Category Archives: Tax Compliance / 税务合规

China’s National Trustworthiness Incentive List: What the 2026 Edition Offers Compliant Foreign Firms

  • The National Development and Reform Commission and the People’s Bank of China issued the 2026 edition of the national trustworthiness incentive list on 9 November 2026 and published it the following day.
    国家发展改革委与中国人民银行于 2026 年 11 月 9 日联合印发《全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)》,次日公布。
  • The list is an incentive catalogue, not an entry threshold: every item names the trusted entities it covers, the department that recognises them and the body that delivers the benefit.
    这是一份激励目录,不是准入门槛:清单逐项写明激励对象、认定部门与实施主体。
  • Twenty-five categories of trusted entities are covered, spanning natural persons, enterprises, individual businesses and social organisations across market regulation, transport, tax, customs, industry and ecology.
    清单覆盖二十五类守信主体,包括自然人、企事业单位、个体工商户和社会组织,涉及市场监管、交通运输、税务、海关、工业、生态环境等领域。
  • More than two hundred measures fall into two families: administrative incentives such as green channels, notification and commitment, and lower inspection frequency, and social incentives such as faster airport screening, easier financial services and platform membership benefits.
    两百余项措施分为两类:一类是绿色通道、告知承诺制、降低抽查检查频次等行政化激励,一类是便捷乘机出行、便利金融服务、平台会员权益等社会化激励。
  • Item 3 covers trusted operators in the information and communications sector, is recognised by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, and opens the pilot notification and commitment route for Category II value-added telecom services in free trade zones.
    清单第 3 项针对信息通信行业守信经营主体,由工业和信息化部认定,其中包含自贸试验区第二类增值电信业务告知承诺试点这一通道。
  • The same item offers one-to-one credit cultivation for companies applying for AEO status with customs, with priority certification where other conditions are equal.
    同一项还为申请海关 AEO 资质的企业提供”一对一”信用培育支持,同等条件下优先认证。
  • Recognition in one system can count in another: an A-grade tax payment credit rating earns a credit bonus when a company is assessed for A-grade labour compliance.
    一个体系内的认定可以在另一个体系里加分:纳税缴费信用 A 级经营主体,在认定劳动保障守法诚信 A 级企业时可获信用加分。

China’s National Trustworthiness Incentive List: What the 2026 Edition Offers Compliant Foreign Firms | 全国守信激励措施基础清单:合规外资企业能从中得到什么

What the list is and is not

On 9 November 2026 the National Development and Reform Commission and the People’s Bank of China jointly issued the National Baseline List of Trustworthiness Incentive Measures (2026 Edition), numbered Fa Gai Cai Jin [2026] No. 1593. It was published the following day, on 10 November. The document is a catalogue, and the most useful thing to establish at the outset is what kind of catalogue it is, because the natural mistake is to read it as a list of permissions.

It is not a market access list. Nothing in it opens a sector, removes a licensing requirement or creates an entitlement to operate. Nor is it a whitelist in the sense that inclusion automatically produces a benefit. Each entry in the list identifies three things: the class of trusted entity the measure is aimed at, the department that recognises an entity as belonging to that class, and the body that actually delivers the measure. A company that reads its own business into an entry has learned that a route may exist. It has not travelled it. The route begins with recognition by the named department.

Nor is the list a statement of new policy in most cases. Much of what it contains describes treatment that already existed somewhere in the system — a green channel here, a reduced inspection frequency there — and the list’s contribution is to write it down in one place, at national level, in a comparable form. That is a modest kind of reform, and an easy one to underestimate. A benefit that exists in one province under one name and in another province under a different name is difficult for a company to plan around. A baseline list makes the benefit legible.

The reason a foreign-invested company should read it, despite its domestic framing, is that the underlying credit systems it draws on are ones foreign firms already inhabit. Customs recognises authorised economic operators. Tax authorities issue credit ratings. Market regulators classify entities by their compliance record. A foreign-invested manufacturer with an AEO certificate and an A-grade tax rating is already inside several of the recognition systems from which the list’s measures flow. What the list adds is a map of what those recognitions can be exchanged for.

The word “baseline” in the title does real work. It signals that the national list is a floor rather than a ceiling — the treatment that should be available to a trusted entity wherever it operates, with provinces and municipalities free to go further. For a company with operations in several places, that is the more useful construction. A single provincial programme tells you what one place offers; a baseline tells you what you can reasonably expect not to lose when you move.

It is also worth being precise about the word “incentive”. In ordinary commercial usage an incentive is something of value offered in exchange for behaviour. Here the measures are largely procedural: a faster channel, a lighter touch, a recognised status. They do not put money in a company’s account and they do not reduce a tax bill. What they do is reduce the cost of compliance — the hours, the waiting, the repeated demonstration of things already demonstrated. For a company whose Chinese operations are compliance-heavy, that is where the value sits, and it is easy to miss if you go looking for a financial benefit that is not there.

Who compiles and who delivers

The list was compiled by twenty departments and units working together. That number is worth pausing on, because it explains the document’s shape. A single ministry writing about its own incentives produces a short, deep document about one sector. Twenty bodies writing together produce a broad, shallow document that touches many sectors and goes into detail only where the compilers chose to. The breadth is the achievement; the shallowness is the price.

Delivery is a separate matter from compilation, and the list distinguishes them. Ten enterprises in aviation, finance and the internet sector participate in implementation. That is a departure from the purely administrative model in which a government body both promises and delivers. Some of the measures in the list are commercial in nature — faster screening at an airport, convenience in financial services, membership benefits on an internet platform — and only the firms that run those operations can actually provide them.

The practical consequence is that the list should be read as a description of what participating bodies have agreed to do, not as a guarantee that any particular counter will recognise it. An airline that participates in the arrangement delivers fast-track treatment within its own operations; it does not speak for every airport. A platform that participates delivers membership benefits on its own service; it does not bind its competitors. When a company plans around a social incentive, the question to ask is which participating entity actually touches its customers or employees.

There is a second consequence, less obvious but more important for compliance planning. Because compilation and delivery sit in different hands, an entity may satisfy the recognition test set by a department and still find that the delivering body has its own operational conditions. The recognition establishes eligibility; the delivering body establishes the terms. Both have to be satisfied, and they are not always documented in the same place.

The fact that twenty bodies had to agree is also, in a quiet way, the list’s main achievement. Each department guards its own assessment criteria and its own discretion, and coordination across that many of them means a series of compromises about how a category is described and how wide a measure is drawn. A reader who finds a provision vague should read the vagueness as the residue of that negotiation rather than as an oversight. It also means the list will move at the speed of its slowest member when revised, which is an argument for checking the annual edition rather than assuming continuity.

Twenty-five categories of trusted entities

The list covers twenty-five categories of trusted entities. The categories are not limited to companies: natural persons, enterprises, individual businesses and social organisations all appear. Nor are they confined to one regulatory domain. The coverage runs across market regulation, transport, tax, customs, industry and ecology, among other fields.

The breadth reflects how trustworthiness is actually assessed in China’s administrative system: sector by sector, by the regulator that holds the relevant file. There is no single national trust score that a company either has or lacks. There are records — inspection histories, filing accuracy, payment punctuality, licensing compliance — held by different bodies, each of which draws its own conclusions. The list works across those separate assessments rather than replacing them with one.

For a foreign-invested enterprise, the practical task is to identify which of the twenty-five categories its own operations place it in. That is not a question about ownership. The categories are defined by conduct and by sector, not by the nationality of the investor. A wholly foreign-owned manufacturer is assessed as a manufacturer; a foreign-invested logistics operator is assessed as a transport or logistics entity. What changes with foreign ownership is the surrounding licensing picture, not the trustworthiness test itself.

The more useful framing is to work backwards from the licences a company holds. Each licence implies a regulator, and each regulator maintains a compliance record and a set of classifications. Those classifications are the raw material from which recognition under the list is built. A company that maps its licences to regulators, and its regulators to entries in the list, will find that the exercise produces a short list of realistic opportunities rather than a long list of theoretical ones.

The presence of natural persons among the twenty-five categories is worth a moment, because it is the part of the list a corporate reader is most likely to skim. Some measures in the list are aimed at individuals rather than at entities, and those can matter for a foreign-invested employer in a mundane, practical way: the employees who travel most, and whose time is most expensive, are often the ones whose personal compliance record determines how smoothly they move through an airport. A group that manages mobility as a benefit rather than as a compliance question may be leaving something on the table.

The inclusion of individual businesses is a reminder of the list’s domestic base. A very large share of China’s service economy operates through individual businesses rather than companies, and a national baseline that ignored them would describe only part of the economy. For a foreign group, the relevance is indirect but real: franchise networks, service partners and last-mile operators in its supply chain may sit in that category, and their access to incentives affects the reliability of the network the group depends on.

Industry and ecology appear among the covered fields, which suggests that environmental compliance records feed into at least some of the categories. That is consistent with the wider direction of Chinese regulation, where environmental performance has become a mainstream input to credit assessment rather than a specialist concern. A manufacturer that has invested in its environmental record may find that the investment is legible in more places than it expected.

Two kinds of incentives

The measures in the list — more than two hundred of them — fall into two families. The distinction matters because the two are obtained and used in different ways.

Administrative incentives are delivered by government bodies and take the form of changed treatment in administrative processes. The list names several: honours and commendation, publicity and promotion, a bonus or an upgrade in public credit evaluation, availability of the notification and commitment model, a green channel for administrative matters, priority consideration in evaluations and selections, and reduced frequency of spot checks and inspections. These are reductions in friction. They do not remove an obligation; they change how often and how intrusively the obligation is verified.

Social incentives are delivered by the participating enterprises and take the form of commercial convenience. The list names convenient air travel, easier access to financial services, and membership benefits on internet platforms. These are consumer-facing and employee-facing benefits rather than regulatory ones, and their value depends entirely on which participating entity is involved and what it has agreed to offer.

Two cautions follow from the structure. The first is that reduced inspection frequency is not exemption from inspection. A company that reads a lower frequency as a licence to let standards slip has misread the measure; the underlying obligation is unchanged, and the consequence of a finding is unchanged. The second is that public credit evaluation bonuses are inputs to other assessments, not outputs in themselves. Their value is realised when the company applies for something else that uses the credit score as a criterion.

For a foreign-invested company, the administrative family is where the operational value sits. Green channels and notification and commitment shorten timelines on applications the company has to make anyway. Lower inspection frequency reduces disruption to production. Neither changes what the company is allowed to do, and both change how much of its week is spent demonstrating that it is allowed to do it.

To capture that value, the measures have to be attached to a calendar. A green channel is only useful to a company that knows which of its recurring applications can use it, and when those applications fall due. The exercise is to list the filings, registrations, renewals and inspections that recur over a year, and then to check each against the current edition of the list. What emerges is usually a small number of touchpoints where a recognised status converts into days saved, and a larger number where it does not apply at all.

There is a communications risk in the other direction. A company that announces that it is “on the national trustworthiness list” has said something the document does not support. The accurate statement is narrower and more useful: recognised by a named department as belonging to a named category of trusted entity, with access to named measures. Precision here is not pedantry. Buyers, banks and counterparties who check the claim will find the narrower version, and a company whose public statements match the document is easier to do business with than one whose statements have to be walked back.

The two families also differ in who inside the company owns them. Administrative incentives belong to the regulatory affairs or government relations function, which knows the filing calendar and the departmental contacts. Social incentives belong to whoever manages travel, treasury and customer relationships. A group that assigns the whole list to one team will usually find that half of it goes unused, not because the measures are unavailable but because the wrong people were looking at them.

The telecom and AEO provisions foreign firms should read

Item 3 of the list concerns trusted operators in the information and communications sector. The recognising department is the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology. For a foreign-invested company in telecoms, cloud or adjacent digital services, this is the entry that deserves the closest reading, because it touches two things such companies tend to care about: how quickly a licence application moves, and how the company is treated once it holds one.

The measure contains four elements. First, it applies to the pilot notification and commitment route for Category II value-added telecom services in free trade zones. Notification and commitment is a model in which the applicant files a statement and undertakes to comply, and the authority accepts the filing rather than conducting a full prior examination. Applied to Category II value-added services in the free trade zones, it shortens the front end of the process considerably — the applicant’s own undertaking does part of the work that a prior review would otherwise do.

Second, the measure provides for lower frequency of routine supervision and spot checks, or exemption from on-site inspection as circumstances warrant. The phrase “as circumstances warrant” carries the discretion; it is not an automatic entitlement, and a company should read it as a direction of travel rather than a fixed rule. Third, under equal conditions, priority is given in the allocation of communications resources, network access, telecom equipment network entry and tendering.

Fourth, and most cross-cutting, the measure provides one-to-one credit cultivation support for companies applying for AEO status with customs, with priority certification under equal conditions. This is the element that reaches beyond the telecoms sector in its logic: a recognition granted by the industry regulator becomes an input into a customs assessment. For a foreign-invested group that already holds AEO status in another jurisdiction and is building a Chinese application, the availability of structured cultivation support is a practical accelerant.

The qualifier “under equal conditions” appears twice, and it should not be read past. It means the measure breaks ties; it does not create a preference that overrides substantive criteria. A company that does not meet the underlying standard for AEO certification will not be certified because it is trusted in the telecoms sense. What it may get is a faster, better-supported route to demonstrating that it does meet the standard.

It is not an accident that telecoms is the sector where the list goes into this level of detail. Value-added telecom services have been among the areas where foreign investment has been permitted within the free trade zones, subject to licensing and to the conditions attached to the pilot. A sector with a live foreign-invested population, a licensing bottleneck at the front end and a supervisory relationship that continues after licensing is exactly where a trustworthiness incentive has something to bite on. The measure is written for companies that are already in the queue.

The order of operations matters. Recognition comes first, from the industry regulator; the measures follow. A company cannot invoke the notification and commitment route on the strength of having read the list. It becomes available once the company is recognised as a trusted operator in the sector, and that recognition depends on the company’s own compliance record with the regulator. The practical implication is that the work of qualifying is done long before an application is filed, in the ordinary course of keeping a clean record.

The AEO element deserves a note on sequencing too. Customs certification is a demanding process with its own criteria, its own documentation and its own assessment. The value of “one-to-one” cultivation support is that it shortens the period between deciding to apply and being ready to be assessed — it does not shorten the assessment itself, and it does not lower the bar. A group planning a Chinese AEO application should treat the support as a project accelerant rather than as a substitute for preparation.

Cross-departmental recognition in practice

The list’s most interesting structural feature is that recognition in one system can be used in another. The example the document gives is specific: an entity with an A-grade tax payment credit rating receives a credit bonus when it is assessed for recognition as an A-grade enterprise for labour compliance.

Read narrowly, that is one line item. Read structurally, it is a statement about how the credit architecture is being knitted together. Historically, a company’s tax record was relevant to the tax authority, its labour record to the human resources authority, its customs record to customs. Each body assessed on its own information. Cross-recognition means that a strong record in one place becomes visible, and valuable, in another.

For a group with multiple entities in China, this changes the calculus of compliance investment. Improving the tax credit rating of one subsidiary may produce benefits in assessments conducted by a different regulator entirely. The return on a compliance improvement is no longer confined to the relationship with the regulator that demanded it. That is an argument for treating credit management as a group-level function rather than a matter for each entity’s finance team.

The example also shows the limits of the mechanism. The tax rating produces a bonus in the labour assessment; it does not produce the labour recognition. The substantive conditions for A-grade labour compliance still have to be met, and the bonus operates at the margin — it can tip a close case, not carry a weak one. Companies that treat cross-recognition as a substitute for meeting the underlying standard will be disappointed, and may waste effort pursuing recognitions they cannot convert.

There is a further practical point about evidence. A cross-recognition works only if the second body can see the first body’s conclusion. That requires the company to be able to produce current evidence of its standing in the originating system, in a form the receiving body accepts. A credit rating that exists in a database the company cannot query is of limited use in an application elsewhere. Groups should be able to document their own standing, on demand, for each recognition they intend to rely on.

Group structure complicates this in a way that is worth planning for. Recognition attaches to a legal entity, not to a group. In a structure with a holding company, a manufacturing subsidiary, a trading company and a services company, the entity that holds the customs certification may not be the entity that holds the tax rating, and neither may be the entity that applies for the licence the group actually wants. Cross-recognition only helps where the recognitions and the application sit in the same entity, or where the receiving body accepts group-level evidence. Mapping which entity holds what is therefore the first step, and it is often the step that reveals the gap.

Annual review and what replaced the old memoranda

The list is updated annually. The compilers have committed to adjusting both the categories of trusted entities and the measures attached to them as laws and policies change. That is a meaningful design choice: a static list would drift out of alignment with the underlying regulations within a few years, and a list that is revised without a fixed rhythm is difficult for companies to track.

The 2026 edition also repealed five joint memoranda on trustworthiness incentives concluded between 2016 and 2018. Those memoranda were bilateral arrangements between pairs of departments, each covering a specific combination of recognition and reward. Replacing them with a single baseline list consolidates the landscape. Instead of tracking a handful of separate agreements, a company tracks one document, revised on a known cycle.

The repeal has a practical implication that is easy to miss. Guidance written around the old memoranda — internal compliance manuals, consultant notes, articles of the kind this one is — may still describe arrangements that no longer exist in that form. A company relying on a memorandum it remembers from several years ago should check whether the measure it describes now appears in the current list, and in what terms. The substance may have survived the consolidation; the instrument has not.

For planning purposes, the annual cycle suggests a simple discipline. Once a year, review which of the twenty-five categories the company plausibly falls into, which recognitions it currently holds, and which measures in the current edition it could actually use. The exercise is short if the company’s licence portfolio is stable, and revealing if it is not. It also produces the evidence file that cross-recognition depends on, as a by-product rather than as a separate project.

Two framing points are worth keeping in view throughout. First, the list rewards conduct, and conduct is something a company controls. Unlike a sectoral opening, which arrives on a schedule set by negotiators, a recognition under the list is earned through the company’s own record. Second, the list is a baseline, not a ceiling. Provincial and municipal programmes may offer more, and often do; the national list establishes the floor of comparable treatment rather than the full extent of what is available.

Where the list sits beside market access rules

The single most important thing to avoid is confusing this document with the rules that govern whether a foreign investor may enter a sector at all. Those rules live in separate instruments and are administered by separate processes. They determine the permitted scope of foreign ownership, the licensing requirements that attach to a given activity, and the conditions under which an application will be considered. The trustworthiness list does none of that.

The relationship between the two is sequential rather than substitutive. Access rules decide whether a company may hold a licence. The trustworthiness list decides how that company is treated once it holds one, and how quickly a further application is processed. A company that cannot obtain the licence will not obtain it by being trustworthy; a company that can obtain it may obtain it faster, and may be supervised more lightly afterwards.

Keeping the two apart matters for planning, because the two carry different kinds of uncertainty. Access rules change through published amendments, and their direction is visible in advance. Trustworthiness recognition depends on the company’s own record and on a departmental assessment, which means it is within the company’s influence but not within its control. A group that builds a China plan on the assumption that recognition will arrive on schedule is taking a risk it does not need to take; a group that builds the plan on the assumption that recognition may never arrive, and treats it as upside, is not.

There is one place where the two do intersect, and it is the reason the telecom item matters. Where a sector’s access route includes a notification and commitment model, the trustworthiness recognition determines whether a company can use that route. In that case the list is not merely about post-licensing treatment; it is about the shape of the application itself. That is the exception, and it is worth identifying clearly rather than generalising from.

The distinction also matters in transactions. A counterparty conducting diligence on a Chinese target will sometimes present a trustworthiness recognition as evidence that the business is properly licensed. It is not. A recognition speaks to conduct within a regulatory relationship; it says nothing about whether the underlying licence exists, covers the activity in question, or remains valid. Buyers should verify the licence independently and treat the recognition as a separate, and lesser, data point.

What a foreign group should review this year

The list is annual, so the review should be too. A short agenda, run once a year, is enough to keep a group from missing what the current edition offers.

Start with the licence portfolio. List every licence, registration and filing the Chinese entities hold, and the regulator behind each. This is the raw material for everything else, and it changes more often than groups expect — a new business line, a new site, an acquisition, and the portfolio has moved.

Then map the portfolio against the twenty-five categories. The aim is not to claim every category that might apply, but to identify the two or three where the company’s record is genuinely strong and where a recognition would be worth having. Chasing recognitions that lead nowhere is a common and expensive mistake.

Then check the current edition for measures attached to those categories, and test each against the company’s actual calendar. A measure that never coincides with a filing the company makes is of no practical value, however attractive it reads.

Then establish the evidence position. For each recognition the company holds, confirm that current proof can be produced on demand, in a form a receiving body will accept. For each recognition it wants, identify what the recognising department would need to see, and whether the company’s record already shows it.

Finally, note the date. The list is revised annually, and the edition that governs this year’s planning is not necessarily the edition that will govern next year’s. A review that runs on a fixed date each year, shortly after the new edition appears, is the simplest way to stay current without tracking every departmental announcement.

Sources

  • 国家发展改革委,《国家发展改革委、中国人民银行联合印发〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉》(发改财金〔2026〕1593 号),2026-11-09。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/tzgg/202611/t20261109_1408743.html
  • 国家发展改革委,《关于〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉的说明》,2026-11-10。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xxgk/zcfb/tz/202611/P020261110521301048830.pdf
  • 国家发展改革委,《全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)》正文,2026-11-10。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/tzgg/202611/P020261110521429669759.pdf
  • 央视网,《国家发展改革委负责同志就〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉答记者问》,2026-11-11。https://gongyi.cctv.com/2026/11/11/ARTIg5m10IKVdLbkUjy3BR7n261111.shtml

全国守信激励措施基础清单:合规外资企业能从中得到什么

这份清单是什么,不是什么

2026 年 11 月 9 日,国家发展改革委与中国人民银行联合印发《全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)》,文号为发改财金〔2026〕1593 号,次日即 11 月 10 日公布。这是一份目录,而读它之前最该弄清楚的,是它属于哪一类目录——因为最容易犯的错,是把它当成一份许可清单。

它不是市场准入清单。里面没有任何一条打开某个行业、取消某项许可要求,或者创设一项经营权利。它也不是那种”进了名单就自动享受待遇”的白名单。清单的每一条都写明三件事:措施针对的是哪一类守信主体、由哪个部门认定主体属于该类、由哪个主体实际实施这项措施。一家公司把自己的业务读进某一条,只是知道可能存在一条路,还没有走上去。路从认定部门作出认定那一刻才开始。

多数情况下,这份清单也不是新政策的宣告。它记载的许多内容,是系统里本来就存在的待遇——这里一条绿色通道,那里一次减少的检查——清单的贡献在于把它们写进同一份文件,放在国家层面,用可比较的形态呈现。这是一种温和的改革,也很容易被低估。同一项便利,在一个省叫一个名字、在另一个省叫另一个名字,企业就无法据此做计划;一份基础清单让这项便利变得可读。

之所以外资企业也该读它,是因为清单所依托的那些信用体系,外资企业本来就在其中。海关认定高级认证企业,税务部门给出纳税信用级别,市场监管部门按合规记录给主体分类。一家持 AEO 证书、纳税信用 A 级的外资制造企业,早已身处清单多项措施所流出的那几个认定体系之内。清单补上的,是一张地图:这些认定可以换到什么。

标题里的”基础”二字是有分量的。它表明国家清单是地板而不是天花板——守信主体无论在哪里经营都应当享有的待遇,省市两级可以在此基础上加码。对在多地布局的企业,这个构造更有用:一份省级方案告诉你一个地方给什么,一份基础清单告诉你,换一个地方时哪些东西不至于丢掉。

“激励”一词也值得说准。在通常的商业语境里,激励是指为换取某种行为而给出的有价值之物。而这里的措施大多是程序性的:更快的通道、更轻的监管、一个被承认的身份。它们不会往企业账上打钱,也不减免税款。它们做的是降低合规成本——工时、等待、以及把已经证明过的事情再证明一遍。对合规负担较重的在华业务而言,价值就在这里;如果一心想找一项财务上的好处,反而会错过它。

谁来编制,谁来实施

清单由二十个部门和单位共同编制。这个数字值得停一下,因为它解释了文件的形状。一个部委写自己的激励措施,会写出一份范围窄、挖得深的文件;二十个主体一起写,写出的是一份覆盖面宽、每处只到必要深度的文件。宽是成就,浅是代价。

实施与编制是两件事,清单把二者分开。航空、金融、互联网领域有十家企业参与实施。这与此前那种”政府既承诺又兑现”的纯行政模式不同。清单里有些措施本身是商业性的——机场快速安检、金融服务的便利、互联网平台的会员权益——只有经营这些业务的企业才真正提供得了。

由此产生一个实务上的后果:清单应当被读成”参与各方同意做什么”的说明,而不是”任何一个柜台都会认”的保证。参与安排的航空公司,在自己的运营范围内提供快捷通道,它代表不了所有机场;参与的平台,在自己服务内提供会员权益,它约束不了竞争对手。企业围绕一项社会化激励做安排时,该问的问题是:究竟是哪一个参与主体,真正接触到自己的客户或员工。

还有第二个后果,不那么显眼,但对合规规划更重要。编制与实施分处两手,意味着一家企业可能满足了部门设定的认定标准,却发现实施主体另有自己的操作条件。认定解决的是”有没有资格”,实施主体解决的是”按什么条款”。两者都要满足,而它们并不总写在同一个地方。

二十个主体必须达成一致,这件事本身也是清单的主要成就,只是不事声张。每个部门都守着自己的评价标准和裁量空间,这么多部门之间的协调,意味着一连串关于类别怎么描述、措施画多宽的妥协。读到某条写得笼统的读者,应当把这种笼统读成谈判的余留,而不是起草的疏漏。它也意味着清单修订时的推进速度取决于最慢的那个成员——这正是每年核对新版本、而不是假定内容延续的理由。

二十五类守信主体

清单覆盖二十五类守信主体。这些类别不限于企业:自然人、企事业单位、个体工商户、社会组织都在其中。它们也不局限于一个监管领域,而是横跨市场监管、交通运输、税务、海关、工业、生态环境等方面。

覆盖面之宽,反映的是中国行政体系认定守信的实际方式:一个领域一个领域地认定,由掌握相应档案的监管部门作出。并不存在一个统一的”全国信用分”,企业要么有、要么没有。存在的是分散在不同机构手里的记录——检查历史、备案准确度、缴款及时性、许可合规情况——各机构各自得出自己的结论。清单是在这些分散评价之间做工作,而不是用一套评价取代它们。

对外资企业来说,实务任务是判断自己的经营把自己放进了二十五类中的哪几类。这不是所有权问题。类别按行为与行业界定,不按投资者的国籍界定。外商独资的制造企业按制造企业评,外资参股的物流企业按交通运输或物流主体评。外资身份改变的是周边的许可图景,不是守信评价本身。

更有用的思路,是从企业持有的许可证件倒推。每一张许可证件对应一个监管部门,每个监管部门维护一份合规记录和一套分类。这些分类,就是清单认定所依据的原料。把许可证件对到部门、把部门对到清单条目,做完之后,企业得到的会是一份不长的、现实可行的机会清单,而不是一份很长的、理论上的可能性清单。

二十五类中有自然人,这一项值得停一下,因为企业读者最容易一眼扫过去。清单里有些措施是针对个人而不是针对单位的,对外资雇主来说,它的意义很朴素:出差最频繁、时间最贵的那些员工,往往正是其个人信用记录决定过关是否顺畅的那批人。把人员流动当福利来管、而不当合规事项来管的集团,可能正把一部分好处留在桌上。

个体工商户被纳入,是清单本土底色的一个提示。中国的服务业有相当大的比例通过个体工商户而非公司运营,一份忽略它们的国家级基础清单,只能描述经济的一部分。对外资集团而言,相关性是间接的,但确实存在:加盟网络、服务商、供应链末端的配送主体可能就落在这一类,它们能否获得激励,会影响集团所依赖的那张网络的可靠程度。

工业和生态环境被列入覆盖领域,说明环境合规记录至少进入了某些类别的认定。这与中国监管的整体走向一致:环境表现已经从专门事项变成了信用评价的常规输入。在环境记录上真正投入过的制造企业,可能会发现这项投入在比预想更多的地方被看见。

两类激励

清单里的措施超过两百项,分为两族。这个区分重要,因为两者的取得方式和使用方式不同。

行政化激励由政府机关实施,表现为行政流程中待遇的改变。清单点到的有:荣誉表彰、宣传推广、公共信用评价加分或提升等级、适用告知承诺制、行政事项办理绿色通道、评先评优优先考虑、降低抽查检查频次。这些是摩擦的减少,不是义务的免除;它们改变的是义务被核验的频率与强度。

社会化激励由参与实施的企业提供,表现为商业上的便利。清单点到的是便捷乘机出行、便利金融服务、互联网平台会员权益。这些面向消费者与员工,而非面向监管,其价值完全取决于涉及哪个参与主体、它承诺了什么。

由这个结构可以引出两点提醒。第一,降低抽查检查频次不等于免于检查。把”频次降低”读成”标准可以松”的企业读错了;底层义务没变,被查出问题后的后果也没变。第二,公共信用评价加分是其他评价的输入,不是结果本身。它的价值,要等到企业去申请另一件以信用分为条件的事情时才兑现。

对外资企业而言,操作价值主要落在行政化那一族。绿色通道与告知承诺制,缩短的是企业本来就要办的申请的时间;检查频次下降,减少的是对生产的打扰。两者都不改变企业可以做什么,改变的是它每周要花多少时间去证明自己可以做。

要把这层价值拿到手,措施必须挂到日历上。绿色通道只对”知道自己哪些常规申请用得上、什么时候到期”的企业有用。做法是把一年里重复发生的备案、登记、续期、检查列出来,再逐项对照现行清单。结果通常是这样:少数几个节点上,一个被承认的身份能换成几天时间;更多的节点上,它完全不适用。

反方向还有一个传播上的风险。宣称自己”进入了全国守信激励清单”的企业,说出了一句文件并不支持的话。准确的说法更窄,也更有用:经某个部门认定为某一类守信主体,可适用某几项措施。这里的精确不是咬文嚼字。会去核对的买方、银行、交易对手,找到的是窄的那个版本;对外表述与文件对得上的企业,比需要不断往回圆的企业更好打交道。

两族措施在企业内部归属的部门也不同。行政化激励属于政府事务或合规事务团队,他们知道申报日历,也知道对口的人是谁。社会化激励属于管差旅、管资金、管客户关系的人。把整份清单交给一个团队去管的集团,通常会有一半用不上——不是因为措施不存在,而是因为看的人不对。

外资企业该细读的电信与 AEO 条款

清单第 3 项针对信息通信行业的守信经营主体,认定部门是工业和信息化部。对身处电信、云服务或相邻数字业务的外资企业来说,这一项最值得细读,因为它触及这类企业通常最在意的两件事:许可申请走得有多快,拿到许可之后被如何对待。

这项措施包含四个要素。其一,适用于自贸试验区第二类增值电信业务的告知承诺试点。告知承诺是一种申请人作出声明并承诺合规、机关接受备案而非进行全面事前审查的模式。用在自贸试验区的第二类增值业务上,它把流程的前端大幅压缩——申请人自己的承诺,承担了一部分本应由事前审查完成的工作。

其二,降低日常监管抽查检查频次,或者视情况可以免予实地检查。”视情况”三个字承载着裁量空间,它不是自动取得的权利;企业宜把它读成一个方向,而不是一条定规。其三,同等条件下,在通信资源、网络接入、电信设备进网以及招投标中优先。

其四,也是最具有穿透力的一条:为申请海关 AEO 资质的企业提供”一对一”信用培育支持,同等条件下优先认证。这一条的思路超出了电信行业本身——行业监管部门作出的认定,成了海关评估的一项输入。对一个已在他国取得 AEO 资质、正在搭建中国申请的外资集团来说,有结构化的培育支持可用,是实打实的加速器。

“同等条件”这个限定出现了两次,不该被读过去。它的意思是:这项措施在条件相当时打破平局,而不是创设一项可以压过实体标准的偏好。达不到 AEO 认证底层标准的企业,不会因为它在电信意义上守信就被认证。它能得到的,是一条更快、更有支撑的路径,去证明自己确实达到标准。

清单恰恰在电信这一行写到这个细度,并非偶然。增值电信是自贸试验区内允许外资进入的领域之一,进入须经许可,并受试点附加条件的约束。一个既有现成外资群体、前端又有许可瓶颈、发证之后还持续监管的行业,正是守信激励能咬得住的地方。这项措施是写给已经在队伍里的企业看的。

顺序很重要。先有认定,来自行业监管部门;措施随之而来。企业不能凭读过清单就去用告知承诺这条通道。它要在被认定为该行业守信经营主体之后才打开,而这项认定取决于企业在监管部门的合规记录。实务含义是:取得资格的功夫,早在提交申请之前就下完了,就在日常把记录做干净这件事里。

AEO 那一部分也有先后次序值得说明。海关认证是一套有自身标准、自身材料、自身评审的过程。”一对一”培育支持的价值,在于缩短从决定申请到具备受评条件之间的那段时间——它不缩短评审本身,也不降低门槛。计划在中国申请 AEO 的集团,宜把这项支持当作项目的加速器,而不是准备的替代品。

跨部门互认在实务中的样子

清单最有意思的结构特征,是一个体系里的认定可以在另一个体系里使用。文件给出的例子很具体:纳税缴费信用 A 级的经营主体,在认定劳动保障守法诚信 A 级企业时可以获得信用加分。

窄读,这只是一个条目;结构性地读,它是一句关于信用架构正在被编织起来的陈述。过去,企业的纳税记录对税务部门有意义,劳动记录对人力资源社会保障部门有意义,海关记录对海关有意义,各管各的信息。跨部门互认意味着,一个地方的好记录,会在另一个地方被看见,并且值钱。

对在华拥有多个实体的集团来说,这改变了合规投入的算法。把某一家子公司的纳税信用级别提上去,可能在完全另一个监管部门主持的评价里产生好处。一项合规改善的回报,不再局限于提出要求的那家监管机构。这本身就是一条论据:信用管理应当作为集团层面的职能,而不是各实体财务团队各自的事。

这个例子也显示了机制的边界。纳税信用带来的是劳动保障评价中的加分,不是劳动保障认定本身。A 级劳动保障守法诚信的实体条件仍须满足,加分只在边缘起作用——它能让一个接近的案子过关,撑不起一个薄弱的案子。把互认当成满足底层标准的替代品的企业,会失望,也可能把力气花在争取一些自己转换不了的认定上。

还有一点关于证据。互认要成立,第二个部门必须看得见第一个部门的结论。这要求企业能够拿出原体系内当前状态的证明,并且是接收方接受的形式。一项只存在于企业查不到的数据库里的信用级别,在别处申请时用处有限。集团应当对打算依赖的每一项认定,都能随时出具有据可查的自身状态说明。

集团架构会让这件事复杂一层,值得提前安排。认定跟着法人实体走,不跟着集团走。在一个有控股公司、制造子公司、贸易公司、服务公司的架构里,持海关认证的实体未必是持纳税信用的那个,而两者又未必是去申请集团真正想要的那张许可证的实体。互认只在两种情况下有用:认定与申请落在同一个实体上,或者接收方接受集团层面的证据。因此第一步是把”哪个实体持有什么”画出来,而这一步往往正是暴露出缺口的那一步。

年度更新,以及被取代的那批备忘录

清单按年度更新。编制方已承诺,随法律法规和政策文件调整,及时调整守信主体的类别和所附的措施。这是一个有意义的设计选择:静态清单过不了几年就会与底层法规脱节,而没有固定节奏的修订又让企业难以跟踪。

2026 年版同时废止了 2016 年至 2018 年间订立的五份守信联合激励合作备忘录。那些备忘录是部门两两之间的安排,每一份覆盖一组特定的”认定加奖励”组合。用一份基础清单取代它们,等于把这张网收拢:企业不必再追几份彼此独立的协议,只需跟踪一份文件,按已知周期修订。

废止有一个容易漏掉的实务含义。围绕旧备忘录写成的指引——内部合规手册、顾问笔记、以及像本文这样的文章——可能仍在描述一种已不以那种形式存在的安排。企业若依赖若干年前记得的一份备忘录,应当核对该措施如今是否出现在现行清单里、以什么措辞出现。实质内容也许在归并中保留了下来,载体没有。

从规划角度看,年度周期提示了一条简单的纪律。每年一次,回顾企业大致落在二十五类中的哪几类、目前持有哪些认定、现行版本里哪些措施是自己真用得上的。许可证件组合稳定的企业,这件事很短;不稳定的企业,会发现它很有启发。它还会顺带产出互认所依赖的那份证据档案,而不是另立一个项目去做。

有两点框架性的判断值得始终放在视野里。第一,清单奖励的是行为,而行为是企业自己可控的。行业开放按谈判方的日程到来,清单下的认定则靠企业自己的记录挣得。第二,清单是基础,不是上限。省市两级的项目往往提供更多;国家清单确立的是可比待遇的地板,而不是可及范围的屋顶。

清单与准入规则各管一段

最要紧的一件事,是不要把这份文件与”外资能不能进入某个行业”的规则混为一谈。那些规则写在另外的文件里,由另外的程序执行。它们决定外资持股的允许范围、某项活动所附的许可要求、以及一份申请在什么条件下会被受理。守信清单一样都不管。

两者的关系是先后关系,不是替代关系。准入规则决定企业能不能拿到许可证件;守信清单决定拿到之后被如何对待,以及下一次申请走得多快。拿不到许可证件的企业,不会因为守信而拿到;能拿到的企业,可能拿得更快,事后也可能被监管得更轻。

把两者分开,对规划有实际意义,因为两者带来的不确定性性质不同。准入规则通过公开修订变化,方向提前可见。守信认定取决于企业自身记录和部门评价,意味着它受企业影响,但不由企业掌握。把中国计划建立在”认定会按时到来”这一假设上的集团,承担了本不必承担的风险;把计划建立在”认定可能一直不来”、并将其视为上行空间的假设上,则不必。

两者有一个交汇点,这也正是电信那一项重要的原因。当某个行业的准入路径包含告知承诺模式时,守信认定就决定了企业能否走这条路。此时清单不只是发证之后的待遇问题,而是申请本身的形态问题。这是例外,值得清楚地点出来,而不是据此推广到所有行业。

这个区分在交易里同样要紧。对一家中国标的做尽职调查的交易对手,有时会把某项守信认定当作”这项业务已经持证”的证据。它不是。认定说的是某段监管关系中的行为表现,与许可证件是否存在、是否覆盖所涉活动、是否仍然有效,一概无关。买方应当独立核验证件,把认定当作另一条、且分量更轻的数据。

今年该复盘什么

清单按年出,复盘也应当按年做。一份简短的议程,每年跑一次,就足以让集团不漏掉现行版本给的东西。

先从许可证件组合开始。把中国各实体持有的许可、备案、登记逐项列出,并标明背后的监管部门。这是其余一切工作的原料,而它变化得比集团预想的更频繁——新增一条业务线、新增一个场地、完成一次收购,组合就变了。

再把组合对到二十五类上去。目的不是把所有可能沾边的类别都申报一遍,而是找出两三类企业记录确实扎实、且认定值得去争取的。追逐一些通向虚无的认定,是常见且昂贵的错误。

然后查现行版本中这些类别所附的措施,逐项对照企业真实的日历。一项永远不会与企业的申报节奏重合的措施,读起来再漂亮,也没有实务价值。

接着确立证据状态。对已经持有的每项认定,确认能否按要求随时出具当前证明;对想要取得的认定,弄清认定部门需要看到什么,以及企业现有记录是否已经呈现了这一点。

最后记下日期。清单按年修订,管今年规划的版本未必管明年的。每年固定一天、在新版本面世后不久做一次复盘,是不必跟踪每一次部门公告、又能保持同步的最简办法。

来源

  • 国家发展改革委,《国家发展改革委、中国人民银行联合印发〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉》(发改财金〔2026〕1593 号),2026-11-09。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/tzgg/202611/t20261109_1408743.html
  • 国家发展改革委,《关于〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉的说明》,2026-11-10。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xxgk/zcfb/tz/202611/P020261110521301048830.pdf
  • 国家发展改革委,《全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)》正文,2026-11-10。https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/tzgg/202611/P020261110521429669759.pdf
  • 央视网,《国家发展改革委负责同志就〈全国守信激励措施基础清单(2026 年版)〉答记者问》,2026-11-11。https://gongyi.cctv.com/2026/11/11/ARTIg5m10IKVdLbkUjy3BR7n261111.shtml

VAT Withholding When the Seller Is Abroad and the Team Is Onshore

  • Services supplied inside China by Overseas Individuals make the buyer the VAT Withholding Agent under Article 15 of the VAT Law, a rule that predates the 2026 announcement.
    境外个人在境内提供服务的,购买方依《增值税法》第十五条成为增值税扣缴义务人;这是既有规则,早于 2026 年的公告。
  • The rate applied to a service supplied inside China by an overseas individual is 6 per cent, and no Urban Maintenance and Construction Tax is levied on that VAT.
    境外个人在境内提供服务适用 6% 税率,且对其缴纳的增值税不征收城市维护建设税。
  • Announcement No. 28 of 2026 builds a withholding system for domestic natural persons; it does not create the buyer’s obligation towards an overseas seller.
    2026 年第 28 号公告建立的是境内自然人的扣缴制度,并没有创设购买方对境外销售方的扣缴义务。
  • Where the seller sits abroad and the team sits onshore, who pays the fee decides the chain: a payer inside China withholds, a payer outside China follows a different route.
    卖方在境外、团队在境内时,由谁付款决定链条:付款方在境内则代扣,付款方在境外则走另一条路径。
  • Cross-Border Service Fees should be contracted on a tax-inclusive basis, because the withholding is computed on the amount paid and cannot be recovered from a clause.
    跨境服务费应按含税口径签约,因为扣缴按实付金额计算,无法靠合同条款追回。
  • Between 1 January and 31 October 2026 the natural person still self-declares; the withholding route under Announcement No. 28 starts on 1 November 2026.
    2026 年 1 月 1 日至 10 月 31 日发生的应税交易仍由自然人自行申报;28 号公告的扣缴路径自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起适用。

VAT Withholding When the Seller Is Abroad and the Team Is Onshore | 卖方在境外、团队在境内:增值税扣缴由谁做、扣什么、凭证怎么走

Overview

A foreign group runs a project in China with a small onshore team: a country manager, two engineers, a part-time designer paid by the day, and a professor flown in for a two-week training block. Invoices arrive from four different places, and the finance team in Shanghai has to decide, for each one, whether tax is withheld, by whom, at what rate, and against which document.

That decision is often described as a new problem created by the 2026 announcement on withholding VAT from natural persons. It is not. The announcement, effective 1 November 2026, builds a withholding system for domestic natural persons. The obligation that concerns an overseas seller is older, sits in Article 15 of the VAT Law, and has not changed. Confusing the two produces either an over-withholding that the seller disputes or an under-withholding that surfaces at audit.

Three chains, kept apart

Three relationships are routinely conflated. They share vocabulary and share nothing else.

Domestic natural person to domestic buyer. Announcement No. 28 of 2026, effective 1 November 2026. The domestic entity that buys from a natural person becomes the withholding agent for that transaction. This article does not re-describe the mechanics; they are covered separately.

Overseas individual to a buyer inside China. Article 15 of the VAT Law: where an overseas unit or individual carries out a taxable transaction inside China, the purchaser is the VAT withholding agent, unless a domestic agent is appointed to declare and pay under State Council rules. This is a pre-existing rule.

Overseas entity to a buyer inside China. The same Article 15 sentence covers units as well as individuals. What differs is the practical route: a domestic agent may be appointed to declare and pay. The announcement does not set a rate conclusion for a corporate seller, and neither does this article.

Keep the three in separate columns on the same page. Most errors come from applying the mechanics of the first chain to a transaction that belongs in the second.

The overseas individual route

For an individual seller, the position is relatively clean. The service is supplied inside China, the purchaser is the withholding agent, the applicable rate for the service is 6 per cent, and the construction tax does not apply.

Two conditions deserve attention. First, “inside China” is a factual question about where the service is consumed, not about where the contract is signed or where the invoice is issued. A consultant who works remotely from abroad for a Chinese project is a different case from one who delivers workshops in Shanghai, and the file should record which one it is.

Second, the exception is narrow. A domestic agent appointed under State Council rules to declare and pay displaces the purchaser’s withholding role. Absent that appointment, the purchaser holds the obligation, and a contract clause allocating tax to the seller does not move it.

Why the construction tax changes the price

Article 3 of the Urban Maintenance and Construction Tax Law provides that VAT paid by an overseas unit or individual on labour and services sold into China is not subject to the construction tax.

The practical effect is a cost structure that differs from a domestic natural person engagement. On the domestic side, VAT is accompanied by the construction tax and its surcharges, which are calculated by reference to the VAT actually paid. On the overseas individual side, the VAT is there and the construction tax is not. A quote built on the domestic template overstates the add-on; a quote built on “no tax” understates the whole.

For a group negotiating a net fee, this is where the argument actually happens. The gross-up must be calculated on the correct base: 6 per cent on the payment, with no construction tax layer. Getting that wrong by a few points is not a rounding issue on a multi-year consulting arrangement; it is a permanent margin difference.

Contracts, invoices and vouchers

The tax outcome is largely fixed before the invoice is issued.

Decide whether the contract price is tax-inclusive. If the fee is stated net and the withholding falls on the payer, the payer absorbs it, and the budget was wrong from the start.

Decide who issues the invoice. An overseas individual generally cannot issue a Chinese invoice; the withholding certificate becomes the document the payer holds. That certificate is what supports the booking and, where relevant, the deduction position. A file without it is a payment without evidence.

Decide how the payment leaves. A cross-border remittance and an onshore payment run on different rails, with different documentation, and the withholding must be settled on the correct rail. Splitting a single engagement across both rails without a rule is how a clean file becomes a reconciliation problem.

The onshore team question

The same person can be engaged in three ways, and each produces a different withholding position.

Engaged as an individual service provider, the payment is a service fee, and the buyer is the withholding agent under Article 15.

Engaged through a domestic staffing or outsourcing arrangement, the payment is to an entity, and the withholding analysis moves to that entity’s own invoicing.

Employed directly by the Chinese subsidiary, the payment is salary, and the question becomes payroll withholding rather than service withholding.

The engagement label is not decisive; the substance is. A daily-paid designer who works on the company’s systems, on the company’s schedule, for one client looks less like a service provider than the contract says. This article flags the boundary only. The rules on dispatch ratios and social insurance sit elsewhere, and they are not affected by the 2026 announcement.

Practical steps

  • Add a withholding determination to the payment approval flow, before the payment is released rather than after.
  • Separate the two payment channels in the ledger: cross-border remittance and onshore payment, each with its own withholding logic.
  • Record the place of performance for every service engagement, in writing, at the point of contracting.
  • Keep the tax residency status and any treaty position of the individual on file, since both affect the analysis and both take time to evidence.
  • For corporate sellers, confirm whether a domestic agent has been appointed; if it has, the file needs that appointment, not a withholding certificate.

Outlook

Expect the first disputes to concern the place of performance rather than the rate, because the rate for an individual service is settled while the geography is not. Expect scrutiny of arrangements that split one engagement into a cross-border contract and an onshore payment run. The defensible position is documentation created at the time of contracting, not reconstructed at the time of examination.

Related reading

  • *Withholding VAT on Natural Person Service Providers* (Article 502) — the domestic natural person mechanics in full.

Sources

  • 国家税务总局四川省税务局·28 号公告附件《境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税管理办法》条文问答:https://sichuan.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/9/art_327_1364961.html
  • 国家税务总局法规库·《中华人民共和国增值税法》及实施条例:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 国家税务总局甘肃省税务局·扣缴申报时限条文问答:http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/9/10/art_75_476972.html
  • 财政部·政策发布:https://www.mof.gov.cn/

卖方在境外、团队在境内:增值税扣缴由谁做、扣什么、凭证怎么走

概述

一家外国集团在中国做一个项目,境内只有一支小团队:一名国别经理、两名工程师、一名按日计酬的兼职设计师,再加一位飞来讲两周课的专家。发票从四个地方来,上海的财务要为每一张判断:要不要扣税、由谁扣、按什么税率、凭什么凭证入账。

这件事常被说成 2026 年自然人增值税扣缴公告带来的新问题。并不是。2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行的公告,建立的是境内自然人的扣缴制度。真正涉及境外销售方的那项义务更早,写在《增值税法》第十五条里,这次没有变。把两者混在一起,结果只有两种:要么多扣,销售方来争;要么少扣,检查时才浮现。

三条链条,必须分开

有三种关系经常被混为一谈。它们用同一套词,除此之外没有共同点。

境内自然人对境内购买方。 2026 年第 28 号公告,自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行。向自然人购买服务的境内单位,就该笔交易成为扣缴义务人。本文不再复述其机制,另有专文。

境外个人对境内购买方。 《增值税法》第十五条:境外单位或者个人在境内发生应税交易的,购买方为增值税扣缴义务人;按照国务院规定委托境内代理人申报缴纳税款的除外。这是既有规则。

境外单位对境内购买方。 第十五条同一句话既覆盖单位也覆盖个人。不同之处在操作路径:可以委托境内代理人申报缴纳。公告没有就企业销售方给出税率结论,本文也不给。

把三条画成同一页上的三列。多数错误,都是把第一条的机制套到了本该归入第二条的交易上。

境外个人这条路径

对个人销售方而言,位置相对清楚:服务在境内提供,购买方是扣缴义务人,服务适用 6% 税率,城建税不征。

有两个条件值得盯住。第一,”在境内”是关于服务在哪里被消费的事实判断,不是合同在哪里签、发票在哪里开。一位在境外远程为中国项目工作的顾问,与一位在上海现场授课的顾问,是两个案子;卷宗里要写清是哪一个。

第二,除外情形很窄。按国务院规定委托境内代理人申报缴纳,才会替代购买方的扣缴地位。没有这项委托,义务就落在购买方身上,合同里约定由销售方承担税负的条款也搬不动它。

城建税如何改变价格

《城市维护建设税法》第三条规定:境外单位或者个人向境内销售劳务、服务缴纳的增值税,不征收城市维护建设税。

实际效果是,成本结构与境内自然人交易不同。境内这一侧,增值税之外还有以实缴增值税为计税依据的城建税及附加;境外个人这一侧,有增值税,没有城建税。拿境内模板做的报价,会把附加算高;拿”没有税”做的报价,会把整体算低。

对谈净额费用的集团来说,分歧就发生在这里。含税还原要按正确的基数算:按付款额计 6%,不再叠加城建税。差几个百分点,放在多年期顾问安排上不是四舍五入的问题,而是永久的毛利差。

合同、发票与凭证

税务结果,很大程度上在开票之前就定了。

先定合同价款是否含税。若约定净额、扣缴落在付款方,就是付款方吸收,预算从一开始就错了。

再定发票由谁开。境外个人通常无法开具中国发票,付款方手上留下的是扣缴凭证。入账靠它;涉及税前扣除的,也靠它。没有这份凭证,就是一笔没有证据的付款。

还要定钱怎么出去。跨境付汇与境内付款走的是两条通道,单据不同,扣缴必须在正确的那条通道上结清。同一项业务拆到两条通道却没有规则,干净的一笔账就会变成对账难题。

在岸团队这一问

同一个人,可以三种方式合作,扣缴位置各不相同。

按个人服务提供者结算,付款是服务费,购买方依第十五条成为扣缴义务人。

通过境内劳务派遣或外包安排结算,付款对象是单位,扣缴分析转到该单位自己的开票环节。

由境内子公司直接雇佣,付款是工资,问题就从服务扣缴变成工资薪金的扣缴。

名义不决定性质,实质才决定。一位按日计酬的设计师,用公司的系统、按公司的排期、只服务一个客户,看起来就不像合同上写的那样是服务提供者。本文只标出这条边界;派遣比例与社保规则另有专文,也不因 2026 年的公告而改变。

落地步骤

  • 在付款审批流里加一个”扣缴判定”节点,放在放款之前,而不是之后。
  • 账上把两条付款通道分开:跨境付汇与境内付款,各自一套扣缴逻辑。
  • 每一项服务合作,在签约时以书面记录实际履行地。
  • 个人的税收居民身份与协定待遇材料归档,两者都影响判断,且都需要时间取证。
  • 对企业销售方,先确认是否已委托境内代理人;若已委托,卷宗里需要的是那份委托,而不是扣缴凭证。

展望

可以预期,第一批争议会集中在履行地,而不是税率——个人服务的税率是清楚的,地理位置不是。也可以预期,把同一项业务拆成一份跨境合同加一笔境内付款的安排会被重点审视。站得住的做法,是在签约当时形成书面记录,而不是在检查时再补。

延伸阅读

  • 《境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税:外资企业采购个人服务的扣缴流程》(第 502 篇)——境内自然人扣缴机制的完整说明。

来源

  • 国家税务总局四川省税务局·28 号公告附件《境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税管理办法》条文问答:https://sichuan.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/9/art_327_1364961.html
  • 国家税务总局法规库·《中华人民共和国增值税法》及实施条例:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 国家税务总局甘肃省税务局·扣缴申报时限条文问答:http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/9/10/art_75_476972.html
  • 财政部·政策发布:https://www.mof.gov.cn/

Penalty Benchmarks for Social Insurance Arrears: A National Yardstick Arrives

  • The national Administrative Penalty Benchmarks for tax matters, 2026 edition, took effect on 1 November 2026 and place Social Insurance Contributions inside a single national yardstick for the first time.
    全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行,社会保险费第一次被纳入全国统一的裁量标尺。
  • Social insurance arrears sit at item 30 of the benchmarks, under the category covering the collection and administration of taxes and fees.
    社保欠缴位列裁量基准第 30 项,归入”违反税(费)款征收管理类”。
  • Under Article 86 of the Social Insurance Law a Late Payment Surcharge of 0.05 per cent per day runs from the date the contribution fell due, alongside any fine.
    按照《社会保险法》第八十六条,滞纳金自欠缴之日起按日加收万分之五,与罚款并行。
  • Arrears below RMB 500,000 attract a fine of one times the amount; between RMB 500,000 and RMB 5 million the tier depends on the share of the amount due.
    欠缴不满 50 万元的,处欠缴数额一倍的罚款;50 万元以上不满 500 万元的,档次取决于占应缴数额的比例。
  • Arrears above RMB 5 million that also exceed 30 per cent of the amount due fall into the severe tier, where the fine is two to three times the arrears.
    欠缴 500 万元以上且占比 30% 以上的,落入”严重”档,罚款为欠缴数额的二倍以上三倍以下。
  • The most common exposure is a Contribution Base set at the local minimum rather than at total wages, which understates every month of the year.
    最常见的风险是把缴费基数按当地最低标准申报,而不是按工资总额申报,这会让全年每一个月都被低估。

Penalty Benchmarks for Social Insurance Arrears: A National Yardstick Arrives | 社保欠缴的处罚裁量:一把全国统一的尺子落地

Overview

On 1 November 2026 the 2026 edition of the national tax administrative penalty benchmarks came into effect. Most of the document restates discretion that already existed. One entry does not: social insurance contributions now appear in the national benchmarks, as item 30, filed under the category that covers the collection and administration of taxes and fees.

For an employer the distinction matters. The benchmarks do not create a contribution, raise a rate, or widen the population that must be insured. They fix, in one place, how large a fine may be once an employer has already failed to pay what it owed. That is a narrower change than a new levy, and a more consequential one than it looks, because a fine is the part of the exposure a finance team cannot forecast from its own payroll data.

What the 2026 edition changes

The document covers nine categories and sixty-six penalty items. Social insurance is one of them.

Three points of reading discipline follow. First, this is a discretion standard, not a liability rule: it tells an authority how to choose a penalty inside a statutory range, and the range itself still comes from the Social Insurance Law. Second, it attaches to the collection relationship, which the tax authorities administer in most of the country since collection duties were transferred to them. Third, it is national, so a group with entities in several provinces is now measured against one scale rather than against whatever practice each locality had settled into.

The three tiers

The structure is a grid of amount and proportion, and the proportion is the half that employers underestimate.

General. Non-payment or underpayment below RMB 500,000; or an amount between RMB 500,000 and RMB 5 million where the shortfall is below 30 per cent of the amount due. Fine: one times the arrears.

Relatively serious. An amount between RMB 500,000 and RMB 5 million where the shortfall is 30 per cent or more; or an amount above RMB 5 million where the shortfall is below 30 per cent. Fine: one to two times the arrears.

Serious. An amount above RMB 5 million where the shortfall is 30 per cent or more, or other serious circumstances. Fine: two to three times the arrears.

Read the grid as a pair of thresholds that move together. A company owing RMB 4 million against an amount due of RMB 10 million is at 40 per cent and therefore in the middle tier, even though the absolute figure is well below the top threshold. A company owing RMB 6 million against RMB 40 million is at 15 per cent and also falls in the middle tier, because above RMB 5 million a share below 30 per cent still lands there rather than in the severe tier. The severe tier needs both conditions at once: more than RMB 5 million, and more than 30 per cent.

Surcharge and fine run in parallel

Article 86 has two stages. The collection authority orders payment or make-up within a time limit and adds a late payment surcharge of 0.05 per cent per day from the date the contribution fell due. If the employer still does not pay, an administrative department imposes a fine of one to three times the arrears.

The surcharge is not a penalty and is not replaced by one. It accrues daily on the amount owed, so it grows with time rather than with anyone’s view of culpability. A company that clears a three-year arrears at the end of an examination pays three years of surcharge on top of the principal, and only then discusses the fine.

Who this reaches

Any employer with staff on a Chinese payroll, domestic or foreign-invested. The group most affected is not the single-site company but the group with branches in several provinces. Until now the same shortfall could be handled differently depending on where the file was opened, which made internal comparisons unreliable. A unified scale makes the group’s own benchmarking possible for the first time, and it also makes an inconsistent internal position harder to defend: a subsidiary cannot argue that its practice was normal locally when the parent applies the same test everywhere.

Where the exposure actually sits

Four practices account for most of the risk, and none of them is exotic.

A base set at the minimum. Declaring on the local minimum base rather than on total wages is the single most common cause of a shortfall. The gap per employee is small and compounds across a headcount and across years.

Wages split into allowances. Moving part of pay into items treated as reimbursements or subsidies keeps it out of the base. Where the item is in substance remuneration, the split does not survive an examination.

Foreign employees. The scope of participation for foreign staff is a question of its own, and the assumption that a foreign national sits outside the system is frequently wrong.

Dispatch and outsourcing. Whether a worker is employed by the entity that uses the labour changes who owes the contribution and where it is paid. This article flags the point only; the rules on dispatch are treated elsewhere.

The waiver that does not work

A signed statement in which an employee gives up social insurance has no legal effect. The obligation is mandatory, and a private agreement cannot dispose of it. This is a rule of the Social Insurance Law that predates the 2026 edition; the benchmarks change the consequence of non-payment, not the validity of the waiver. Companies that hold such statements sometimes treat them as evidence of employee consent. They are evidence of the opposite: that the employer knew the obligation existed.

Practical steps

  • Reconcile the contribution base to total wages for each entity and each month, not to the declared figure alone.
  • Confirm where each branch is registered and pays; the paying location decides which authority opens the file.
  • Run a historical self-review before an examination finds the gap. Voluntary correction and assessed correction are different conversations, with different starting points for the fine.
  • For foreign staff, settle the participation position and any bilateral social security agreement before the next filing cycle, not after.
  • Reconcile once: contribution data, individual income tax and the annual settlement read the same payroll, and a single monthly reconciliation prevents three separate corrections.

Outlook

Expect local guidance on how the tiers are applied in practice, and expect the first wave of cases to involve groups with cross-province payroll rather than single entities. The useful preparation is arithmetic. Know the base, know the gap, and know which tier that gap falls into before anyone asks the question.

Related reading

  • *Centralised Payment Rules for Labour Dispatch* (Article 490) — where dispatch ends and direct employment begins.
  • *Social Insurance for Foreign Employees* (Article 248) — the participation question for expatriate staff.

Sources

  • 国家税务总局·《国家税务总局关于发布〈全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)〉的公告》(国家税务总局公告 2026 年第 20 号):https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c100012/c5252754/content.html
  • 国家税务总局 12366 纳税服务平台·裁量基准违法行为种类与阶次:https://12366.chinatax.gov.cn/wap/pages/detailall.html?id=0000000002026101400015&url=sscx/toDetail
  • 国家税务总局·关于该公告的政策解读(明确”9 类 66 项””税费皆重”口径):https://shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfw/zcjd/202610/t481675.html
  • 人力资源社会保障部·《中华人民共和国社会保险法》相关:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/

社保欠缴的处罚裁量:一把全国统一的尺子落地

概述

2026 年 11 月 1 日,全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)开始施行。文件的大部分内容是对既有裁量口径的重述,只有一处不是:社会保险费第一次出现在全国统一的裁量基准里,列为第 30 项,归入”违反税(费)款征收管理类”。

对用人单位来说,这个区别是实质性的。裁量基准没有新设一个费种,没有提高费率,也没有扩大参保人群。它做的是把”欠缴之后罚款可以罚多少”固定在一个地方。这比新开一个费种要窄,却比看上去更要紧——因为罚款恰恰是财务团队无法从自己的工资数据里推算出来的那部分敞口。

2026 年版改变了什么

文件覆盖九类、六十六项处罚事项,社保是其中一项。

读这份文本有三条纪律。第一,它是裁量标准,不是责任规则:它告诉执法机关在法定幅度内如何选择罚则,而幅度本身仍来自《社会保险法》。第二,它附着在征缴关系上,而征缴职责划转之后,多数地区的征缴关系由税务机关管理。第三,它是全国性的:在多省设有实体的集团,从此面对同一把尺子,而不是各省各自形成的做法。

三个档次

结构是一张”金额 × 比例”的网格,而比例正是用人单位最容易低估的那一半。

一般。 不缴或少缴社会保险费不满 50 万元;或者金额在 50 万元以上不满 500 万元,且欠缴数额占应缴社会保险费不满 30%。罚款为欠缴数额的一倍。

较重。 金额在 50 万元以上不满 500 万元且占比 30% 以上;或者金额在 500 万元以上且占比不满 30%。罚款为欠缴数额的一倍以上二倍以下。

严重。 金额在 500 万元以上且占比 30% 以上,或者有其他严重情节。罚款为欠缴数额的二倍以上三倍以下。

读这张网格,要把它看成两个同时移动的门槛。一家企业欠缴 400 万元、应缴 1000 万元,占比 40%,即便绝对金额远低于最高门槛,也落在”较重”档。另一家欠缴 600 万元、应缴 4000 万元,占比 15%,同样落在”较重”档——因为金额一旦超过 500 万元,占比不满 30% 仍归入这一档,而不是”严重”档。”严重”档需要两个条件同时成立:500 万元以上,且占比 30% 以上。

滞纳金与罚款并行

第八十六条分两个阶段。征收机构责令限期缴纳或者补足,并自欠缴之日起按日加收万分之五的滞纳金。逾期仍不缴纳的,由有关行政部门处欠缴数额一倍以上三倍以下的罚款。

滞纳金不是罚款,也不会被罚款吸收。它按欠缴金额逐日累积,随时间增长,而不随任何人对过错程度的判断变化。一家企业在检查结束时一次性清缴三年的欠费,就要为这三年补缴三年的滞纳金,之后才轮到讨论罚款。

波及谁

凡是在中国有工资表、有在册员工的用人单位,无论内资还是外资,都在射程之内。受影响最明显的并不是单点企业,而是在多省设有分支机构的集团。同一笔欠缴,此前可能因为案卷开在哪个地区而处理不同,集团内部的横向比较因此并不可靠。统一尺度第一次让集团自己做横向基准成为可能,也让内部口径不一致更难解释:当母公司对所有主体适用同一套测试时,子公司无法再主张”当地就是这么做的”。

风险实际落在哪里

四种做法解释了大部分风险,而它们都不算罕见。

按最低基数申报。 按当地最低缴费基数而不是工资总额申报,是欠缴最常见的成因。单人差额不大,但会随人数和年份累加。

把工资拆成补贴。 把部分薪酬放进按报销或补贴处理的项目,就能把它排除在基数之外。如果该项目实质上是劳动报酬,拆分经不起检查。

外籍员工。 外籍人员的参保范围本身是一个独立问题,”外籍人士不在体系内”这一假定经常是错的。

派遣与外包。 劳动者究竟受雇于使用劳动力的单位还是另一主体,决定了谁欠缴、在哪里缴。本文只作提示,派遣规则另有专文。

那份放弃声明没有用

员工签署的自愿放弃社保声明不具备法律效力。缴费是强制性义务,私人约定无权处分。这是《社会保险法》层面早已存在的规则,早于 2026 年版裁量基准;基准改变的是不缴的后果,不是声明的效力。持有这类声明的企业有时把它当作员工同意的证据,它证明的恰恰相反:用人单位知道这项义务存在。

落地步骤

  • 逐主体、逐月把缴费基数与工资总额勾稽,而不是只核对申报数。
  • 确认每个分支机构的登记地与缴费地;缴费地决定由哪一级机关立案。
  • 在检查发现缺口之前先做历史自查。主动纠正与被查后纠正,是两场不同的对话,罚款的起点也不同。
  • 外籍员工的参保口径与双边社保协定衔接,要在下一个申报周期之前定下来,而不是之后。
  • 只做一次勾稽:社保缴费、个人所得税与年度汇算读的是同一份工资表,每月核对一次,可以省掉三次分别更正。

展望

可以预期各地会就档次的具体适用给出操作口径,也可以预期第一批案例会集中在跨省发薪的集团,而不是单一主体。真正有用的准备是算术:先知道基数,再知道缺口,再知道这个缺口落在哪一档——在有人来问之前。

延伸阅读

  • 《劳务派遣集中支付规则》(第 490 篇)——派遣与直接用工的边界。
  • 《外籍员工的社会保险》(第 248 篇)——外派人员的参保问题。

来源

  • 国家税务总局·《国家税务总局关于发布〈全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)〉的公告》(国家税务总局公告 2026 年第 20 号):https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c100012/c5252754/content.html
  • 国家税务总局 12366 纳税服务平台·裁量基准违法行为种类与阶次:https://12366.chinatax.gov.cn/wap/pages/detailall.html?id=0000000002026101400015&url=sscx/toDetail
  • 国家税务总局·关于该公告的政策解读(明确”9 类 66 项””税费皆重”口径):https://shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfw/zcjd/202610/t481675.html
  • 人力资源社会保障部·《中华人民共和国社会保险法》相关:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/

Non-Resident Enterprise Income Tax: A Consultation Draft That Widens Scope and Unifies Filing

  • On 30 October 2026 the State Taxation Administration released a consultation draft of the Measures for the Administration of Enterprise Income Tax on the Establishment and Place of Business of Non-Resident Enterprises, with comments due by 29 November 2026.
    2026 年 10 月 30 日,国家税务总局公布《非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税管理办法(征求意见稿)》,意见反馈截止 2026 年 11 月 29 日。
  • The draft would replace the 2009 interim measures on construction projects and labour services and would repeal them at the same time.
    征求意见稿拟取代 2009 年出台的《非居民承包工程作业和提供劳务税收管理暂行办法》,并同步废止该暂行办法。
  • Its scope would move from construction and labour services to every establishment and place of business a non-resident enterprise maintains in China.
    适用范围拟从承包工程作业和提供劳务,拓展到非居民企业在境内的各类机构、场所。
  • Self-assessment and specified withholding would share one place of tax payment, the location of the establishment or place of business.
    自行申报与指定扣缴的纳税地点拟统一为机构、场所所在地。
  • Reporting would be simplified, with fewer forms and data items, drawing on the systems already in place.
    报送资料拟予精简,依托现有信息化系统减少报送频次、精简表格与数据项。
  • The official explanation points to sporting and cultural performances, Chinese-foreign cooperation in running schools and partnership enterprises as the categories that are growing.
    官方解读指出,来华举办文体演出活动、开展中外合作办学、设立合伙企业等类型的机构、场所日益增多。
  • Nothing in the draft is in force, and the text may still change before it is finalised.
    征求意见稿尚未生效,正式定稿前文本仍可能调整。

Non-Resident Enterprise Income Tax: A Consultation Draft That Widens Scope and Unifies Filing | 非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税:一份拓宽口径并统一纳税地点的征求意见稿

Overview

On 30 October 2026 the State Taxation Administration published a consultation draft of the Measures for the Administration of Enterprise Income Tax on the Establishment and Place of Business of Non-Resident Enterprises. Comments are due by 29 November 2026.

The draft is a rewrite, not a patch. It would replace the 2009 interim measures governing tax administration for non-resident enterprises that undertake construction and installation projects or provide labour services in China, and it would repeal those interim measures when it takes effect.

Read the status line first: this is a text open for comment. Nothing in it applies today, no commencement date has been fixed, and the provisions described below are proposals.

What the draft would change

The Administration describes three lines of change.

One tax, a wider population. The 2009 measures covered several taxes. The provisions on taxes other than enterprise income tax have since been superseded by other laws and regulations, so the draft addresses enterprise income tax alone. In exchange, its population widens from construction and labour services to every establishment or place of business a non-resident enterprise maintains in China.

One place of payment. Self-assessment and specified withholding would both be handled where the establishment or place of business is located, and the same local authority would administer self-assessment, specified withholding and recovery of unpaid tax. Where withholding happens away from that location, an upgraded information system is meant to carry the filing rather than a second filing venue.

Less to file. Reporting frequency and content would be trimmed and forms and data items reduced, on the strength of systems already in use.

Who falls inside the wider scope

The official explanation names the pressure behind the widening: sporting and cultural performances, Chinese-foreign cooperation in running schools, and partnership enterprises. Each involves a non-resident enterprise with a presence in China that does not resemble a construction site, and none of them is named in the title of the 2009 measures.

For a foreign group, the practical question is which of its China activities now sit inside a single rulebook. A touring performance, a joint teaching programme, a partnership interest held through a fund — none of these fits the two categories the 2009 measures name. A unified rule does not change the tax base; it changes who administers it and where.

Relationship with existing law

Article 3 of the Enterprise Income Tax Law already taxes a non-resident enterprise on income effectively connected with an establishment or place of business in China. Tax treaties decide whether a permanent establishment exists in the first place, and the draft does not displace that analysis.

What the draft does is administrative: it organises filing, withholding and recovery for entities already within Article 3. It should be read alongside treaty analysis, not instead of it. The distinction matters because a group may have a treaty permanent establishment and no entity, or an entity and no permanent establishment; the draft speaks to the administration of the tax, not to whether it is due.

What to do while waiting

  • Inventory every Chinese presence: branch, representative office, project site, performance venue, cooperation programme, partnership interest. List the entity, the activity, the revenue and the current filing arrangement for each.
  • Mark where the place of filing differs from the place where the establishment sits. Those are the rows that would move under a unified rule, and they are the rows that carry cash-flow consequences.
  • Review existing withholding arrangements. If a specified withholding relationship was set up because the payer and the establishment were in different provinces, ask whether it would still be needed.
  • Check the supporting documents behind each arrangement, because simplification of forms does not simplify the underlying facts.
  • If the draft touches a structure you rely on, use the comment window. Submissions go through the “interaction — comment collection” section of the Administration’s website, or by letter to the International Taxation Department, 68 Zaolin Qianjie, Xicheng District, Beijing 100053, marked with the title of the draft.

Outlook

Two things are worth watching when the final text appears: whether the wider population is defined by reference to existing concepts or by a new list, and whether the unified place of payment carries transitional arrangements for groups already filing elsewhere. Neither is settled in the draft.

Related reading

  • *Non-Resident Taxpayers Claiming Tax-Treaty Benefits: A 2026 Compliance Guide for Foreign-Invested Enterprises* (Article 283) — the treaty layer the draft assumes but does not restate.

Sources

  • 国家税务总局·《非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税管理办法(征求意见稿)》公开征求意见:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/chinatax/n810356/n810961/c5253117/content.html
  • 国家税务总局·新闻稿及解读:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/chinatax/n810219/n810724/c5253170/content.html
  • 国家税务总局·政策文件:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/

非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税:一份拓宽口径并统一纳税地点的征求意见稿

概述

2026 年 10 月 30 日,国家税务总局公布《非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税管理办法(征求意见稿)》,意见反馈截止 2026 年 11 月 29 日。

这份文本是重写,不是打补丁。它拟取代 2009 年出台的《非居民承包工程作业和提供劳务税收管理暂行办法》,并在施行时同步废止该暂行办法。旧办法管的是非居民企业在中国境内承包工程作业和提供劳务的税收征管,新文本管的是非居民企业在境内的各类机构、场所。标题里不再限定活动类型,适用范围也就随之打开。

先看状态:这是一份公开征求意见的文本。其中任何一条目前都不适用,施行日期尚未确定,下面描述的条款都是拟议内容。企业不应据此调整申报,但可以据此准备。这个区别在实务中经常被忽略——征求意见稿被当成新闻转发几轮之后,往往就有人开始问”什么时候开始按新表报”。

为什么值得单独写一篇?因为非居民企业所得税的征管长期存在一个结构性错位:法律层面的”机构、场所”是一个宽口径概念,征管层面的专门规则却只覆盖承包工程和劳务两类。中间那一段,缺少专门的程序规则。这次修订想处理的,正是这一段。

时间线也很清楚:10 月 30 日公布,11 月 29 日截止反馈,前后一个月。这一个月里企业能做的,主要是把自家的情况摸清、把意见递上去;至于申报怎么改,要等正式文本。

拟修订的内容

税务总局的口径概括为三条。

一个税种,更宽的人群。 2009 年的暂行办法涉及多个税种。其中企业所得税以外的条款,已被其他法律法规代替,因此本次修订只聚焦企业所得税。作为交换,适用范围从承包工程作业和提供劳务,拓展到非居民企业在境内的各类机构、场所。这一进一出并非偶然:把不再适用的条款清出去,才有空间把口径统一起来。

一个纳税地点。 自行申报与指定扣缴的纳税地点拟统一为机构、场所所在地;自行申报、指定扣缴、税款追缴的管理部门,也统一为机构、场所所在地主管税务机关。异地扣缴不再另设申报地点,而是通过升级信息系统便利申报缴税。对跨省经营的主体,这一条改变的是申报路径,而不是税额。

更少的报送。 依托信息化系统简化报送频次与要求,精简表格和数据项。精简的前提是系统里已有数据,因此它更像是对既有信息的重新组织,而不是对企业提出新的举证要求。

三条合起来,指向的是一次规则整合与征管便利,不是新增税负。判断口径、税率、征税范围都没有被改写,被改写的是”由谁管、在哪里报、报多少张表”。

这一点需要说透,因为它决定了企业该紧张还是该松一口气。如果修订新增了税负,动作应当是重估项目回报;如果修订只是把征管归口,动作应当是核对内部流程。从三条内容看,属于后者:没有新的征税对象,没有新的税率,没有新的减免,只有管辖与程序的重新排列。

报送资料精简的幅度,征求意见稿没有给出具体数字,也没有列明表格名称,因此现在无法据此估算工作量。可以确定的是方向:减少频次、减少表格、减少数据项。对企业而言,这意味着过去为应对多口径报送而做的内部台账,可能需要重新设计;也意味着依赖人工汇总的环节,会进一步被系统取数替代。

谁会落入更宽的口径

官方解读点出了推动这次修订的现实背景:随着新经济新业态发展,来华举办文体演出活动、开展中外合作办学、设立合伙企业等类型的非居民企业机构、场所日益增多。这三类的共同点,是在中国有实体存在,但形态不像工地,也都不在旧办法标题所列的两类活动之内。

以文体演出为例:一个境外演出团体来华巡演数周,有场地、有票房、有本地承办方,但没有常设的分支机构。以合作办学为例:境外院校与境内机构合作开课,有教学场所、有收费、有师资派驻,但法律形态取决于办学安排。以合伙企业为例:境外合伙人通过基金持有境内合伙企业权益,有分配、有份额,但没有独立法人。三类情形的共同点是”有机构、场所在起作用”,而旧办法的标题里只有承包工程和劳务。

对境外集团而言,实际问题是:自己在中国的哪些活动,今后会被装进同一本规则。巡回演出、合作办学项目、通过基金持有的合伙企业权益,都不属于旧办法标题所列的两类活动。统一规则不改变税基,改变的是谁管、在哪里管。

这里有一个容易被跳过的判断:口径拓宽,指的是征管对象变多,还是纳税义务变多?从文本看是前者。被纳入的仍然是《企业所得税法》第三条项下的机构、场所,只是它们从此有了专门的程序规则,而不再需要借用旧办法的框架。对已经按现行规则申报的主体,变化在于表格与受理机关;对过去未被明确覆盖的主体,变化在于从此有了确定的申报路径。

自查可以用三个问题串起来(以下属于实务梳理,不是条文标准):这项活动在中国有没有固定或相对固定的场所?有没有人员在这里持续提供劳务?收入是否与这个场所或人员有关?三个问题都答”有”,基本可以确认落入机构、场所的范围;答”部分有”,就需要回到第三条与协定文本逐项对照,而不是凭经验判断。三个问题的价值不在精确,而在于把散落在业务部门的信息收拢到一张表上。

与现行法律的关系

《企业所得税法》第三条已经对非居民企业取得与境内机构、场所有实际联系的所得征税。税收协定则决定常设机构是否成立。征求意见稿不替代这一层分析。

它做的是征管层面的事:为已经落在第三条范围内的主体,安排申报、扣缴与追缴。因此它应当与协定分析并行阅读,而不是替代协定分析。这个区分很重要:一个集团可能有协定意义上的常设机构而没有实体,也可能有实体而不构成常设机构;征求意见稿解决的是税怎么管,不是税该不该征。

顺序也要摆正。先按国内法判断是否存在机构、场所与所得的实际联系,再按协定判断常设机构是否成立、利润如何归属,最后才落到征求意见稿所规定的申报与扣缴程序。把顺序颠倒过来,容易在程序问题上得出错误结论——比如因为”没有独立法人”就认为无需申报,或者因为”有合同”就认为一定构成机构、场所。征求意见稿没有、也不打算解决这些前置判断。

还要注意一个常见的混淆:把”统一纳税地点”读成”统一税负”。两者没有关系。统一纳税地点解决的是向谁申报、由谁追缴;税负取决于所得性质、金额与可适用的协定待遇。跨省经营主体真正要算的是现金流与合规成本——申报集中到一地,可能减少多头报送,也可能让原本分散在各地的资料归集变得更集中、更依赖总部。

两层结论不一致是常态。国内法上构成机构、场所,协定下未必构成常设机构;反之亦然。处理路径也不同:前者决定税该不该征、征多少,后者决定向谁报、怎么报。把两层混在一起讨论,内部评审时最容易卡住。

等待期内的准备动作

等待期不是空档期。规则一旦定稿,留给企业调整申报安排的时间通常不长,而申报安排牵动的是财务共享中心、资金归集与内部审批链条,改起来比改一张表慢得多。以下动作可以在文本定稿前完成。

盘点的口径建议宽一些,不要只列有营业执照的主体。非居民企业所得税的”机构、场所”并不限于已办理登记的主体,项目现场、演出场地、派驻团队都可能落在里面。列的时候按”活动”而不是按”公司”来列,往往能发现漏项。

  • 盘点在华存在:分支机构、代表处、项目现场、演出场所、合作办学项目、合伙企业权益。逐项列出主体、活动、收入与现行申报安排。
  • 标出”申报地”与”机构场所所在地”不一致的条目。这些正是统一规则下会发生位移的条目,也是现金流受影响最直接的条目。
  • 复核现有扣缴关系。如果指定扣缴是因为付款方与机构场所分处不同省份而设,就要问一句:统一之后是否还需要。
  • 检查每项安排背后的支撑材料。表格简化不等于事实简化,材料该有的还得有。
  • 与属地主管税务机关做一次非正式沟通,确认现行做法在本地是如何执行的。征求意见阶段的口径交流,成本远低于定稿后的更正。
  • 如果征求意见稿触及企业正在使用的架构,利用意见窗口。提交渠道有两个:登录国家税务总局网站在”互动交流—意见征集”栏目提出;或信函寄至北京市西城区枣林前街 68 号国家税务总局国际税务司(邮编 100053),信封注明”《非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税管理办法》征求意见”。

意见不必写成法律意见书。对多数企业而言,最有用的是把具体场景讲清楚:什么样的活动、在哪个环节、现行做法是什么、统一之后会遇到什么障碍。这类反馈比原则性表态更容易被采纳。

如果决定不提交意见,也建议留一份内部备忘,记录当时的判断依据:哪些活动被认定为机构、场所,哪些没有,理由是什么。正式文本出台后,这份备忘会是最省事的对照材料——它记录的不是结论,而是得出结论时所用的假设,而假设往往才是需要修订的部分。备忘不必长,一页纸足够,但要有日期与经办人,否则半年之后没人说得清当时的依据是什么。

展望

正式文本出台时,有两点值得盯:更宽的口径是以现有概念界定,还是另设一份清单;统一的纳税地点是否为已在异地申报的集团安排过渡。这两点在征求意见稿里都还没有落定。

还有一点值得留意:暂行办法拟同步废止,新旧两套规则不会长期并行。这对企业是好事,规则单一,判断简单;但切换时点前后的申报归属仍要提前排好,尤其是跨年度项目——项目跨越定稿日期的,按哪一套规则归属,要以正式文本为准。在此之前,企业能做的其实只有两件事:把自家的清单摸清楚,把意见递上去。

延伸阅读

  • 《非居民纳税人享受税收协定待遇:外商投资企业 2026 合规指引》(第 283 篇)——征求意见稿预设但未重述的协定层。

来源

  • 国家税务总局·《非居民企业机构、场所企业所得税管理办法(征求意见稿)》公开征求意见:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/chinatax/n810356/n810961/c5253117/content.html
  • 国家税务总局·新闻稿及解读:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/chinatax/n810219/n810724/c5253170/content.html
  • 国家税务总局·政策文件:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/

Withholding VAT on Natural Person Service Providers: What Changes for Foreign-Invested Buyers

  • The Measures for Domestic Entities Withholding VAT on Natural Persons, an annex to Announcement No. 28 of 2026, took effect on 1 November 2026.
    财政部、税务总局公告 2026 年第 28 号所附《境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税管理办法》,自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行。
  • A domestic entity that buys research and development, software, design, consulting, broadcasting and film production, cultural or education services from a natural person becomes the withholding agent.
    境内单位向自然人购买研发、软件、设计、咨询、广播影视节目(作品)制作、文化、教育服务,即成为扣缴义务人。
  • Withholding is triggered when the single-day sales amount reaches the Per-Transaction Threshold, but a return must still be filed when nothing was withheld.
    当次(日)销售额达到按次纳税起征点时触发代扣,但未发生代扣的,仍须办理申报。
  • Surcharges are withheld together with VAT, and the amount is paid within 15 days of the following month.
    附加税费随增值税一并扣缴,并在次月 15 日内解缴。
  • The obligation is statutory: a contract clause making the service provider bear all taxes does not move it.
    该义务是法定的:约定由服务提供方承担全部税费的条款,并不能转移这项义务。
  • Where the natural person has already paid the tax, no withholding is due, but an invoice is still needed for the corporate income tax deduction.
    自然人已缴纳税款的,不再代扣,但企业所得税税前扣除仍需取得发票。

Withholding VAT on Natural Person Service Providers: What Changes for Foreign-Invested Buyers | 境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税:外资企业采购个人服务的扣缴流程

Overview

The Ministry of Finance and the State Taxation Administration published the Measures for Domestic Entities Withholding VAT on Natural Persons as an annex to Announcement No. 28 of 2026. The measures took effect on 1 November 2026.

For a foreign-invested company the practical effect is a shift in who does the paperwork. Previously the consultant paid the tax and had an invoice issued in their own name. Now the company buying the service is the withholding agent: it withholds, files and pays, on its own monthly cycle.

What the measure covers

Article 1 lists the services: research and development, software, design, consulting, broadcasting and film and television programme production, culture, and education — the qualifying taxable transactions. Specific scope follows Announcement No. 9 of 2026.

Article 2 defines the payer as the domestic entity that is the purchaser. Consideration covers the full price corresponding to economic benefits in monetary and non-monetary form, so in-kind elements do not sit outside the measure.

The counterparty is a natural person, not a company: an individual consultant, a freelance designer and a sole practitioner trainer all fall inside; a domestic company providing the same service does not.

The four mechanics

Trigger. Where the natural person’s transaction with a single withholding agent reaches the per-transaction threshold that day, the agent withholds at payment; if the tax was paid, no withholding is due.

Surcharge. Surcharges are withheld with VAT, in one calculation.

Deadline. The tax period is one month; the agent files and pays within 15 days of the following month’s first day. The return form is prescribed by Announcement No. 19 of 2026: the date of the withholding obligation is given to the day, and several dates for one person go on separate lines.

Correction. Where a sales allowance, suspension or return changes the amount, the agent corrects the return for that period, not the next one.

Filing even when nothing was withheld

Under Article 6, where the day’s sales amount is below the threshold, an exemption applies, or no withholding is required because the tax was paid, the agent must still file.

A company can withhold nothing all month and still owe a nil return. This turns a working payment process into a penalty exposure: the payment team sees no tax movement, the tax team never hears of it.

The fix is procedural: payment approval must notify tax whenever a natural-person service invoice is processed, whether or not tax was withheld.

The invoice and the deduction

Article 5 settles double payment: where VAT has been withheld, the natural person does not pay again when applying for an invoice; if they do not apply, the agent may remind them.

Withholding does not remove the need for an invoice, which in practice remains the voucher for the corporate income tax deduction, so the reminder is a control rather than a courtesy.

Two withholdings, calculated separately

Buying services from an individual also triggers individual income tax withholding on remuneration for services. The two run in parallel, are calculated separately, and neither offsets the other.

One payment instruction therefore needs two determinations, possibly on different cycles. Treating the measure as a replacement for the individual income tax process produces double counting or under-withholding.

Why this is a contract problem

Agreements with individual consultants commonly say that all taxes are borne by the consultant. That can allocate the economic burden; it cannot change who the withholding agent is, because that status is assigned by the measure.

In a dispute, if the company fails to withhold and the authority pursues the tax, the clause gives a claim against the consultant, not an answer to the authority. Drafting should separate who bears the cost from who performs the obligation. Only the first is negotiable.

Two boundaries: Article 14 excludes individuals working through a platform that files on their behalf; Article 15 leaves transactions from 1 January to 31 October 2026 to the natural person, who declares under Article 44 of the VAT Law Implementing Regulations.

Practical checklist

  • Amend the consultant agreement: withholding arrangement, identity details, cost clause apart from the obligation.
  • Gate payment approval: payments to natural persons for listed services route to tax.
  • Keep a ledger by payment date: the return is monthly, the trigger daily.
  • Confirm which entity is the purchaser; the obligation attaches to it, not to the group.
  • Retain invoice, calculation and filing record together; a nil month still needs one.

Outlook

The measure moves collection upstream, from the individual’s visit to the tax office to the buyer’s return. For groups with many small engagements, cost and risk move to procurement and tax.

Related reading

  • Article 359 covers VAT on labour dispatch — supplied labour through an intermediary.

Sources

  • 江苏省税务局·12366 热点问答(含起征点与施行日期):https://jiangsu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/12/art_8353_1791332.html
  • 深圳市税务局·问答(含第一条范围原文):https://shenzhen.chinatax.gov.cn/sztax/lyhf/202610/fc631bf1e27b48aa953375a5ccc3841a.shtml
  • 甘肃省税务局·问答(含第五条、第十五条原文):http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/9/10/art_75_476972.html
  • 国家税务总局 12366 纳税服务平台·答复:https://12366.chinatax.gov.cn/nszx/onlinemessage/detail?id=fbfe39593caa4745b006f0e06c343507
  • 国家税务总局·政策文件:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/

境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税:外资企业采购个人服务的扣缴流程

概述

财政部、税务总局发布公告 2026 年第 28 号,附件为《境内单位代扣代缴自然人增值税管理办法》,自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行。办法全文不长,条文集中在扣缴范围、触发条件、申报期限与过渡安排四件事上。它管的是增值税这一个税种,但一次付款往往牵动多个税种,所以真正要改的是流程,而不是某一张申报表。

对在华外资企业而言,实际影响是”谁去跑手续”发生了变化。此前,企业按项目聘请个人顾问,通常由该个人到税务机关缴税、以自己名义代开发票,企业取得发票后列支成本。新办法实施后,购买服务的境内单位成为扣缴义务人:由企业扣、由企业申报、由企业解缴,并且按月并入自己的申报节奏。义务由此从供应商一侧转到采购方一侧,而交易对手并不在企业控制之下。

对多数外资企业来说,这不是一个新税种,而是一次征收方式的调整:税负本身没有变化,变的是由谁申报、在什么时点申报,以及一旦漏报由谁承担后果。

扣缴义务的性质值得说重一些:它不是”帮忙代付”,而是一项独立的法律义务:判断标准、申报期限、资料留存都由办法规定,与合同怎么签没有关系。企业过去对个人供应商的管理方式——收票、付款、归档——在新办法下不再够用,需要往前提一步。

办法覆盖什么

第一条列举了服务范围:研发服务、软件服务、设计服务、咨询服务、广播影视节目(作品)制作服务、文化服务、教育服务,统称符合规定的应税交易。各项的具体范围,按《财政部 税务总局关于增值税征税具体范围有关事项的公告》(财政部 税务总局公告 2026 年第 9 号)执行。也就是说,范围不是靠这七类名称自行解释,而要回到第 9 号公告去找边界。

第二条界定付款方。”支付价款的境内单位”,指作为应税交易购买方的境内单位。价款不限于货币:它包括货币和非货币形式经济利益对应的全部价款。以股权或者实物折抵的部分,因此也不在办法之外,不能因为”没走银行”就认为不在范围内。

交易对手是自然人,不是公司。个人顾问、自由职业设计师、独立执业培训师都在范围内;提供同样服务的境内公司不在范围内。这条界线看起来清楚,实务中却常被”个人工作室”这类主体形态模糊掉,签约前应先看清对方登记为什么主体、发票由谁开具。

把这三条放在一起看,外资企业最常见的几类采购几乎都在范围内:市场部门聘请的自由摄影师与插画师、研发部门按项目聘请的外部专家、人力资源部门请来做内训的独立讲师。它们的共同特征是:合同主体是个人,付的是服务费,不是工资。

四项机制

触发。 自然人与单一扣缴义务人发生符合规定的应税交易,当次(日)销售额达到按次纳税起征点的,扣缴义务人在支付价款时代扣增值税;自然人已缴纳税款的,无需代扣。

附加。 扣缴增值税时,应同时扣缴附加税费,一次计算、一次解缴,不需要为附加单独跑一次申报。

期限。 计税期间为一个月,扣缴义务人应自发生应税交易次月 1 日起 15 日内,向主管税务机关办理扣缴申报并缴纳税款。申报表由国家税务总局公告 2026 年第 19 号公布,附填报说明:其中”扣缴义务发生日期”一栏须具体到年月日;同一自然人多日发生应税交易的,按不同日期分行填写。

更正。 因销售折让、中止或者退回导致应扣缴增值税发生变化的,应当更正扣缴当期的扣缴申报,而不是在下一期冲抵。

四项机制里,前两项决定”扣多少”,后两项决定”什么时候交、交错了怎么改”。真正容易出问题的往往是后两项,因为它们跨部门、跨系统,而扣多少通常还有财务系统兜底。申报表要求填到”日”,也说明征管是按日建账的:申报按月,但每一笔的时点都要能被还原。期限这一项还有一个连带影响:它把自然人服务的扣缴并入了企业原有的增值税申报节奏,不需要另建一套申报日历,但需要在原有流程里多留一道核对。

没有代扣也要申报

当次(日)销售额未达到起征点、适用免征增值税政策,或者按第三条规定无需代扣的,扣缴义务人仍应按第五条办理申报。这是第六条,也是最容易被漏掉的一条:它的存在本身,就是对”没扣就不用管”这一假设的否定。

这一条的杀伤力在于它与直觉相反。企业可能整月一分钱没扣,却仍然欠一份申报。让一个运转良好的付款流程变成处罚风险的,往往就是这一项:付款团队看到没有税款变动,税务团队压根不知道发生过这笔交易。

补救办法在流程而不在技术:付款审批环节只要处理到自然人服务发票,无论是否代扣,都应同步通知税务岗。这个动作成本很低,但需要写进制度,否则只能依赖个人记性,而个人记性恰恰是流程里最不可靠的一环。反过来说,只要当月发生过一笔这样的付款,就不存在”这个月不用管”的情况。

发票与税前扣除

第五条同时解决了重复缴税的问题。已按规定扣缴的应税交易,自然人申请代开发票时无需再次缴纳税款;自然人未申请代开发票的,扣缴义务人可以向其发起开票提醒。

代扣并不取代发票。实务中,发票仍是企业所得税税前扣除的凭证,因此开票提醒是一项控制动作,不是礼貌提醒。此外,发票信息应与已扣缴事实对得上,让两套记录相互印证,而不是各记一笔、事后对不上。对财务共享中心而言,这意味着发票、扣缴计算与申报记录要能按同一笔交易串起来;开票时间晚于付款时间的,台账要留出这段时差。对税务岗而言,最实用的控制点是”付款前看到发票”,而不是”付款后补发票”。

两套扣缴,分别计算

向个人采购服务,还会触发第二条扣缴线:劳务报酬所得的个人所得税。两套扣缴并行办理、分别计算,互不抵减,缴了其中一套不等于履行了另一套。

操作上的后果是:一笔付款指令在放行前需要两个判断——一边是增值税及附加,一边是个人所得税——而且两者的申报周期可能不同。把新办法当成对原有个税流程的替代,结果不是重复扣,就是少扣。这一点在系统改造时尤其要写清楚:两条扣缴线共用一张付款单,但不能共用一套逻辑;两者的计算口径也不相同,不能把一个数字直接套到另一套上。

为什么这是合同问题

与个人顾问签订的服务协议里,常见一句”因本项合作产生的全部税费由顾问承担”。这类条款可以分配双方之间的经济负担,但不改变扣缴义务人是谁,因为这一身份由办法规定,不由合同约定。

这个区分在争议中很关键。企业未扣缴、税务机关追缴时,条款给企业的是向顾问追偿的请求权,而不是对税务机关的抗辩。因此起草时应把两个问题分开写:谁承担成本,谁履行义务。只有前者可以谈,后者只能照办。实务中还有一种变体:约定由顾问自行开票、企业凭票付款。这种安排在新办法下仍然可行,但它只解决凭证问题,不解决扣缴问题。

两条边界规则补完整图景。第十四条规定,互联网平台内从业人员通过平台发生符合规定的应税交易,由平台企业按规定办理代办申报的,不适用本办法。第十五条是过渡安排:2026 年 1 月 1 日至 10 月 31 日期间自然人发生的符合规定的应税交易,由自然人按《中华人民共和国增值税法实施条例》第四十四条规定自行申报纳税。这条过渡条款的实际含义是:11 月 1 日之前的存量交易,不由境内单位补扣,但仍要确认对方是否已经申报。

实操清单

  • 修改个人顾问合同模板:写明扣缴安排,要求提供身份与税收居民信息,并把成本承担条款与义务履行条款分开表述。
  • 在付款审批中加一道闸:向自然人支付列举范围内服务的款项,放行前转税务岗确认。
  • 按付款日期建立扣缴台账,因为申报按月,而触发按次(日)。
  • 确认签约主体是谁,义务落在购买方实体上,不落在集团层面。
  • 发票、扣缴计算与申报记录合并留存;零税款的月份同样需要申报记录。
  • 对 11 月 1 日前的存量个人服务交易做一次抽查,确认对方已按规定自行申报。
  • 在合同、付款、申报三个环节各设一个检查点,比集中培训一次更管用。
  • 把”是否属于列举范围”做成付款系统的选项,而不是靠人工判断。判断看的是交易性质,不是付款名目;把”顾问费”改称”服务费”,结论不变。

展望

办法把个人服务环节的增值税征收前移:从自然人跑税务局,变成购买方按月申报。对存在大量小额合作——设计、研发、技术咨询、培训——的集团而言,合规成本从供应商一侧转移到采购与税务一侧,风险也随之转移,而且转移得更快。需要提前做的,不是等第一笔业务发生,而是把合同模板与付款流程先改到位。过渡期之前的存量交易,办法已交回自然人自行申报,企业要做的是确认,而不是补扣。对采购量大的企业,最省事的做法是把判断前移到供应商准入环节:新签个人顾问时一次性录入身份、居民状态与开票方式,后续每笔付款按规则分流。

延伸阅读

  • 本库第 359 篇写的是劳务派遣的增值税处理,问题不同:那是通过企业中介提供劳动力,而不是直接向自然人采购服务。两篇可以对照读,但不要把结论混用。

来源

  • 江苏省税务局·12366 热点问答(含起征点与施行日期):https://jiangsu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/12/art_8353_1791332.html
  • 深圳市税务局·问答(含第一条范围原文):https://shenzhen.chinatax.gov.cn/sztax/lyhf/202610/fc631bf1e27b48aa953375a5ccc3841a.shtml
  • 甘肃省税务局·问答(含第五条、第十五条原文):http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/9/10/art_75_476972.html
  • 国家税务总局 12366 纳税服务平台·答复:https://12366.chinatax.gov.cn/nszx/onlinemessage/detail?id=fbfe39593caa4745b006f0e06c343507
  • 国家税务总局·政策文件:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/

Tax Credit for Reinvested Profits: The 2025 Rules and Their October 2026 Local Landing

  • The credit for reinvested profits rests on Announcement No. 2 of 2025 by the Ministry of Finance, the State Taxation Administration and the Ministry of Commerce, and on SAT Announcement No. 18 of 2025 on administration; it is not a 2026 policy, and October 2026 is when local execution became visible.
    利润再投资税收抵免依据财政部、税务总局、商务部 2025 年第 2 号公告与税务总局 2025 年第 18 号公告,并非 2026 年新出台的政策;2026 年 10 月是地方落地集中显现的时间。
  • Profits distributed by a Chinese resident enterprise and reinvested directly in China between 1 January 2025 and 31 December 2028 earn a credit of 10 per cent of the investment amount against the investor’s tax payable for the year, with unused credit carried forward.
    境外投资者在 2025 年 1 月 1 日至 2028 年 12 月 31 日期间,将以境内居民企业分配利润进行的符合条件的直接投资,可按投资额 10% 抵免当年应纳税额,不足部分准予结转以后年度。
  • Five conditions must be met together: the source of profit, the form of investment, the industry falling within the national encouraged catalogue, a holding period of at least five years, and a direct transfer of funds with no intermediate account.
    五项条件须同时满足:利润来源、投资方式、产业属于全国鼓励外商投资产业目录、持股满五年、资金直接划转不得周转。
  • The credit coexists with the deferral under Caishui [2018] No. 102: deferral changes when the withholding tax is paid, the credit reduces how much is paid.
    抵免与财税〔2018〕102 号项下的递延纳税可以同时享受:递延改变纳税时点,抵免减少纳税金额。
  • Two dates govern exit: five years of holding, and a seven-day window to declare and pay deferred tax after the investment is recovered, with a proportional reduction of the credit if the holding period falls short.
    退出环节受两个时点约束:持股满五年;收回投资后七日内申报补缴递延税款,持股不满五年的还须按比例减少抵免额度。
  • In October 2026 Bao’an district in Shenzhen publicised its first completed case, a Singapore-held airport equipment maker that ran the sequence from business registration change through commerce review, tax confirmation and foreign exchange registration.
    2026 年 10 月,深圳市宝安区公布首例落地案例:一家新加坡股东持股的空港装备制造企业走完工商变更、商务审核、税务确认、外汇登记全流程。

Tax Credit for Reinvested Profits: The 2025 Rules and Their October 2026 Local Landing | 利润再投资税收抵免:2025 年政策规则与 2026 年 10 月地方落地

Overview

The credit for reinvested profits is often described as a recent incentive. It is not. The substantive rule is Announcement No. 2 of 2025, issued jointly by the Ministry of Finance, the State Taxation Administration and the Ministry of Commerce on 27 June 2025; the administrative detail is SAT Announcement No. 18 of 2025, of 1 August 2025. What October 2026 adds is evidence of local execution: a first completed case in Shenzhen’s Bao’an district, an exchange meeting there on 16 October, a seminar in Luohu on 20 October, and confirmation forms issued by Gansu’s tax authority for four enterprise-instances, reported on 13 October.

The measure sits on an older one rather than replacing it. Caishui [2018] No. 102, with SAT Announcement No. 53 of 2018, allows a foreign investor to defer withholding tax on profits reinvested directly in China; the 2025 credit is additional and may be claimed at the same time. Deferral changes when the tax is paid, the credit reduces how much is paid.

How the credit works

The window runs from 1 January 2025 to 31 December 2028. Within it, where a foreign investor uses profits distributed by a Chinese resident enterprise for qualifying direct investment in China, it may credit 10 per cent of the investment against its tax payable for the year; excess credit is carried forward.

Where a treaty provides a dividend rate below 10 per cent, the credit may be computed at that rate instead. The election is irrevocable — including when the investor recovers the investment after five years and declares the deferred tax, the lower treaty ratio cannot then be substituted.

The tax against which the credit is set is defined narrowly: the enterprise income tax payable on dividends, interest, royalties and similar income under Article 3(3) of the Enterprise Income Tax Law that the investor derives from the profit-distributing enterprise after the date of reinvestment. In practice the credit is absorbed by withholding tax on later distributions from the same company.

Five conditions, all required

Source of profit. A dividend or other equity return formed from retained earnings actually distributed by a resident enterprise. Undistributed profit does not qualify.

Form of investment. Capital increase, new establishment or equity acquisition. New subscription, conversion or acquisition of shares in a listed company is excluded, except qualifying strategic investment.

Industry. The investee’s business must fall within the national catalogue of industries encouraged for foreign investment. A regional catalogue does not substitute for it — the condition most often misread.

Holding period. Continuous holding of at least five years, or 60 months.

Flow of funds. For cash, from the distributor’s account directly to the investee or the equity seller, with no intermediate account in China or abroad. For non-cash consideration, ownership passes directly, and may not be held by another enterprise or individual even temporarily.

Procedure, and two dates

The filing route runs through the investee. The investor reports to the local commerce authority on the Ministry of Commerce’s unified platform: names and jurisdictions, the locations of investee and distributor, the date of reinvestment, the industry and the amount, with evidence. The local authority verifies and submits the file to the provincial commerce authority, which confirms eligibility with the finance and tax authorities at the same level and issues a Profit Reinvestment Confirmation Form with a nationally unique code.

For the credit, the investor gives the distributor the information report form and the confirmation form; the distributor submits the withholding return and both forms to its competent tax authority.

Two dates matter on exit. The first is the fifth anniversary. The second is the seven days after recovery: where the investment is recovered after five years, the deferred tax is declared and paid within seven days to the tax authority where the distributor sits, and any remaining credit may offset the liability. Where recovery happens earlier, the deferred tax is payable and the credit is reduced proportionally, with any excess already used paid within seven days.

Beyond the window, a balance remaining at 31 December 2028 may be used until exhausted. Investment made between 1 January 2025 and the announcement could be submitted for retroactive treatment, but credit formed in that interval offsets only tax arising afterwards. Investment before 1 January 2025 cannot be treated retroactively.

Where it landed in October 2026

Bao’an. In August 2026 an airport equipment manufacturer with a Singaporean shareholder completed a reinvestment and applied the credit — the district’s first case. On 16 October the district commerce and tax bureaus held an exchange meeting at the company with twelve foreign-invested enterprises from Germany, Italy, Japan, Sweden and Hong Kong; its finance team walked through registration change, commerce review, tax confirmation and foreign exchange registration. The district recorded RMB 5 billion of actual foreign investment in 2025, up 41.2 per cent and third in the city, with 19 multinational regional headquarters recognised.

Luohu. On 20 October the district investment promotion bureau held a seminar for more than twenty foreign-invested enterprises, at which the tax department explained the scope and conditions.

Gansu. During 2026 the provincial tax authority has issued the confirmation form for four enterprise-instances, as reported by China Tax News on 13 October.

National. Reinvestment reached RMB 93.99 billion in January–September 2026, up 4.7 per cent, its share up 1.5 percentage points, per the Ministry of Commerce briefing on 22 October.

Implications for foreign companies

Three errors account for most lost claims, and each is structural.

Routing the money through the overseas parent destroys eligibility: the funds must move from the distributor’s account directly to the investee, so the sequencing has to be designed before the distribution resolution.

Assuming any equity purchase qualifies is the second: listed shares are outside the scope unless the investment is a qualifying strategic investment.

Reading the regional catalogue is the third: the test is the national catalogue, and a project listed only provincially fails.

The two dates belong in the investment agreement. A five-year hold is a long commitment for a group that may need to restructure, and a partial recovery triggers a seven-day payment window.

The local cases show where the bottleneck sits. Bao’an’s four steps belong to four functions, and the confirmation form is issued mid-chain; a group that starts after the capital is paid in has usually broken the flow condition. In provinces with fewer cases, issuance of the form is itself the pacing item.

Related reading

  • *China’s 15-Measure Action Plan for Stabilising Foreign Investment: A Clause-by-Clause Guide* (Article 471) — reinvestment appears there as one item in a wider facilitation package.
  • Withholding tax on dividends and the treaty network: how the rate is fixed before the credit election is made.

Sources

  • 国家税务总局甘肃省税务局·《中国税务报》关于为 4 户次企业出具《利润再投资情况表》的报道(2026-10-13):http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/13/art_560_480123.html
  • 深圳市宝安区人民政府·宝安区首例利润再投资税收抵免办结(2026-10-21):https://www.baoan.gov.cn/baqwqfbgs/gkmlpt/content/13/13034/post_13034898.html
  • 深圳市人民政府·罗湖区外商投资企业政策座谈会(2026-10-20):https://www.sz.gov.cn/cn/zjsz/fwts_1_3/tzdt_1/content/post_13033609.html
  • 国家税务总局山东省税务局·政策文件栏目(含财政部 税务总局 商务部 2025 年第 2 号公告、国家税务总局 2025 年第 18 号公告):https://shandong.chinatax.gov.cn/col/col17634/index.html
  • 国家税务总局·境外投资者以分配利润直接投资税收抵免政策与申报口径(总局政策文件栏目):https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/

利润再投资税收抵免:2025 年政策规则与 2026 年 10 月地方落地

概述

利润再投资税收抵免常被描述为一项新近推出的优惠。这个说法不准确。实体规则是财政部、税务总局、商务部于 2025 年 6 月 27 日联合发布的 2025 年第 2 号公告;征管口径是国家税务总局于 2025 年 8 月 1 日发布的 2025 年第 18 号公告。两份文件在符合条件的窗口期开始时就已生效。2026 年 10 月增加的是地方执行的证据:深圳市宝安区首例办结、10 月 16 日该区举办的交流会、10 月 20 日罗湖区的座谈会,以及甘肃省税务局为 4 户次企业出具《利润再投资情况表》(10 月 13 日报道)。

这项政策不是取代旧政策,而是叠加在旧政策之上。财税〔2018〕102 号文及国家税务总局 2018 年第 53 号公告,允许境外投资者将以分配利润直接在境内投资时暂不征收预提所得税。2025 年的抵免是额外的,可以与递延同时享受。两者作用在不同的变量上:递延改变纳税时点,抵免减少纳税金额。对一个已在中国子公司累积利润、正在权衡汇出还是再投资的集团来说,这是现行外资制度中最具体的现金激励;它的适用条件又相当机械,意味着工作重点在材料与顺序,而不在政策解释。

抵免如何计算

窗口期为 2025 年 1 月 1 日至 2028 年 12 月 31 日。在此期间,境外投资者将以境内居民企业分配的利润用于境内符合条件的直接投资,可按投资额的 10% 抵免当年应纳税额;超过当年应纳税额的部分,准予向以后年度结转使用。

若我国与该投资者所在税收管辖区签订的税收协定规定股息适用税率低于 10%,可按协定税率计算抵免。该选择一经作出不得变更。尤其是在持股满五年后收回投资、申报补缴递延税款时,不能再改用更低的协定比例——设立之初的选择决定后续全部计算。

可用于抵免的税额界定得较窄:限于境外投资者自利润分配再投资之日以后,从利润分配企业取得的、按企业所得税法第三条第三款规定的股息红利、利息、特许权使用费等所得应缴纳的企业所得税。实务中,抵免额度通常由同一公司后续分配产生的预提所得税吸收,而不是由其他来源所得的税款吸收。

五项条件,须同时满足

利润来源。 分配的利润须属境内居民企业向投资者实际分配的留存收益所形成的股息、红利等权益性投资收益。账上有利润但未分配不行,分配这个动作必须已经发生。

投资方式。 以分得利润进行的境内直接投资,包括增资、新建、股权收购等权益性投资。新增、转增、收购上市公司股份不在范围内,符合条件的战略投资除外。

产业范围。 再投资期限内,被投资企业从事的产业须属于《鼓励外商投资产业目录》中的全国鼓励外商投资产业目录所列产业。地区目录不能替代全国目录,这是最常被误读的一项条件。

投资期限。 连续持有满五年(60 个月)以上。

资金流转。 以现金支付的,款项须从利润分配企业账户直接转入被投资企业或股权转让方账户,直接投资前不得在境内外其他账户周转;以实物、有价证券等非现金形式支付的,资产所有权须直接从利润分配企业转入被投资企业或股权转让方,不得由其他企业、个人代为持有或临时持有。

办理路径与两个时点

资料报送经由被投资企业完成。境外投资者通过被投资企业,经商务部业务系统统一平台(外商投资综合管理应用)向所在地商务主管部门报送:境外投资者名称与国别、被投资企业与利润分配企业名称及所在地、再投资时间、行业领域与金额,并附凭证。企业所在地商务主管部门比对核实后,提交省级商务主管部门,由省级商务主管部门会同同级财政、税务等部门确认符合条件,出具载有全国唯一编码的《利润再投资情况表》等材料;被投资企业将材料交给境外投资者。

抵免环节,境外投资者向利润分配企业提供《境外投资者再投资税收抵免信息报告表》和《利润再投资情况表》。利润分配企业申报抵减时,向主管税务机关提交《中华人民共和国扣缴企业所得税报告表》及上述两份表格。

退出环节受两个时点约束。第一个是持股满五年。第二个是收回投资后的七日:投资满五年后收回全部或部分直接投资的,应在收回投资后七日内向利润分配企业所在地税务机关申报补缴递延税款,抵免结转余额可抵减其应纳税款;持股不满五年收回的,除补缴递延税款外,还须按比例减少可享受的抵免额度,已使用额度超过调整后额度的,应在七日内补缴超出部分。

窗口期结束后,2028 年 12 月 31 日以后仍有抵免余额的,可继续享受至余额用完。2025 年 1 月 1 日至公告发布前发生的符合条件投资,可自公告发布之日起申请追补享受,但该期间形成的抵免额度仅可用于抵减公告发布之日后产生的符合条件应纳税额;2025 年 1 月 1 日之前的投资不得追溯享受。

2026 年 10 月的地方落地

深圳宝安。 2026 年 8 月,一家外资股东来自新加坡的空港装备制造企业完成利润再投资并成功适用抵免政策,为宝安区首例。10 月 16 日,宝安区商务局、区税务局在该企业举办外资企业交流会,来自德国、意大利、日本、瑞典及中国香港等国家和地区的 12 家重点外资企业参加,企业财务团队按工商变更、商务审核、税务确认、外汇登记四步拆解了全流程。宝安区 2025 年实际使用外资 50 亿元、同比增长 41.2%,规模居深圳全市第三;全区累计认定跨国公司总部企业 19 家。

深圳罗湖。 10 月 20 日,罗湖区投资促进局举办外资企业专题交流座谈会,20 余家重点外资企业参加,区税务部门就抵免政策的适用范围与享受条件作了讲解。

甘肃。 2026 年,甘肃省税务局落实境外投资者利润再投资递延纳税政策,已为 4 户次企业出具《利润再投资情况表》,据《中国税务报》10 月 13 日报道。出具情况表是税务机关一侧的动作,也是把一笔符合条件的交易转化为扣缴义务人可以据以操作的文件的那一步。

全国口径。 据商务部 2026 年 10 月 22 日在国务院新闻办公室发布会上的数据,1—9 月利润再投资 939.9 亿元,同比增长 4.7%,占比较去年同期提高 1.5 个百分点。

对外资企业的实务意义

绝大多数落空的申请源于三类错误,而三类都属架构与顺序问题,不是解释问题。

第一类是把钱先汇到境外母公司。把股息汇给香港控股公司、再从香港汇回作为出资,是最常见的资金安排之一,而它直接摧毁资格,因为款项须从利润分配企业账户直接转入被投资企业。顺序必须在作出分配决议之前设计,而不是在之后补救。

第二类是想当然地认为任何股权购买都符合条件。上市公司股份不在范围内,除非属于符合条件的战略投资——这是一个比二级市场买入窄得多的类别。

第三类是拿地区目录当全国目录。条件指向的是《鼓励外商投资产业目录》中的全国目录;一个只列入省级鼓励目录、未列入全国目录的项目,不满足条件。

在资格之外,两个时点应当写进投资协议。五年持有对一个可能需要重组的集团是长承诺;部分收回触发七日缴款窗口,资金安排稍有疏漏就会错过。若设立时已按协定税率作出选择,退出计算就按该比例进行,不能改用届时看起来更有利的更低税率。

地方案例提示了实操瓶颈的位置。宝安的四步——工商变更、商务审核、税务确认、外汇登记——分属四个不同职能,而情况表在链条中段出具。若集团在资金已经缴付之后才启动流程,通常已经破坏了资金流转条件。甘肃的 4 户次则说明另一面:在案例较少的省份,税务机关出具情况表本身就是影响进度的环节,及早与当地商务、税务部门沟通,比把内部材料做到完美更有价值。

延伸阅读

  • 《中国利用外资固稳促优行动方案 15 条逐条解读》(第 471 篇)——再投资在其中是一项更宽泛便利化安排中的一个条目。
  • 股息预提所得税与税收协定网络:在作出抵免比例选择之前,税率如何确定。
  • 财税〔2018〕102 号项下的再投资递延纳税及其与集团资金安排的衔接。

来源

  • 国家税务总局甘肃省税务局·《中国税务报》关于为 4 户次企业出具《利润再投资情况表》的报道(2026-10-13):http://gansu.chinatax.gov.cn/art/2026/10/13/art_560_480123.html
  • 深圳市宝安区人民政府·全区首例利润再投资税收抵免落地(2026-10-21):https://www.baoan.gov.cn/baqwqfbgs/gkmlpt/content/13/13034/post_13034898.html
  • 深圳政府在线·罗湖区外资企业专题交流座谈会(2026-10-20):https://www.sz.gov.cn/cn/zjsz/fwts_1_3/tzdt_1/content/post_13033609.html
  • 红网政务·政策要点梳理(含 2025 年第 2 号公告与 2025 年第 18 号公告引述):https://gov.rednet.cn/content/646054/66/16396922.html
  • 国家税务总局山东省税务局·政策公告列表(可见 2025 年第 18 号公告条目):https://shandong.chinatax.gov.cn/col/col17634/index.html?uid=1845&pageNum=2

China Adjusts Export Tax Rebates: New Energy Vehicles Cut to 9% from April 2027

  • Announcement No. 29 of 2026, issued on 12 October 2026, lowers the VAT export rebate rate for new energy vehicles from 13% to 9% from 1 April 2027.
    2026 年 10 月 12 日发布的 2026 年第 29 号公告,将新能源汽车的增值税出口退税率由 13% 下调至 9%,自 2027 年 4 月 1 日起执行。
  • The same announcement cancels, rather than reduces, the VAT export rebate for electronic cigarette devices and similar products from the same date.
    同一公告对电子烟设备装置等产品采取的是取消而非下调,同样自 2027 年 4 月 1 日起执行。
  • Affected products are identified through two annexes rather than described in the body of the announcement, so classification comes before rate calculation.
    受影响的产品通过两份附件清单界定,而非由公告正文描述,因此商品归类要先于税率测算。
  • For products subject to consumption tax, the export consumption tax policy is not adjusted and refund or exemption continues to apply.
    对征收消费税的产品,出口消费税政策不作调整,继续适用退(免)税政策。
  • The applicable rate follows the export date stated on the export goods declaration, which decides which side of 1 April 2027 a shipment falls on.
    适用税率以出口货物报关单注明的出口日期界定,这条口径决定了一票货物落在 2027 年 4 月 1 日的哪一侧。
  • The export rebate rate library, 2026C version, was issued on 10 October 2026, requiring local audit systems to be upgraded and barring unilateral rate changes.
    出口退税率文库 2026C 版于 2026 年 10 月 10 日发布,要求各地升级审核系统,并严禁擅自改变退税率。

China Adjusts Export Tax Rebates: New Energy Vehicles Cut to 9% from April 2027 | 中国调整出口退税:新能源汽车退税率自 2027 年 4 月起降至 9%

Overview

On 12 October 2026, the Ministry of Finance and the State Taxation Administration issued Announcement No. 29 of 2026 on export tax rebates. It lowers the value-added tax export rebate rate for new energy vehicles from 13% to 9%, and removes the VAT export rebate altogether for electronic cigarette devices and certain related products. Both changes take effect on 1 April 2027 and are scoped by product lists attached to the announcement.

Consumption tax treatment is untouched, and the applicable rate follows the export date on the export goods declaration. For exporters, the practical question is therefore less the rate than which side of 1 April 2027 a shipment falls on.

Key developments in 2026

What the announcement changes

Article 1 provides that, from 1 April 2027, the VAT export rebate rate for new energy vehicles is reduced from 13% to 9%, with the product list in Annex 1. Article 2 provides that, from the same date, the VAT export rebate for electronic cigarette devices and similar products is cancelled, with the product list in Annex 2.

The two are not the same kind of change. One reduces a rate; the other withdraws an entitlement. A product in Annex 1 still receives a rebate on export, at a lower rate. A product in Annex 2 receives no VAT rebate at all, which changes the cost structure of the transaction rather than its rate.

Scope is set by the annexes

Both articles point to lists in the annexes rather than describing goods in the body of the text. The reference to new energy vehicles in the title is a summary, not the legal boundary. The first step for any exporter is to match its portfolio against Annex 1 and Annex 2, item by item, using the classification under which goods are actually declared.

VAT and consumption tax run on separate tracks

Article 3 provides that, for listed products subject to consumption tax, the export consumption tax policy is not adjusted and the refund or exemption continues to apply. Both taxes are often discussed together in export pricing. A lower VAT rebate rate implies no change in consumption tax treatment: the two have different bases, rules and refund processes, and the announcement adjusts only one.

The declaration-date rule

Article 4 provides that the rate for the listed products is determined by the export date stated on the export goods declaration. This is the transition mechanism, and the provision most likely to matter day to day.

Goods declared before 1 April 2027 remain subject to the rate in force at the time of that declaration; the new rates attach to declarations made on or after that date. The reference point is the declaration date, not the contract, invoice, payment or factory-departure date. Exporters shipping near the boundary should treat the declaration date as the controlling variable, confirm how their broker records it, and keep the declaration on file.

The 2026C library

On 10 October 2026, the State Taxation Administration issued the export rebate rate library, 2026C version (Shuizong Huolao Han [2026] No. 214), requiring local authorities to upgrade audit systems and prohibiting unilateral changes to rates.

This is how the announcement reaches the declaration and refund systems: the library is what the audit software reads, and local practice is expected to follow it. The version is also a checkpoint: where an internal tax code points to an earlier version, a calculation may use a rate the system will not apply on assessment.

Practical implications for foreign businesses

  • Map the portfolio against both annexes first. Scope is set by the lists, and the two carry different consequences. A review at the ten-digit classification level underpins every later step.
  • Treat the declaration date as the boundary. Goods declared on or after 1 April 2027 fall under the new treatment regardless of when the contract was signed or goods produced.
  • Do not read the VAT change across to consumption tax. Where consumption tax applies, the export policy is unchanged; pricing sheets that merge the two taxes should be separated.
  • Distinguish a cut from a cancellation internally. A 9% rebate still produces a refund; a cancelled one produces none. Cash-flow forecasting and explanations to headquarters should treat them separately.
  • Re-run refund calculations transaction by transaction. The effect depends on product mix, declared value and the rate for each item, so a portfolio average is likely to mislead.
  • Reconcile internal tax codes with the 2026C library. Where an ERP system or broker template uses an earlier version, reconcile it before the first declaration under the new rates.

Related reading

  • China’s export tax rebate framework: rates, catalogues and declaration practice
  • Consumption tax on exported goods: refund and exemption rules
  • New energy vehicle exports from China: classification and certification essentials
  • How tax rate libraries are updated and how far they bind local practice

Sources

  • Ministry of Finance, Tax Policy Department — Announcement No. 29 of 2026, full text including Articles 1 to 4 and both annexes: https://szs.mof.gov.cn/zhengcefabu/202610/t20261012_4002592.htm
  • State Taxation Administration, tax policy and regulation database — record of the announcement and related rebate rules: https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • Beijing Municipal Tax Service, taxpayer knowledge base — policy collection including rate library updates: https://znhd.beijing.chinatax.gov.cn:8443/znhdzsknsrd/index?from=zcfg
  • State Taxation Administration — announcements and rate library releases: https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • Ministry of Finance, Tax Policy Department — release index for the announcement and annexes: https://szs.mof.gov.cn/zhengcefabu/202610/t20261012_4002592.htm
  • State Taxation Administration — library and audit system notices for local authorities: https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/

中国调整出口退税:新能源汽车退税率自 2027 年 4 月起降至 9%

概述

2026 年 10 月 12 日,财政部、税务总局发布 2026 年第 29 号公告,对出口退税作出调整。公告将新能源汽车的增值税出口退税率由 13% 下调至 9%,并对电子烟设备装置等产品取消增值税出口退税。两项调整均自 2027 年 4 月 1 日起执行,适用产品范围由公告所附清单界定。

公告对受影响产品的消费税待遇未作改动,并设定一条统一的过渡口径:适用税率以出口货物报关单注明的出口日期界定。因此,对出口企业而言,未来数月真正需要回答的问题,与其说是税率本身,不如说是一票货物落在 2027 年 4 月 1 日的哪一侧。

需要说明的是,公告调整的是退税率与适用范围,并未改变出口退(免)税的基本申报程序。企业原有的单证留存、申报期限与审核流程继续适用,变动集中在两点:哪些产品在范围内,以及某票货物适用哪一档税率。两份附件分别对应下调与取消两种处理,核对时宜分别标注,不宜合并为一张清单处理。这一区分也影响与海外客户、供应商的沟通方式:属于可预见的价格要素,宜在合同条款中提前安排,而不是等到报关时再作说明。

2026 年主要进展

公告调整了什么

第一条规定,自 2027 年 4 月 1 日起,将新能源汽车的增值税出口退税率由 13% 下调至 9%,具体产品清单见附件 1。第二条规定,自同日起,取消电子烟设备装置等产品的增值税出口退税,具体产品清单见附件 2。

两条的性质并不相同。一条是下调税率,另一条是取消待遇。列入附件 1 的产品仍可就出口取得退税,只是税率降低,围绕它的申报、匹配、退税申请等流程继续运转。列入附件 2 的产品则不再取得增值税出口退税,改变的是交易的成本结构,而不只是税率高低。这一区别在内部沟通中容易被”退税率调整”四个字掩盖,但在财务处理上并不相同:前者是退税额减少,后者是该项退税不再存在。

产品范围由附件界定

两条均指向附件中的产品清单,而非在正文中描述货物本身。标题层面的”新能源汽车”是一句概括,不是法律边界。因此,出口企业的第一步实务动作,是按实际报关使用的商品归类,逐项比对附件 1 与附件 2。若企业同时出口两类产品,两份附件须分别核对,因为后果并不一样。

这一步往往需要关务、税务与业务部门共同完成。单靠财务口径,很难判断某个具体型号究竟落入哪一份清单;而归类一旦有偏差,后续的退税测算与合同定价都会随之偏离。对存在多种配置或选装件的产品,还应确认附件清单是按整机归类还是按部件归类,这一判断会直接影响最终适用哪一档税率。

增值税与消费税分属两条线

第三条规定,对上述产品中征收消费税的产品,出口消费税政策不作调整,继续适用消费税退(免)税政策。这一点之所以重要,是因为在出口定价的实际讨论中,两个税种常被放在一起。增值税退税率下调,并不意味着消费税待遇发生任何变化。两者计税依据不同、管理规则不同、退还流程也不同,而本次公告只调整了其中之一。对同时涉及两类税种的产品,建议在内部台账中分别列示,避免一处口径变动牵连另一处。

由此带来的实务提示是:把两个税种合并在一张测算表里的做法,需要拆开重新核对。对既涉及增值税退税、又涉及消费税退(免)税的产品,两张表的适用规则应分别标注,避免因一处变动而误改另一处。

以报关单出口日期界定的过渡规则

第四条规定,所列产品的出口退税率以出口货物报关单注明的出口日期界定。这是过渡安排,也是最容易在日常操作中产生分歧的条款。

在 2027 年 4 月 1 日之前报关出口的货物,仍适用报关时有效的退税率;新税率适用于该日及之后报关的货物。判断基准是报关单上注明的出口日期,而不是合同签订日、发票开具日、收款日或货物出厂日。对于发货时点临近这条分界线的企业,建议把报关日期作为控制变量,事先与报关代理确认其记录方式,并留存报关单,因为退税审核环节看的正是这份单证。

还有一种情形值得留意:若一批货物因故改单、退关后重新申报,报关单上的出口日期会随之变化,适用税率也应重新确认。这类情况在临近生效日的出货高峰中并不罕见,提前与报关代理约定处理方式,比事后追溯更为稳妥。此外,出口日期与收汇、开票时点并不必然同步,财务在归档时宜以报关单为准,而不是以账面确认收入的日期为准。

2026C 版退税率文库与系统准备

2026 年 10 月 10 日,税务总局发布出口退税率文库 2026C 版(税总货劳函〔2026〕214 号)。随文库下发的通知要求各地税务机关升级审核系统,并明确严禁擅自改变退税率。

这是公告在实际操作中传导至报关与退税系统的通道。退税申请进入审核时,审核软件读取的正是该文库;各地执行也被要求以文库为准,而不是另行偏离。对企业来说,文库版本同时是一个可用的校验点:如果内部税码或主数据表仍指向旧版本,测算时采用的税率可能并非系统在审核时实际适用的税率。文库升级通常由系统服务商或内部信息部门完成,税务与关务团队宜在升级后做一次抽样验证,确认常用商品编码对应的税率已同步更新。

对外资企业的实务意义

  • 先比对两份附件,再做任何测算。 适用范围由清单确定,两份清单的后果不同。按十位商品编码做一次归类复核,是后续所有步骤的基础。
  • 把报关日期而非发货日期当作分界线。 计划在 2027 年 4 月 1 日及之后报关的货物,无论合同何时签订、货物何时生产,都适用新的处理方式。
  • 不要把增值税的变化推及消费税。 对征收消费税的产品,出口消费税政策并未调整。把两个税种合并在同一张表里测算的做法,建议拆开处理。
  • 在内部报告中区分”下调”与”取消”。 9% 的退税率仍会产生退税款,取消则不再产生。两者在现金流预测中的处理方式不同,向总部解释口径时也应分开说明。
  • 按交易逐笔重算退税,而不是套用总体假设。 变化的影响取决于产品结构、申报价格与每一项商品的适用税率,用平均率做组合层面的估算容易失真。
  • 核对内部税码是否与 2026C 版文库一致。 若企业资源计划系统或报关行的模板仍沿用旧版文库,建议在新税率下的首次报关前完成对账,并把报关单与退税资料一并归档。

在实际操作中,企业通常还要回答三个问题:出口产品是否落入附件 1 或附件 2、报关时点能否与业务节奏匹配、内部系统与文库版本是否对齐。把这三项前置核对,可以减少申报环节的反复。

对于产品线较宽的企业,建议按商品编码建立一张对照表,标注适用附件、现行税率与新税率生效后的税率,并按季度复核一次。这样在 2027 年 4 月之前,定价、合同条款与系统参数就有条件同步调整,而不必等到首批货物报关时才发现口径不一致。对于以出口为主要销售渠道的企业,这张对照表也可以作为与海外客户沟通价格调整的依据,使双方对变化的来源有共同的事实基础。

相关阅读

以下主题可作为进一步核对的起点。

  • 中国出口退税框架:税率、商品目录与报关实务
  • 出口货物的消费税:退(免)税规则
  • 中国新能源汽车出口:商品归类与认证要点
  • 退税率文库如何更新,以及它在多大程度上约束地方税务机关的执行口径

来源

  • 财政部税政司·2026 年第 29 号公告全文(含第一条至第四条及两份产品附件):https://szs.mof.gov.cn/zhengcefabu/202610/t20261012_4002592.htm
  • 国家税务总局税收政策法规库·公告及相关出口退税规则的汇总收录:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 北京市税务局税费知识库·含出口退税率文库更新在内的政策汇编:https://znhd.beijing.chinatax.gov.cn:8443/znhdzsknsrd/index?from=zcfg
  • 国家税务总局官网·公告发布与出口退税率文库:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 财政部税政司·公告及附件发布索引:https://szs.mof.gov.cn/zhengcefabu/202610/t20261012_4002592.htm
  • 国家税务总局·面向各地税务机关的文库与审核系统通知:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/

China’s Unified National Tax Penalty Benchmark 2026: What Changes on 1 November

  • The State Taxation Administration has issued the National Tax Administrative Penalty Discretion Benchmark (2026 Edition), effective 1 November 2026.
    国家税务总局发布《全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)》,自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行。
  • The benchmark applies nationwide, replacing a landscape in which discretion standards were set province by province and then region by region.
    该基准在全国范围统一适用,改变了此前由各省、后由各区域分别确定裁量标准的格局。
  • It optimises the discretion tiers, applicable conditions and specific standards for 9 categories and 66 tax administrative penalty items.
    其对 9 类 66 项税务行政处罚事项的裁量阶次、适用条件、具体标准作了全面优化。
  • A separate list of “minor violations not punished” was issued at the same time, covering 8 penalty items distilled from the benchmark.
    同时发布的《税务行政处罚”轻微不罚”事项清单》,涵盖从裁量基准中归纳的 8 项行政处罚事项。
  • The reform path ran from province-level uniformity to regional uniformity and then to a single national standard, with regional benchmarks jointly issued by provincial bureaus from early 2025.
    这一改革路径由省内统一走向区域统一,再走向全国统一;2025 年初起,各区域省级税务局已先后联合发布区域裁量基准。
  • The benchmark constrains how tax authorities exercise discretion; it does not alter a taxpayer’s filing and payment obligations.
    裁量基准约束的是税务机关如何行使裁量权,并不改变纳税人的申报与缴纳义务。

China’s Unified National Tax Penalty Benchmark 2026: What Changes on 1 November | 中国全国税务行政处罚裁量基准 2026:11 月 1 日起的变化

Overview

The State Taxation Administration has published the National Tax Administrative Penalty Discretion Benchmark (2026 Edition), which takes effect on 1 November 2026. Its significance lies in its geographic reach: for the first time, the standards guiding how tax authorities select and calibrate penalties apply uniformly nationwide.

The benchmark covers 9 categories and 66 tax administrative penalty items, and it was issued alongside a list of “minor violations not punished” covering 8 items. Together they change the framework within which a compliance failure is assessed, and they are relevant to any business that operates in more than one province.

Key developments in 2026

One benchmark for the whole country

Before this edition, discretion standards were set lower in the system: provinces adopted their own benchmarks, and later groups of provinces issued joint regional ones. A company operating in several provinces could face different treatment for the same violation, not because the law differed but because the standard did.

The 2026 edition consolidates this into a single national instrument with a common effective date. The change is one of standardisation: how existing items are graded and applied becomes uniform.

Nine categories, sixty-six items

The benchmark addresses 9 categories and 66 tax administrative penalty items. For each, it optimises three elements: the discretion tiers, the conditions under which each tier applies, and the specific standards attached to them.

The stated objectives are more reasonable division of items, more scientific discretion factors and a more precise scale. In practice these determine whether a set of facts is treated as minor, ordinary or serious, and so what penalty range a taxpayer can expect.

The “minor violations not punished” list

The accompanying list of penalty matters where a minor violation is not punished covers 8 items, distilled from the benchmark. It sits alongside the benchmark rather than replacing it, identifying circumstances in which a violation, though established, does not attract a penalty.

The list is best read as a defined exception, not a general leniency policy. Where its conditions are met, it provides a basis for arguing that no penalty should be imposed; where they are not, the ordinary benchmark applies.

How the benchmark arrived here

The reform moved from uniformity within a province, to uniformity within a region, to uniformity across the country.

In early 2025, provincial bureaus in the Northeast, Southwest, Northwest, Central-South, North China and East China regions successively issued joint regional benchmarks. Those were the intermediate step; the 2026 edition completes the progression at national level.

What local authorities are required to do

The announcement sets expectations for local tax authorities: penalties must be imposed strictly in accordance with the law, decisions must be made within the range of the discretion benchmark, and the lawful rights and interests of taxpayers and fee payers must be protected.

The instruction is directed at the authorities, not at taxpayers. The benchmark governs the exercise of public power; it does not add to, or relieve a company of, its obligations to register, file, report and pay on time.

Practical implications for foreign businesses

  • Read the benchmark as a predictability gain, not a discount. For a multi-province operation, the same facts should now be assessed against the same standard, making compliance design and provisioning more tractable.
  • Use the “minor violations not punished” list as a documented defence, and check its conditions first. The list covers 8 defined items. It is an exception with conditions, not a general exemption, so the file should show how each condition is met.
  • Keep the benchmark in its proper place. It constrains the authority’s choice of penalty; it does not change filing deadlines, documentation requirements or payment obligations. Compliance work upstream of an audit remains the primary risk control.
  • Revisit penalty provisioning across entities. Where a group has subsidiaries in several provinces, one standard gives a common basis for estimating exposure and explaining it to a parent or auditor.
  • Brief local finance teams on the 1 November date. The benchmark applies from that date, so reviews, voluntary disclosures or remediation that straddle the change should note which standard applies to which period.
  • Treat the two documents as a pair. The benchmark sets the tiers and the list carves out the exceptions; reading one without the other gives an incomplete picture of how a specific issue would be handled.

Related reading

  • China’s tax audit and assessment process: what to expect from a review
  • Penalty and late-payment rules under the Tax Collection and Administration Law
  • Managing tax compliance across multiple provinces in China
  • Voluntary disclosure and remediation practice for foreign-invested enterprises

Sources

  • State Taxation Administration — official announcements, including the 2026 edition of the national penalty discretion benchmark: https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • Xinhua report of 6 October 2026 — coverage of the benchmark, the 9 categories and 66 items, and the 8-item list: https://big5.china.com.cn/gate/big5/news.china.com.cn/2026-10/06/content_118723541.shtml
  • Tax policy and regulation database — consolidated record of tax rules and penalty provisions: https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • The State Council policy library — policy documents and implementing notices: https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/
  • State Taxation Administration — the announcement page for the benchmark and the accompanying list: https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • Tax policy and regulation database — reference texts for the underlying penalty provisions: https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/

中国全国税务行政处罚裁量基准 2026:11 月 1 日起的变化

概述

国家税务总局公布《全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)》,自 2026 年 11 月 1 日起施行。它的意义与其说在于某一条具体规则,不如说在于适用范围:指导税务机关如何选择与衡量处罚的标准,第一次在全国范围内统一适用。

该基准覆盖 9 类 66 项税务行政处罚事项,并与一份涵盖 8 项事项的《税务行政处罚”轻微不罚”事项清单》一并发布。两份文件共同改变了合规问题被评估时所处的框架,对在多个省份经营的企业尤为相关。

对已在华设立多家实体的外资集团而言,这一变化更多影响内部风险口径的统一,而不是某一次具体处罚的结果。此前各区域标准并存时,同类问题在不同省份的结论可能不一致,集团层面难以用一套假设做汇总;统一之后,至少在这 9 类 66 项事项上,各地面对的是同一份文本。

2026 年主要进展

全国共用一套基准

在此版本之前,裁量标准由税务系统的较低层级确定。各省制定本省基准,其后若干省份又联合发布区域基准。因此,在多省经营的企业,可能因为裁量标准不同,而对同一类违法行为面对不同处理,尽管法律条文本身并无差异。

2026 年版将上述安排整合为一份全国统一的文件,并设定了统一的施行日期。这一变化属于结构层面的调整:重点不在于增加事项,而在于把既有事项的分级与适用方式统一起来。

需要区分的是,统一的是裁量标准,而不是法律条文本身。处罚的种类与幅度仍由相关法律法规设定,基准处理的是在同一法定区间内如何选择的问题:哪些情节应当从轻,哪些应当从重,各档之间如何衔接。这一区分决定了企业评估风险时的正确顺序:先看行为本身是否构成违法,再看它落在哪一档,最后才是具体幅度。把顺序倒过来,容易把标准统一误读为处罚减轻。

9 类 66 项

基准针对 9 类 66 项税务行政处罚事项,对每一项优化三个要素:裁量阶次、各阶次的适用条件,以及与之对应的具体标准。

据公告表述,优化的目标是使事项划分更合理、裁量因素更科学、裁量尺度更精确。落到实务中,这些要素决定的正是:一组具体事实会被归入轻微、一般还是严重,从而决定纳税人可以预期怎样的处罚区间。

三个要素彼此关联:阶次回答分为几档,适用条件回答什么情形进入哪一档,具体标准回答进入该档之后如何确定处罚。对纳税人而言,最有用的往往不是具体幅度,而是适用条件,因为它把事实与结论之间的对应关系写清楚了,也使内部复核有了可引用的依据。

“轻微不罚”事项清单

同时发布的《税务行政处罚”轻微不罚”事项清单》,涵盖从裁量基准中归纳的 8 项行政处罚事项。它与基准并行,而不是替代基准;其运作方式,是列出虽已构成违法、但不予处罚的具体情形。

这份清单更宜理解为一项有明确边界的例外,而不是普遍性的从宽政策。对纳税人而言,它的价值在于所列条件:条件满足时,清单提供了主张不予处罚的依据;条件不满足时,仍回到基准的一般规则。

因此在实务中,主张适用的前提是把事实与清单条件逐项对应,而不是笼统说明情节轻微。清单只覆盖 8 项事项,超出这一范围的情形,仍应回到基准中寻找从轻或减轻的依据,两条路径不宜混用。

基准的形成路径

这一改革的推进顺序值得留意,因为它解释了最终文件为何呈现现在的形态:先是在一个省范围内统一,接着在一个区域内统一,最后在全国范围内统一。

2025 年初,东北、西南、西北、中南、华北、华东等区域的相关省级税务局已先后联合发布各区域裁量基准。这些区域文件是中间步骤;2026 年版在全国层面完成了这一进程,也使此前各区域的成果有了共同的参照。

对在此之前已经形成的区域实践而言,2026 年版并非推倒重来,而是把这些区域安排收敛到同一套表述之下。这也意味着,此前按区域标准形成的内部判断,需要按全国文本重新核对一次,尤其是那些原本依赖本地口径作出的处理。

对各地税务机关的要求

公告对各地税务机关提出了明确要求:严格依法依规实施处罚,在裁量基准范围内作出处罚决定,保障纳税人缴费人的合法权益。

这项要求指向的是税务机关,而不是纳税人,这一区分很重要。基准约束的是公权力的行使方式;它既不增加、也不减免企业自身的登记、申报、报送与按期缴纳义务。

从企业角度看,这一表述也提供了一个沟通基础:在处罚决定作出之前,可以要求说明所适用的裁量阶次及其依据,并在陈述申辩环节针对适用条件提出意见。这属于程序层面的权利,与行为是否构成违法是两个不同的问题。

对外资企业的实务意义

对外资企业来说,这份基准更接近一本参照手册,而不是一份需要逐条执行的新义务清单。它描述的是税务机关在遇到某类问题时通常会如何分级处理,企业可以据此判断自身的风险位置,也可以据此准备说明材料。以下六点是较为直接的用法,既涉及判断口径,也涉及内部文档的准备方式。

  • 把基准理解为可预期性的提升,而不是处罚的减免。 对跨省经营的企业而言,好处在于同一组事实如今应对应同一套标准,内部合规设计与准备金的计提因此更容易安排。
  • 把”轻微不罚”清单当作有据可依的抗辩,并先核对条件。 清单涵盖 8 项明确事项,属于附条件的例外,而非普遍豁免;主张时应在案卷中说明各项条件如何满足。
  • 把基准放在它该在的位置。 它约束的是税务机关对处罚的选择,并不改变申报期限、资料要求或缴纳义务。稽查之前的合规工作,仍是风险控制的主要环节。
  • 重新审视各实体的处罚准备金。 当集团在多个省份设有子公司时,统一的全国标准为估算风险敞口提供了共同基础,也便于向母公司或审计机构解释。
  • 就 11 月 1 日这一时点向本地财务团队作说明。 基准自该日起适用,跨越这一时点的自查、主动披露或整改,宜注明各期间分别适用哪一套标准。
  • 把两份文件成对阅读。 基准设定阶次,清单划出例外;只看其中一份,对某个具体问题会得到不完整的判断。

总体来看,这次调整对企业的直接要求并不多,更多是内部文档与判断口径的更新。比较务实的做法是:把 9 类 66 项中与本企业常见风险相关的部分摘出来,标注对应的阶次与适用条件,交给各地财务负责人共用;同时把 8 项轻微不罚事项单独列一页,说明适用条件与所需证据。这样在遇到具体问题时,各地团队面对的是同一份材料,而不是各自的区域经验。

需要强调的是,基准统一并不改变企业的合规义务。申报、缴纳与资料留存的要求仍按现行规定执行,日常的账务与票据管理依旧是风险控制的基础;基准只是在问题发生之后,约束处理方式的那一环。把两者分清,既能避免因为标准统一而放松日常管理,也能避免在问题已经发生时错过可以援引的条件。对于在华经营时间较长、经历过区域标准并存阶段的企业,建议把过去几年的处理案例按新文本重新归类一次,看看哪些判断仍站得住,哪些需要修正。

相关阅读

以下主题与本文所涉规则直接相关,可作为进一步核对的起点。

  • 中国税务稽查与评估流程:一次检查通常包含哪些环节
  • 《税收征收管理法》下的处罚与滞纳金规则
  • 在华跨省经营时的税务合规管理与内部口径统一
  • 外商投资企业的主动披露、整改实务与相关程序要点

来源

  • 国家税务总局官网·公告发布,含《全国税务行政处罚裁量基准(2026 年版)》:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 新华社 2026 年 10 月 6 日报道·基准、9 类 66 项与 8 项清单的相关报道:https://big5.china.com.cn/gate/big5/news.china.com.cn/2026-10/06/content_118723541.shtml
  • 国家税务总局税收政策法规库·税收规则与处罚条款的汇总收录:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 中国政府网政策库·政策文件及实施通知:https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/
  • 国家税务总局·基准及配套清单的公告页面:https://www.chinatax.gov.cn/
  • 国家税务总局税收政策法规库·处罚条款的参考文本:https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/