigation vs. Arbitration | 涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁

Overview

A foreign business operating or investing in China will, at some point, need to enforce a contract, recover a debt, or defend a claim. China offers two principal routes for foreign-related civil and commercial disputes: litigation in the Chinese courts and arbitration (domestic or international). The choice shapes everything that follows — where the hearing is held, what language is used, whether the outcome is confidential, and, crucially, how the result is recognized and enforced across borders. This article outlines China’s court system for foreign-related cases, the rise of specialized foreign-related tribunals and the International Commercial Court, and the rules for recognizing and enforcing foreign court judgments and arbitral awards in China.

China’s court system for foreign-related cases

China has a four-tier court structure: basic people’s courts, intermediate people’s courts, high people’s courts (provincial), and the Supreme People’s Court (SPC) at the apex. Foreign-related civil and commercial cases are generally heard at the intermediate court level or above; the SPC has issued guidance concentrating such cases in designated courts to build expertise. The SPC’s 2022 report to the NPC noted that first-instance foreign-related civil and commercial cases grew from 14,800 in 2013 to 27,300 in 2021, underscoring how central these disputes have become.

Procedure is governed by the Civil Procedure Law (CPL). Foreign parties enjoy equal procedural standing; they may appoint local or foreign lawyers (though only Chinese-licensed lawyers may appear as agents in Chinese courts), and courts in major hubs provide English and other multilingual services. The SPC has also launched an online filing platform for cross-border litigants and a unified foreign-law ascertainment platform, addressing two historic pain points — service abroad and proving foreign law.

Specialized foreign-related tribunals and the International Commercial Court

To raise the quality and international credibility of foreign-related adjudication, China has built a tier of specialized foreign-related tribunals (涉外法庭) within selected intermediate and primary courts — for example, in Shenzhen (Qianhai), Beijing, Shanghai, and other pilot zones. These courts concentrate complex cross-border commercial disputes, apply international treaties and trade-usage reasoning, and publish guiding cases.

At the national apex, the SPC established the International Commercial Court (CICC) in 2018. The CICC hears first-instance international commercial disputes directly, applies a “one-instance finality” model for selected cases, maintains a panel of international commercial expert mediators, and aims to align with internationally accepted commercial-judgment standards. For a foreign investor choosing litigation, designating a seat in a city with a strong foreign-related tribunal — and, where eligible, the CICC — materially improves predictability.

Recognition and enforcement of foreign court judgments

Enforcing a foreign court judgment in China is harder than enforcing an arbitral award, because there is no multilateral treaty equivalent to the New York Convention for judgments. The pathway is the CPL plus international bilateral judicial-assistance treaties. As of the SPC’s 2022 briefing, China had concluded judicial-assistance treaties with 39 countries, of which 35 contain provisions on recognition and enforcement of civil and commercial judgments. Within those treaty partners, a foreign judgment is recognized and enforced through the treaty mechanism.

For countries without a treaty, enforcement rests on reciprocity. China has moved from strict, case-by-case reciprocity toward a more flexible “presumed reciprocity” (推定互惠) standard — reflected in the 2017 Nanning Statement from the China-ASEAN Chief Justices’ Roundtable and the 2018 SPC–Singapore memorandum. Landmark cases include the Nanjing Intermediate Court’s recognition of a Singapore commercial judgment (the *Kolmar* case, the first PRC recognition under reciprocity) and, in 2022, a Shanghai maritime court’s recognition of an English commercial judgment on a legal-reciprocity basis. The SPC’s 2021 Minutes of the National Forum on Foreign-related Commercial and Maritime Trials systematized the review standard — scope of foreign judgments, reciprocity analysis, grounds for refusal, and punitive-damages handling — giving lower courts a uniform framework.

Arbitration as the foreign-friendly default

Because of the treaty gap for judgments, arbitration is usually the preferred dispute-resolution clause for foreign parties. A valid arbitration agreement ousts the courts (subject to the separability of the arbitration clause), proceedings can be conducted in English with a neutral seat, and — above all — the award is enforceable across borders under the New York Convention (China has been a member since 1987). For enforcement inside China, the CPL (Article 290, formerly 283) lets a foreign party apply to an intermediate court at the place of the awarded party’s domicile or property; Chinese courts recognize and enforce New York Convention awards except on narrow public-policy or due-process grounds. The SPC has also clarified that an award rendered in China with a foreign arbitral institution as the seat is treated as a Chinese foreign-related award and enforced accordingly. (See the CIETAC article for institutional detail.)

What to do next

  • Choose the forum deliberately — arbitration for cross-border enforceability; litigation where you need injunctive relief, evidence preservation, or a treaty-based judgment route.
  • Pick a strong seat — a city with a specialized foreign-related tribunal, or the SPC International Commercial Court where eligible.
  • Check treaty coverage before relying on a foreign court judgment; absent a treaty, plan for a reciprocity analysis and budget for a harder fight.
  • Put a clear arbitration clause (institution, seat, language, rules) in every cross-border contract — it is the single most important enforceability decision.
  • For enforcement in China, apply to the intermediate court at the debtor’s domicile or asset location; for awards, rely on the New York Convention.

Sources

Related reading

  • see also: CIETAC & international arbitration — the leading China-seated institution and NY Convention enforcement.
  • see also: Anti-monopoly & merger control filing — challenging or enforcing SAMR decisions.
  • see also: PIPL compliance for foreign companies — cross-border enforcement of data orders.

涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁

概述

在中国经营或投资的外国企业,终有一天需要履行合同、追收债务或应对索赔。中国为涉外民商事争议提供两条主要路径:在中国法院诉讼与仲裁(国内或国际)。这一选择决定了后续一切——审理地点、使用语言、结果是否保密,以及最关键的:裁决能否跨境承认与执行。本文概述中国涉外案件的法院体系、专门涉外审判庭与国际商事法庭的兴起,以及外国法院判决与仲裁裁决在中国的承认和执行规则。

中国涉外案件的法院体系

中国法院为四级结构:基层人民法院、中级人民法院、高级人民法院(省级),以及顶端的最高人民法院(SPC)。涉外民商事案件一般由中级人民法院及以上审理;最高人民法院通过指导意见将此类案件集中由指定法院管辖,以积累专业经验。最高人民法院 2022 年向全国人大常委会的报告指出,一审涉外民商事案件从 2013 年的 1.48 万件增至 2021 年的 2.73 万件,凸显此类争议的重要性。

程序受《民事诉讼法》规范。外国当事人享有平等诉讼地位;可委托本地或外国律师(但仅中国执业律师可在法庭代理),主要枢纽城市法院提供英文等多语言服务。最高人民法院还上线了跨境诉讼当事人网上立案平台与统一的域外法查明平台,直击两大历史痛点——境外送达与外国法证明。

专门涉外审判庭与国际商事法庭

为提升涉外审判质量与国际公信力,中国在部分中院、基层法院设立专门涉外审判庭(涉外法庭),例如深圳(前海)、北京、上海等地。这些法庭集中审理复杂跨境商事争议,适用国际条约与贸易惯例推理,并发布指导性案例。

在国家顶端,最高人民法院于 2018 年设立国际商事法庭(CICC)。CICC 直接审理一审国际商事纠纷,对相关案件实行”一审终审”,设有国际商事专家委员会调解机制,并力求与国际商事裁判标准接轨。对外国投资者而言,在选择诉讼时,将管辖地指定于拥有强涉外审判庭的城市——符合条件时指定 CICC——可显著提升可预见性。

外国法院判决的承认与执行

在中国执行外国法院判决,难于执行仲裁裁决,因为判决领域没有类似《纽约公约》的多边条约。路径是《民事诉讼法》加国际双边司法协助条约。据最高人民法院 2022 年通报,中国已与 39 个国家缔结司法协助条约,其中 35 个含有民商事判决承认与执行内容。在与这些条约伙伴之间,外国判决经条约机制获得承认与执行。

对无条约国家,执行依赖互惠原则。中国已从严格、逐案互惠转向更灵活的“推定互惠”标准——体现于 2017 年中国—东盟大法官论坛《南宁声明》与 2018 年最高人民法院—新加坡最高法院备忘录。标志性案件包括南京中院承认新加坡商事判决(高尔集团案,中国首例依互惠承认外国判决)以及 2022 年上海海事法院依法律互惠标准承认英国商事判决。最高人民法院 2021 年《全国法院涉外商事海事审判工作座谈会会议纪要》系统化了审查标准——外国判决范围、互惠认定、不予承认事由、惩罚性赔偿处理——为下级法院提供统一框架。

作为涉外友好默认的仲裁

鉴于判决的条约缺口,仲裁通常是外国当事人的优选争议条款。有效的仲裁协议排除法院管辖(仲裁条款独立性除外),程序可用英文、中性仲裁地,且最重要的是——裁决可依 《纽约公约》跨境执行(中国自 1987 年起为成员国)。在中国境内执行时,《民事诉讼法》第二百九十条(原第二百八十三条)允许外国当事人向被申请人住所地或财产所在地中院申请;中国法院仅在狭窄的公共政策或正当程序事由下拒绝承认执行纽约公约裁决。最高人民法院还明确:以外国仲裁机构为仲裁地、在中国境内作出的裁决,视为中国涉外裁决并依此执行。(机构细节见贸仲文章。)

下一步建议

  • 审慎选择 forum——注重跨境可执行性选仲裁;需要禁令、证据保全或依条约执行判决时选诉讼。
  • 选定强管辖地——拥有专门涉外审判庭的城市,或符合条件时的最高法院国际商事法庭。
  • 签约前核查条约覆盖:依赖外国法院判决前,先确认是否有条约;无条约则须准备互惠分析并预留更艰难的对抗预算。
  • 在每份跨境合同中写入清晰仲裁条款(机构、仲裁地、语言、规则)——这是影响可执行性的最关键单项决定。
  • 在中国境内执行时,向债务人住所地或财产所在地中院申请;裁决则依托《纽约公约》。

来源

相关阅读

  • 参见:贸仲与涉外仲裁 — 中国主要仲裁地机构与纽约公约执行。
  • 参见:反垄断与经营者集中申报 — 对 SAMR 决定的异议与执行。
  • 参见:外资企业的个人信息保护法合规 — 数据命令的跨境执行。

Litigating in Chinese Courts: A 2026 Practical Guide for Foreign Parties in Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Cases

  • Since the 2023 amendment to the Civil Procedure Law (in force 1 January 2024), Chinese courts may take jurisdiction over foreign-related disputes with “other proper connections” to China beyond the six traditional connecting factors, giving foreign parties a broader and more predictable door to Chinese litigation.
    自 2023 年《民事诉讼法》修改(2024 年 1 月 1 日施行)以来,除六类传统连接点外,中国法院对与我国存在”其他适当联系”的涉外纠纷也可行使管辖权,为外国当事人提供了更宽、更可预期的中国诉讼之门。
  • Service of process on a party without a domicile in China runs through judicial-assistance agreements, the Hague Service Convention, postal service, service on authorised agents and public notice; electronic service through the court’s online platform is now expressly available with consent.
    对在中国境内无住所当事人的送达,沿司法协助协定、海牙送达公约、邮寄送达、向授权代理人送达与公告送达等路径展开;经同意,还可通过法院在线平台进行电子送达。
  • The SPC’s Online Litigation Rules (Fa Shi [2021] No. 12) make online filing, evidence exchange, mediation, hearings and service legally valid, with an online-video witness mechanism allowing cross-border parties to authorise a lawyer without notarisation or consular authentication of the power of attorney.
    最高法《人民法院在线诉讼规则》(法释〔2021〕12 号)使在线立案、证据交换、调解、庭审与送达具有法律效力,其在线视频见证机制允许跨境当事人不经公证、认证、转递即可委托律师。
  • Foreign court judgments and arbitral awards may be submitted as documentary evidence without prior recognition, but facts found in them are not exemption-from-proof facts and must still be examined through cross-examination.
    外国法院判决与仲裁裁决可作为书证提交使用,无须先行承认,但其所认定事实不属于免证事实,仍须经质证并结合全案证据审查认定。
  • Concentration of foreign-related commercial jurisdiction is spreading: Fuzhou’s six districts will centralise first-instance foreign and Hong Kong/Macao/Taiwan commercial cases under RMB 40 million in Cangshan from 1 October 2026, following Wuxi, Shanghai and other cities with SPC-approved international commercial tribunals.
    涉外商事集中管辖正在铺开:继无锡、上海等城市设立经最高法批准的国际商事法庭后,福州六城区 4000 万元以下一审涉外涉港澳台商事案件自 2026 年 10 月 1 日起集中至仓山区法院。
  • For foreign parties, the practical 2026 guide is: determine jurisdiction early, plan service and evidence strategy around the online platform, use the apostille route for notarised documents from Hague members, and keep translation and authentication ready before filing.
    对外国当事人,2026 年实操指南是:尽早确定管辖、围绕在线平台规划送达与举证策略、海牙成员国公证文书走附加证明书通道、立案前备妥翻译与认证。

Litigating in Chinese Courts: A 2026 Practical Guide for Foreign Parties in Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Cases | 在中国法院诉讼:涉外民商事案件外国当事人的 2026 年实务指南

The framework after the 2023 Civil Procedure Law amendment

The fifth amendment to the Civil Procedure Law, adopted on 1 September 2023 and in force since 1 January 2024, was the first to systematically revise the special provisions on foreign-related civil procedure. For foreign parties, the headline change is jurisdiction: in addition to the six traditional connecting factors (place of contract conclusion, place of contract performance, location of the subject matter, location of seizable property, place of the tort, and domicile of the representative office), Article 276(2) now provides that Chinese courts may hear a foreign-related dispute if there are “other proper connections” with China. This is the statutory codification of the “proper connection” doctrine first applied by the SPC in the 2019 ZTE v. Conversant standard-essential-patent case. In practice it means that disputes which do not map onto the six factors — for example, standard-essential patent global licensing disputes or disputes where China is the main market — can still be heard in China. Foreign parties negotiating contracts with Chinese counterparties should assume that Chinese courts may assert jurisdiction more readily than before, and should draft jurisdiction clauses accordingly.

Service of process

Service on a party without a domicile in China follows a hierarchy set out in the Civil Procedure Law: judicial-assistance agreements between China and the foreign state; the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents (China is a member); postal service where the receiving state permits it; service through the litigant’s authorised agent; and, as a last resort, public notice (a three-month period, with notice published in newspapers distributed domestically and abroad). Two 2026-relevant points: first, electronic service is available — under the SPC’s Online Litigation Rules, with the consent of the addressee, courts may serve documents to an e-mail address, instant-messaging account or the litigation platform account; second, the SPC’s December 2025 batch of judicial interpretation amendments (published as Fa Shi [2026] No. 16 and related instruments, effective 15 August 2026) updated the provisions on service through judicial-assistance channels and translation requirements, aligning the wording with the 2023 Civil Procedure Law. For a foreign company served in China, the practical response is the same as for any defendant: verify the authenticity of the service, check deadlines (answer period for foreign parties is 30 days, extendable), and instruct counsel immediately.

Evidence from abroad

Foreign-origin evidence raises authentication questions. Documents created outside China that are used as evidence in Chinese civil proceedings generally require notarisation in the country of origin and consular legalisation by the Chinese embassy or consulate, unless the state is a party to the Hague Apostille Convention — for the states that have joined, an apostille certificate issued by the competent authority suffices and no consular legalisation is needed. Translations into Chinese must be provided. Two nuances are worth stating: first, a foreign court judgment or arbitral award may be submitted as documentary evidence without a prior recognition proceeding; second, facts confirmed by a foreign judgment or award are not “exemption-from-proof” facts under the Civil Procedure Law interpretation — the opposing party may challenge them and the court will examine them through cross-examination together with the rest of the evidence. This means a foreign judgment can be persuasive, but it does not automatically prove its underlying facts in Chinese proceedings.

Online litigation and the video-witness mechanism

The SPC’s Online Litigation Rules (Fa Shi [2021] No. 12, effective 1 August 2021) established that online filing, mediation, evidence exchange, hearings and service have the same legal effect as offline equivalents, subject to party consent. For cross-border parties, the most useful mechanism is online video witnessing: a party outside China authorising a Chinese lawyer may, instead of notarising and legalising the power of attorney, apply for an online video witness session in which the judge, the foreign party and the entrusted lawyer appear simultaneously; the power of attorney is signed under the judge’s video supervision and no notarisation, authentication or forwarding is required. After the video witness, the lawyer may proceed with online filing and fee payment. In practice, foreign parties should still check with the specific court whether the video-witness route is available for their case type, and should have the entity’s identity documents and signatory authority ready in advance.

Which court and which procedure

Since the 2022 jurisdiction provisions (Fa Shi [2022] No. 18), first-instance foreign-related civil and commercial cases are generally handled by grassroots courts, with intermediate courts hearing cases above value thresholds or of particular types. Centralisation is the other trend: SPC-approved international commercial tribunals operate in Wuxi, Suzhou, Chengdu and other cities, Shanghai and Beijing run international commercial courts, and on 20 August 2026 the Fujian Higher People’s Court announced that from 1 October 2026 first-instance foreign, Hong Kong/Macao/Taiwan-related commercial cases under RMB 40 million in Fuzhou’s six urban districts will be centralised in Cangshan District People’s Court. For a foreign party, the practical question is not “which court is generally competent” but “which court is designated for this case type and amount” — check the local higher court’s announcements, which are increasingly specific.

Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments and awards

Enforcement of a foreign judgment in China requires an application to the intermediate court, grounded in a judicial-assistance treaty or reciprocity, and recognition is granted only where the judgment is final, the rendering court had proper jurisdiction, no violation of China’s basic legal principles, sovereignty, security or public interest, and no conflict with an existing Chinese judgment or a previously recognised foreign judgment. Foreign arbitral awards are enforced under the New York Convention (China acceded in 1987), and the 2023 Civil Procedure Law amendment adopted the “seat of arbitration” standard for determining the nationality of foreign awards — an award made in the territory of a foreign state is a foreign award, to be enforced under the Convention. The practical message: enforcement is possible but procedurally exacting, and the strength of the underlying dispute-resolution clause (arbitration vs. litigation, seat, governing law) is decided at contract-drafting stage, not at enforcement stage.

Practical checklist for foreign parties in 2026

  1. Determine jurisdiction at the contract stage: specify the Chinese court or the arbitration institution, seat and governing law; be aware that “proper connection” gives Chinese courts broad jurisdiction where no clause exists.
  2. Before filing, plan service: if the defendant is abroad, estimate the route (treaty, Hague, postal, agent, public notice) and the time cost; consider electronic service with consent.
  3. Prepare evidence in advance: notarise and apostille (for Hague members) foreign documents, obtain certified Chinese translations, and do not rely on a foreign judgment as proof of facts without supporting evidence.
  4. Use the online platform: register for online filing, consider the video-witness mechanism for the power of attorney, and expect e-service once you consent.
  5. Check centralisation announcements: confirm the designated court for the case type and amount in the relevant province or city.
  6. For enforcement, confirm treaty or reciprocity grounds and the finality of the judgment before commencing the case in China.

Outlook

Chinese courts are consolidating their position as a serious forum for cross-border commercial disputes: broader jurisdiction, modernised service rules, online procedure and specialised tribunals. For foreign parties the practical implication is that careful drafting and early procedural planning now matter more than ever — the system is faster, more digital and more predictable than a decade ago, but it demands that foreign parties engage with its rules deliberately.

Sources


在中国法院诉讼:涉外民商事案件外国当事人的 2026 年实务指南

2023 年《民事诉讼法》修改后的框架

2023 年 9 月 1 日通过、2024 年 1 月 1 日起施行的《民事诉讼法》第五次修改,是首次系统完善第四编”涉外民事诉讼程序的特别规定”。对外国当事人,最醒目的变化是管辖:在六类传统连接点(合同签订地、合同履行地、诉讼标的物所在地、可供扣押财产所在地、侵权行为地、代表机构住所地)之外,第二百七十六条第二款规定,涉外民事纠纷与中华人民共和国存在”其他适当联系”的,可以由人民法院管辖。这是最高法 2019 年在”中兴诉康文森”标准必要专利案中确立的”适当联系”规则的法律化。实践中,无法对应六类连接点的纠纷——如标准必要专利全球许可纠纷或中国为主要市场的纠纷——仍可在华审理。与中国对手方缔约的外国当事人应意识到中国法院比以前更容易主张管辖,并相应起草管辖条款。

送达程序

对在中国境内无住所当事人的送达,依《民事诉讼法》确立的层级展开:中国与外国国家间的司法协助协定;海牙送达公约(中国为成员国);受送达国允许的邮寄送达;经授权代理人的送达;以及最后手段的公告送达(三个月期限,在国内外公开发行的报刊上刊登)。两点与 2026 年相关:其一,电子送达可用——依《人民法院在线诉讼规则》,经受送达人同意,法院可向电子邮箱、即时通讯账号或诉讼平台账号送达文书;其二,最高法 2025 年 12 月通过的一批司法解释修改(法释〔2026〕16 号及相关文件,2026 年 8 月 15 日施行)更新了司法协助送达与译文要求条款,与 2023 年《民事诉讼法》表述对齐。在华被送达的外国公司,实务应对与任何被告相同:核验送达真实性、核对期限(外国当事人答辩期为 30 日、可延长)、立即委托律师。

域外证据

域外形成证据存在认证问题。在中国民事诉讼中用作证据的中国境外形成文件,一般须在来源国公证,并经中国驻外使领馆领事认证;除非该国为海牙《取消外国公文书认证要求的公约》成员国——成员国主管机关签发的附加证明书(Apostille)即可,无须领事认证。须提供中文译文。两点值得强调:其一,外国法院判决或仲裁裁决可未经承认程序直接作为书证提交;其二,外国判决或裁决认定的事实不属于民事诉讼法司法解释所列”免证事实”——对方可提出异议,法院将组织质证并结合全案证据审查认定。这意味着外国判决有说服力,但并不能自动证明其认定的事实。

在线诉讼与视频见证机制

最高法《人民法院在线诉讼规则》(法释〔2021〕12 号,2021 年 8 月 1 日施行)规定,经当事人同意,在线立案、调解、证据交换、庭审与送达与线下具有同等法律效力。对跨境当事人,最有用的是在线视频见证:境外当事人委托中国律师时,可不必公证认证授权委托书,而是申请在线视频见证——法官、境外当事人与受委托律师三方同时在线,在法官视频见证下签署委托文件,无须再办理公证、认证、转递。视频见证后,律师可代为网上立案、网上交费。实践中,外国当事人仍应事先向具体法院确认视频见证通道是否适用其案件类型,并提前备好主体身份文件与签署权限证明。

管辖法院与程序

自 2022 年管辖规定(法释〔2022〕18 号)以来,一审涉外民商事案件一般由基层法院管辖,中级法院审理超标的额或特定类型案件。集中化是另一趋势:无锡、苏州、成都等城市设有经最高法批准的国际商事法庭,上海、北京设有国际商事法院;2026 年 8 月 20 日福建省高院公告,自 2026 年 10 月 1 日起福州六城区 4000 万元以下一审涉外涉港澳台商事案件集中至仓山区法院。对外国当事人,实际问题不是”哪个法院一般有管辖权”,而是”本案型与标的额指定哪个法院”——关注当地高院公告,这类公告日益具体。

外国判决与裁决的承认与执行

外国判决在华执行需向中级法院申请,依据司法协助条约或互惠,且仅在判决终局、作出法院有适当管辖、不违反中国法律基本原则与主权安全公共利益、不与既有中国判决或已承认外国判决冲突时准予承认。外国仲裁裁决依《纽约公约》(中国 1987 年加入)执行;2023 年《民事诉讼法》修改采纳”仲裁地”标准认定外国裁决国籍——在外国领域内作出的裁决为外国裁决,按公约执行。实务信息:执行可行但程序严格,底层争议解决条款(仲裁还是诉讼、仲裁地、准据法)在缔约阶段决定,而非执行阶段。

2026 年外国当事人实操清单

  1. 缔约阶段确定管辖:写明中国法院或仲裁机构、仲裁地、准据法;注意无条款时”适当联系”赋予中国法院宽泛管辖。
  2. 立案前规划送达:被告在境外的,估算路径(条约、海牙、邮寄、代理人、公告)与时间成本;考虑经同意电子送达。
  3. 提前备证:海牙成员国文件公证并办附加证明书,获取盖章中文译文;不依赖外国判决直接证明事实而无佐证。
  4. 善用在线平台:注册在线立案,考虑授权委托书视频见证通道,同意后接受电子送达。
  5. 核对集中化公告:确认所在省市的指定法院。
  6. 执行案件:立案前确认条约或互惠依据及判决终局性。

展望

中国法院正巩固其作为跨境商事争议严肃审判机构的地位:更宽的管辖、现代化的送达规则、在线程序与专门法庭。对外国当事人,实务含义是精心起草与早期程序规划比以往更重要——体系比十年前更快、更数字、更可预期,但它要求外国当事人刻意依其规则行事。

Sources

Fuzhou Centralises Foreign-Related Commercial Jurisdiction in Six Urban Districts: What It Means for Cross-Border Dispute Resolution in Fujian

  • On 20 August 2026 the Fujian Higher People’s Court announced that, with approval of the Supreme People’s Court, first-instance foreign-related, Hong Kong-, Macao- and Taiwan-related commercial cases from six urban districts of Fuzhou will be centrally handled by Cangshan District People’s Court from 1 October 2026.
    2026 年 8 月 20 日,福建省高级人民法院公告,经最高人民法院批准,自 2026 年 10 月 1 日起,福州六城区第一审涉外、涉港澳台商事案件由仓山区人民法院集中管辖。
  • The centralised jurisdiction covers cases with a claim amount below RMB 40 million in the first instance, previously within the jurisdiction of Cangshan and the courts of Gulou, Taijiang, Jin’an, Mawei and Changle districts.
    集中管辖覆盖标的额为人民币 4000 万元以下(不含本数)的第一审涉外、涉港澳台商事案件,含仓山区本辖区及原由鼓楼、台江、晋安、马尾、长乐五区法院管辖的案件。
  • The move is anchored in Article 4(1) of the SPC’s Provisions on Jurisdiction over Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Cases (Fa Shi [2022] No. 18), which allows higher courts, with SPC approval, to centralise such cases in designated lower courts.
    公告依据《最高人民法院关于涉外民商事案件管辖若干问题的规定》(法释〔2022〕18 号)第四条第一款作出,该条允许高级法院经最高法批准将此类案件集中到指定下级法院。
  • Cases already accepted but not yet concluded by the five district courts before 1 October 2026 will continue to be tried by the original courts; the new rule applies to filings on or after the effective date.
    2026 年 10 月 1 日前鼓楼、台江、晋安、马尾、长乐五区法院已受理尚未审结的案件,仍由原审理法院继续审理;新规则适用于生效之日起的新立案。
  • Centralisation is part of a national trend: Cangshan hosts the Maritime Silk Road Court, and Fuzhou is building a “Maritime Silk Road Legal Services District” that integrates an international arbitration centre, notary services and lawyer services under one roof.
    集中管辖是全国趋势的一部分:仓山区设有”海丝法庭”,福州正打造”海丝中央法务区”,把国际仲裁中心、公证中心与律师服务中心集于一处。
  • For foreign-invested companies litigating or contracting in Fujian, the practical effect is a more predictable forum: one court, one set of procedures and specialised judges for cross-border commercial disputes under RMB 40 million.
    对在闽经营或缔约的外资企业,实际效果是更可预期的管辖法院:4000 万元以下的跨境商事争议将由一家法院、一套程序、专业法官集中处理。

Fuzhou Centralises Foreign-Related Commercial Jurisdiction in Six Urban Districts: What It Means for Cross-Border Dispute Resolution in Fujian | 福州六城区涉外涉港澳台商事案件集中管辖:对福建跨境争议解决的意义

The announcement

On 20 August 2026 the Fujian Higher People’s Court published a public notice on centralised jurisdiction over first-instance foreign-related, Hong Kong-, Macao- and Taiwan-related commercial cases in six urban districts of Fuzhou. With the approval of the Supreme People’s Court, and with effect from 1 October 2026, Fuzhou’s Cangshan District People’s Court will centrally handle such cases within its own jurisdiction and those previously handled by the district courts of Gulou, Taijiang, Jin’an, Mawei and Changle, where the amount in dispute in the first instance is below RMB 40 million (not including RMB 40 million itself). Cases already accepted but not yet concluded by the five district courts before 1 October 2026 remain with the original courts. The notice states that any earlier rules inconsistent with it are superseded.

The legal basis

The announcement cites Article 4(1) of the Supreme People’s Court’s Provisions on Jurisdiction over Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Cases (Fa Shi [2022] No. 18), in force since 1 January 2023. That instrument reformed the old system under which first-instance foreign-related cases were concentrated in intermediate courts: it returned most first-instance foreign-related civil and commercial cases to grassroots courts, set standards based on case value and case type, and — relevant here — expressly permitted a higher people’s court, with SPC approval, to designate specific lower courts for centralised handling. Fuzhou’s Cangshan court is a designated court under exactly this authority. The legal effect is that parties no longer need to guess which of six urban-district courts will hear a cross-border commercial dispute; the forum is fixed by a single notice.

Why centralisation matters in practice

Centralised jurisdiction produces three practical benefits for foreign parties. First, predictability: a foreign investor or trading partner can determine the competent court in advance, which matters for drafting jurisdiction clauses and for estimating procedural timelines. Second, specialisation: concentrating cross-border commercial cases in one court builds judicial expertise in foreign contract law, letters of credit, guarantees, bills of lading, foreign-invested enterprise disputes and recognition and enforcement issues; consistent rulings reduce forum-shopping and legal risk. Third, procedural efficiency: one court applies one set of filing, service and evidence rules, reducing the risk of venue objections and transfers between district courts, which in cross-border cases are particularly costly in time. The RMB 40 million threshold also signals a division of labour: cases above the threshold continue to follow the standard jurisdiction rules, typically to the intermediate court.

The context: the Maritime Silk Road Legal Services District

The centralisation is not an isolated measure. Cangshan hosts the Maritime Silk Road Court (Haishi Fating), created by converting the Jinshan Tribunal into a specialised court for commercial, IP and property-related disputes in Cangshan. Fuzhou is simultaneously building the Fuzhou Section of the Maritime Silk Road Central Legal Services District, which relocated to a new site at the end of 2025 and integrates a lawyer services centre, an administrative reconsideration centre, a notary centre, an international arbitration centre and a “Maritime Silk Road Legal Services Development Centre” in a “front shop, back factory” model — unified intake at the front, professional service units at the back. The district brings together 633 law firms across 33 provincial regions online, with service coverage reaching 35 countries and regions. The district courts’ business is the judicial arm of this broader legal-services ecosystem: a company that contracts in Fuzhou can now litigate in Cangshan, arbitrate at the international arbitration centre and obtain notarisation and certification in the same legal-services cluster.

The national trend behind the local move

Fuzhou follows a pattern visible across China since the 2023 amendment to the Civil Procedure Law and the 2022 jurisdiction provisions: encouraging lower-court centralisation of foreign-related cases and the establishment of international commercial courts and tribunals in major cities. Wuxi, Shenzhen, Suzhou, Chengdu and other cities have set up international commercial tribunals approved by the SPC; Shanghai and Beijing have international commercial courts. The rationale is consistent: as cross-border dispute volumes rise, China’s courts are concentrating expertise, unifying procedure and signalling to foreign parties that Chinese courts are a professional, efficient forum for commercial disputes — a deliberate complement to the arbitration institutions that have long been the default for international parties.

Practical guidance for foreign companies

For a foreign-invested enterprise or trading counterparty with operations in Fujian, the practical checklist is: (1) review jurisdiction clauses in contracts governed by Chinese law to confirm whether Cangshan is the designated forum for disputes under RMB 40 million; (2) when drafting new contracts with Fujian counterparties, consider whether to elect Cangshan or the international arbitration centre in the legal services district; (3) for existing cases, confirm which court holds jurisdiction under the transitional rule — cases accepted before 1 October 2026 stay where they are; (4) use the legal services district for notarisation, authentication and translation services to keep evidence in order; and (5) monitor whether neighbouring regions adopt similar centralisation, which would further streamline cross-border dispute resolution in the province. The new regime does not change substantive law or the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments — it changes which Chinese court hears a first-instance cross-border commercial case, and that change is, for most parties, a welcome simplification.

Outlook

Centralised foreign-related jurisdiction in Fuzhou will take effect on 1 October 2026. In the medium term, expect the Cangshan court to publish its own procedural guidance, for the volume of cross-border commercial cases in Fuzhou to concentrate in a single docket, and for the Maritime Silk Road legal-services ecosystem to deepen the integration of litigation, arbitration and notarial services. For foreign parties, the practical message is simple: cross-border dispute resolution in Fujian is becoming more specialised, more centralised and more predictable.

Sources


福州六城区涉外涉港澳台商事案件集中管辖:对福建跨境争议解决的意义

公告内容

2026 年 8 月 20 日,福建省高级人民法院发布关于对福州六城区第一审涉外、涉港澳台商事案件实行集中管辖的公告。经最高人民法院批准,自 2026 年 10 月 1 日起,福州市仓山区人民法院集中管辖其辖区以及原由鼓楼、台江、晋安、马尾、长乐五区人民法院管辖的、标的额为人民币 4000 万元以下(不含本数)的第一审涉外、涉港澳台商事案件。2026 年 10 月 1 日前五区法院已受理尚未审结的案件,仍由原审理法院继续审理。公告明确,此前规定与公告不一致的,按公告执行。

法律依据

公告援引《最高人民法院关于涉外民商事案件管辖若干问题的规定》(法释〔2022〕18 号,2023 年 1 月 1 日起施行)第四条第一款。该文件改革了旧的”涉外一审案件集中于中级法院”体系:将多数一审涉外民商事案件回归基层法院,按案件标的与类型设定标准,并在相关条款中明确允许高级人民法院经最高人民法院批准指定特定下级法院集中管辖。福州仓山区法院正是依据这一授权被指定。法律效果是:当事人不再需要猜测六城区中哪家法院审理跨境商事争议,管辖法院由一份公告一次性固定。

集中管辖的实践价值

集中管辖为外国当事人带来三项实际收益。第一,可预期性:外国投资者或贸易伙伴可预先确定管辖法院,这对起草管辖条款、估算程序周期至关重要。第二,专业化:将跨境商事案件集中于一家法院,可积累涉外合同法、信用证、保函、提单、外商投资企业纠纷与承认执行问题的审判经验;裁判尺度统一减少”择地行诉”与法律风险。第三,程序效率:一家法院适用一套立案、送达与证据规则,降低管辖异议与区际移送风险——跨境案件中此类程序消耗尤为昂贵。4000 万元门槛也显示分工:超门槛案件继续按标准管辖规则办理,通常进入中级法院。

背景:海丝中央法务区

集中管辖并非孤立措施。仓山区设有”海丝法庭”(由金山法庭整建制进驻升级而成),专业管辖仓山区商事、知识产权及涉房涉地纠纷。福州同时在建设”海丝中央法务区”福州片区,该片区 2025 年底迁入新址,按”前店后厂、线上线下结合”模式集成律师行业服务高质量发展中心、行政复议中心、公证中心、国际仲裁中心与海丝法务发展中心——前台统一收件、分类流转、跟踪督办,后台由各进驻单位提供专业服务。法务区线上”云平台”汇聚 33 个省级行政区 633 家律所资源,业务辐射全球 35 个国家和地区。仓山区法院的集中管辖正是这一更大法律服务生态的司法臂膀:在福州缔约的公司,如今可在仓山诉讼、在国际仲裁中心仲裁、在同一法务集群完成公证认证。

地方动作背后的全国趋势

福州的举措顺应了 2023 年《民事诉讼法》修改与 2022 年管辖规定以来全国可见的模式:鼓励涉外案件向基层集中,并在一线城市设立国际商事法庭与法庭。无锡、深圳、苏州、成都等城市已设立经最高法批准的国际商事法庭;上海、北京设有国际商事法院。逻辑一致:随着跨境争议量上升,中国法院集中专业力量、统一程序、向外国当事人传递”中国法院是专业高效的商事争议解决机构”的信号——这是对长期作为国际当事人默认选择的仲裁机构的刻意补充。

外资企业实操指引

对在福建经营或有交易对手的外资企业,实操清单是:(1)审阅适用中国法的合同管辖条款,确认 4000 万元以下争议是否落入仓山管辖;(2)与福建对手方起草新合同时,考虑选择仓山法院还是法务区国际仲裁中心;(3)既有案件确认过渡规则下的管辖——2026 年 10 月 1 日前已受理的维持原法院;(4)利用法务区获取公证、认证与翻译服务,保持证据有序;(5)关注邻近地区是否跟进同类集中管辖,进一步简化全省跨境争议解决。新制度不改变实体法,也不改变外国判决的承认与执行规则——它改变的是哪家中国法院审理一审跨境商事案件,而这一改变对多数当事人而言是受欢迎的简化。

展望

福州涉外集中管辖将于 2026 年 10 月 1 日生效。中期可预期:仓山法院将发布自身程序指引,福州跨境商事案件将集中于单一案卷,海丝法律服务生态将深化诉讼、仲裁与公证的一体化。对外国当事人,信息简洁:福建的跨境争议解决正变得更专业、更集中、更可预期。

Sources

Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Litigation in China: The CICC Mechanism and Extraterritorial-Law Ascertainment (2025–2026)

  • The Supreme People’s Court’s 2025 opinion on the International Commercial Court (CICC) upgrades foreign-related adjudication: model jurisdiction clauses, pre-trial conferences and standardised bilingual procedures.
    最高人民法院2025年《国际商事法庭高质量发展意见》升级涉外审判:管辖示范条款、审前会议与标准化中英双语程序。
  • China is building a cross-border legal-service database and expert participation to make extraterritorial-law ascertainment faster and more accurate.
    中国正构建跨境法律服务数据库并引入专家参与,使域外法查明更高效准确。
  • In 2025 foreign parties chose Chinese maritime courts for disputes with no real China link in 23 cases, signalling rising confidence in China as a dispute venue.
    2025年有23件与中国无实际联系的外籍当事人主动选择中国海事法院管辖,显示对中国作为争议地的信心上升。
  • The SPC handled 21,000 arbitration judicial-review cases (+12.8% yoy) and recognised/enforced 108 overseas awards, while admitting/executing 972 foreign judgments on treaty or reciprocity grounds.
    最高法办理商事仲裁司法审查2.1万件(同比+12.8%),承认执行境外仲裁裁决108件,并依条约或互惠承认执行外国判决972件。
  • A one-stop international commercial dispute platform mediated 155 foreign-related cases, integrating litigation, mediation and arbitration.
    一站式国际商事纠纷多元化解平台调解涉外案件155件,诉讼、调解、仲裁有机衔接。
  • Practical step: draft a clear jurisdiction and arbitration clause, keep bilingual evidence, and use the CICC platform or recognised arbitration for cross-border disputes.

实操建议:拟定清晰的管辖与仲裁条款,留存双语证据,并借助国际商事法庭平台或受认可仲裁解决跨境争议。

Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Litigation in China: The CICC Mechanism and Extraterritorial-Law Ascertainment (2025–2026) | 涉外民商事审判与域外法查明:最高法国际商事法庭机制(2025–2026)

China is actively shaping itself as a preferred venue for international commercial disputes. Two instruments matter for foreign investors: the Supreme People’s Court’s (SPC) mechanism for the International Commercial Court (CICC), and the evolving system for ascertaining foreign law. The 2025 SPC opinion and the 2026 work report show where the reform is heading.

The CICC upgrade

In September 2025 the SPC issued the *Opinion on Promoting High-Quality Development of the International Commercial Court*, setting out six innovations. It optimises foreign-related jurisdiction by giving the CICC a demonstrative role, improving party-agreed jurisdiction, and publishing a model jurisdiction clause. It refines case management with pre-trial conferences and unified workflow norms. It simplifies the proof of overseas official documents and standardises English versions of common bilingual judicial documents. It strengthens treaty and customary-law application with a filing mechanism for such rulings. And it innovates the tribunal by allowing qualified mainland/HK/Macau expert members as people’s assessors in designated first-instance CICC cases.

Extraterritorial-law ascertainment

A recurring pain point in foreign-related cases is proving what foreign law says. The opinion pushes a cross-border legal-service database to let courts ascertain foreign law efficiently and accurately, and brings expert committee members into the proceedings to give ascertainment assistance. On the ground, 15 provincial courts — Chongqing, Yunnan, Gansu, Qinghai and others — have deepened ascertainment cooperation; Guangxi has built an “ASEAN corpus” for judicial application. The direction is “soft connectivity” of rules to serve the western land-sea corridor.

Why parties are choosing China

The 2026 SPC work report shows growing confidence. The Shanghai Maritime Court promoted a model jurisdiction clause; cases where parties contracted for its jurisdiction rose from 361 (2021) to 712 (2025). In 2025, in 23 cases with no real connection to China, foreign parties still chose a Chinese maritime court — a notable vote of confidence. The one-stop international commercial dispute platform mediated 155 foreign-related cases, while litigation, mediation and arbitration were linked.

Enforcement and reciprocity

The SPC handled 21,000 commercial arbitration judicial-review cases (up 12.8% yoy) and concluded 108 applications to recognise/enforce overseas arbitral awards. On treaty or reciprocity grounds it recognised and enforced 972 foreign judgments (up 2x). The Hainan Free Trade Port adapted interim-arbitration innovation and concluded its first foreign-related ad-hoc arbitration case. For foreign investors, this means a Chinese judgment or an award routed through China is increasingly portable abroad, and foreign awards are enforceable here.

Practical steps

  1. Draft the clause carefully. Use the CICC model jurisdiction clause and a clear arbitration agreement.
  2. Keep bilingual records. Standardised English judicial documents ease cross-border proof.
  3. Use the platform. For mid-tier disputes, the one-stop mediation platform can resolve faster than litigation.
  4. Plan for enforcement. Prefer seats/awards recognised under treaties China applies; document the connection.
  5. Ascertain foreign law early. Engage experts and the cross-border database before the merits hearing.

涉外民商事审判与域外法查明:最高法国际商事法庭机制(2025–2026)

中国正积极将自己塑造为国际商事争议的首选地。对外国投资者而言,有两件制度工具至关重要:最高人民法院的国际商事法庭(CICC)机制,以及不断演进的域外法查明体系。2025年意见与2026年工作报告揭示了改革方向。

国际商事法庭升级

2025年9月,最高法发布《关于推进国际商事法庭高质量发展 服务保障高水平对外开放的意见》,提出六项创新。它优化涉外管辖,发挥国际商事法庭示范引领作用,完善当事人约定管辖,并发布管辖示范条款。它以审前会议与统一流程规范细化案件管理,简化域外公文书证证明手续,统一常用涉外司法文书的中英双语范本。它强化国际条约与国际惯例适用并建备案机制,并创新法庭运行——允许符合条件的内地及港澳专家委员作为人民陪审员参审特定一审国际商事案件。

域外法查明

涉外案件的一大痛点是证明外国法的内容。意见推动构建跨境法律服务数据库,助力法院高效准确查明域外法,并引入专家委员出庭提供查明协助。实践中,重庆、云南、甘肃、青海等15地法院深化查明合作;广西推进”东盟语料库”司法应用。方向是以规则机制”软联通”服务西部陆海新通道。

当事人为何选择中国

2026年最高法工作报告显示信心上升。上海海事法院推广管辖协议示范条款,约定由其管辖的案件由2021年361件增至2025年712件。2025年有23件与中国无实际联系的外籍当事人仍选择中国海事法院管辖——这是显著的信任投票。一站式国际商事纠纷多元化解平台调解涉外案件155件,诉讼、调解、仲裁有机衔接。

执行与互惠

最高法办理商事仲裁司法审查2.1万件(同比+12.8%),办结申请承认执行境外仲裁裁决108件。依条约或互惠承认执行外国判决972件(同比增2倍)。海南自贸港对接临时仲裁制度创新,审结执结首例涉外临时仲裁案。对外资而言,这意味着经中国路径的判决或裁决日益可在境外流通,外国裁决也可在华执行。

实操步骤

  1. 谨慎起草条款。 使用国际商事法庭管辖示范条款与清晰的仲裁协议。
  2. 留存双语记录。 标准化英文司法文书便利跨境举证。
  3. 善用平台。 中等争议可经一站式调解平台更快解决。
  4. 规划执行。 优先选择中国适用的条约项下可获承认的仲裁地/裁决,并留存连接点证据。
  5. 尽早查明外国法。 在实体审理前引入专家与跨境数据库。

Practitioner Quick Reference

  • CICC model clause: use the SPC’s model jurisdiction clause for international commercial disputes.
    国际商事法庭示范条款:涉外商事争议采用最高法管辖示范条款。
  • Bilingual records: standardised English judicial documents ease cross-border proof.
    双语记录:标准化英文司法文书便利跨境举证。
  • One-stop platform: mediation resolved 155 foreign-related cases; faster than pure litigation.
    一站式平台:调解涉外案件155件,快于纯诉讼。
  • Enforcement is real: 972 foreign judgments recognised; 108 overseas awards enforced in 2025.
    执行可行:2025年承认外国判决972件、执行境外裁决108件。
  • Ascertain foreign law early: use the cross-border database and expert committee members.
    尽早查明外国法:用跨境数据库与专家委员。

Common Pitfalls

  • Vague clauses: an unclear jurisdiction/arbitration clause invites forum fights.
    条款含糊:管辖或仲裁条款不清易引发管辖争议。
  • No bilingual evidence: poor documentation slows extraterritorial-law proof.
    无双语证据:材料不足拖慢域外法查明。
  • Wrong seat choice: picking a non-recognised seat hurts later enforcement.
    仲裁地选错:选非受认可地不利后续执行。

2026 Watchlist

  • CICC precedents: watch model-clause and treaty-application rulings from the International Commercial Court.
    国际商事法庭先例:关注管辖示范条款与国际条约适用的裁判。
  • Hainan ad-hoc arbitration: more foreign-related interim-arbitration cases may be concluded.
    海南临时仲裁:更多涉外临时仲裁案或将审结。
  • Judgment reciprocity: the recognised foreign-judgment count is growing — track recognised seats.
    判决互惠:被承认外国判决数量增长——跟踪受认可仲裁地。

Key Figures

  • 21,000: commercial arbitration judicial-review cases in 2025 (+12.8% yoy).
    2.1万件:2025年商事仲裁司法审查案件(同比+12.8%)。
  • 108: overseas arbitral awards recognised and enforced.
    108件:承认并执行的境外仲裁裁决。
  • 972: foreign judgments recognised/enforced on treaty or reciprocity grounds.
    972件:依条约或互惠承认执行的外国判决。
  • 155: foreign-related cases mediated on the one-stop platform.
    155件:一站式平台调解的涉外案件。

Sources

Where Will Your China Dispute Be Heard? Jurisdiction over Foreign-Related Civil Cases under the Amended Civil Procedure Law in Force from 1 January 2024

  • From 1 January 2024 the amended Civil Procedure Law widens Chinese courts’ reach over foreign-related civil and commercial disputes, adding an “other appropriate connection” catch-all.
    自2024年1月1日起施行的修改后民事诉讼法扩张了人民法院对涉外民商事案件的管辖范围,并新增”其他适当联系”兜底规则。
  • Article 277 lets parties choose Chinese courts by written agreement with no requirement that the chosen forum have an actual connection with the dispute.
    第二百七十七条允许当事人书面协议选择人民法院管辖,不再要求所选法院与争议存在实际联系。
  • Under Article 278, a foreign defendant who answers on the merits or counterclaims without first objecting to jurisdiction is deemed to have accepted the Chinese court.
    根据第二百七十八条,外国被告未先提出管辖异议即应诉答辩或提出反诉的,视为人民法院有管辖权。
  • Three categories are exclusive to Chinese courts: formation, dissolution, liquidation and resolution validity of Chinese entities; validity of IP examined and granted in China; and joint venture, cooperative venture and cooperative resource-exploration contracts performed in China.
    三类案件专属人民法院管辖:中国境内法人的设立、解散、清算与决议效力;在中国境内审查授予的知识产权有效性;在中国境内履行的中外合资、中外合作经营企业合同与中外合作勘探开发自然资源合同纠纷。
  • Article 280 lets a Chinese court accept a dispute already filed abroad, but an exclusive foreign choice-of-court clause can produce non-acceptance or dismissal.
    第二百八十条允许人民法院受理已在外国法院起诉的同一纠纷,但排他性外国法院管辖协议可导致不予受理或裁定驳回起诉。
  • Forum non conveniens under Article 282 works only if the defendant objects to jurisdiction and all five statutory conditions hold at once, with a return clause if the foreign court declines.
    第二百八十二条的不方便法院原则,须被告提出管辖异议且五个法定要件同时具备方可适用,并设有外国法院拒绝管辖时的回流条款。
  • At the enforcement stage Article 301 requires a finding that a foreign court lacked jurisdiction where there was no appropriate connection, where Chinese exclusive jurisdiction was breached, or where an exclusive choice-of-court agreement was ignored.
    在承认与执行环节,第三百零一条要求人民法院在外国法院与纠纷无适当联系、违反中国专属管辖规定或违反排他性管辖协议时,认定其无管辖权。

Where Will Your China Dispute Be Heard? Jurisdiction over Foreign-Related Civil Cases under the Amended Civil Procedure Law in Force from 1 January 2024 | 你的中国争议将在哪里审理?2024年1月1日施行的修改后民事诉讼法下涉外民商事案件的管辖权

Overview

Adopted in 1991 by the Fourth Session of the Seventh National People’s Congress and amended in 2007, 2012, 2017 and 2021 without substantive change to foreign-related procedure, the Civil Procedure Law was amended on 1 September 2023 by the Fifth Session of the Standing Committee of the 14th National People’s Congress, effective 1 January 2024, rewriting Part Four, the “Special Provisions on Foreign-Related Civil Procedure”.

Chinese courts now hear cases from more than one hundred countries and regions. The amendment spans jurisdiction, parallel proceedings and forum non conveniens, service, judicial assistance and evidence-taking, and recognition of foreign judgments. Only jurisdiction is covered here; service is at No. 68, enforcement at No. 77.

Connecting Factors and the Appropriate-Connection Catch-All

Article 276 (former Article 272): in an action other than one on personal status against a defendant with no domicile in China, a Chinese court may take the case if any of these lies in Chinese territory — the place of contract signature, of performance, of the subject matter of the action, of attachable property, of the tortious act, or a representative office’s domicile.

Paragraph 2 is new and the widest provision in Part Four: where the dispute has other appropriate connections with China, a Chinese court may take jurisdiction. A closed list becomes an open standard — having no entity in China no longer means beyond reach.

Choice-of-Court Agreements

Article 277 is new: parties choosing a Chinese court by written agreement confer jurisdiction on it. The deletion matters more — the old requirement that the chosen place have an actual connection with the dispute is gone, so two foreign parties under a contract signed and performed abroad may now validly litigate in China. Limits: writing, and exclusive jurisdiction.

Submission by Appearance

Article 278 is new and is where unadvised foreign defendants lose: a party that raises no jurisdictional objection and answers on the merits or counterclaims is deemed to have accepted jurisdiction. The objection comes first, within the period for filing a defence.

Exclusive Jurisdiction

Article 279 (former Article 273) reserves three categories: (1) formation, dissolution and liquidation of a legal person or other organisation established in Chinese territory, and the validity of its resolutions; (2) validity of intellectual property examined and granted in Chinese territory; (3) disputes from performance in Chinese territory of Chinese-foreign equity joint venture, cooperative joint venture, and cooperative natural-resource exploration and development contracts.

A resolution-validity suit therefore goes to a Chinese court whatever the shareholders’ agreement says, and a joint venture contract performed in China cannot be routed offshore by drafting.

Parallel Proceedings

Article 280: where one party sues abroad and the other in China on the same dispute, or one sues in both, a Chinese court with jurisdiction may accept the case. Exception: an exclusive foreign choice-of-court agreement violating neither Chinese exclusive jurisdiction nor China’s sovereignty, security or public interest — the court may rule not to accept, and dismisses if already accepted.

Under Article 281, on written application based on the foreign court having accepted first, the court may stay — unless the parties chose a Chinese court, the dispute is exclusively Chinese, or a Chinese hearing is clearly more convenient. If the foreign court takes no necessary measures to hear the case, or fails to conclude it within a reasonable period, it shall resume. Where a foreign judgment has been recognised in whole or part, a fresh action on that part is not accepted, or is dismissed.

Forum Non Conveniens

Article 282 applies only where the defendant objects to jurisdiction and all five conditions hold at once: (1) the basic facts did not occur in Chinese territory and hearing and participating are clearly inconvenient; (2) there is no agreement choosing a Chinese court; (3) the case is not within exclusive jurisdiction; (4) it does not involve China’s sovereignty, security or public interest; (5) a foreign court is more convenient. The court may then dismiss and tell the plaintiff to sue abroad. Return clause: if that court declines jurisdiction, takes no necessary measures, or fails to conclude within a reasonable period, and the party sues again in China, the court shall accept.

How Chinese Courts Test a Foreign Court’s Jurisdiction

Article 301 directs a court to find a foreign court had no jurisdiction where: (1) it had none under its own law, or had it but with no appropriate connection to the dispute; (2) it breached Chinese exclusive jurisdiction; or (3) it breached an exclusive choice-of-court agreement.

That is item (1) of Article 300, whose five refusal grounds are: no jurisdiction under Article 301; the respondent not lawfully summoned, denied a reasonable chance to state its case and defend, or lacking capacity without proper representation; judgment obtained by fraud; a Chinese judgment already given on the same dispute, or a third-country judgment already recognised; and violation of the basic principles of Chinese law or harm to sovereignty, security or the public interest. Article 303 allows reconsideration by the next higher court within ten days of service; Article 305 refers proceedings involving a foreign state to China’s foreign state immunity law. Enforcement is at No. 77.

Litigation or Arbitration

A valid arbitration clause displaces court jurisdiction on the merits and the award travels under the New York Convention — but the Article 279 categories and the sovereignty and public-interest boundaries remain. See No. 77 and this site’s arbitration articles.

Practical Steps for FIEs

  1. Re-examine pre-2024 dispute clauses. Exclusivity now decides acceptance.
  2. Use Article 277 deliberately. No actual connection is needed; exclusive jurisdiction still binds.
  3. Screen contracts against Article 279. Its three categories cannot be contracted out of.
  4. Object before answering. No answer, no counterclaim, until that call is made.
  5. Plan the filing sequence. Filing first abroad may support a stay — not against a Chinese forum clause, exclusive jurisdiction or clear Chinese convenience.
  6. Plead forum non conveniens; never assume it. All five conditions together, and the case can return.
  7. Draft jurisdiction with enforcement in mind. Article 301 waits at the Chinese end.

Disputes touching Hong Kong, China, Macao, China or Taiwan, China follow separate judicial-assistance arrangements.

Related Reading

See dispute-resolution pathways (No. 39), cross-border service (No. 68) and enforcement (No. 77).


你的中国争议将在哪里审理?2024年1月1日施行的修改后民事诉讼法下涉外民商事案件的管辖权

概述

《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》于1991年由七届全国人大四次会议通过,此后历经2007、2012、2017、2021年四次修正,但历次修正均未对涉外民事诉讼程序作实质性调整。2023年9月1日,十四届全国人大常委会第五次会议通过《全国人民代表大会常务委员会关于修改〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的决定》,自2024年1月1日起施行,修改重点正是第四编”涉外民事诉讼程序的特别规定”。这是该编自1991年以来第一次系统性重写。

近年来人民法院审理的涉外民商事案件已覆盖一百多个国家和地区,境外当事人主动选择中国法院管辖的案件日益增多,管辖规则因此需要与跨境交易的现实相匹配。立法机关将修改内容概括为五方面:扩大涉外案件管辖权,增加平行诉讼一般规定与不方便法院原则,改革涉外送达,完善司法协助与域外调查取证,完善外国判决承认与执行的基本规则。本文只处理其中后果最直接的管辖权问题——送达见本站编号68,执行见本站编号77,本文仅在与管辖权相关处一笔带过。对外资企业而言,管辖规则的变化不只是诉讼技术问题:它决定了合同争议解决条款是否仍然有效、争议将在何处审理,以及一份境外判决日后能否在中国落地。

连结点与”适当联系”兜底规则

第二百七十六条(原第二百七十二条)是基础规则。因涉外民事纠纷,对在中国领域内没有住所的被告提起除身份关系以外的诉讼,如果下列地点位于中国领域内,可以由该地人民法院管辖:合同签订地、合同履行地、诉讼标的物所在地、可供扣押财产所在地、侵权行为地、代表机构住所地。

第二款为新增,也是修改后第四编扩张力度最大的条款:除前款规定外,涉外民事纠纷与中华人民共和国存在其他适当联系的,可以由人民法院管辖。封闭式列举由此转为开放式标准,此前因不符合任何列举项而无法受理的纠纷得以进入中国法院,例如商业重心、受影响市场或实质履行部分在中国,但没有任何单一列举连结点被完整满足的情形。”适当联系”如何认定,将在个案中由受诉法院结合纠纷与中国的实际牵连程度判断,境外企业不宜再以”未在中国设立主体”作为免受管辖的当然理由。对外国企业而言结论很直白:在中国没有子公司、分支机构或登记代表机构,已不再意味着处于中国法院管辖范围之外。同时,”可供扣押财产所在地”这一连结点既关乎管辖,也直接影响保全与后续执行的可行性。

协议管辖

第二百七十七条为新增:涉外民事纠纷的当事人书面协议选择人民法院管辖的,可以由人民法院管辖。更重要的是被删去的内容——旧法要求协议选择的法院所在地与争议有实际联系,该限制已取消。合同在境外签订、境外履行、适用外国法的两个外国当事人,如今仍可有效约定由中国法院审理,其立法目的是使中国法院成为国际商事主体可选的中立审判地。两项限制仍在:须采书面形式,且不得突破专属管辖。实践中还应把管辖条款写到可执行的程度,明确具体法院或明确的确定方法,避免因约定不明在受理阶段另生争议。同时须注意区分排他性与非排他性表述:选择中国法院时若写成非排他,对方仍可能在境外另行起诉,从而落入下文的平行诉讼情形。

应诉管辖

第二百七十八条同为新增,也是缺乏准备的外国被告最容易失手之处:当事人未提出管辖异议,并应诉答辩或者提出反诉的,视为人民法院有管辖权。顺序决定一切——管辖异议须在提交答辩状期间内、在就实体问题作出回应之前先行提出,逾期或先行实体答辩即丧失抗辩机会。收到起诉材料后的第一项工作因此不是准备实体抗辩,而是判断是否提出管辖异议;在管辖问题尚未决定时就指示律师”先把答辩交上去”,等于把选择权提前用掉。这一点对总部远在境外、内部审批链条较长的外资企业尤为关键,应在收到材料的第一时间启动应对,而不是等待总部逐级决策。

专属管辖的三类案件

第二百七十九条(原第二百七十三条)将三类纠纷保留给人民法院专属管辖:

  1. 因在中国领域内设立的法人或者其他组织的设立、解散、清算,以及其作出的决议的效力等发生的纠纷;
  2. 因与在中国领域内审查授予的知识产权的有效性有关的纠纷;
  3. 因在中国领域内履行中外合资经营企业合同、中外合作经营企业合同、中外合作勘探开发自然资源合同发生的纠纷。

这三类专属管辖不因当事人另有约定而改变,也是协议管辖自由的边界所在。

后果非常具体。就中国公司股东会或董事会决议效力提起的诉讼,无论股东协议如何约定都归人民法院审理;对中国专利、商标有效性的争议留在中国,无效宣告本身仍走行政程序并经行政诉讼救济;在中国境内履行的合资合同不能安排到境外审理——写入境外法院,或在某些情形下约定境外仲裁地,都需逐案评估而非沿用模板。对以合资方式进入中国的投资者,这意味着争议解决条款必须与主合同的履行地事实一并审阅,不能只看条款文本本身,还须核对合同实际在何地履行、标的物与知识产权登记在何处。

平行诉讼

第二百八十条是平行诉讼的第一条一般性规定。当事人之间的同一纠纷,一方向外国法院起诉、另一方向人民法院起诉,或者一方既向外国法院起诉又向人民法院起诉的,人民法院依法有管辖权的可以受理;仅在境外先行起诉并不阻断中国诉讼。例外是排他性管辖协议:当事人订立排他性管辖协议选择外国法院管辖,且不违反本法专属管辖规定、不涉及中国主权、安全或社会公共利益的,人民法院可以裁定不予受理;已经受理的,裁定驳回起诉。”排他性”三个字承载了全部分量。

第二百八十一条规定受理之后的处理。当事人以外国法院已经先于人民法院受理为由书面申请中止诉讼的,人民法院可以裁定中止诉讼,但有下列情形之一的除外:(一)当事人协议选择人民法院管辖,或者纠纷属于人民法院专属管辖;(二)由人民法院审理明显更为方便。外国法院未采取必要措施审理案件,或者未在合理期限内审结的,依当事人书面申请,人民法院应当恢复诉讼。外国法院的生效判决、裁定已被全部或部分承认的,当事人就已获承认部分又起诉的,裁定不予受理;已受理的裁定驳回起诉。合并来看,这是一场受到管理的”赛跑”:抢先在境外起诉换来的是可能的中止,而非永久阻断;一旦境外程序停滞,中止会被解除、诉讼恢复。对外国当事人而言,起诉地与起诉时点的选择因此不再是单纯的策略问题,而须结合管辖协议文本、专属管辖清单与两地程序推进速度一并评估。

不方便法院原则

第二百八十二条将不方便法院原则成文化,适用以被告提出管辖异议为前提,且五个要件须同时具备:(一)案件争议的基本事实不是发生在中国领域内,人民法院审理案件和当事人参加诉讼均明显不方便;(二)当事人之间不存在选择人民法院管辖的协议;(三)案件不属于人民法院专属管辖;(四)案件不涉及中国主权、安全或者社会公共利益;(五)外国法院审理案件更为方便。五项同时满足的,可以裁定驳回起诉,并告知原告向更方便的外国法院起诉。条文另设回流条款:驳回后外国法院拒绝行使管辖权、未采取必要措施审理或未在合理期限内审结,当事人又向人民法院起诉的,人民法院应当受理。被告因此无法借助该原则使原告陷入无处起诉的境地。需要强调的是,不方便法院原则不会由法院主动适用:被告若未在法定期间内提出管辖异议,即使五个要件客观上成立,也无从主张。

人民法院如何反向审查外国法院的管辖权

到了承认环节,管辖权会从相反方向再次出现。新增第三百零一条要求人民法院在下列情形之一时认定该外国法院对案件无管辖权:(一)外国法院依照其法律对案件没有管辖权,或者虽有管辖权但与案件所涉纠纷无适当联系;(二)违反本法对专属管辖的规定;(三)违反当事人排他性选择法院管辖的协议。

该条服务于第三百条第(一)项。第三百条列举不予承认和执行的五种情形:依第三百零一条认定外国法院无管辖权;被申请人未得到合法传唤,或虽经合法传唤但未获得合理的陈述、辩论机会,或无诉讼行为能力的当事人未得到适当代理;判决、裁定系通过欺诈取得;人民法院已就同一纠纷作出判决、裁定,或已承认第三国法院就同一纠纷作出的判决、裁定;违反中国法律的基本原则或损害国家主权、安全、社会公共利益。

另有两条须一并留意。第三百零三条规定,当事人对承认和执行或不予承认和执行的裁定不服的,可以自裁定送达之日起十日内向上一级人民法院申请复议。新增第三百零五条规定,涉及外国国家的民事诉讼,适用中华人民共和国有关外国国家豁免的法律规定;有关法律没有规定的,适用本法。对外国当事人而言,第三百零一条的意义在于把”管辖”从起诉阶段的程序问题,变成了判决能否在中国落地的实体门槛:一份由与纠纷无适当联系的法院作出的判决,即便在原审地完全有效,在中国仍可能被拒绝承认。执行实务见本站编号77,本文不展开。

诉讼还是仲裁

有效的仲裁条款可排除法院对实体争议的管辖,裁决依《纽约公约》跨境流通,从而规避上述大部分管辖权博弈。但它不是万能出口:第二百七十九条的专属管辖事项以及公共利益与主权边界依然存在,在中国境内履行的合资合同、中国授权专利的有效性,都无法仅凭条款起草搬到境外。诉讼与仲裁的取舍应针对具体标的逐项判断,而不是作为默认选项照抄模板;对同一份合同中的不同争议类型,甚至可能需要作出不同安排。可参见本站编号77及本站国际仲裁类文章。

外资企业的实操步骤

  1. 重新体检2024年之前签署的争议解决条款。 排他性与非排他性如今直接决定人民法院是否受理,务必明确写清。
  2. 有意识地运用第二百七十七条。 选择中国法院不再需要实际联系,但永远不能突破专属管辖。
  3. 逐份合同对照第二百七十九条筛查。 在中国境内履行的中外合资、合作经营与合作勘探开发合同,法人设立、解散、清算与决议效力纠纷,以及中国授权知识产权的有效性,均属人民法院管辖。
  4. 建立管辖异议内部流程。 在是否提异议的决定作出前,不得提交实体答辩状、不得提出反诉。
  5. 规划起诉顺序。 抢先在境外起诉可能支持中止,但在已协议选择人民法院、属于专属管辖或由中国审理明显更方便时不适用。
  6. 不方便法院须主动主张,不可默认。 五个要件必须同时成立,且案件可能回流至中国。
  7. 起草管辖条款时即考虑执行。 第三百零一条在中国这一端等着,境外判决能否在中国落地,往往在签约时就已决定。

涉及中国香港、中国澳门、中国台湾地区的争议,适用各自的区际司法协助安排,而非上述外国判决规则。

相关阅读

可参阅本站涉外争议解决总体路径(编号39)、跨境送达与诉讼程序(编号68),以及外国裁决与判决的执行(编号77),了解本文未覆盖的前后环节。三者与本文的管辖权规则共同构成涉外争议从立案到执行的完整链条。

Sources

Recognizing and Enforcing Foreign Arbitral Awards in Mainland China: A Practical Guide under the New York Convention

  • The New York Convention has applied in mainland China since 22 April 1987, subject to China’s reciprocity reservation and commercial reservation.
    《纽约公约》自1987年4月22日起在中国内地施行,并受中国作出的互惠保留与商事保留两项声明的约束。
  • The seat of arbitration—not the institution’s nationality, the hearing place, or the rules’ governing law—is the sole test of an award’s nationality.
    仲裁地——而非仲裁机构国籍、开庭地或仲裁规则所适用法域——是判定裁决国籍的唯一标准。
  • Awards seated in mainland China are domestic; awards from the Hong Kong SAR or Macao SAR follow special mutual-enforcement arrangements, not the Convention.
    仲裁地位于中国内地的裁决为内国裁决;中国香港特别行政区、中国澳门特别行政区作出的裁决依专项相互执行安排处理,而非《纽约公约》。
  • File with the intermediate people’s court at the debtor’s domicile or where its property is located; the limitation period is two years under the Civil Procedure Law.
    应向被执行人住所地或财产所在地的中级人民法院提出申请;依《民事诉讼法》申请期间为两年。
  • Non-compliant documents are not accepted: submit the original award or certified copy, the arbitration agreement, and a certified Chinese translation.
    材料不合规将不予受理:须提交裁决正本或经证明副本、仲裁协议,以及经认证的中文译本。
  • Article V of the Convention exhaustively lists the only grounds for refusal, and they are narrowly construed in favour of enforcement.
    《纽约公约》第五条穷尽列举了拒绝承认与执行的唯一事由,且应作有利于执行的严格限缩解释。
  • Any proposed refusal must be escalated through the cascade reporting system to the Supreme People’s Court before a rejection can be issued.
    凡拟不予承认执行的,均须通过逐级报核制度层报最高人民法院,方可作出驳回裁定。

Recognizing and Enforcing Foreign Arbitral Awards in Mainland China: A Practical Guide under the New York Convention | 外国仲裁裁决在中国内地的承认与执行实操:《纽约公约》项下实务指引

The New York Convention and China’s Two Reservations

The Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (the “New York Convention”) entered into force for China on 22 April 1987, after China’s accession on 2 December 1986. It remains the cornerstone of cross-border award enforcement in mainland China, and China made two declarations every foreign investor should understand before drafting a dispute clause.

First, the reciprocity reservation: China applies the Convention only to awards made in the territory of another Contracting State, so an award from a non-Contracting State cannot be enforced through the Convention and would need a different, less certain basis.

Second, the commercial reservation: China applies the Convention only to disputes arising from legal relationships, contractual or not, considered commercial under Chinese law; non-commercial disputes fall outside it. In short, seat the arbitration in a Contracting State and ensure the dispute is commercial under Chinese law.

How the Nationality of an Award Is Determined: The Seat Rule

A recurring source of confusion is whether an award is “foreign” for New York Convention purposes. Chinese courts apply a single, exclusive test—the seat of arbitration (仲裁地); the institution’s nationality, the hearing place, and the governing law of the rules are all irrelevant.

If the seat is in mainland China, the award is a domestic award and the Convention does not apply; enforcement follows the ordinary route under the Arbitration Law and the Civil Procedure Law. If the seat is outside mainland China and in a Contracting State, the award is a “foreign award” enforceable under the Convention. Thus an award by a foreign institution (such as the ICC or SIAC) seated in mainland China is still domestic, while a Chinese institution’s award seated abroad is, for enforcement purposes, foreign. This seat-based test guards against forum-shopping and aligns with the “delocalised” nature of international arbitration, though a clause that fixes the seat ambiguously can still trigger a costly nationality dispute.

Awards Excluded from the New York Convention

Three categories fall outside the New York Convention in China:

  1. Awards seated in mainland China — enforced as domestic awards.
  2. Awards made in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China or the Macao Special Administrative Region of China — enforced under the special mutual-enforcement arrangements with the two Special Administrative Regions, not the Convention. The mainland-Hong Kong arrangement (2000, supplemented 2019) and the mainland-Macao arrangement (2007) apply.
  3. Awards made in the Taiwan region of China — handled through the cross-strait judicial mutual-assistance framework rather than the Convention.

The Convention and these arrangements are mutually exclusive; choosing the correct channel at the outset determines the court, procedure, and limitation period.

Where to File: Jurisdiction of the Intermediate People’s Court

Applications are heard by an intermediate people’s court (中级人民法院) at the domicile of the person subjected to enforcement (the debtor) or where its property is located; where property spans multiple jurisdictions, the applicant may choose among the courts with property jurisdiction.

Before filing, map the debtor’s registered address, place of business, and bank accounts, equity, and real estate in mainland China; a court lacking both domicile and assets in its territory has no jurisdiction, and the application will be transferred or rejected.

The Two-Year Time Limit

The application is subject to the two-year limitation under the Civil Procedure Law. The starting point follows the award: from the last day of a fixed performance period, from each installment’s last day if installments are specified, or from the award’s effective date if no period is fixed.

Crucially, the limitation is a defence the debtor may raise; the court does not examine it on its own motion. Parties should still file promptly: once the period lapses the right to apply is effectively lost, and early filing preserves the ability to seek property preservation in mainland China.

Documents You Must Prepare

Under the Supreme People’s Court’s 1987 notice and later practice, the applicant must submit:

  • a written application;
  • the original award or a duly certified copy;
  • the original arbitration agreement or a certified copy; and
  • a Chinese translation of the award and the arbitration agreement, certified by an entity qualified to provide translation.

The translation requirement is strict: foreign-language materials must carry a Chinese translation. If the documents are incomplete or non-compliant, the court will not accept the application; it will notify the applicant to cure the defects within a prescribed period, and if they are not cured the application is rejected. Getting the paperwork right the first time is decisive.

Grounds for Refusal under Article V

The New York Convention is pro-enforcement: Article V exhaustively lists the grounds on which a court may—but need not—refuse recognition and enforcement, and they are construed narrowly:

(a) incapacity of a party, or invalidity of the arbitration agreement under the law applicable to it; (b) the party was not given proper notice of the appointment of the arbitrator or of the proceedings, or was otherwise unable to present its case; (c) the award deals with a dispute not contemplated by, or beyond the scope of, the submission to arbitration (if the separable part can be enforced, only that part is refused); (d) the composition of the arbitral authority or the procedure was not in accordance with the parties’ agreement or, failing such agreement, with the law of the seat; (e) the award has not yet become binding, or has been set aside or suspended by a competent authority of the country in which, or under the law of which, it was made.

In addition, recognition and enforcement may be refused if the subject matter is not arbitrable under Chinese law, or if it would be contrary to China’s public policy. Chinese courts apply the public-policy exception restrictively, confining it to the most fundamental principles and basic social interests of Chinese law, and not as a general escape hatch for dissatisfied debtors.

The Cascade Reporting and Approval System

The most distinctive feature of award enforcement in China is the cascade reporting and approval system (逐级报核制度). Because local courts once showed protectionist tendencies toward local debtors, the Supreme People’s Court requires any intermediate court proposing to refuse recognition or enforcement of a foreign award to report first to the Higher People’s Court; if the High Court agrees, it must report further to the Supreme People’s Court, whose decision binds the lower courts. A refusal cannot be issued without that authorisation.

For domestic (non-foreign-related) arbitration judicial-review matters, the Supreme People’s Court later streamlined the reporting level: such cases are reported only to the Higher People’s Court, without Supreme People’s Court approval. The foreign-award track, by contrast, retains the full two-tier escalation to the Supreme People’s Court.

How the Supreme People’s Court Unifies Review Standards

To curb inconsistency across localities, the Supreme People’s Court has deployed several instruments:

  • The Minutes of the National Courts’ Forum on Foreign-Related Commercial and Maritime Trial Work (《全国法院涉外商事海事审判工作座谈会会议纪要》), consolidating judicial views on recognizing and enforcing foreign arbitral awards.
  • Guiding Cases (指导性案例) on arbitration, binding lower courts and showing how Article V defences apply.
  • The bilingual Annual Report on Judicial Review of International Commercial Arbitration in China, publishing representative cases with English and Chinese reasoning.
  • The inclusion of 24 Chinese New York Convention cases in the UNCITRAL CLOUT (Case Law on UNCITRAL Texts) database.

Together these measures raise predictability and weaken the old local-protectionist route for a debtor’s Article V objection.

A Practical Checklist for Foreign-Invested Enterprises

For a foreign-invested enterprise that may enforce or resist a foreign award in mainland China, the following steps improve outcomes.

  • Draft the arbitration clause for the enforcement stage. Fix the seat in a New York Convention Contracting State, name a neutral institution, and avoid ambiguous seat language. The seat—not the institution or the rules—decides whether the Convention applies.
  • Pre-set a service address and keep records. Build a clear service address and a reliable notice channel into the contract and the proceeding, and preserve every dispatch. A clean record defeats the “no proper notice” defence before it is raised.
  • Map assets and time your preservation. Before and during arbitration, identify the debtor’s bank accounts, equity, and real property in mainland China. Chinese courts have, in practice, granted interim property preservation in support of foreign-seated arbitration; applying early can freeze assets before the award is final.
  • Use the settlement window. Between the award and enforcement—and even during recognition proceedings—a structured settlement is sometimes more valuable than contested enforcement against an asset-poor debtor.

Related Reading

See CIETAC international arbitration (No. 40), the Supreme People’s Court and CICC (No. 185), and the 2026 Arbitration Law revision (No. 166).


外国仲裁裁决在中国内地的承认与执行实操:《纽约公约》项下实务指引

《纽约公约》与中国两项保留

《承认及执行外国仲裁裁决公约》(以下简称”《纽约公约》”)于1987年4月22日对中国正式施行(中国于1986年12月2日加入)。它至今仍是中国内地跨境仲裁裁决承认与执行的基石;中国加入时作出的两项声明,外资企业拟定争议条款前须充分理解。

第一项是互惠保留:中国仅对另一缔约国领土内作出的裁决适用《纽约公约》予以承认和执行,非缔约国境内作出的裁决无法经该公约在中国内地执行,而须依赖其他(且确定性更低的)基础。

第二项是商事保留:中国仅对按照中国法律认定为契约性或非契约性商事法律关系所引起的争议适用《纽约公约》,非商事事项被排除在外。简而言之,将仲裁地设于缔约国,并确保基础争议具有商事性质。

裁决国籍的判定标准:仲裁地规则

一个反复造成混淆的问题是:一项裁决在《纽约公约》意义上究竟是否”外国裁决”。中国法院采用唯一且排他性的判断标准——仲裁地(seat);仲裁机构的国籍、开庭地所在国、仲裁规则所适用法域,均与裁决国籍的判定无关。

如果仲裁地位于中国内地,该裁决被视为内国裁决,《纽约公约》不予适用,其执行遵循《仲裁法》与《民事诉讼法》的普通内国路径。如果仲裁地位于中国内地境外且属于某一缔约国,则该裁决为可据《纽约公约》执行的”外国裁决”。由此推之:一家外国机构(例如国际商会 ICC 或新加坡国际仲裁中心 SIAC)作出但仲裁地设在中国内地的裁决,仍属内国裁决;而一家中国机构但在境外设仲裁地作出的裁决,在执行意义上反而是外国裁决。这一以仲裁地为核心的判断标准,既防范当事人挑选法院,也契合国际仲裁”非本地化”的普遍理解;但对仲裁地约定模糊的条款,仍可能在执行阶段引发成本高昂的国籍争议。

被排除在《纽约公约》之外的裁决

有三类裁决不属于《纽约公约》的适用范围:

  1. 仲裁地位于中国内地的裁决——作为内国裁决执行。
  2. 在中国香港特别行政区或中国澳门特别行政区作出的裁决——依据内地与两个特别行政区之间的专项相互执行安排执行,而非《纽约公约》。内地与香港特区的安排(2000年订立,2019年补充)以及内地与澳门特区的安排(2007年)适用。
  3. 在中国台湾地区作出的裁决——通过两岸司法互助框架处理,而非《纽约公约》。

《纽约公约》与这些专项安排相互排斥;在起点选对渠道,决定了由哪一家法院、适用何种程序以及何种时效。

管辖法院:中级人民法院

承认与执行外国仲裁裁决的申请,由被执行人住所地或者被执行财产所在地的中级人民法院管辖。当财产分布于多个管辖区域时,申请人可在有财产管辖权的法院中择一提出申请。

实践中,提起申请前应摸清债务人的登记地址、主要营业地,以及位于中国内地的银行账户、股权与不动产。一家辖区内既无财产又无住所的法院将欠缺管辖权,申请会被移送或驳回。

两年的申请期间

承认与执行外国裁决的申请,受《民事诉讼法》两年期间约束。起算点取决于裁决内容:确定履行期限的,自履行期限届满之日起算;分期履行的,自每次履行期限届满之日起算;未确定履行期限的,自裁决生效之日起算。

关键在于,该期间是债务人可提出的抗辩,法院并不会在立案阶段依职权主动审查。尽管如此,当事人仍应及时提出申请:一旦期间届满,申请权实际上即告丧失;及早申请也保留了就债务人位于中国内地的财产申请保全的可能。

必须准备好的文件

根据最高人民法院1987年实施意见及后续实践,申请人应当提交:

  • 书面申请;
  • 裁决正本或者经证明无误的副本;
  • 仲裁协议正本或者经证明无误的副本;
  • 裁决书与仲裁协议的中文译本,且译本须由具备资质的翻译机构认证。

翻译要求十分严格:以外文提交的材料必须附具中文译本。若材料不齐全或不符合要求,法院将不予受理,并通知申请人在指定期限内补正;逾期未补正的,申请将被驳回。因此,第一次就把文书备齐备对,具有决定性意义。

《纽约公约》第五条的抗辩事由

《纽约公约》以支持执行为基调:第五条穷尽列举了法院”可以”(而非”必须”)拒绝承认与执行的事由,且应作严格限缩解释:

(a) 当事人无行为能力,或仲裁协议依其应适用的法律无效; (b) 被申请人未获关于指派仲裁员或仲裁程序的适当通知,或因其他缘故未能申辩; (c) 裁决处理的争议非提交仲裁的标的,或超出提交仲裁的范围(可分离部分仍可执行的,仅该部分被拒绝); (d) 仲裁庭的组成或仲裁程序与当事人约定不符,或在无约定时与仲裁地法不符; (e) 裁决尚未对当事人发生拘束力,或已被作出裁决的国家或依其法律作出裁决的国家的主管机关撤销或中止。

此外,若争议事项依中国法不可仲裁,或承认与执行将违背中国公共政策,亦可拒绝。中国法院对公共政策例外作限制解释,仅将其局限于中国法律最根本的原则与基本社会公益,绝非债务人可随意借用的逃逸通道。

逐级报核制度

中国裁决执行中最具特色的一项制度,或许是逐级报核制度。鉴于地方法院曾对本地债务人表现出保护主义倾向,最高人民法院要求:凡拟拒绝承认与执行外国裁决的中级法院,须先报所在高级人民法院;若高级人民法院同意,还须进一步层报最高人民法院,且其决定对下级法院具有约束力。未经最高人民法院核准,不得作出不予承认执行的裁定。

对于非涉外(即内国仲裁审查)的仲裁司法审查事项,最高人民法院后续精简了报核层级:此类案件通常仅层报高级人民法院,不再要求最高人民法院核准。相比之下,外国裁决的执行轨道保留了完整的”高院—最高院”两级上核。

最高人民法院统一审查标准的举措

为遏制各地尺度不一,最高人民法院采取了多项举措:

  • 《全国法院涉外商事海事审判工作座谈会会议纪要》,系统梳理了承认与执行外国仲裁裁决的司法观点。
  • 仲裁领域的指导性案例,对下级法院具有拘束力,并示范第五条抗辩应如何适用。
  • 中英双语的《中国国际商事仲裁司法审查年度报告》,以中英文发布典型案例并阐释法院推理。
  • 中国有24篇适用《纽约公约》的案例被联合国国际贸易法委员会 CLOUT(贸法会法规判例法)数据库收录。

上述举措共同提升了可预见性,并压缩了债务人借地方保护获取第五条异议支持的空间。

外资企业的实操清单

对于可能在中国内地执行或抗拒外国裁决的外商投资企业,以下步骤能改善结果:

  • 为执行阶段拟定仲裁条款。 将仲裁地固定为《纽约公约》缔约国,指定中立机构,并避免模糊的仲裁地措辞。切记:决定《纽约公约》是否适用的,是仲裁地,而非机构或规则。
  • 预设送达地址并留痕。 在合同与仲裁程序中嵌入清晰的送达地址与可靠通知渠道,并保留每一次送达记录。干净完整的记录,能在异议提出前就击破”未获适当通知”的抗辩。
  • 摸清资产并把握保全时点。 在仲裁前与仲裁中,梳理债务人位于中国内地的银行账户、股权与不动产。中国法院在实践中已就境外仲裁地仲裁准予临时财产保全;及早申请,可在裁决终局前冻结资产。
  • 善用和解窗口。 在裁决作出后至执行前,乃至承认与执行程序进行中,结构化和解有时价值高于对抗式执行一个资产匮乏的债务人。

相关阅读

可参阅本站 CIETAC 国际仲裁(编号40)、最高人民法院与国际商事法庭 CICC(编号185),以及2026年《仲裁法》修订(编号166)。

Sources

China’s Revised Arbitration Law (2026): what foreign parties and FIEs need to know

  • China’s Arbitration Law has been comprehensively revised for the first time since 1994: the new law was passed on 12 September 2025, promulgated by Presidential Order No. 54, and takes effect on 1 March 2026 with eight chapters and 96 articles.
    中国《仲裁法》迎来 1994 年以来首次全面修订:新法于 2025 年 9 月 12 日通过,以第 54 号主席令公布,自 2026 年 3 月 1 日起施行,共八章 96 条。
  • The revision introduces the “seat of arbitration” (仲裁地) concept aligned with international practice — the seat determines the law governing the arbitral procedure and the courts with supervisory jurisdiction, so foreign parties should now state it expressly in their clauses.
    修订引入与国际接轨的”仲裁地”制度——仲裁地决定仲裁程序适用法及行使司法监督权的法院,外方当事人今后应在仲裁条款中明确约定。
  • A new “special (ad hoc) arbitration” regime lets parties in foreign-related maritime disputes, or between enterprises registered in a Free Trade Zone or the Hainan Free Trade Port, choose a tribunal outside any institution — a first for the mainland.
    新增”特别仲裁”(临时仲裁)制度:涉外海事纠纷,或自贸试验区、海南自贸港内登记企业之间的涉外纠纷,当事人可在仲裁机构之外自组仲裁庭——系内地首创。
  • Foreign arbitration institutions may now set up business offices in FTZs and Hainan to conduct foreign-related arbitration, and Chinese institutions may handle international investment (treaty) arbitration.
    境外仲裁机构今后可在自贸区、海南自贸港等区域设立业务机构办理涉外仲裁,中国仲裁机构亦可办理国际投资(条约)仲裁案件。
  • Online arbitration is expressly recognised — proceedings may be conducted over the internet unless a party objects — reflecting practice where 93 institutions handled online cases worth ¥300 billion in 2024.
    在线仲裁获明文确认——除当事人明确不同意外,仲裁可通过信息网络在线进行——呼应 2024 年 93 家机构在线办案、标的额 3000 亿元的实践。
  • Court support is strengthened: parties can seek pre-arbitration property, conduct and evidence preservation, courts must handle preservation promptly, and the period to apply to set aside an award is cut from six months to three.
    法院支持力度加大:当事人可申请仲裁前的财产、行为与证据保全,法院应及时处理保全,申请撤销裁决的期限由六个月缩短为三个月。
  • The law adds a good-faith principle and anti-sham-arbitration rules, an arbitrator disclosure system, and defines arbitration institutions as public-interest non-profit legal persons.
    新法增设诚信原则与防范虚假仲裁规定、仲裁员信息披露制度,并明确仲裁机构为公益性非营利法人。

China’s Revised Arbitration Law (2026): what foreign parties and FIEs need to know | 中国修订《仲裁法》(2026 年施行):外方当事人与外资企业须知

Overview

Arbitration is the default forum for cross-border commercial disputes: it is confidential, final in a single instance, and — thanks to the 1958 New York Convention — enforceable in over 170 jurisdictions. For a foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) or an overseas counterparty contracting with a Chinese business, the arbitration clause is often the single most important dispute-resolution decision in the contract.

On 12 September 2025 the Standing Committee of the 14th National People’s Congress passed a comprehensively revised Arbitration Law. It was promulgated by Presidential Order No. 54 and takes effect on 1 March 2026. This is the first full overhaul since the original 1994 statute (in force from 1995). The new law runs to eight chapters and 96 articles — 16 more than before — and is squarely aimed at raising the credibility and international competitiveness of Chinese arbitration. This article explains the changes that matter most to foreign parties. It is general information, not legal advice.

Why the revision, and how big it is

By August 2025 China had 285 arbitration commissions handling disputes involving parties from more than 100 countries and regions, across finance, e-commerce, construction, maritime and intellectual property. The 1994 law, however, predated modern practice: it did not recognise a “seat” of arbitration, permitted only institutional arbitration (no ad hoc tribunals), and said little about online hearings or interim relief. The revision closes those gaps and consciously converges with the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration.

Change 1 — the “seat of arbitration”

The headline reform for international users is the introduction of the seat (仲裁地). Except where the parties have agreed otherwise on the law applicable to the procedure, the seat now determines both the procedural law and the court that exercises supervisory jurisdiction (for interim measures, set-aside and the like). Where parties do not agree the seat, it is fixed by the agreed arbitration rules; if the rules are silent, the tribunal designates it by reference to the principle of convenient dispute resolution. Practical effect: foreign parties should state the seat expressly — e.g. “the seat of arbitration shall be Shanghai” — separately from the hearing venue, because the two are now distinct legal concepts.

Change 2 — special (ad hoc) arbitration

The mainland has, until now, recognised only institutional arbitration. The new law adds a “special arbitration” regime with four defining features:

  • Eligible cases only. It is limited to foreign-related disputes — either foreign-related maritime disputes, or foreign-related disputes between enterprises registered in a State Council-approved Free Trade Zone, the Hainan Free Trade Port, or other areas designated by the State.
  • Written agreement, seat in China. The parties must agree in writing and designate a place in China as the seat, so Chinese arbitration law applies, the award is a Chinese award, and Chinese courts conduct judicial review.
  • Qualified arbitrators. The tribunal members must meet the statutory qualification requirements for arbitrators.
  • Filing. Within three working days of forming the tribunal, the parties must file details (names, seat, tribunal composition, rules) with the arbitration association.

For FTZ and Hainan-registered FIEs, this opens a genuinely new option for disputes with foreign counterparties — closer to the flexibility of ad hoc arbitration abroad, but with defined guardrails.

Change 3 — opening to foreign institutions and investment arbitration

The law codifies two opening measures already piloted: it supports Chinese institutions “going out” to establish offices abroad, and permits overseas arbitration institutions to establish business offices in FTZs and the Hainan FTP to conduct foreign-related arbitration. It also confirms that Chinese institutions and tribunals may administer international investment arbitration under the relevant investment treaties and the rules agreed by the disputing parties — a foundation for China to position itself as a seat for investor-state cases.

Change 4 — online arbitration and stronger court support

Two further reforms speak directly to efficiency:

  • Online arbitration. Article 11 provides that arbitration may be conducted online through information networks unless a party expressly disagrees. This reflects reality: in 2024, 93 institutions handled online cases worth ¥300 billion.
  • Interim measures and evidence. The law aligns with the Civil Procedure Law so that, in urgent cases, a party may apply to a court for property preservation, conduct preservation (an order requiring or prohibiting an act) and evidence preservation before commencing arbitration. Courts must handle such applications promptly, whether relayed by the institution or filed directly. The tribunal may also request relevant parties to assist in collecting evidence.

Change 5 — credibility, disclosure and a shorter set-aside window

Several provisions raise trust in the process and speed up finality:

  • Arbitration must follow the good-faith principle, with new rules against sham arbitration.
  • Arbitrators must disclose any circumstances that could give rise to reasonable doubts about their independence or impartiality; the institution informs the parties.
  • The methods for recognising an arbitration agreement are broadened (e.g. where one party asserts an agreement and the other does not deny it before the first hearing).
  • The period to apply to set aside an award is shortened from six months to three months.
  • Arbitration institutions are defined as public-interest, non-profit legal persons, with the State Council authorised to issue registration rules.

What this means for foreign investors and FIEs

  • Review your arbitration clauses. State the institution (or, if eligible, ad hoc arbitration), the seat, the rules and the language. Distinguish seat from hearing venue.
  • Consider ad hoc arbitration only if eligible — maritime, or FTZ/Hainan-registered enterprises in foreign-related disputes.
  • Plan for interim relief. Pre-arbitration preservation is now clearer; identify assets and evidence early.
  • Diarise the three-month set-aside window — challenges must move faster than before.
  • Enforcement. Awards seated in China are Chinese awards; foreign awards continue to be recognised and enforced through the New York Convention and the Civil Procedure Law’s judicial-assistance provisions.

What to do next

  1. Audit existing China-related contracts and update dispute-resolution clauses ahead of the 1 March 2026 effective date.
  2. Decide seat and institution deliberately; do not leave the seat undefined.
  3. If you operate in an FTZ or Hainan, evaluate whether special arbitration suits your commercial relationships.
  4. Brief your legal and finance teams on the shorter set-aside period and the strengthened interim-measures toolkit.
  5. Confirm specifics with qualified PRC counsel before signing or amending clauses.

Sources

  • Ministry of Justice press conference on the revised Arbitration Law (official): https://www.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbgw/sfbxwfbhzb/2025nsfbfbh/acf20250925/?CTPIC=ecc680
  • MOJ briefing transcript — key changes and special arbitration explained: https://www.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbgw/sfbxwfbhzb/2025nsfbfbh/acf20250925/mtgz20250925/202509/t20250930_525844.html
  • Supreme People’s Court International Commercial Court — Q&A on the revision (People’s Court Daily): https://cicc.court.gov.cn/html/1/218/149/156/12620.html
  • China Court Net — commentary on the revised Arbitration Law: https://www.chinacourt.org/article/detail/2025/09/id/8991625.shtml
  • MOJ feature — “Advancing high-quality development of arbitration” (on the law’s entry into force): http://legalinfo.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbzhfx/zt/2025nzt0120/xcgvxxddzcf/202603/t20260302_532106.html

Related reading

  • CIETAC & international arbitration — 贸仲与涉外仲裁
  • Enforcing foreign arbitral awards and judgments in China — 在中国承认与执行外国仲裁裁决和判决
  • Foreign-related dispute resolution: litigation vs arbitration — 涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁

中国修订《仲裁法》(2026 年施行):外方当事人与外资企业须知

概述

仲裁是跨境商事纠纷的首选解决方式:保密、一裁终局,并且凭借 1958 年《纽约公约》可在 170 多个法域获得承认与执行。对与中国企业签约的外资企业或境外交易对手而言,仲裁条款往往是合同中最重要的一项争议解决安排。

2025 年 9 月 12 日,十四届全国人大常委会表决通过全面修订的《仲裁法》,以第 54 号主席令公布,自 2026 年 3 月 1 日起施行。这是 1994 年原法(1995 年施行)以来的首次全面修订。新法共八章 96 条,比修订前增加 16 条,核心目标是提升中国仲裁的公信力与国际竞争力。本文说明对外方当事人最重要的变化,仅为一般性信息,非法律意见。

为什么修、改动有多大

截至 2025 年 8 月,全国依法设立 285 家仲裁委员会,当事人涉及 100 多个国家和地区,纠纷涵盖金融、电子商务、建筑工程、海事海商、知识产权等领域。但 1994 年的仲裁法落后于现代实践:不承认”仲裁地”,只允许机构仲裁(无临时仲裁庭),对在线开庭与临时措施着墨极少。此次修订弥补了这些空白,并有意与《联合国国际商事仲裁示范法》相融通。

变化一——”仲裁地”制度

对国际用户而言,最重磅的改革是引入”仲裁地”。除当事人对仲裁程序适用法另有约定外,仲裁地现同时决定程序适用法与行使司法监督权的法院(保全、撤销等)。当事人未约定仲裁地的,按约定的仲裁规则确定;规则没有规定的,由仲裁庭按便利争议解决原则确定。实务影响: 外方应在条款中明确约定仲裁地——例如”仲裁地为上海”——并与开庭地相区分,因为二者现已是不同的法律概念。

变化二——特别仲裁(临时仲裁)

内地此前只承认机构仲裁。新法增设”特别仲裁”制度,有四个特征:

  • 仅限特定案件。 限于涉外纠纷——涉外海事纠纷,或在国务院批准设立的自贸试验区、海南自贸港及国家规定的其他区域内登记的企业之间发生的涉外纠纷。
  • 书面约定、仲裁地在中国。 当事人须书面约定并选择中国境内地点为仲裁地,从而适用中国仲裁法、裁决为中国裁决、由中国法院进行司法审查。
  • 仲裁员合格。 仲裁庭成员须符合仲裁法关于仲裁员资格的统一要求。
  • 备案。 组庭后三个工作日内,须将当事人名称、仲裁地、仲裁庭组成、仲裁规则向仲裁协会备案。

对自贸区和海南登记的外资企业,这为与外方对手的纠纷开辟了全新选项——更接近境外临时仲裁的灵活度,又设有明确边界。

变化三——向境外机构与投资仲裁开放

新法将两项试点措施法制化:支持中国仲裁机构”走出去”到境外设立业务机构,允许境外仲裁机构在自贸区、海南自贸港等区域设立业务机构办理涉外仲裁。同时明确,中国仲裁机构、仲裁庭可依据有关投资条约、协定并按争议双方约定的仲裁规则办理国际投资仲裁案件——为中国打造投资者—国家案件仲裁地奠定基础。

变化四——在线仲裁与更强的法院支持

另有两项改革直指效率:

  • 在线仲裁。 第十一条规定,除当事人明确表示不同意外,仲裁活动可通过信息网络在线进行。这呼应现实:2024 年 93 家机构办理在线案件,标的额 3000 亿元。
  • 临时措施与证据。 新法与《民事诉讼法》衔接:情况紧急时,当事人可在申请仲裁前向法院申请财产保全、行为保全(责令作出或禁止某行为)与证据保全。无论由机构转交还是当事人直接提交,法院都应及时处理。仲裁庭亦可请求有关方面协助收集证据。

变化五——公信力、披露与更短的撤销期限

多项条款提升过程可信度并加快终局:

  • 仲裁应遵循诚信原则,增设防范虚假仲裁规定。
  • 仲裁员须披露可能导致对其独立性、公正性产生合理怀疑的情形,由机构告知当事人。
  • 扩大仲裁协议的认定方式(如一方主张有协议、另一方在首次开庭前不予否认的)。
  • 申请撤销裁决的期限由六个月缩短为三个月。
  • 明确仲裁机构为公益性非营利法人,授权国务院制定登记管理办法。

对外资投资者与外资企业的意义

  • 审查你的仲裁条款。 明确机构(或在符合条件时选择临时仲裁)、仲裁地、规则和语言,并区分仲裁地与开庭地。
  • 仅在符合条件时考虑临时仲裁——涉外海事,或自贸区/海南登记企业的涉外纠纷。
  • 提前谋划临时救济。 仲裁前保全更清晰,尽早锁定资产与证据。
  • 牢记三个月撤销窗口——异议须比以往更快启动。
  • 执行。 仲裁地在中国的裁决为中国裁决;外国裁决继续通过《纽约公约》与《民事诉讼法》司法协助条款获得承认与执行。

下一步建议

  1. 在 2026 年 3 月 1 日生效前,梳理现有涉华合同并更新争议解决条款;
  2. 审慎确定仲裁地与机构,切勿让仲裁地处于未约定状态;
  3. 若在自贸区或海南经营,评估特别仲裁是否契合你的商业关系;
  4. 就更短的撤销期限与增强的保全工具,向法务与财务团队做说明;
  5. 签署或修订条款前,与执业中国律师确认具体事项。

Sources

  • 司法部关于新修订仲裁法的新闻发布会(官方):https://www.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbgw/sfbxwfbhzb/2025nsfbfbh/acf20250925/?CTPIC=ecc680
  • 司法部发布会实录——主要修改与特别仲裁制度解读:https://www.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbgw/sfbxwfbhzb/2025nsfbfbh/acf20250925/mtgz20250925/202509/t20250930_525844.html
  • 最高人民法院国际商事法庭——仲裁法修订答记者问(人民法院报):https://cicc.court.gov.cn/html/1/218/149/156/12620.html
  • 中国法院网——新修订仲裁法评论:https://www.chinacourt.org/article/detail/2025/09/id/8991625.shtml
  • 司法部专题——《推进新时代仲裁事业高质量发展》(写在实施之际):http://legalinfo.moj.gov.cn/pub/sfbzhfx/zt/2025nzt0120/xcgvxxddzcf/202603/t20260302_532106.html

相关阅读

  • 贸仲与涉外仲裁 / CIETAC & international arbitration
  • 在中国承认与执行外国仲裁裁决和判决 / Enforcing foreign arbitral awards and judgments
  • 涉外争议解决:诉讼与仲裁 / Foreign-related dispute resolution

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China

  • Article 27 of the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch treats workers used in the form of dispatch under the name of contracting or outsourcing as dispatched workers, and applies the dispatch rules to them.
    《劳务派遣暂行规定》第27条规定,用人单位以承揽、外包等名义、按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照该规定处理。
  • Once an outsourcing arrangement is pierced, the client is pulled back under the very “three-nature” post restriction and 10% headcount cap it was trying to avoid.
    外包一旦被穿透,发包方将重新落入其试图规避的三性岗位限制与10%用工比例上限。
  • Chinese courts apply substantive review and ask one question first: does the client exercise dominant labour management over the workers?
    中国法院坚持实质审查原则,首要审查发包方是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。
  • At its 16 July 2026 briefing on disguised-employment disputes, the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing reported that confirming an employment relationship, or holding the enterprise liable as employer, is the common outcome.
    北京市房山区人民法院2026年7月16日涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议通报指出,最终确认劳动关系或判令企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。
  • Representative offices of foreign enterprises are exempt from the three-nature and 10% limits under Article 25; WFOEs and joint ventures are not.
    依第25条,外国企业常驻代表机构使用被派遣劳动者不受三性岗位与10%比例限制;外商独资企业与合资企业并无此项豁免。
  • Piercing carries joint and several liability, plus fines of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker where a breach is not remedied within the ordered period.
    穿透后产生连带赔偿责任,逾期不改正的还将按每人5000元以上1万元以下的标准处以罚款。
  • The cure lies in substance, not the title: price by deliverable, manage the task rather than the person, and let the contractor supply tools, discipline and payroll.
    整改的关键在实质而非名称:按成果计价、”对事不对人”地行使管理权、由承包方配置生产资料并独立承担用工义务。

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China | 外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

Overview: the cap that pushes employers into outsourcing

A foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) needing flexible headcount meets two hard limits at once. Article 3 of the *Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 22, effective 1 March 2014) confines dispatched workers to temporary, auxiliary or substitute posts; Article 4 caps them at 10% of total headcount, counting direct-contract employees plus dispatched workers.

The response is predictable: rather than shrink the dispatched population, rename it. The dispatch agreement becomes a “service outsourcing” agreement, the workers stay at the same desks under the same supervisors, and the 10% calculation appears to reset to zero. That is what Article 27 exists to defeat.

Article 27: the anti-circumvention clause

Article 27 is one sentence: where an employing entity uses workers in the form of labour dispatch under the name of contracting, outsourcing or the like, the matter shall be handled in accordance with these Provisions.

The consequence is total. A relabelled arrangement does not merely lose its outsourcing character; it falls under the entire dispatch regime — three-nature posts, the 10% cap, the licence requirement, equal pay for equal work, the thirteen mandatory terms of Article 7, the three return grounds of Article 12, and joint liability under Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law*. An employer that changed the label to escape one rule inherits all of them, years later, with no records built to satisfy them.

Six dimensions that separate outsourcing from dispatch

The *Shanxi Province Guidelines on Labour Dispatch* (April 2026) draw the distinction across six dimensions — a useful audit grid, because it tracks what an inspector or judge tests.

DimensionLabour dispatchGenuine service outsourcing
Supplier qualificationDispatch Operation Licence requiredNo special licence
Post restrictionTemporary, auxiliary or substitute onlyNone
PartiesThree: agency, client, workerTwo: principal and contractor
Management authorityClient manages the workers directlyPrincipal does not manage them
PricingBy headcount and working timeBy completion of the work
Governing lawLabour contract legislationThe Civil Code

Where the contractor’s workers take instructions from the principal, work to the principal’s arrangements, or provide labour in the principal’s name, the Guidelines warn the arrangement may be treated as dispatch, with liability allocated accordingly.

Substantive review: the 2026 cases

On 16 July 2026 the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing briefed the press on model disguised-employment disputes. Spokesperson Ma Yanjia described the pattern: enterprises sign agreements under different names and build multi-layered engagement chains, packaging what is properly an employment relationship as contracting, outsourcing or cooperation. The court applies a substantive review principle, asking whether the enterprise exercises dominant labour management over the worker. Confirming an employment relationship, or imposing employer liability, was the common outcome.

“We manage them, the outsourcer pays them.” A courier company’s outsourcing fee comprised commission, a management service fee, taxes and rebates — with the service fee set at zero. Its station manager ran attendance in a WeChat group, pay flowed from the courier company’s own funds, and the app showed riders as its staff. The consideration was implausibly low and the structure suggested avoidance of employment status and transfer of commercial risk: the employment relationship lay with the courier company.

A contracting agreement over real employment. Another agreement cast riders as individual business operators paid by a platform — yet the company set shifts, controlled order volume and could assign orders individually. However an agreement is dressed, where the substance matches employment, a de facto relationship is recognised.

Outsourcing in name, dispatch in fact. Company A employed a worker and placed him in sales at Company B under a “labour outsourcing cooperation agreement” by which A would second personnel to B. He worked on B’s premises under B’s direction, with pay and benefits confirmed, settled and paid by B — a textbook “fake outsourcing, real dispatch”. After B returned him, A terminated him for serious misconduct; because B could not evidence that the return followed the agreed procedure, A paid damages for unlawful termination. After a return, the agency must independently verify a statutory ground for termination.

Why FIEs sit closer to the line

Article 25 grants an exemption most FIEs do not have. Representative offices of foreign enterprises and of foreign financial institutions — and employers of international seafarers — are not subject to the three-nature restriction or the dispatch ratio. That is structural, not a privilege: an RO cannot employ Chinese staff directly and can only staff itself through dispatch. WFOEs and joint ventures get nothing of the kind. Fully bound by Articles 3 and 4, they are the ones reaching for outsourcing — and the ones exposed to piercing.

Multi-city footprints add a second trap: under Articles 18 and 19, cross-region dispatch requires social insurance enrolment in the client’s locality, and where the agency has no branch there, the client enrols and pays on its behalf.

What piercing costs

Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law* requires rectification, with a fine of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker if it is not made in time, and Article 92(2) imposes joint and several liability on agency and client for loss caused to a dispatched worker; Shanxi treats them as co-parties in dispatch disputes. Article 22 of the Interim Provisions separately allows rectification orders and warnings where auxiliary posts were set without the democratic procedure — staff or employee-congress discussion, equal consultation with the union, and internal publication. Because Article 57 makes dispatch a licensed business, an “outsourcer” usually holds no licence, so piercing converts the arrangement into unlicensed dispatch. Port operators bound by both red lines are already converting non-compliant dispatch into structured outsourcing.

Rebuilding the arrangement so it survives review

  1. From people to work product. Contract for a defined deliverable, not the labour of named individuals; drop “project personnel” for “service team”.
  2. Manage the task, not the person. Remove the principal’s attendance, appraisal and disciplinary power over individuals; keep work rules in the contractor’s system; equipment should be the contractor’s.
  3. Pay for outcomes. Delete per-head pricing and line items for management fees, social insurance, salary and income tax; tie milestones to delivery and acceptance, not to “payable monthly”.
  4. Harden the liability allocation. The contractor alone bears employment contracting, wages, social insurance and work-injury liability; the principal accepts only the work product, against written confirmation that those obligations have been met.

What to do next

  1. Map the population. Count direct employees, dispatched workers and every outsourced head on your premises. If that group were pierced tomorrow, would you be within 10%, and would the posts be temporary, auxiliary or substitute?
  2. Test each supplier against the six dimensions. Pricing basis and management authority decide most cases.
  3. Do supplier due diligence. Verify the Dispatch Operation Licence and its validity — licensing authorities must publish the licensed-agency list and any change, revocation or cancellation — and the RMB 2 million minimum registered capital under Article 7 of the *Administrative Licensing Measures for Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 19, effective 1 July 2013). Never accept a human resources service licence as a substitute.
  4. Audit the evidence trail, not just the contract. Where the paper says outsourcing and the group chat says supervision, the group chat wins.
  5. Fix the democratic procedure for auxiliary posts, and never assume a group RO’s Article 25 exemption travels to the WFOE.
  6. Plan the return route in advance. Returns are limited to the three Article 12 grounds, and workers protected by Article 42 of the *Labour Contract Law* cannot be returned on objective-change or redundancy grounds before the dispatch term expires.

外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

概览:把雇主推向外包的比例上限

需要弹性用工的外商投资企业会同时撞上两道硬约束。《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源和社会保障部令第22号,2014年3月1日施行)第3条规定,用工单位只能在临时性、辅助性或者替代性岗位上使用被派遣劳动者;第4条规定被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量的10%,用工总量为订立劳动合同人数与使用的被派遣劳动者人数之和。

企业的反应可以预见:不是压减派遣人数,而是改换名称。派遣协议改签为”服务外包”协议,劳动者仍在原岗位、由原主管指挥,10%的计算似乎归零。第27条正是为了打掉这一操作而设。

第27条:反规避条款

第27条只有一句话:用人单位以承揽、外包等名义,按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照本规定处理。

后果是整体性的。被重新贴标签的安排不只是失去外包属性,而是整体落入派遣规则体系——三性岗位、10%比例、供应商许可、同工同酬、第7条协议13项必备条款、第12条仅有的三种退回情形,以及《劳动合同法》第92条的连带责任。为规避一条规则而改名的雇主,往往在数年后一次性承受全部规则,且手中没有任何为满足这些规则而准备的材料。

区分外包与派遣的六个维度

2026年4月印发的《山西省劳务派遣用工指引》从六个维度系统区分二者,可直接用作自查表,因为它对应的正是监察人员或法官实际审查的内容。

维度劳务派遣真实的服务外包
主体资质须取得《劳务派遣经营许可证》无特殊资质要求
岗位限制仅限临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位无岗位限定
法律关系三方:派遣单位、用工单位、劳动者两方:发包方与承包方
管理权限用工单位直接管理劳动者发包方不管理承包方员工
费用结算按人数与工作时间结算按业务完成情况结算
法律适用劳动合同相关法律法规《民法典》

指引提示:承包单位劳动者若接受发包企业指挥管理、按发包企业安排提供劳动,或以发包企业名义提供劳动,该安排可能被认定为劳务派遣,并据此确定发包单位与外包单位的法律责任。

实质审查:2026年的案例

2026年7月16日,北京市房山区人民法院召开涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议纠纷典型案例新闻通报会。新闻发言人马艳佳指出的模式是:企业通过签订不同名目的协议,设计多层用工链条,将本应属于劳动关系的情况包装成承揽、外包、合作等其他法律关系。法院坚持实质审查原则,重点审查企业是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。从审理结果看,最终确认存在劳动关系或判决企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。

“自己管人、外包发钱”。 某快递公司的外包费用由佣金、管理服务费、税费及返费构成,其中管理服务费为0。站长在微信群中监督骑手考勤,报酬资金来自快递公司,APP显示骑手为该公司员工。合同对价明显偏低,结构上存在规避劳动关系、转嫁商业风险之嫌,法院认定劳动关系存在于快递公司与劳动者之间。

以承揽合同行用工之实。 另一份协议约定骑手作为个体工商户承揽配送、由第三方平台付酬,但公司对其排班、控制接单量并可单独派单。即便披上承揽外衣,只要用工实质符合劳动关系,即认定为事实劳动关系。

名为外包实为派遣。 甲公司与劳动者签订劳动合同并安排其至乙公司任销售,甲乙之间的《劳务外包合作协议》约定由甲向乙派驻人员。该劳动者在乙公司场所、受乙公司管理指挥,工资福利由乙公司确认、结算和支付——属典型的“假外包、真派遣”。乙公司退回后,甲公司径行以严重违纪解除劳动合同;因乙公司未能提交充分证据证明退回符合约定的处罚程序,甲公司被判支付违法解除劳动关系赔偿金。退回之后,派遣单位须独立审查是否符合法定解除情形,不能被动接受用工单位的退回决定。

外资企业为何更接近红线

第25条给予的豁免,多数外资企业并不享有。 外国企业常驻代表机构、外国金融机构驻华代表机构,以及以派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的船员用人单位,不受三性岗位和劳务派遣用工比例的限制。这是制度配套而非优惠:代表处本身不能直接与中国员工建立劳动关系,只能通过派遣用工。外商独资企业与合资企业则完全没有该项豁免,须完整遵守第3条与第4条——这正是不少外资雇主转向”外包”的动因,也正是其穿透风险的来源。

多城市布点还带来第二重风险。依第18、19条,跨地区派遣应在用工单位所在地参加社会保险;派遣单位在当地未设分支机构的,由用工单位代为办理参保、缴费。

被穿透的代价

《劳动合同法》第92条规定责令改正,逾期不改的按每人5000元以上1万元以下处以罚款;第92条第2款规定,用工单位给被派遣劳动者造成损害的,派遣单位与用工单位承担连带赔偿责任,山西的指引亦明确二者在派遣争议中为共同当事人。《劳务派遣暂行规定》第22条另行规定,辅助性岗位未经民主程序(职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表平等协商、并在单位内公示)确定的,责令改正、给予警告。由于《劳动合同法》第57条将劳务派遣设为许可经营事项,被当作”外包方”引入的供应商通常并无该许可,穿透之后即转化为无证派遣。受双重红线约束的港口企业已开始将违规派遣转为规范化服务外包。

如何重构安排以经得起审查

  1. 从”对人”到”对事”。 约定特定的交付成果而非特定劳动者的劳务;避免”项目人员”等称谓,改用”服务团队””项目小组”。
  2. 管理权”对事不对人”。 删除发包方对劳动者个人的考勤、考核与处分条款;劳动纪律与考核标准独立于发包方制度体系;工作服装、电脑设备等生产资料原则上由承包方配置。
  3. 按成果付费。 删除按人头计价,以及管理费、社保公积金、薪资个税等人身性支出明细;付款节点与交付、验收挂钩,删除”按月支付”等按时间计费规则。
  4. 强化责任边界。 由承包方独立承担劳动合同签订、工资支付、社保缴纳与工伤赔偿等全部法定义务;发包方仅对成果验收,并可要求承包方提供已履行上述义务的书面确认作为验收前提。

下一步建议

  1. 先做人数盘点。 统计直接雇员、被派遣劳动者以及在本单位场所工作的全部外包人员。若外包人员明日被穿透,是否仍在10%以内?相关岗位是否属于三性?
  2. 用六个维度逐一检验供应商。 费用结算方式与管理权限是决定多数案件的两项。
  3. 做好供应商尽调。 核验《劳务派遣经营许可证》的真实性与有效期(许可机关应公示获证单位名单及变更、撤销、注销情况),并核对《劳务派遣行政许可实施办法》(人社部令第19号,2013年7月1日施行)第7条要求的注册资本不少于人民币200万元。切勿以”人力资源服务许可”替代劳务派遣经营许可。
  4. 审查证据链,而不只是合同。 当书面文件写着外包、微信群里却在下达管理指令时,微信群会胜出。
  5. 补齐辅助性岗位的民主程序,且不要假定集团代表处的第25条豁免可延伸至外商独资企业。
  6. 提前规划退回路径。 退回仅限第12条的三种情形,且属于《劳动合同法》第42条保护情形的劳动者,在派遣期限届满前不得以客观情况重大变化或经济性裁员为由退回。

Sources