Tag Archives: Labour Dispatch

Dispatch under the microscope: stabilisation-refund rules and posting standards tighten China’s labour-dispatch compliance loop

  • Two September implementation moves bring the national unemployment-insurance support package (人社部发〔2026〕39号) down to operational level: Jilin province opened public consultation on 10 September 2026 on its implementing notice, and Jiangsu published standard reference texts for recruitment information on 2 September.
    9月的两步落地动作把全国失业保险稳岗扩岗政策包(人社部发〔2026〕39号)推进到操作层面:吉林省2026年9月10日就本省落实通知公开征求意见,江苏省9月2日发布招聘信息参考文本。
  • The national notice continues the job-stabilisation refund through end-2026: enterprises meeting non-layoff thresholds receive up to 30% of the previous year’s unemployment-insurance contributions (large enterprises) or up to 60% (SMEs); social organisations, law firms, accounting firms and individually-insured businesses are covered by reference.
    国家通知将稳岗返还政策延续实施至2026年底:符合裁员率门槛的企业按上年度实际缴纳失业保险费的30%(大型企业)或60%(中小微企业)享受返还;社会组织、律师事务所、会计师事务所及以单位形式参保的个体工商户参照实施。
  • Dispatch-specific fund rules are now explicit: labour-dispatch enterprises claiming the refund must provide their social-insurance office with the insured entity’s employment forms, the user-enterprise type, and the prior-year contribution breakdown — and must pass the funds on to the actual user enterprise within 30 working days of receipt, or return them.
    派遣专项资金规则已经明确:劳务派遣企业申领稳岗返还须向社保经办机构提供参保单位用工形式、用工单位类型、上年度实际缴纳失业保险费明细,并在收到资金30个工作日内拨付到实际用工单位,逾期未拨付应退回。
  • Jilin’s implementing draft adds a fund-security layer aimed at dispatch: stronger identification management for labour-dispatch units as key institutions, with data-cross-checking and suspicious-business screening to prevent abuse of the refund channel.
    吉林落实稿增加了面向派遣的基金安全层:对劳务派遣单位等重点机构加强标识管理和疑点业务排查,常态化开展跨部门数据比对,守住返还资金安全底线。
  • Jiangsu’s reference texts standardise recruitment postings across the market: 5 sections and 22 items covering job, pay and employer information; dual traceability distinguishing who recruits from who uses labour under outsourcing and dispatch arrangements; and listed prohibited conducts including false advertising and discrimination — reaching 7,700-plus HR service agencies and 17,000-plus dispatch units.
    江苏参考文本规范全市场招聘信息发布:5个板块22个项目覆盖岗位、报酬与用工单位信息;区分劳务外包、派遣情形下”谁招人、谁用人”的双追溯;并清单化列明虚假招聘、就业歧视等禁止行为——覆盖7700余户人力资源服务机构与1.7万余户劳务派遣单位。
  • For foreign-invested employers, the two moves read together: dispatch remains a tightly supervised channel — the 10% ratio cap and the three-characteristic (temporary, auxiliary, substitute) rule still govern usage — while the refund and subsidy money flowing through dispatch chains is now tracked end to end.
    对外资用工方而言,两步落地应连读:劳务派遣仍是强监管用工通道——10%比例红线与”三性”岗位要求继续适用——而经由派遣链条流转的返还与补贴资金现已全程可追踪。

Dispatch under the microscope: stabilisation-refund rules and posting standards tighten China’s labour-dispatch compliance loop | 派遣用工进入监管显微镜:稳岗返还资金规则与招聘信息标准收紧合规闭环

Overview

September 2026 has produced two operational moves on the employment side that foreign-invested employers in China should read together. On 2 September, the Jiangsu provincial human-resources department published standard reference texts for recruitment information, aimed squarely at the HR-services and labour-dispatch market. On 10 September, Jilin province opened public consultation on its implementing notice for the national unemployment-insurance stabilisation package (Notice No. 39 of 2026, 人社部发〔2026〕39号), which contains the most explicit dispatch-specific fund rules yet issued under the programme.

Neither document is a new national statute; both are the execution layer that determines how the national framework touches enterprises — and both single out labour dispatch.

The national framework: Notice No. 39 of 2026

The joint notice by the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Finance and the State Taxation Administration (issued with State Council consent, published 2 July 2026) continues three instruments through end-2026:

  • Job-stabilisation refund (稳岗返还). Insured enterprises with 12 months of full contribution and layoff rates within the control target (20% for enterprises of 30 or fewer employees) receive up to 30% (large) or 60% (SMEs) of the prior year’s unemployment-insurance contributions. Social organisations, law firms, accounting firms and individually-insured businesses are covered by reference.
  • One-off job-expansion subsidy (一次性扩岗补助). Up to RMB 1,500 per hire for employing current-year graduates and unemployed youth aged 16–24, with three months of contributions.
  • Skills-upgrade subsidies. RMB 1,000/1,500/2,000 by certificate level, up to three claims a year for multiple in-demand certificates.

The dispatch-specific rules

The dispatch layer appears in the implementing detail. Jilin’s consultation draft requires that labour-dispatch enterprises claiming the stabilisation refund provide the social-insurance office with the insured unit’s employment forms, the type of user enterprise, and the prior-year contribution breakdown — documentation that maps the money to the actual users of dispatched labour. The enterprise must pass the refund to the actual user enterprise within 30 working days of receipt; untransferred funds must be returned.

The draft also directs stronger identification management for dispatch units as key institutions in fund-security work: regular cross-department data comparison and screening of suspicious business, to keep the refund channel from becoming a pass-through for non-qualifying entities.

Jiangsu’s recruitment-posting standards

The Jiangsu reference texts standardise what a lawful recruitment posting must contain — 5 sections and 22 items covering job attributes, working hours and content, employment form, requirements, pay standards and deduction items, allowances, board and lodging, and the employing unit’s information. Three design choices matter for compliance:

  • Dual traceability. Postings must distinguish the labour relationship from the actual user of labour — under outsourcing and dispatch, “who recruits” and “who uses” must both be identifiable, making the posting itself part of the evidence chain that separates lawful outsourcing from disguised dispatch.
  • Agency transparency. The publishing unit must list the contact person, the human-resources service licence number, and the publication and expiry dates of the information.
  • Prohibited-conduct lists. Discriminatory criteria, false advertising and illegal fees are enumerated as red lines, with a risk-warning block built into the standard text.

The texts reach 7,700-plus human-resources service agencies and 17,000-plus labour-dispatch units in the province — meaning the standard travels through the intermediaries that most foreign-invested employers actually use.

What this means for foreign-invested employers

  • If you use dispatch, audit the ratio and the posts. The 10% cap and the temporary/auxiliary/substitute restriction remain the controlling rules; the new fund rules do not relax them and add paper that evidences who the user enterprise is.
  • Expect dispatch chains to be documented end to end. Refund money now moves with contribution breakdowns and 30-day pass-through requirements; foreign-invested user enterprises receiving staff through dispatch should align with their dispatch partner on the refund split and the documentation.
  • Recruitment postings through agencies should follow the standard fields. Where your hiring runs through an HR-services agency, require postings in the reference-text format — the licence number, publication dates and prohibited-conduct warnings are now the market standard in Jiangsu and a likely template elsewhere.
  • Check subsidy eligibility at group level. Stabilisation refunds and expansion subsidies apply to FIEs on the same terms; the “no/low layoff” test and the graduate-hire conditions are worth calendaring before year-end.
  • Watch other provinces’ implementing notices. Jilin’s consultation closes in mid-October; other provinces will follow with their own versions — the dispatch documentation requirements are the section to monitor.

Sources

  • 中华人民共和国人力资源和社会保障部 — 人力资源社会保障部 教育部 财政部 国家税务总局关于失业保险支持企业稳岗扩岗的通知(人社部发〔2026〕39号全文): https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/xxgk2020/fdzdgknr/zcfg/gfxwj/shbx/202607/t20260702_579405.html
  • 吉林省人力资源和社会保障厅 — 关于公开征求《关于做好2026年失业保险支持企业稳岗扩岗政策落实有关工作的通知》意见的通知(2026年9月10日,含派遣企业申领与资金拨付规则): https://hrss.jl.gov.cn/hdjl/zxzx/wsdc/202609/t20260910_9705986.html
  • 中华人民共和国人力资源和社会保障部 — 江苏:发布招聘信息参考文本源头规范人力资源市场秩序(2026年9月2日地方动态): https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/SYrlzyhshbzb/dongtaixinwen/dfdt/202609/t20260902_583221.html

Related reading

  • see also: labour dispatch compliance for FIE employers (fie-labour-dispatch-compliance)
  • see also: outsourcing versus dispatch boundary cases (outsourcing-vs-dispatch-boundary)

派遣用工进入监管显微镜:稳岗返还资金规则与招聘信息标准收紧合规闭环

概述

2026年9月,用工领域出现两个外资用工方应当连读的操作性动作。9月2日,江苏省人社部门发布招聘信息参考文本,直指人力资源服务与劳务派遣市场。9月10日,吉林省就全国失业保险稳岗扩岗政策包的落实通知(人社部发〔2026〕39号)公开征求意见,其中包含该项政策下迄今最明确的派遣专项资金规则。

两份文件都不是新的国家法规;它们是决定国家框架如何落到企业头上的执行层——而且都点名了劳务派遣。

国家框架:人社部发〔2026〕39号

人社部、教育部、财政部、国家税务总局联合通知(经国务院同意,2026年7月2日公布)将三项工具延续至2026年底:

  • 稳岗返还。 足额缴费12个月以上、裁员率符合控制目标(30人及以下参保企业不高于20%)的企业,按上年度实际缴纳失业保险费的30%(大型企业)或60%(中小微企业)享受返还;社会组织、律师事务所、会计师事务所以及以单位形式参保的个体工商户参照实施。
  • 一次性扩岗补助。 招用毕业年度及离校两年内未就业高校毕业生、16—24岁登记失业青年并足额缴费3个月以上的,按每招用1人不超过1500元发放。
  • 技能提升补贴。 按证书等级分别领取不超过1000元、1500元、2000元,取得多项急需紧缺证书的最多3次。

派遣专项规则

派遣层出现在落实细则中。吉林征求意见稿要求,申领稳岗返还的劳务派遣企业须向社保经办机构提供参保单位的用工形式、用工单位类型、上年度实际缴纳失业保险费明细——把资金与派遣劳动的实际使用者对应起来。企业须在收到资金30个工作日内拨付到实际用工单位;未拨付的应退回。

征求意见稿还要求在基金安全工作中对劳务派遣单位等重点机构加强标识管理:常态化跨部门数据比对与疑点业务排查,防止返还通道被不符合条件的主体当作过道。

江苏的招聘信息标准

江苏参考文本规范了合法招聘发布应包含的内容——5个板块22个项目,覆盖岗位属性、工作时间与内容、用工形式、任职要求、工资标准与代扣代缴项目、各项补贴、食宿待遇及用工单位信息。三个设计要点与合规直接相关:

  • 双追溯。 发布信息须区分劳动关系主体与实际用工主体——劳务外包、派遣情形下”谁招人、谁用人”都必须可查,发布信息本身成为区分合法外包与假外包真派遣的证据链一环。
  • 机构透明。 发布单位须列明联系人、人力资源服务许可证号、信息发布日期与有效期。
  • 禁止行为清单。 就业歧视、虚假招聘、违规收费被逐项列明为红线,标准文本固定栏还设有风险警示提示。

参考文本覆盖全省7700余户人力资源服务机构与1.7万余户劳务派遣单位——也就是说,标准经由外资用工方实际使用的中介机构传导。

对外资用工方的启示

  • 使用派遣的,先审计比例与岗位。 10%比例红线与”三性”岗位限制仍是控制性规则;新的资金规则没有放松它们,反而增加了证明用工单位身份的书面材料。
  • 派遣链条将被全程留痕。 返还资金现在随缴费明细与30日拨付要求流转;经由派遣用工的外资用工方应与派遣伙伴对齐返还资金的分配与单据。
  • 经由机构发布的招聘信息应按标准字段执行。 招聘经由人力资源服务机构进行的,要求其按参考文本格式发布——许可证号、发布日期与禁止行为警示已成为江苏市场标准,并可能向其他省份扩散。
  • 在集团层面核对补贴资格。 稳岗返还与扩岗补助对外资企业同等适用;”不裁员少裁员”测试与毕业生招用条件值得在年底前排入日历。
  • 跟踪其他省份落实通知。 吉林征求意见10月中旬截止;其他省份将陆续发布各自版本——派遣单证要求是需要盯住的章节。

来源

  • 中华人民共和国人力资源和社会保障部 — 关于失业保险支持企业稳岗扩岗的通知(人社部发〔2026〕39号全文): https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/xxgk2020/fdzdgknr/zcfg/gfxwj/shbx/202607/t20260702_579405.html
  • 吉林省人力资源和社会保障厅 — 稳岗扩岗落实通知征求意见(2026年9月10日): https://hrss.jl.gov.cn/hdjl/zxzx/wsdc/202609/t20260910_9705986.html
  • 中华人民共和国人力资源和社会保障部 — 江苏:发布招聘信息参考文本源头规范人力资源市场秩序(2026年9月2日): https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/SYrlzyhshbzb/dongtaixinwen/dfdt/202609/t20260902_583221.html

相关阅读

  • 见:外资用工方的劳务派遣合规(fie-labour-dispatch-compliance)
  • 见:外包与派遣的边界案例(outsourcing-vs-dispatch-boundary)

Labour Dispatch in China 2026: VAT Changes and Compliance Sharpening

  • Following the entry into force of the VAT Law on 1 January 2026, the simple-method option for labour dispatch services was removed and replaced by a differential-taxation rule: eligible dispatch companies may deduct wages, benefits and social-insurance paid on behalf of the user unit from their taxable sales, applying the 6% standard rate with input-VAT credit available.
    《增值税法》2026 年 1 月 1 日施行后,劳务派遣服务取消简易计税方法,改为差额征税规则:符合条件的派遣公司可从销售额中扣除代用工单位支付的工资、福利和社会保险费,适用 6% 税率并允许抵扣进项税额。
  • A valid Labour Dispatch Operating Permit is now the gatekeeper for differential taxation — unlicensed human-resources companies performing de facto dispatch work must be taxed on the full amount at 6%.
    《劳务派遣经营许可证》成为享受差额征税的前置条件——未取得资质而实际从事类似派遣业务的人力资源公司,须按全额 6% 计税,不得自行适用差额征税。
  • Invoice compliance is mandatory: the deduction requires “same-invoice itemisation” of the service fee and the deducted amounts, together with lawful and valid deduction vouchers.
    开票合规是硬要求:差额扣除须”同票列明”服务费与扣除额,且扣除凭证须合法有效。
  • The dispatch ratio cap remains 10% of a user unit’s total workforce, and 2026 enforcement has sharpened the distinction between genuine outsourcing and disguised dispatch, looking at actual control and management rather than contract labels.
    用工单位使用被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量的 10% 的红线保持不变;2026 年监管强化了真外包与假派遣的区分,以实际用工管理状态而非合同名称作为认定标准。
  • For foreign-invested enterprises using dispatch or outsourcing, the practical agenda is to verify permit status of service providers, re-model contract and invoicing arrangements under the new VAT rules, and audit workforce ratios and de facto management control to avoid reclassification risk.
    对使用派遣或外包的外资企业,实操议程包括:核验服务商许可资质、按新增值税规则重构合同与开票安排、审查用工比例与实际管理控制,避免被重新定性。

Labour Dispatch in China 2026: VAT Changes and Compliance Sharpening | 2026 年中国劳务派遣:增值税调整与合规趋严

Overview

Two parallel changes are reshaping how foreign-invested enterprises use flexible staffing in China in 2026. The first is tax-technical: the entry into force of the VAT Law on 1 January 2026 removed the simple-method option for labour dispatch services and replaced it with a refined differential-taxation rule. The second is enforcement-related: regulators have sharpened the line between genuine outsourcing and disguised labour dispatch, signalling that contract labels no longer determine the legal character of a staffing arrangement.

Both changes matter to FIEs because dispatch and outsourcing are common vehicles for headcount flexibility — but the compliance cost of getting the characterisation wrong is now materially higher. Mischaracterised dispatch can mean back taxes under the full-taxation rule, unpaid social-insurance obligations, and exposure under the 10% dispatch-ratio cap.

The VAT change: from simple method to differential taxation

Before 2026, a general VAT taxpayer providing labour dispatch services could choose the simple method: taxable sales calculated after deducting wages, benefits and social insurance paid on behalf of the user unit, at a 5% collection rate, but with no input-VAT credit. The structural problem was the lost input credit — the entire point of the simple method was simplicity, and it carried a permanent tax cost.

The VAT Law and its implementing rules removed the simple-method option for dispatch services but preserved the deductibility logic in a more advantageous form: eligible general taxpayers may deduct from taxable sales the wages, benefits and social insurance (and housing fund) paid on behalf of the user unit, then apply the standard 6% rate and claim input-VAT credit on their own deductible inputs. For a compliant dispatch company, the net tax burden can be lower than under the old simple method.

The catch is the eligibility gate. Under the transitional announcement (Ministry of Finance and STA Announcement No. 10 of 2026, issued 30 January 2026), the deduction applies only to taxpayers holding a Labour Dispatch Operating Permit (《劳务派遣经营许可证》) and satisfying invoice and voucher requirements. Unlicensed human-resources and management-consulting companies that previously self-applied differential taxation on the strength of an outsourcing contract must now be taxed on the full amount at 6%. The announcement also addresses group structures: a head office with a permit and a branch that has registered with the local human-resources authority can apply the differential rule; a branch that has not registered cannot.

The invoice and voucher discipline

Differential taxation in China is only as good as the paperwork. The rules require “same-invoice itemisation”: the invoice must separately list the service fee and the deducted amounts (wages, benefits, social insurance and housing fund paid on behalf of the user unit), so that the tax authority can verify the deduction at the invoice level. In addition, the taxpayer must hold lawful and valid deduction vouchers — evidence of the actual payments made on behalf of the user unit. For FIEs as the user side, the practical implication is that their dispatch invoices must carry the itemised format, and that the underlying payroll and social-insurance records should be obtainable for audit if the tax authority reviews the user’s deduction chain.

The 10% ratio cap and the “disguised dispatch” crackdown

Separately, the dispatch ratio cap remains fixed: a user unit may not use dispatched workers in excess of 10% of its total workforce (defined as the number of workers on employment contracts plus the number of dispatched workers). The cap is policed by local human-resources authorities, which have been issuing guidance and answering implementation questions through 2026 — for example, Shenzhen’s Bao’an District Human Resources Bureau published a staff interpretation in August 2026 confirming the 10% calculation basis.

In parallel, 2026 enforcement has focused on “disguised dispatch” dressed up as outsourcing. The emerging test looks at substance over form: if workers are directly managed and controlled by the user unit, occupy long-term fixed positions, work on core business processes, or are mixed with the user’s own staff, the arrangement is recharacterised as labour dispatch regardless of what the contract is called. The consequences flow from recharacterisation: the 10% cap applies, social-insurance and equal-pay obligations attach, and tax treatment may need to be restated. Foreign-invested companies should audit not just contract titles but actual management control — who assigns daily tasks, who approves leave, who evaluates performance — because those facts determine the legal character of the arrangement.

What this means for foreign-invested enterprises

  1. Verify the provider’s permit. Confirm that every dispatch service provider holds a valid Labour Dispatch Operating Permit and, where branches are involved, that the branch has registered with the local human-resources authority.
  2. Re-model the VAT arrangement. Confirm that invoices follow the same-invoice itemisation format and that deduction vouchers are retained; where the provider is unlicensed, model the full-taxation cost into the contract price.
  3. Audit the ratio. Count the workforce (contract workers plus dispatched workers) and confirm the dispatched headcount stays within 10%; where a JV or WFOE has multiple user entities, assess each separately.
  4. Test for disguised dispatch. Review actual management control, job stability and mixing of staff. Where recharacterisation risk is real, convert long-term outsourced roles to direct employment or a compliant licensing structure.
  5. Update contracts and policies. Align service agreements, insurance arrangements and payroll handling with the new tax and enforcement posture, and document the control assessment for inspection readiness.

Related reading

  • The VAT Law and its implementing rules, together with Announcement No. 10 of 2026 on VAT preferential policy transition.
  • The Labour Contract Law and the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (including the 10% cap and the temporary/auxiliary/substitute position rule).
  • The Social Insurance Law and local implementation rules governing contribution bases for dispatched workers.

Sources

  • 国家税务总局深圳市税务局《财政部 税务总局关于增值税法施行后增值税优惠政策衔接事项的公告》(财政部 税务总局公告 2026 年第 10 号): https://shenzhen.chinatax.gov.cn/sztax/zdgkml/gkmlzcfg/gkmlzcwj/202602/9495df1a52004ae8b249888aa8452416.shtml
  • 国家税务总局上海市税务局《关于增值税法施行后增值税优惠政策衔接事项的公告》: https://shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/gate/big5/shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/zzzb/zcwj/202602/t479283.html
  • 深圳市宝安区人力资源局《劳务派遣的用工比例?》: https://www.baoan.gov.cn/rlzyj/zmhd/cjwtjd/ldrszcyw/content/post_12944402.html
  • 国家税务总局内蒙古自治区税务局《对呼伦贝尔市政协五届五次会议第 26287 号提案的答复》: https://neimenggu.chinatax.gov.cn/nmgzzqswj/msxxgkml_19393/hlbesswj/202608/t20260818_896749.html
  • 临清市人力资源和社会保障局(劳务派遣相关法规依据): http://www.linqing.gov.cn/site_lqsrlzyhshbzjm/channel_jkf_lqsrlzyhshbzjm_66827effd5cf8a7893ef8e3c/doc_6a856c1bf07c36bc32c06716.html

2026 年中国劳务派遣:增值税调整与合规趋严

概述

2026 年,两股并行的变化正在重塑外资企业在中国使用弹性用工的方式。其一是税收技术层面:《增值税法》2026 年 1 月 1 日施行,取消了劳务派遣服务的简易计税方法,代之以细化的差额征税规则。其二是执法层面:监管部门强化了真外包与假劳务派遣的界限,明确合同名称不再决定用工安排的法律性质。

两项变化对外资企业都很重要,因为派遣和外包是人力弹性常用的载体——但定性错误的合规成本如今显著上升。派遣定性错误可能意味着按全额计税补缴税款、未缴社保义务,以及 10% 派遣比例红线的违规风险。

增值税变化:从简易计税到差额征税

2026 年以前,提供劳务派遣服务的一般纳税人可以选择简易计税:销售额扣除代用工单位支付的工资、福利和社保后,按 5% 征收率计税,但不能抵扣进项税额。结构性痛点在于进项损失——简易计税的全部意义就是简化,其代价是永久的税负成本。

《增值税法》及其实施规则取消了派遣服务的简易计税方法,但以更有利的形式保留了扣除逻辑:符合条件的一般纳税人可从销售额中扣除代用工单位支付的工资、福利和社会保险费(含住房公积金),适用 6% 标准税率,并可就自身可抵扣进项申报抵扣。对合规派遣公司而言,净税负可能低于旧简易计税。

关键在于资格门槛。根据过渡期公告(财政部 税务总局公告 2026 年第 10 号,2026 年 1 月 30 日发布),扣除仅适用于持有《劳务派遣经营许可证》且满足开票、凭证要求的纳税人。此前仅凭外包合同就自行适用差额征税的未持证人力资源公司、管理咨询公司,如今须按全额 6% 计税。公告还回应了集团结构:总公司持证、分公司已向当地人社部门备案的,分公司可适用差额征税;分公司未备案的,不能适用。

开票与凭证纪律

中国的差额征税是否有效,取决于单据。规则要求”同票列明”:发票须分别列明服务费与扣除额(代用工单位支付的工资、福利、社保和住房公积金),便于税务机关在发票层面核验扣除。此外,纳税人须持有合法有效的扣除凭证——代用工单位实际付款的凭据。对作为用工方的外资企业,实务含义是:派遣发票必须是列明格式,且底层工资和社保记录应可调取,以备税务机关核查扣除链条。

10% 比例红线与”假外包”整治

与此同时,派遣比例红线保持不变:用工单位使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量(订立劳动合同人数与被派遣劳动者人数之和)的 10%。该红线由地方人社部门执行,2026 年各地持续发布指引并解答实施问题——例如深圳市宝安区人力资源局 2026 年 8 月发布的答复即确认了 10% 的计算口径。

并行地,2026 年执法聚焦于披着外包外衣的”假派遣”。新测试标准看实质而非形式:如果劳动者由用工单位直接管理控制、岗位长期固定、参与主营业务、与正式员工混岗作业,无论合同如何命名,一律重新定性为劳务派遣。重新定性的后果随之而来:适用 10% 红线、承担社保与同工同酬义务、税收处理可能需重述。外资企业应审查的不只是合同标题,还有实际管理控制——谁安排日常任务、谁批假、谁考核绩效——因为这些事实决定用工安排的法律性质。

对外资企业的意义

  1. 核验服务商资质。确认每家派遣服务商持有有效的《劳务派遣经营许可证》,涉及分支机构的,确认分支机构已向当地人社部门备案。
  2. 重构增值税安排。确认发票采用同票列明格式并留存扣除凭证;服务商无资质的,将全额计税成本计入合同价格。
  3. 审查比例。统计用工总量(合同工加派遣工),确认派遣人数在 10% 以内;合资公司或外商独资企业有多个用工主体的,分别评估。
  4. 排查假派遣。审查实际管理控制、岗位稳定性与混岗情况。重新定性风险真实存在的,将长期外包岗位转为直接雇佣或合规持牌结构。
  5. 更新合同与政策。使服务协议、保险安排和工资处理与新的税收与执法姿态对齐,并留存控制权评估文档以备检查。

相关阅读

  • 《增值税法》及其实施规则,以及 2026 年第 10 号公告关于增值税优惠政策衔接的规定。
  • 《劳动合同法》与《劳务派遣暂行规定》(含 10% 红线和临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位规则)。
  • 《社会保险法》及各地关于派遣工缴费基数的实施规则。

来源

  • 国家税务总局深圳市税务局《财政部 税务总局关于增值税法施行后增值税优惠政策衔接事项的公告》(财政部 税务总局公告 2026 年第 10 号):https://shenzhen.chinatax.gov.cn/sztax/zdgkml/gkmlzcfg/gkmlzcwj/202602/9495df1a52004ae8b249888aa8452416.shtml
  • 国家税务总局上海市税务局《关于增值税法施行后增值税优惠政策衔接事项的公告》:https://shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/gate/big5/shanghai.chinatax.gov.cn/zzzb/zcwj/202602/t479283.html
  • 深圳市宝安区人力资源局《劳务派遣的用工比例?》:https://www.baoan.gov.cn/rlzyj/zmhd/cjwtjd/ldrszcyw/content/post_12944402.html
  • 国家税务总局内蒙古自治区税务局《对呼伦贝尔市政协五届五次会议第 26287 号提案的答复》:https://neimenggu.chinatax.gov.cn/nmgzzqswj/msxxgkml_19393/hlbesswj/202608/t20260818_896749.html
  • 临清市人力资源和社会保障局(劳务派遣相关法规依据):http://www.linqing.gov.cn/site_lqsrlzyhshbzjm/channel_jkf_lqsrlzyhshbzjm_66827effd5cf8a7893ef8e3c/doc_6a856c1bf07c36bc32c06716.html

Labour dispatch and secondment rules

  • Labour dispatch is strictly regulated: it may be used only for temporary (≤6 months), auxiliary, or substitution posts (“三性”) and is capped at 10% of the user unit’s total workforce, calculated per entity.
    劳务派遣受严格规制:仅可用于临时性(不超 6 个月)、辅助性或替代性岗位(”三性”),且不得超过用工单位用工总量的 10%,并按单个用人单位核算。
  • A dispatch agency must be licensed, hold at least RMB 2 million registered capital, and sign a written fixed-term contract of at least two years with each dispatched worker; the agency and user unit bear joint and several liability.
    派遣单位须取得许可、注册资本不少于 200 万元,并与被派遣劳动者订立 2 年以上固定期限书面合同;派遣单位与用工单位对被派遣劳动者所受损害承担连带责任。
  • “Fake outsourcing, real dispatch” is policed — characterisation turns on the substance of control and the employment relationship, not on contract labels.
    “假外包真派遣”被严格监管——定性取决于控制权与劳动关系的实质,而非合同名称。
  • Intra-group expatriate secondment is not the statutory “labour dispatch” model but is still bound by work-permit and employment-law rules.
    集团内外籍员工借调并非中国法意义上的”劳务派遣”模型,但仍受工作签证与劳动法规则约束。
  • Fix the employer of record and ensure the work permit, residence permit, labour contract, social insurance, and IIT withholding all point to that same entity.
    应固定用人单位(雇主),并确保工作许可证、居留证件、劳动合同、社保与个税代扣均指向同一实体。
  • When an expatriate will genuinely be employed and directed by a different entity, file a new work-permit application in that entity’s name rather than relying on informal secondment.
    当外籍员工将真正由另一实体雇佣并指挥时,应以该实体名义重新申请工作许可证,而非依赖非正式借调。

Labour dispatch and secondment rules | 劳务派遣与借调规则

Overview

When a foreign-invested enterprise wants flexible staffing — or wants to move an expatriate between group entities — two very different Chinese legal constructs come into play. Labour dispatch (劳务派遣) is a tightly regulated triangular arrangement (dispatch agency employs, user unit directs) subject to the “three-characteristic” test and a hard 10% cap. Secondment (借调) of expatriates within a corporate group is a different animal, governed mainly by work-permit and employment-law rules rather than the dispatch statute. Confusing the two — or dressing up dispatch as “outsourcing” — is a common and penalty-bearing mistake. This article sets out the dispatch rules and the practical limits on intra-group expatriate movement.

Informational guidance only; structures should be validated with PRC labour and immigration counsel.

The 10% cap and the “three characteristics”

China’s *Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 22, in force since 1 March 2014) restricts where and how dispatch may be used:

  • The “three characteristics” (三性). Dispatched workers may be used only on (1) temporary posts (existing no more than 6 months), (2) auxiliary posts (non-core business roles supporting the main business), and (3) substitutional posts (covering an employee who is on study leave, maternity, or otherwise absent). Auxiliary posts must be determined through discussion with the employee representative congress or all employees, negotiated with the union/worker representatives, and publicly posted within the unit.
  • The 10% cap. The number of dispatched workers must not exceed 10% of the user unit’s total workforce, where “total workforce” = employees with labour contracts + dispatched workers. The cap is calculated per employing entity — a corporate group must not aggregate all subsidiaries into one headcount to disguise non-compliance.

A dispatch agency itself must be licensed, have registered capital of at least RMB 2 million, and sign a written fixed-term contract of at least two years with each dispatched worker. During any period the worker is returned but idle, the agency must pay no less than the local minimum wage. The dispatch agency and the user unit bear joint and several liability for harm to the dispatched worker.

Dispatch vs. outsourcing

The line between labour dispatch and labour outsourcing (业务外包) is heavily policed because “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” (假外包真派遣) is a known avoidance tactic. The distinguishing features:

  • Labour dispatch: the dispatch agency recruits and employs the worker (signs the contract, pays wages, pays social insurance); the user unit directs the worker’s labour even though it has no employment relationship. The worker is integrated into the user unit’s management.
  • Labour outsourcing: the contractor employs and manages its own staff and delivers a defined result or service to the client; the client does not direct the individual workers. If, in substance, the client controls the workers’ daily labour using its facilities and under its arrangements, the arrangement may be re-characterised as dispatch — pulling it back inside the 10% cap and the “three-characteristic” limits.

Practically, name-calling does not decide the characterisation; the substance of control and the employment relationship does.

Secondment of expatriates within a group

Moving an expatriate between affiliated companies is not “labour dispatch” in the Chinese statutory sense (the dispatched-worker rules target the domestic triangular model), but it is constrained by two other regimes:

  • Work-permit linkage. A foreign employee’s right to reside and work in China is tied to the employer named on the work permit and residence permit. “Seconding” an expat to perform duties for a different group entity is permissible only if the work-permit basis supports it — typically the permit-holder entity is the employer of record, and the expat’s duties may extend to affiliated companies under a group arrangement. Where the expat will genuinely be employed and directed by a different entity, the proper route is usually a new work permit in that entity’s name, with the residence permit aligned. Simply having the expat “help out” at an affiliate on another entity’s permit risks a status mismatch.
  • Employment and tax. The employer of record bears the labour-contract, social-insurance, and individual-income-tax withholding obligations, even if the economic cost is recharged internally. Inter-company secondment agreements should allocate costs, define the reporting line, and preserve compliance with both the Labour Contract Law and the work-permit conditions.

A useful discipline: decide who is the employer of record and ensure the work permit, labour contract, social insurance, and IIT withholding all point to that same entity; treat any group-internal deployment as a documented secondment, not an informal arrangement.

Pitfalls

  • Using dispatch to fill core, long-term roles — this breaches the “three characteristics” and the 10% cap.
  • Failing to publicise auxiliary-post determinations or to follow the worker-representative process.
  • Aggregating group headcount to dodge the 10% cap (must be calculated per entity).
  • Mislabelling dispatch as outsourcing while retaining daily control of the workers.
  • Moving expatriates between entities without aligning the work permit and residence permit to the actual employer of record.

What to do next

  • Before using dispatch, confirm the posts meet the “three characteristics” and that dispatched headcount stays at or below 10% per entity.
  • Use a licensed dispatch agency (≥ RMB 2 million capital) and ensure a ≥2-year contract with each dispatched worker.
  • Publicise auxiliary-post decisions and keep evidence of the worker-representative process.
  • Distinguish true outsourcing (client does not direct workers) from dispatch; do not rely on contract labels.
  • For intra-group expatriate moves, fix the employer of record and align the work permit, residence permit, contract, social insurance, and IIT withholding to it.
  • When an expat will genuinely work for a different entity, file a new work-permit application rather than informal secondment.

Sources

  • Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security — Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (MOHRSS Order No. 22): http://www.mohrss.gov.cn/xxgk2020/gzk/gz/202112/t20211228_431639.html
  • State Council (gov.cn) — Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (State Council Gazette version): https://big5.www.gov.cn/gate/big5/www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security (MOHRSS, official portal): https://www.mohrss.gov.cn

Related reading

  • see also: Hiring local staff: contracts & social insurance / 雇佣本地员工:合同与社保
  • see also: Work visas & residence permits / 工作签证与居留许可

劳务派遣与借调规则

概述

当外资企业希望灵活用工——或在集团内部调动外籍员工时,会触及两种截然不同的中国法律构造。劳务派遣是一种受严格规制的三角关系(派遣单位雇人、用工单位指挥),须通过”三性”测试并受 10% 硬性上限约束。集团内外籍员工借调则是另一回事,主要受工作签证与劳动法规则约束,而非派遣法规。混淆二者——或将派遣包装成”外包”——是常见的、会被处罚的错误。本文列明派遣规则,以及集团内外籍人员调动的实务边界。

本文仅为信息性指引;相关架构须经中国劳动与移民律师核验。

10% 上限与”三性”

中国《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人社部令第 22 号,2014 年 3 月 1 日施行)对派遣的使用场景与方式作出限制:

  • “三性”。 被派遣劳动者只能用于 (1) 临时性 岗位(存续不超过 6 个月)、(2) 辅助性 岗位(为主营业务提供服务的非主营业务岗位)、(3) 替代性 岗位(替代脱产学习、休假等缺席的员工)。辅助性岗位须经职工代表大会或全体职工讨论,与工会/职工代表协商确定,并在单位内公示。
  • 10% 上限。 使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工单位用工总量的 10%;”用工总量”= 订立劳动合同人数 + 被派遣劳动者人数。该比例按单个用人单位核算——集团公司不得将各子公司合并计算以规避合规。

派遣单位本身须取得行政许可、注册资本不少于 200 万元,并与被派遣劳动者订立 2 年以上 固定期限书面合同。劳动者被退回而无工作期间,派遣单位须按月支付不低于当地最低工资标准的报酬。派遣单位与用工单位对被派遣劳动者所受损害承担连带责任。

派遣与外包之别

劳务派遣与业务外包的界限被严格监管,因为”假外包真派遣”是已知的规避手法。区分要点:

  • 劳务派遣: 派遣单位招用并雇佣劳动者(签合同、发工资、缴社保);用工单位指挥劳动者,虽无劳动关系。劳动者被整合进用工单位的管理。
  • 业务外包: 承包单位自雇自管员工,向客户交付既定成果或服务;客户不直接指挥个别劳动者。若实质上是客户用其设施、按其安排控制劳动者日常劳动,该安排可能被重新定性为派遣——从而重新落入 10% 上限与”三性”限制。

实务中,名称不决定定性;控制权与劳动关系才是。

集团内外籍员工的借调

在关联公司间调动外籍员工,并非中国法意义上的”劳务派遣”(派遣规则针对的是国内三角模型),但受另两套制度约束:

  • 工作许可证关联。 外籍员工在华居留与工作的权利,绑定于工作许可证与居留证件载明的雇主。”借调”外籍员工为不同集团实体履职,仅在工作许可基础支持时才合法——通常是持证人所在实体为用人单位(雇主),外籍员工依集团安排可向关联公司延伸履职。若外籍员工将真正由另一实体雇佣并指挥,通常的正规路径是在该实体名下重新申请工作许可证,并使居留证件同步。仅凭另一实体的许可让外籍员工”帮衬”,存在身份错配风险。
  • 雇佣与税务。 用人单位(雇主)承担劳动合同、社保及个人所得税代扣义务,即便经济成本在内部划转。集团间借调协议应分配成本、界定汇报线,并保持对《劳动合同法》与工作许可条件二者的合规。

一条有用的纪律:先确定谁是用人单位(雇主),并确保工作许可证、劳动合同、社保与个税代扣均指向同一实体;将任何集团内部派驻作为有文件的借调处理,而非非正式安排。

常见陷阱

  • 以派遣填补核心、长期岗位——违反”三性”与 10% 上限。
  • 未公示辅助性岗位决定,或未遵循职工代表程序。
  • 合并集团人数以规避 10% 上限(须按实体核算)。
  • 在保留日常控制权的前提下将派遣误标为外包。
  • 在实体间调动外籍员工时,未将工作许可证与居留证件与真实雇主对齐。

下一步建议

  • 使用派遣前,确认岗位符合”三性”,且各实体派遣人数 ≤ 10%。
  • 使用取得许可的派遣机构(注册资本 ≥ 200 万元),并确保与被派遣者订立 ≥ 2 年合同。
  • 公示辅助性岗位决定,并留存职工代表程序的证据。
  • 区分真实外包(客户不指挥劳动者)与派遣;勿依赖合同标签。
  • 集团内外籍调动,固定用人单位,并使工作许可证、居留证件、合同、社保与个税代扣均指向它。
  • 外籍员工将真正为另一实体工作,应重新申请工作许可证,而非非正式借调。

来源

  • 人力资源和社会保障部——《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人社部令第 22 号):http://www.mohrss.gov.cn/xxgk2020/gzk/gz/202112/t20211228_431639.html
  • 国务院办公厅(gov.cn)——《劳务派遣暂行规定》(国务院公报版):https://big5.www.gov.cn/gate/big5/www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • 人力资源和社会保障部(MOHRSS,官网):https://www.mohrss.gov.cn

相关阅读

  • see also: 雇佣本地员工:合同与社保 / Hiring local staff: contracts & social insurance
  • see also: 工作签证与居留许可 / Work visas & residence permits

China’s 2026 Rectification of Labour-Dispatch Violations: Compliance Guide for Foreign-Invested Employers

  • A nationwide campaign to clean up the human-resources market ran from April to July 2026, with dispatch-rule violations a stated enforcement priority.
    2026年4月至7月开展了全国清理整顿人力资源市场秩序专项行动,劳务派遣违规被列为明确的执法重点。
  • The campaign targets unlicensed dispatch, “fake outsourcing, real dispatch,” illegal recruitment intermediaries, “recruit-to-train” loan fraud and employment discrimination.
    行动剑指未经许可经营劳务派遣、”假外包、真派遣”、非法职业中介、”招转培(贷)”欺诈与就业歧视。
  • The Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch cap dispatched workers at 10% of a user employer’s total workforce and restrict them to temporary, auxiliary or substitute posts.
    《劳务派遣暂行规定》将被派遣劳动者数量限制在用工单位总量的10%以内,并将其限定于临时性、辅助性或替代性岗位。
  • Guangdong’s first provincial dispatch service standard (DB44/T 2805-2026) raises the compliance bar for dispatch agencies operating in the province.
    广东省首项劳务派遣省级地方标准(DB44/T 2805-2026)提高了在该省经营派遣机构的合规门槛。
  • Foreign-invested manufacturers and shared-service centres using dispatch at scale must re-test their agency licensing, ratios and post mix now.
    大规模使用派遣的外资制造企业与共享服务中心,须立即重新核验合作机构资质、用工比例与岗位结构。
  • Practical step: audit every dispatch arrangement against the 10% cap and the temporary/auxiliary/substitute test before the next labour inspection.
    实操建议:在下次劳动监察前,按10%上限与”三性”标准审计每一项派遣安排。

China’s 2026 Rectification of Labour-Dispatch Violations: Compliance Guide for Foreign-Invested Employers | 2026年劳务派遣违规整治:外资用人单位合规指引

In 2026 the human-resources market came under intensified scrutiny. The Office of the State Council’s Employment Promotion and Labour Protection Leading Group issued a notice deploying a nationwide campaign — running April to July 2026 — to clean up the human-resources market order. For foreign-invested manufacturers, call centres, shared-service centres and any employer leaning on dispatched labour, the campaign is a reminder that dispatch compliance is no longer a back-office formality.

What the campaign targets

The campaign concentrates on conduct that undermines fair employment and market order:

  • Illegal recruitment intermediaries and unlicensed dispatch operators.
  • “Fake outsourcing, real dispatch” — disguising employment relationships as service outsourcing to dodge dispatch rules.
  • “Recruit-to-train (loan)” fraud — luring jobseekers into paid training under the guise of recruitment.
  • False recruitment — fabricated “central/state-owned enterprise internal referrals” or “guaranteed placements.”
  • Employment discrimination — improper restrictions on gender, age, region and the like.
  • Network recruitment-order violations — unlicensed or non-compliant job-posting platforms.

Labour dispatch is explicitly named: the campaign requires regulating dispatch employment and investigating unlicensed dispatch and “fake outsourcing, real dispatch.” Enterprises are advised to audit network recruitment and postings, strictly review the qualifications of partner HR agencies, and keep dispatch ratios and post scopes compliant.

The legal baseline: Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch

The *Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch* (enforced since 2014) remain the core rule. Key points foreign employers must respect:

  • Ratio cap. The number of dispatched workers used by a user employer shall not exceed 10% of its total workforce.
  • “Three-nature” limit. Dispatched workers may only be assigned to temporary, auxiliary or substitute posts.
  • Equal pay for equal work. Dispatched workers are entitled to the same remuneration and working conditions as directly-hired staff in comparable posts.
  • Agency licensing. Only legally licensed dispatch agencies may supply dispatched labour; operating without a licence is a primary enforcement target.

Guangdong has raised the bar further. Its provincial standard *Specification for Labour Dispatch Services* (DB44/T 2805-2026) — the province’s first dispatch-specific provincial standard — covers the full dispatch lifecycle. It requires dispatch agencies to conclude written labour contracts of at least two fixed terms with dispatched workers (probation may be agreed only once), pay wages in full and on time per contract with records filed, and — for cross-region dispatch — apply the wage and working-condition standards of the user employer’s location. Agencies must also handle pension, medical (including maternity), work-injury and unemployment insurance and housing fund on time.

Why foreign employers are exposed

Foreign-invested groups often centralise headcount in China through dispatch or outsourced “managed services.” Three patterns draw scrutiny:

  1. Using dispatch to bypass headcount or headcount-ratio limits in a legal entity.
  2. Outsourcing a function that is, in substance, managed and directed in-house — the classic “fake outsourcing, real dispatch.”
  3. Relying on a low-cost agency without verifying its dispatch licence and social-insurance compliance.

Each can convert a routine commercial arrangement into a labour-enforcement finding, with back-pay, social-insurance arrears and penalties.

Practical steps

  1. Audit the 10% ratio. Count dispatched workers against total workforce per legal entity; remediate breaches before inspection.
  2. Test the “three-nature” post mix. Confirm dispatched roles are genuinely temporary, auxiliary or substitute; re-classify permanently embedded roles.
  3. Verify agency licensing. Obtain and retain the dispatch licence of every partner agency; confirm it is in scope and current.
  4. Close the equal-pay gap. Align dispatched-worker pay and conditions with directly-hired comparators.
  5. Fix cross-region dispatch. Apply the user-location wage and social-insurance standards where dispatch crosses regions.
  6. Document the genuine-outside nature of outsourcing. Keep governance evidence that outsourced functions are not merely in-house direction.

2026年劳务派遣违规整治:外资用人单位合规指引

2026年,人力资源市场受到更强监管。国务院就业促进和劳动保护工作领导小组办公室印发通知,部署自2026年4月至7月在全国范围开展清理整顿人力资源市场秩序专项行动。对于依赖劳务派遣的外资制造企业、呼叫中心、共享服务中心及各类用人单位而言,此次行动提醒:派遣合规已不再是后台琐事。

行动打击对象

行动聚焦破坏公平就业与市场秩序的行为:

  • 非法职业中介与未经许可经营劳务派遣。
  • “假外包、真派遣”——以服务外包之名掩盖劳动关系以规避派遣规则。
  • “招转培(贷)”欺诈——以招聘为名诱骗求职者参与付费培训。
  • 虚假招聘——虚构”央国企内推””保录直签”等。
  • 就业歧视——对性别、年龄、地域等的不合理限制。
  • 网络招聘秩序违规——无资质或不合规的招聘信息发布平台。

劳务派遣被明确点名:行动要求规范劳务派遣用工,重点查处未经许可擅自经营劳务派遣、”假外包、真派遣”。企业被建议全面排查网络招聘与信息发布、严格审查合作人力资源服务机构资质,并使派遣比例与岗位范围合规。

法律基线:《劳务派遣暂行规定》

《劳务派遣暂行规定》(2014年起施行)仍是核心规则。外资用人单位须遵守的要点:

  • 比例上限。 用工单位使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量的10%。
  • “三性”限制。 被派遣劳动者只能被派遣至临时性、辅助性或者替代性的岗位。
  • 同工同酬。 被派遣劳动者享有与用工单位同类岗位直接用工人员同等的劳动报酬与劳动条件。
  • 机构许可。 仅依法取得许可的派遣机构可派遣劳动者;无许可经营是首要执法目标。

广东进一步抬高了门槛。其地方标准《劳务派遣服务规范》(DB44/T 2805-2026)是广东省首项劳务派遣省级地方标准,覆盖派遣全周期。它要求派遣单位与被派遣劳动者订立两年以上固定期限书面劳动合同(试用期仅可约定一次),按合同约定按时足额发放工资并归档,跨地区派遣的按用工单位所在地标准执行劳动报酬与劳动条件;派遣单位还须按时为被派遣劳动者办理养老、医疗(含生育)、工伤、失业等社会保险及住房公积金。

外资为何易被波及

外资集团常通过派遣或外包”托管服务”在华集中用工。三类情形易受关注:

  1. 借派遣规避法人实体内的编制或比例限制。
  2. 外包实质由内部管理与指挥的职能——典型的”假外包、真派遣”。
  3. 依赖低成本机构而未核验其派遣许可与社保合规。

任一情形都可能将常规商业安排转化为劳动执法认定,伴随补薪、社保补缴与处罚。

实操步骤

  1. 审计10%比例。 按法人实体统计被派遣劳动者占用工总量比例,在监察前整改超标。
  2. 测试”三性”岗位结构。 确认派遣岗位确属临时性、辅助性或替代性,将长期嵌入式岗位重新归类。
  3. 核验机构许可。 取得并留存每个合作派遣机构的派遣许可证,确认其在有效期内且范围匹配。
  4. 弥合同工同酬差距。 使派遣员工薪酬条件与直接用工对标岗位对齐。
  5. 规范跨地区派遣。 跨地区派遣时适用用工单位所在地工资与社保标准。
  6. 留存外包真实性证据。 保留证明外包职能非内部化指挥的治理证据。

Practitioner Quick Reference

  • Campaign window April–July 2026: nationwide clean-up; dispatch is an explicit priority.
    行动期2026年4—7月:全国清理;派遣为明确重点。
  • 10% cap + three-nature posts: the two mechanical tests every dispatch arrangement must pass.
    10%上限加”三性”岗位:每项派遣安排都须通过的两项机械测试。
  • Licence is non-negotiable: only licensed agencies may supply dispatch labour.
    许可不可妥协:仅持证机构可派遣劳动者。
  • Guangdong DB44/T 2805-2026: provincial standard raises the agency bar (2-year contracts, on-time pay, cross-region standards).
    广东DB44/T 2805-2026:省级标准抬高机构门槛(两年合同、按时发薪、跨地区标准)。

Common Pitfalls

  • Assuming outsourcing avoids the rules: if you direct the work in-house, it may be re-characterised as “fake outsourcing, real dispatch.”
    以为外包可规避规则:若由内部指挥工作,可能被重新定性为”假外包、真派遣”。
  • Forgetting the 10% is per legal entity: group-wide averaging does not satisfy the per-entity cap.
    忘记10%按法人实体计算:集团整体平均不能满足单体上限。
  • Trusting the agency blindly: the user employer shares exposure for an unlicensed or non-compliant partner.
    盲目信任机构:用工单位对无许可或不合规的合作方同样担责。

Sources

Labour Dispatch in China: The 2026 Signals and Foreign-Employer Compliance

  • In August 2026 the Supreme People’s Court and five central departments issued the Opinions on Strengthening the Management of Employed Court Clerks, which require courts to sign labour contracts directly with clerks and “gradually eliminate labour dispatch” — a significant signal in the broader shift from dispatched to direct employment.
    2026 年 8 月,最高人民法院会同中央组织部、中央政法委、中央编办、财政部、人力资源社会保障部印发《关于进一步加强人民法院聘用制书记员管理工作的意见》,要求法院直接与聘用制书记员签订劳动合同、”逐步取消劳务派遣用工方式”——在从派遣到直接用工的整体转向中释放重要信号。
  • Under the Labour Contract Law, labour dispatch is limited to temporary, auxiliary or substitute positions, and dispatched workers may not exceed 10% of total headcount; violations carry fines and correction orders.
    依《劳动合同法》,劳务派遣仅限临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位,被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量 10%;违反的责令限期改正并处罚款。
  • The dispatch unit is the employer of record, but the user unit bears day-to-day duties: working hours, leave and overtime pay obligations rest with the user unit, and the user unit and dispatch unit bear joint liability for harm caused by dispatched workers.
    劳务派遣单位是用人单位,但用工单位承担日常义务:执行劳动标准、支付加班费、提供岗位福利;被派遣劳动者因执行工作任务造成他人损害的,由用工单位承担侵权责任,派遣单位有过错的承担相应责任。
  • The SPC’s labour dispute interpretation (II), effective September 2025, applies a “facts-first” principle: courts determine whether a labour relationship exists by the substance of control, not the contract title — relevant where “outsourcing” is in fact disguised dispatch.
    最高法劳动争议司法解释(二)(2025 年 9 月施行)确立”事实优先”原则:法院综合人格、经济、组织从属性判断劳动关系,不囿于合同名称——对”假外包真派遣”直接相关。
  • For foreign-invested employers, the practical checklist is to verify dispatch positions against the three-role and 10% caps, keep dispatch agreements clearly allocating duties, document the distinction between genuine outsourcing and dispatch, and prepare for direct-employment transitions in services they currently dispatch.
    对外资雇主,实操清单是:对照三性与 10% 上限核验派遣岗位、派遣协议明确划分权责、留存”真外包”与派遣的区分证据、对现派遣岗位的转直接用工过渡做好准备。

Labour Dispatch in China: The 2026 Signals and Foreign-Employer Compliance | 中国劳务派遣:2026 年信号与外资雇主合规

Why this matters now

In August 2026 the Supreme People’s Court, together with the Central Organisation Department, the Central Political and Legal Affairs Commission, the Central Establishment Office, the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security, issued the Opinions on Further Strengthening the Management of Employed Court Clerks. The Opinions state that courts should sign labour contracts directly with employed clerks and “gradually eliminate the labour dispatch model”. Although the document addresses court staffing, it is the clearest institutional signal in years that China’s regulators view direct employment, not dispatch, as the default model — a signal relevant to every employer using dispatched workers, including foreign-invested companies. Combined with the facts-first test in the SPC labour dispute interpretation (II) (effective September 2025), which treats disguised dispatch as direct employment, the 2026 message for foreign employers is: re-audit dispatch arrangements, confirm genuine outsourcing where claimed, and plan transitions to direct employment where the law requires it.

The legal framework for dispatch

Under the Labour Contract Law (Article 66), labour dispatch may only be used for temporary (no more than six months), auxiliary (supporting positions in the main business) or substitute (positions whose incumbents are on leave or otherwise unavailable) positions. The Dispatch Provisions (MOHRSS Order No. 22) add a hard cap: dispatched workers may not exceed 10% of the user unit’s total headcount. Where the user unit exceeds the cap or uses dispatch in non-qualifying positions, the labour administrative authority orders rectification within a period and may fine. The dispatch unit is the employer of record — it signs the labour contract, pays social insurance and handles termination — but the user unit bears day-to-day obligations: implementing labour standards, paying overtime and providing post benefits. For tort harm caused by dispatched workers performing work, the user unit bears the liability; the dispatch unit bears corresponding liability if at fault. If the dispatch unit and the user unit have agreed on internal allocation in the dispatch agreement, that allocation binds them but does not bind the injured party.

The “facts-first” test and disguised dispatch

The SPC labour dispute interpretation (II), effective September 2025, entrenches a “facts-first” principle: courts determine whether a labour relationship exists by looking at the substance — personality subordination (management, discipline, attendance), economic subordination (payment of remuneration) and organisational subordination (work as part of the business) — rather than the label on the contract. For foreign employers, this matters because arrangements labelled “business outsourcing” or “service contracts” are frequently re-characterised as dispatch or direct employment where the user unit actually manages the workers, schedules them, sets pay levels or integrates them into core operations. The consequence of re-characterisation is severe: back payment of social insurance with surcharges, double-wage compensation for unsigned contracts, unpaid overtime and, in the worst cases, full work-injury benefits and statutory severance.

The direct-employment signal in 2026

The August 2026 Opinions on court clerks require courts to transition from dispatched to direct employment for clerical staff, with service-length continuity arrangements and ten-level grading systems. The document’s significance for employers generally is directional: it signals that regulators and courts expect dispatch to shrink toward its statutory niche. For foreign-invested companies, the practical implication is to treat dispatch as a constrained tool, not a general staffing model. Where dispatch is used legitimately (temporary, auxiliary or substitute positions within the 10% cap), maintain clear dispatch agreements; where dispatch is used in core operations or above the cap, plan the transition to direct employment — including service-length carry-over under Article 46 of the labour interpretation (I), which aggregates years of service where the worker is moved to a new employer not for his or her own reasons.

Practical steps for foreign employers

First, audit every dispatched position against the three-role test and the 10% cap; flag non-compliant uses. Second, for each dispatch agreement, confirm the allocation of day-to-day obligations (working hours, leave, overtime, post benefits) between the user unit and the dispatch unit, and confirm social insurance is paid by the dispatch unit. Third, where “outsourcing” is claimed, verify genuine outsourcing: the contractor manages its own workers, invoices for results, and the user unit does not direct daily work; keep evidence of this boundary. Fourth, for positions to be converted to direct employment, plan service-length aggregation, contract signing within one month of employment, and coordinate with payroll for social insurance registration. Fifth, monitor judicial trends: the facts-first test will continue to be applied by arbitration committees and courts, so documentation discipline matters more than contract labels.

Compliance notes

The 10% cap is calculated on the user unit’s total headcount including the dispatched workers themselves; excluding them from the denominator is a common error. The three-role test applies cumulatively: a position must satisfy temporary or auxiliary or substitute conditions at the time of use. Dispatched workers have the right to equal pay for equal work, and the user unit cannot “send back” a dispatched worker in violation of the law without consequences. Finally, the August 2026 Opinions are specific to courts; there is no general regulation yet mandating the elimination of dispatch, but the direction of travel is clear — treat direct employment as the default and dispatch as the exception.


中国劳务派遣:2026 年信号与外资雇主合规

为什么当下重要

2026 年 8 月,最高人民法院会同中央组织部、中央政法委、中央编办、财政部、人力资源社会保障部印发《关于进一步加强人民法院聘用制书记员管理工作的意见》。意见要求人民法院直接与聘用制书记员签订劳动合同,”逐步取消劳务派遣用工方式”。虽然文件针对法院队伍建设,但这是多年来监管层最明确的制度信号之一:中国监管者把直接用工、而非派遣,视为默认模式——这对所有使用派遣劳动者的雇主、包括外资企业都直接相关。叠加最高法劳动争议司法解释(二)(2025 年 9 月施行)确立的”事实优先”测试——将”假派遣”重新定性为直接劳动关系——2026 年对外资雇主的讯息是:重新审计派遣安排、确认声称的”真外包”、按法律要求规划转直接用工。

派遣的法律框架

依《劳动合同法》第六十六条,劳务派遣仅限临时性(存续不超过 6 个月)、辅助性(为主营业务提供服务的非主营业务岗位)、替代性(用工单位的劳动者因脱产学习、休假等原因无法工作的一定期间内,由其他劳动者替代工作的岗位)岗位。人社部《劳务派遣暂行规定》(第 22 号令)增设硬性上限:被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工单位用工总量的 10%。超比例或非三性岗位用派遣的,劳动行政部门责令限期改正并处罚款。派遣单位是用人单位——签劳动合同、缴社保、办理解除——但用工单位承担日常义务:执行劳动标准、支付加班费、提供岗位福利。被派遣劳动者因执行工作任务造成他人损害的,由用工单位承担侵权责任;派遣单位有过错的,承担相应责任。派遣单位与用工单位在派遣协议中约定内部责任分担的,该约定对其有约束力,但不得对抗受害人。

“事实优先”测试与”假派遣”

最高法劳动争议司法解释(二)(2025 年 9 月施行)强化”事实优先”原则:法院综合人格从属性(管理、纪律、考勤)、经济从属性(报酬支付)与组织从属性(劳动属业务组成部分)判断劳动关系是否存在,不拘泥于合同名称。对外资雇主,这很关键,因为标为”业务外包”或”服务合同”的安排,一旦用工单位实际管理劳动者、排班、定薪或将其纳入核心运营,常被重新定性为派遣甚至直接劳动关系。重新定性的后果严重:补缴社保及滞纳金、未签书面合同二倍工资差额、补发加班费,最严重时承担全部工伤保险待遇与法定经济补偿。

2026 年的直接用工信号

2026 年 8 月书记员意见要求法院将派遣用工转为直接用工,配套工龄衔接安排与十级分级管理。该文件对一般雇主的意义是方向性的:它表明监管与司法预期派遣将收缩至其法定适用空间。对外资企业,实际含义是把派遣视为受约束的工具而非通用用工模式。合法使用派遣(三性岗位且不超 10% 上限)的,保留清晰的派遣协议;在核心岗位或超比例使用派遣的,规划转直接用工——包括依劳动争议司法解释(一)第四十六条处理工龄合并计算(劳动者非因本人原因被安排到新用人单位且原单位未支付经济补偿的,年限合并计算)。

外资雇主实操步骤

其一,对照三性测试与 10% 上限逐岗审计,标记不合规使用。其二,对每份派遣协议,确认用工单位与派遣单位之间日常义务(工时、休假、加班、岗位福利)的分配,并确认社保由派遣单位缴纳。其三,对声称”外包”的安排,核验真外包:承包方自行管理其人员、按成果开票、用工单位不指挥日常工作;留存边界证据。其四,对拟转直接用工的岗位,规划工龄合并、用工之日起一个月内签订书面合同,并与薪酬团队协调社保登记。其五,跟踪司法趋势:仲裁委与法院将持续适用”事实优先”测试,留痕纪律比合同名称更重要。

合规提示

10% 上限以用工单位用工总量(含被派遣劳动者本人)为基数计算;把派遣人员从分母中剔除是常见错误。三性测试须在用工时点逐岗判断。被派遣劳动者享有同工同酬权利,用工单位违法退回派遣劳动者须承担后果。最后,2026 年 8 月意见仅针对法院系统,尚无普遍强制取消派遣的法规,但方向明确——把直接用工作为默认、派遣作为例外。

Sources

Staffing a China Representative Office Through Labour Dispatch: Why It Is Mandatory and How RO Rules Differ from a WFOE

  • A representative office has no legal personality and cannot be an employer, so it can never sign a labour contract with local staff directly.
    代表机构不具有法人资格,不能作为用人单位,因此不能直接与本地员工签订劳动合同。
  • Guo Fa [1980] No. 272, Article 11 still governs: an RO must entrust a local foreign affairs service unit or another designated body to engage staff.
    国发〔1980〕272号第十一条至今有效:代表处聘请工作人员、租用房屋,应当委托当地外事服务单位或中国政府指定的其它单位办理。
  • Article 25 of the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch exempts ROs from the “three-nature” post test and the 10% headcount cap—an exemption a WFOE does not enjoy.
    《劳务派遣暂行规定》第二十五条豁免代表机构适用”三性”岗位与10%用工比例限制,而外资子公司不享有该豁免。
  • Exemption from the cap is not exemption from compliance: the dispatch licence, the thirteen mandatory clauses, equal pay and social insurance all still bind.
    免于比例限制不等于免于合规:派遣许可、十三项必备条款、同工同酬与社会保险义务依然适用。
  • Direct hiring by an RO is normally recharacterised as a civil service relationship, stripping staff of double-wage, severance, social insurance and work-injury protections.
    代表处直接招人通常被认定为劳务关系而非劳动关系,员工将无法主张二倍工资、经济补偿、社保与工伤待遇。
  • Article 5 of the Supreme People’s Court Judicial Interpretation (II) on Labour Disputes lets a registered RO be named as a party, and the foreign parent can be joined.
    最高人民法院《劳动争议司法解释(二)》第五条允许依法设立的代表机构作为劳动争议当事人,境外母公司还可能被追加参加诉讼。

Staffing a China Representative Office Through Labour Dispatch: Why It Is Mandatory and How RO Rules Differ from a WFOE | 外国企业常驻代表机构在华用工:为何必须走劳务派遣,以及代表处与外资子公司的规则差异

The Structure Choice Nobody Prices In

Cost, speed and licensing scope dominate the first China budget; the employment model rarely reaches the table. Yet an RO cannot hire anyone — every local employee must arrive through a third party.

Liaison, market research, product display, business contact → an RO. Contract signing, fapiao, revenue, profit-making operations → a WFOE or JV. Price the model at the outset. (See our structure-choice article.)

Legal Status, and Why the RO Cannot Be an Employer

State Council Order No. 584 (19 Nov 2010; effective 1 Mar 2011; amended 18 Jul 2013) governs RO registration. Art. 2: an RO conducts non-profit-making activities connected with the foreign enterprise and has no legal person status.

  • Art. 6: annual report 1 Mar–30 Jun — parent’s lawful existence, RO activities, audited income and expenditure.
  • Art. 7: books recording fund remittances and income/expenditure, kept on premises; no use of another party’s account.
  • Art. 8: chief rep, reps and staff obey entry/exit, residence, employment, tax and forex rules.
  • Art. 9: particulars — name, chief rep, scope, premises, term, parent name and domicile.
  • Art. 10: name = nationality + Chinese name + city + “代表处”.
  • Art. 11: one chief rep plus one to three reps.

The certificate is a Registration Certificate, not a business licence. Labour Contract Law Art. 2 does not list an RO as an employer; its Implementing Regulations Art. 4 lets only a licensed domestic branch be an employer — not an RO.

Hiring runs through Guo Fa [1980] No. 272, Art. 11: an RO leasing premises or engaging staff shall entrust the local foreign affairs service unit or another unit designated by the Chinese government. Still the direct basis for RO employment.

The Standard Compliant Model

  1. The RO signs a labour dispatch agreement with a qualified foreign affairs service unit — a local foreign enterprise service company, the FESCO-type category — or a licensed dispatch company.
  2. That unit signs the labour contract, forms the employment relationship, pays social insurance and housing fund.
  3. It dispatches the individual to the RO.

The employer is the service unit; the RO is the host unit, directing daily work while payroll, contributions and termination run through the agency.

Direct Hiring, Recharacterisation and Standing in Disputes

Direct engagement by an RO is normally a civil service relationship, not employment. The individual cannot claim double wages, statutory severance, employer social insurance, work-injury treatment, or statutory hours/termination limits; a document headed “labour contract” may still fail (Beijing High Court Answers, Art. 24). Exposure: unquantified civil claims, work-injury liability without cover, withholding failures surfacing on a WFOE upgrade or in due diligence.

SPC Judicial Interpretation (II) on Labour Disputes, Art. 5: a duly established RO may be a party to a labour dispute, and the foreign parent can be joined where lawfully applied for.

Dispatch Rules: Where an RO Differs from a WFOE

The Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (MOHRSS Order No. 22), effective 1 Mar 2014.

Art. 3, three-nature: dispatch only in temporary (≤6 months), auxiliary (non-core, serving core posts; needs democratic procedure) or substitute posts.

Art. 4, 10% cap: dispatched workers must not exceed 10% of total headcount.

Art. 25, the key provision: ROs and foreign financial-institution representative offices using dispatched workers are not subject to the three-nature post test or the headcount ratio.

A 100-staff WFOE may host ten dispatched workers at most, in qualifying posts, after a democratic procedure; an RO may staff its whole office through dispatch, any post, indefinitely.

The Rules That Still Apply to an RO

  • Arts. 5–6: written fixed-term contract of two years or more; one probation period only.
  • Art. 7, thirteen mandatory items: post, location, headcount and term, equal-pay remuneration and payment, social insurance amount and payment, hours/rest/leave, work-injury/maternity/illness, safety and training, severance costs, agreement term, service-fee standard and payment, breach liability.
  • Art. 10: the agency applies for work-injury recognition and bears work-injury liability, subject to any compensation arrangement with the host unit.
  • Art. 11: licence lapse — existing contracts run to expiry.
  • Arts. 12–13: return grounds and the Art. 42 protection.
  • Arts. 18–19: cross-regional insurance at the host unit’s location; absent a local branch, the host unit enrols and pays on the agency’s behalf.
  • Art. 27: contracting dressed as dispatch falls under these Provisions.

Due Diligence on the Service Provider

  1. Verify the Labour Dispatch Business Licence and validity.
  2. Confirm the contracting entity is the licence holder — an unlicensed affiliate is attackable as unlicensed dispatch.
  3. Test cross-regional capability; without a local branch, Art. 19 shifts enrolment onto the RO.
  4. Review social insurance and IIT remittance records.
  5. Map the agreement against the thirteen Art. 7 items.
  6. Pin down work-injury liability and the Art. 10 compensation arrangement.

No provider is endorsed here; seek a licensed foreign enterprise service company with a record in the relevant city.

Chief Representative, Tax and the Upgrade to a WFOE

Foreign chief reps and reps sit on a different track: appointment flows from the parent’s letter and Art. 9 particulars, not a dispatch agreement; work permit, residence, IIT and forex follow Art. 8 of Order No. 584.

ROs are often taxed on a deemed basis, income imputed from expenditure, so personnel costs booked as RO expenses feed into the tax base.

On upgrading to a WFOE: succession — staff are employed by the agency, so convert via new contracts or a tripartite novation; continuity of service length for severance and paid annual leave, recorded expressly; sequencing — once the WFOE exists, the three-nature test and 10% cap apply in full, so the dispatched population must be converted or trimmed to the cap.

Related Reading

See our labour dispatch compliance overview, the outsourcing/dispatch boundary, equal pay and social insurance for dispatched workers, and the structure-choice comparison. —


外国企业常驻代表机构在华用工:为何必须走劳务派遣,以及代表处与外资子公司的规则差异

被普遍低估的架构变量

首次为中国市场编制预算时,讨论多集中在成本、速度与经营范围,用工模式很少进入对比表格。但代表处不能雇人——前台不行,分析员不行,中国区负责人也不行。每一位本地员工都必须通过第三方进入。

决策树很短:只做联络、市场调研、产品展示与业务接洽 → 代表处;要签合同、开具发票、收取收入、开展盈利经营 → WFOE 或合资公司。用工模式落在这条线的代表处一侧,应在决策之初计价。(更完整对比可参阅本站架构选择文章。)

法律地位,以及代表处为何不能成为用人单位

《外国企业常驻代表机构登记管理条例》由2010年11月19日中华人民共和国国务院令第584号公布,自2011年3月1日起施行,并根据2013年7月18日《国务院关于废止和修改部分行政法规的决定》修订。

第二条:代表机构是指外国企业依照本条例规定,在中国境内设立的从事与该外国企业业务有关的非营利性活动的办事机构;代表机构不具有法人资格。它不能以自己名义经营,也不能成为劳动合同的一方当事人。

  • 第六条:应当于每年3月1日至6月30日向登记机关提交年度报告,内容包括外国企业的合法存续情况、代表机构的业务活动开展情况及其经会计师事务所审计的费用收支情况。
  • 第七条:应当依法设置会计账簿,真实记载外国企业经费拨付和代表机构费用收支情况,并置于代表机构驻在场所;不得使用其他企业、组织或者个人的账户。
  • 第八条:首席代表、代表以及工作人员应当遵守法律、行政法规关于出入境、居留、就业、纳税、外汇登记等规定。
  • 第九条 登记事项:代表机构名称、首席代表姓名、业务范围、驻在场所、驻在期限、外国企业名称及其住所。
  • 第十条 名称构成:外国企业国籍 + 外国企业中文名称 + 驻在城市名称 + “代表处”字样。
  • 第十一条:应当委派一名首席代表,可根据业务需要委派1至3名代表。

登记机关核发的是《外国企业常驻代表机构登记证》,而非营业执照——这决定了用工分析的结论。《劳动合同法》第二条列举的用人单位主体中并无代表机构;《劳动合同法实施条例》第四条允许不具备法人资格但依法取得营业执照或者登记证书的分支机构作为用人单位,但该特殊情形适用于境内分支机构,代表机构不适用。

专门通道是《国务院关于管理外国企业常驻代表机构的暂行规定》(国发〔1980〕272号)第十一条:常驻代表机构租用房屋、聘请工作人员,应当委托当地外事服务单位或者中国政府指定的其它单位办理。年代虽早,从未被取代,至今仍是代表处用工的直接依据。

标准合规模式

  1. 代表机构与有资质的外事服务单位——即各地外企服务公司,业内常称 FESCO 类机构——或持证劳务派遣公司签订劳务派遣协议。
  2. 该单位与员工签订劳动合同,建立劳动关系,缴纳社会保险与住房公积金。
  3. 该单位将员工派遣至代表机构工作。

此时员工的用人单位是外事服务单位,代表机构是用工单位。代表机构负责日常工作指挥;薪酬发放、法定缴费、合同管理与解除终止手续,均由该机构依代表机构指令并以其资金执行。

直接雇佣的定性风险与争议主体资格

代表处直接招人的,用工关系一般被认定为劳务关系(民事雇佣)而非劳动关系。员工由此不能主张未签书面劳动合同的二倍工资、法定经济补偿、用人单位社会保险缴纳、工伤待遇,以及工时与解除方面的法定限制。即便签署名为”劳动合同”的协议,也可能因违反上述规定而不被认定为劳动关系。北京市高级人民法院与北京市劳动人事争议仲裁委员会《关于审理劳动争议案件解答(一)》第24条即持此口径。

这并非节省。它留下无法量化的民事索赔、没有保险覆盖的工伤责任、个人所得税代扣代缴失职风险,以及在升级 WFOE 或接受尽调时必然暴露的问题。

主体资格也已变化。最高人民法院《劳动争议司法解释(二)》第五条明确:依法设立的外国企业常驻代表机构可以作为劳动争议案件的当事人;当事人依法申请追加外国企业参加诉讼的,人民法院依法予以支持。代表处可以以自己的名义被诉,境外母公司也可能被追加。此前把代表处视为防火墙的集团,应保持派遣文件、薪酬记录与解除档案的完备。

派遣规则:代表处与外资子公司的关键差异

《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源和社会保障部令第22号)2013年12月20日审议通过,2014年1月24日公布,自2014年3月1日起施行。对普通用工单位(含外资子公司)有两项主导约束。

第三条”三性”:用工单位只能在临时性、辅助性或者替代性岗位上使用被派遣劳动者。临时性指存续时间不超过6个月的岗位;辅助性指为主营业务岗位提供服务的非主营业务岗位;替代性指劳动者因脱产学习、休假等原因无法工作的一定期间内,可由其他劳动者替代工作的岗位。辅助性岗位须经职工代表大会或者全体职工讨论,提出方案和意见,与工会或职工代表平等协商确定,并在用工单位内公示。

第四条 10% 比例:用工单位使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量的10%;用工总量 = 订立劳动合同人数 + 使用的被派遣劳动者人数。

第二十五条是本篇的关键条款:外国企业常驻代表机构和外国金融机构驻华代表机构等使用被派遣劳动者的,以及船员用人单位以劳务派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的,不受临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位和劳务派遣用工比例的限制。

一家 100 人的外资子公司最多只能使用 10 名被派遣劳动者,且岗位须合格并履行民主程序;代表处则可整个办公室通过派遣配置,岗位不限、期限不限——因为它没有其他合法路径。

代表处仍须遵守的规则

  • 第五条:劳务派遣单位应当依法与被派遣劳动者订立2年以上的固定期限书面劳动合同。第六条:与同一被派遣劳动者只能约定一次试用期。
  • 第七条 十三项必备条款:派遣岗位名称和岗位性质、工作地点、派遣人员数量和派遣期限、按同工同酬原则确定的劳动报酬数额和支付方式、社会保险费的数额与支付方式、工作时间和休息休假事项、工伤及生育或者患病期间的相关待遇、劳动安全卫生以及培训事项、经济补偿等费用、协议期限、劳务派遣服务费的支付方式和标准、违反协议的责任等。
  • 第十条 工伤:被派遣劳动者在用工单位因工作遭受事故伤害的,劳务派遣单位应当依法申请工伤认定,用工单位应当协助调查核实;劳务派遣单位承担工伤保险责任,但可与用工单位约定补偿办法。
  • 第十一条:劳务派遣单位行政许可有效期未延续,或者《劳务派遣经营许可证》被撤销、吊销的,已依法订立的劳动合同应当履行至期限届满。
  • 第十二条 退回情形:用工单位有《劳动合同法》第四十条第三项、第四十一条规定情形的;用工单位被依法宣告破产、吊销营业执照、责令关闭、撤销、决定提前解散或经营期限届满不再继续经营的;劳务派遣协议期满终止的。第十三条:被派遣劳动者有《劳动合同法》第四十二条情形的,在派遣期限届满前不得依第十二条第一款第一项退回。
  • 第十八、十九条 跨地区社保:跨地区派遣的,应当在用工单位所在地为被派遣劳动者参加社会保险、按用工单位所在地规定缴费;派遣单位在用工单位所在地设立分支机构的由分支机构办理参保,未设立的由用工单位代劳务派遣单位办理参保手续、缴纳社会保险费。
  • 第二十七条 反规避:用人单位以承揽、外包等名义,按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按本规定处理——即”假外包真派遣”。
  • 第二十二条、第二十条 罚则:用工单位违反第三条第三款的,由人社行政部门责令改正、给予警告;给被派遣劳动者造成损害的依法承担赔偿责任。其他违反劳务派遣规定的,按《劳动合同法》第九十二条执行。

服务商尽职调查清单

全部员工都挂在一份协议之后,服务商因此构成集中度风险。

  1. 核验《劳务派遣经营许可证》及其有效期。
  2. 确认签约主体与持证主体一致——与不持证的咨询关联方签约,可能被认定为无证派遣。
  3. 测试跨地区参保能力:当地无分支机构时,第十九条会把参保与缴费义务转移到代表处身上。
  4. 查阅社保与个人所得税代缴记录。
  5. 逐条比对第七条十三项必备条款。
  6. 锁定工伤责任与第十条允许的补偿办法约定。

本文不推荐任何特定服务商;应寻找持证的外企服务公司,或在相关城市有实绩的持证派遣公司。

首席代表、税务与升级为 WFOE

被委派为首席代表或代表的外籍人员处于另一条轨道:其任职来源于母公司委派文件与第九条登记事项,而非派遣协议;工作许可、居留、个人所得税与外汇登记遵循第584号令第八条及外籍人员单独规则。不要默认把他们并入派遣人员群体。

代表处在实践中常见按经费支出换算收入等核定征收方式。计入代表处费用支出的人力成本会直接进入税基,因此派遣服务费与通过机构发放的薪酬,既是人力问题也是税务问题。测算运营成本时应与税务顾问确认。

升级为 WFOE 需就三件事作出安排。劳动关系承继:员工的用人单位是派遣机构,转为直接雇佣意味着终止派遣安排并订立新的劳动合同,或通过三方协议完成变更。工龄连续计算:属于主体一方安排的转移,应在新合同中书面明确经济补偿与带薪年休假等事项上的工龄连续计算。节奏安排:WFOE 设立后,”三性”与 10% 比例限制对其全面适用,该群体需转为直接雇佣或压缩至比例上限之内。

相关阅读

可参阅本站外资企业劳务派遣合规总览、外包与派遣边界的界定、被派遣劳动者同工同酬与社会保险,以及主体架构选择对比文章。

Sources

Equal Pay, Social Insurance and Joint Liability for Dispatched Workers in China: What the Foreign Host Employer Must Own

  • Equal pay for dispatched workers is a rule about the remuneration distribution method, not about matching one headline number.
    被派遣劳动者的同工同酬,规范的是”劳动报酬分配办法”,而非简单对齐某一个工资数字。
  • The dispatch agency is the statutory social insurance contributor, but the host employer bears joint and several liability for damage caused to the worker.
    劳务派遣单位是法定参保缴费主体,但用工单位对给被派遣劳动者造成的损害承担连带赔偿责任。
  • In cross-region dispatch, remuneration, working conditions and social insurance all follow the standard of the host employer’s location.
    跨地区派遣时,劳动报酬、劳动条件与社会保险均按用工单位所在地标准执行。
  • Work injury enrolment and rate track the host employer’s industry on a higher-of-the-two basis, and recognition must be applied for within 30 days.
    工伤保险参保与费率按用工单位所在行业、就高原则确定,工伤认定申请须在30日内提出。
  • Guangdong’s DB44/T 2805-2026 specification makes the principles auditable: two-year contracts, one probation, full wages, five insurances plus the fund, 30-day injury filing, three-year ledgers.
    广东《劳务派遣服务规范》(DB44/T 2805-2026) 使法定原则可审计:两年以上合同、只约定一次试用期、工资足额发放、五险一金、30日内申请工伤认定、台账留存不少于3年。
  • In a dispute arising from dispatch, the agency and the host employer are co-parties; the host cannot stay out of the room.
    因劳务派遣引发劳动争议的,派遣单位与用工单位为共同当事人,用工单位无法置身事外。
  • Returning a dispatched worker is not an at-will right: the statutory grounds are exhaustive and protected categories cannot be returned.
    退回被派遣劳动者并非用工单位的任意权利:法定情形穷尽列举,受保护情形不得退回。

Equal Pay, Social Insurance and Joint Liability for Dispatched Workers in China: What the Foreign Host Employer Must Own | 被派遣劳动者的同工同酬、社会保险与用工单位连带责任:外资用工单位必须自己扛的部分

Why the Host Employer Carries Real Exposure

For a foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) using dispatched workers (被派遣劳动者), the comfortable assumption is that the staffing agency owns the employment relationship and therefore the risk. Chinese law does not support it. The agency (劳务派遣单位) is the employer of record and the statutory social insurance contributor, but the host employer (用工单位) carries duties that cannot be contracted away: equal pay, post-related welfare and workplace safety, and joint and several liability for damage caused to the worker. An indemnity in the dispatch agreement allocates cost between the two companies; it does not affect the worker’s right to pursue both. The 10% cap and the three-nature post test stay in the background; the recurring risk sits in pay, insurance and injury.

Equal Pay Is a Rule About the Pay Method

Article 63 of the Labour Contract Law gives dispatched workers equal pay for equal work, and its wording is routinely misread. The host must apply to them the same remuneration distribution method (劳动报酬分配办法) it applies to its own employees in the same category of post; where no comparable post exists, pay is benchmarked to the same or a similar post in the host’s locality. Two consequences follow.

  • The test is structural, not arithmetic. Identical gross figures are not required if grading, bonus formula, allowance rules and increment mechanism are the same and consistently applied. But an identical base salary with dispatched workers excluded from the annual bonus or shift allowance will fail.
  • The obligation flows through the paperwork. The labour contract between agency and worker and the dispatch agreement between agency and host must both state remuneration consistent with the rule. A flat per-head “service rate” that never discloses actual pay tells against the host.

Article 62 adds a parallel duty: provide the welfare benefits attached to the post and do not discriminate. Canteen, shuttle transport, protective equipment, on-post training and holiday arrangements are post-related benefits, not perks for direct hires.

Collective Consultation on Auxiliary Posts

Using dispatched workers on auxiliary posts requires a procedure, not a management decision. Under the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch the proposal must be discussed by the employee representative congress or all employees, determined through equal consultation with the union or employee representatives, and published inside the host. Skipping it draws an order to rectify and a warning from the human resources and social security authority, plus damages where the worker suffers loss. Keep the minutes, the consultation record and the notice.

Cross-Region Dispatch: The Host’s Location Governs

Under Article 61, remuneration and working conditions follow the standard of the host’s location when an agency dispatches across regions. Where an FIE centralises a national staffing contract with an agency headquartered in a low-cost province and deploys workers into a Tier-1 city plant, minimum wage, overtime base and allowance practice benchmark to the host site, not the agency’s registered address.

Social insurance follows the same logic: the agency must enrol the worker at the host’s location and contribute under that location’s rules. Where it has a branch there, the branch enrols and pays; where it does not, the host enrols and pays on the agency’s behalf — the limb FIEs most often overlook, because it makes the host the operational payer by default.

Social Insurance: Legal Payer Versus Practical Backstop

The agency is the statutory contribution subject for the social insurances and, in most localities, the housing provident fund. Host exposure arises three ways: the default enrolment duty above; joint damages liability where the agency under-contributes and the worker’s loss connects to the host’s arrangements; and contribution-base compression, where the agency pays on the local minimum base rather than actual wages, so that when the worker claims the shortfall the host is drawn in as co-respondent.

Work Injury: The Rate Follows the Host’s Industry, the Clock Is 30 Days

Work injury insurance is priced through differential industry rates and rate bands under the Regulations on Work-Related Injury Insurance. The 2025 MOHRSS guidance on implementing those Regulations (人社部发〔2025〕62号, Opinions (III)) is the reference local bureaux apply to dispatch: the agency remains the statutory enrolling party, enrolment is effected at the place of dispatch, and the rate is set by reference to the host’s industry, taking the higher rate where the agency’s registered industry would price lower. An FIE in manufacturing or logistics cannot import a cheap service-sector rate through an agency.

Two operational rules matter more than the rate.

  • The agency applies for injury recognition; the host assists the investigation. The agency bears work injury insurance liability but may agree a compensation-sharing method with the host. For occupational disease the host handles diagnosis and appraisal and must truthfully supply the occupational history, hazard-exposure history and workplace monitoring results.
  • Thirty days. The employing entity must file the recognition application with the coordinating-region social insurance administration within 30 days of the accident or diagnosis. If missed, the worker, close relatives or the union may file within one year — but benefits accruing during the delay are borne by the entity that missed the deadline.

Joint Liability and Co-Respondent Status

Article 92(2) of the Labour Contract Law is the anchor: where the host causes damage to a dispatched worker, agency and host bear joint and several liability. Procedurally, the Law on Mediation and Arbitration of Labour Disputes makes them co-parties where the dispute arises from dispatch, so the FIE cannot stay outside the proceedings. Preserve attendance, overtime, payslip and safety-training records as rigorously as for direct employees, align the two parties’ position before the first hearing, and avoid clauses purporting to waive the worker’s statutory rights, which are void against the worker.

When a Dispatched Worker Cannot Be Returned

Return to the agency (退回) is not an at-will right; the grounds are exhaustive: material change of objective circumstances or economic redundancy; the host being declared bankrupt, having its licence revoked, ordered to close, dissolved early, or ceasing operations; or expiry of the dispatch agreement. Even then, where the worker falls within the protected categories of Article 42 — occupational-hazard exposure without an exit health check or suspected occupational disease under observation, confirmed occupational disease or work injury with lost working capacity, illness or non-work injury within the medical period, pregnancy, maternity or nursing, or fifteen years’ service with fewer than five years to retirement — the host may not return the worker on the objective-change ground before the term expires, and where it expires the arrangement continues until the protected condition ends. While unassigned after return, the agency must pay the worker monthly at no less than the local minimum wage.

Guangdong’s DB44/T 2805-2026 Service Specification

Guangdong has implemented a local standard for labour dispatch services, DB44/T 2805-2026 (《劳务派遣服务规范》), publicised through the Ministry’s China HR Market portal. It converts statutory principles into auditable requirements for agencies in the province: a written fixed-term labour contract of two years or more; one probation period only per worker with the same agency; full and timely wages; enrolment in the five social insurances and the housing fund; work-injury recognition applied for within 30 days; and retention of dispatch ledgers for not less than three years. For an FIE host in Guangdong it is a ready-made supplier scorecard.

Due Diligence and Contract Checklist for the Host

Agency due diligence: valid dispatch operating permit and expiry date; registered capital; whether it has a branch at the host’s location, which determines who enrols for social insurance; litigation and penalty history; and contribution-base practice evidenced by payment receipts, not by representation.

Dispatch agreement: all thirteen matters required by Article 7 of the Interim Provisions must appear, and two of them decide the case if the arrangement is challenged — the remuneration amount and payment method determined on the equal-pay principle, and the social insurance amount and payment method.

Beyond the statutory minimum: an audit right over contribution records; a warranty that the contribution base equals actual wages; a 30-day injury-filing protocol with named contacts; allocation of the work-injury compensation share; a three-year ledger covenant; immediate notice of any permit lapse; and an exit mechanism that does not depend on returning protected workers.

Related Reading

See our labour dispatch compliance overview for FIEs (No. 168), the outsourcing-versus-dispatch boundary and “false outsourcing, real dispatch” (No. 179), and secondment arrangements (No. 34).


被派遣劳动者的同工同酬、社会保险与用工单位连带责任:外资用工单位必须自己扛的部分

用工单位为何仍有实质风险敞口

对使用被派遣劳动者的外资企业而言,最省心的假设是:劳动关系在劳务派遣单位,风险自然也在派遣单位。中国法律并不支持这一假设。劳务派遣单位是法律上的用人单位与法定参保缴费主体,但用工单位承担的义务无法通过合同转移出去:同工同酬、与岗位相关的福利待遇与劳动安全卫生条件,以及对给被派遣劳动者造成损害的连带赔偿责任。派遣协议中的商业补偿条款只是在两家公司之间分配成本,并不影响劳动者同时向双方主张权利。10%用工比例上限与临时性、辅助性、替代性”三性”岗位判断仍是背景约束,但外资企业反复出现的诉讼风险,集中在报酬、社保与工伤三条线上。

同工同酬规范的是”分配办法”

《劳动合同法》第六十三条赋予被派遣劳动者同工同酬的权利,其关键表述常被误读:用工单位应当按照同工同酬原则,对被派遣劳动者与本单位同类岗位的劳动者实行相同的劳动报酬分配办法;用工单位无同类岗位劳动者的,参照用工单位所在地相同或者相近岗位劳动者的劳动报酬确定。由此产生两个结论。

  • 判断标准是结构性的,而非算术性的。 若职级评定、奖金公式、津贴规则与调薪机制相同且一贯执行,并不要求工资总额完全一致;反之,基本工资相同但将被派遣劳动者排除在年度奖金方案或倒班津贴之外的,仍构成违反。
  • 义务通过书面文件传导。 派遣单位与劳动者订立的劳动合同、派遣单位与用工单位订立的劳务派遣协议,其载明或约定的劳动报酬均应符合同工同酬要求。仅以”人头服务费”包干定价、从不披露劳动者实际报酬的派遣协议,在争议中是对用工单位不利的证据。

第六十二条还设定了并行义务:用工单位应当向被派遣劳动者提供与工作岗位相关的福利待遇,不得歧视。食堂、班车、劳动防护用品、上岗培训与休假安排属于岗位相关待遇,而非仅面向直签员工的酌情福利。

辅助性岗位的集体协商程序

在辅助性岗位使用被派遣劳动者,需要的是一套程序而非一项管理决定。依《劳务派遣暂行规定》,应当经职工代表大会或者全体职工讨论,提出方案和意见,与工会或者职工代表平等协商确定,并在用工单位内公示。未履行该程序的,由人力资源社会保障行政部门责令改正、给予警告;给被派遣劳动者造成损害的,依法承担赔偿责任。会议纪要、协商记录与内部公示文件均应留存。

跨地区派遣:以用工单位所在地为准

《劳动合同法》第六十一条规定,劳务派遣单位跨地区派遣劳动者的,被派遣劳动者享有的劳动报酬和劳动条件,按照用工单位所在地的标准执行。对于将全国用工集中交由注册在低成本省份的派遣机构、再把人派到一线城市工厂的外资企业,这一点尤为关键:最低工资、加班工资基数、津贴惯例与工时安排,均以用工单位所在地为基准,而非派遣单位注册地。

社会保险遵循同一逻辑:派遣单位应当在用工单位所在地为被派遣劳动者参加社会保险,按照用工单位所在地规定缴纳社会保险费。派遣单位在当地设立分支机构的,由分支机构办理参保、缴费;未设立分支机构的,由用工单位代派遣单位办理参保手续、缴纳社会保险费——这一款最容易被外资企业忽略,因为它使用工单位在默认状态下成为实际经办与缴费主体。

社会保险:法定缴费主体与实际兜底方

派遣单位是各项社会保险,以及多数地区住房公积金的法定缴费主体。用工单位的风险敞口来自三处:上述默认参保义务;派遣单位少缴或不缴、且劳动者所受损失与用工单位安排相关联时的连带赔偿责任;以及缴费基数压缩——派遣机构常按当地最低基数而非实际工资缴纳,劳动者事后主张差额时,用工单位被列为共同当事人,其签约时测算的成本模型随之失效。

工伤:费率跟随用工单位行业,时限是30日

依《工伤保险条例》,工伤保险费实行行业差别费率与行业内费率档次。人力资源社会保障部2025年印发的《关于执行〈工伤保险条例〉若干问题的意见(三)》(人社部发〔2025〕62号)是各地经办机构目前适用于劳务派遣的参照:派遣单位仍为法定参保主体,在派遣地办理参保,费率参照用工单位所在行业确定;派遣单位自身注册行业费率更低的,按就高原则执行。其实际效果是,制造、建筑、物流行业的外资用工单位,无法通过派遣机构套用低费率的服务业费率。

有两条操作规则比费率本身更重要。

  • 派遣单位申请工伤认定,用工单位应当协助调查核实。 派遣单位承担工伤保险责任,但可以与用工单位约定补偿办法。涉及职业病诊断、鉴定的,由用工单位负责处理,并如实提供职业史、职业危害接触史与工作场所危害因素检测结果等资料。
  • 30日。 用人单位应当自事故伤害发生之日或被诊断、鉴定为职业病之日起30日内,向统筹地区社会保险行政部门提出工伤认定申请。逾期未提出的,劳动者、近亲属或工会组织可在1年内直接申请,但延误期间发生的符合规定的工伤待遇费用,由未按期申请的单位负担。

连带责任与共同当事人地位

《劳动合同法》第九十二条第二款是核心依据:用工单位给被派遣劳动者造成损害的,劳务派遣单位与用工单位承担连带赔偿责任。在程序上,《劳动争议调解仲裁法》规定因劳务派遣发生争议的,派遣单位与用工单位为共同当事人,外资企业因此无法置身程序之外。实务上应做到:对被派遣劳动者的考勤、加班、工资条与安全培训记录,与直签员工同等严格地留存;在首次开庭前统一双方口径;避免约定放弃劳动者法定权利的条款,此类条款对劳动者无效,即便在双方之间可用于分摊成本。

不得退回被派遣劳动者的法定情形

退回派遣单位并非用工单位的任意权利,法定情形穷尽列举:出现《劳动合同法》第四十条第三项(客观情况发生重大变化)或第四十一条(经济性裁员)情形的;用工单位被依法宣告破产、吊销营业执照、责令关闭、撤销、决定提前解散或者经营期限届满不再继续经营的;劳务派遣协议期满终止的。即便如此,劳动者属于第四十二条保护情形的——从事接触职业病危害作业未进行离岗前职业健康检查或疑似职业病病人在诊断观察期间、患职业病或因工负伤并被确认丧失或部分丧失劳动能力、患病或非因工负伤在规定医疗期内、女职工在孕期产期哺乳期、在本单位连续工作满十五年且距法定退休年龄不足五年——用工单位在派遣期限届满前不得依据客观情况重大变化的理由退回;派遣期限届满的,应当延续至相应情形消失时方可退回。违法退回的,按第九十二条第二款承担责任;被退回后无工作期间,派遣单位应当按照不低于所在地最低工资标准,向劳动者按月支付报酬。

广东省地方标准 DB44/T 2805-2026

广东省已实施劳务派遣服务地方标准《劳务派遣服务规范》(DB44/T 2805-2026),由人力资源社会保障部主管的中国人力资源市场网对外发布。该标准将法定原则转化为可审计的服务要求,适用于在粤经营的派遣机构:与被派遣劳动者订立2年以上固定期限书面劳动合同;同一劳动者只能约定一次试用期;工资足额及时发放;依法参加五险并缴存住房公积金;30日内申请工伤认定;派遣与用工台账留存不少于3年。对广东的外资用工单位而言,这套标准是现成的供应商评分表;在争议中,它也是裁审机关可援引的规范性基准。

用工单位的尽调与合同条款清单

派遣机构尽调: 劳务派遣经营许可证是否有效及有效期;注册资本;是否在用工单位所在地设有分支机构(决定由谁办理参保);诉讼与行政处罚记录;缴费基数的实际做法,应以缴费凭证样本为证,而非以对方陈述为证。

劳务派遣协议: 《劳务派遣暂行规定》第七条要求的十三项内容应逐项载明,其中两项在争议中具有决定性——按照同工同酬原则确定的劳动报酬数额和支付方式,以及社会保险费的数额和支付方式。

建议在法定最低要求之外增加: 对缴费记录的审计权;缴费基数等于实际工资的承诺与保证;载明双方对接人的30日工伤申报流程;工伤赔付份额的分担约定;不少于3年的台账留存承诺;许可证失效时立即通知用工单位的义务;以及不依赖退回受保护劳动者的退出机制。

相关阅读

可参阅本站外资企业劳务派遣合规总论(编号168)、外包与派遣边界”假外包真派遣”(编号179)与派遣与借调 secondment(编号34)。

Sources

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China

  • Article 27 of the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch treats workers used in the form of dispatch under the name of contracting or outsourcing as dispatched workers, and applies the dispatch rules to them.
    《劳务派遣暂行规定》第27条规定,用人单位以承揽、外包等名义、按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照该规定处理。
  • Once an outsourcing arrangement is pierced, the client is pulled back under the very “three-nature” post restriction and 10% headcount cap it was trying to avoid.
    外包一旦被穿透,发包方将重新落入其试图规避的三性岗位限制与10%用工比例上限。
  • Chinese courts apply substantive review and ask one question first: does the client exercise dominant labour management over the workers?
    中国法院坚持实质审查原则,首要审查发包方是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。
  • At its 16 July 2026 briefing on disguised-employment disputes, the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing reported that confirming an employment relationship, or holding the enterprise liable as employer, is the common outcome.
    北京市房山区人民法院2026年7月16日涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议通报指出,最终确认劳动关系或判令企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。
  • Representative offices of foreign enterprises are exempt from the three-nature and 10% limits under Article 25; WFOEs and joint ventures are not.
    依第25条,外国企业常驻代表机构使用被派遣劳动者不受三性岗位与10%比例限制;外商独资企业与合资企业并无此项豁免。
  • Piercing carries joint and several liability, plus fines of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker where a breach is not remedied within the ordered period.
    穿透后产生连带赔偿责任,逾期不改正的还将按每人5000元以上1万元以下的标准处以罚款。
  • The cure lies in substance, not the title: price by deliverable, manage the task rather than the person, and let the contractor supply tools, discipline and payroll.
    整改的关键在实质而非名称:按成果计价、”对事不对人”地行使管理权、由承包方配置生产资料并独立承担用工义务。

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China | 外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

Overview: the cap that pushes employers into outsourcing

A foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) needing flexible headcount meets two hard limits at once. Article 3 of the *Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 22, effective 1 March 2014) confines dispatched workers to temporary, auxiliary or substitute posts; Article 4 caps them at 10% of total headcount, counting direct-contract employees plus dispatched workers.

The response is predictable: rather than shrink the dispatched population, rename it. The dispatch agreement becomes a “service outsourcing” agreement, the workers stay at the same desks under the same supervisors, and the 10% calculation appears to reset to zero. That is what Article 27 exists to defeat.

Article 27: the anti-circumvention clause

Article 27 is one sentence: where an employing entity uses workers in the form of labour dispatch under the name of contracting, outsourcing or the like, the matter shall be handled in accordance with these Provisions.

The consequence is total. A relabelled arrangement does not merely lose its outsourcing character; it falls under the entire dispatch regime — three-nature posts, the 10% cap, the licence requirement, equal pay for equal work, the thirteen mandatory terms of Article 7, the three return grounds of Article 12, and joint liability under Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law*. An employer that changed the label to escape one rule inherits all of them, years later, with no records built to satisfy them.

Six dimensions that separate outsourcing from dispatch

The *Shanxi Province Guidelines on Labour Dispatch* (April 2026) draw the distinction across six dimensions — a useful audit grid, because it tracks what an inspector or judge tests.

DimensionLabour dispatchGenuine service outsourcing
Supplier qualificationDispatch Operation Licence requiredNo special licence
Post restrictionTemporary, auxiliary or substitute onlyNone
PartiesThree: agency, client, workerTwo: principal and contractor
Management authorityClient manages the workers directlyPrincipal does not manage them
PricingBy headcount and working timeBy completion of the work
Governing lawLabour contract legislationThe Civil Code

Where the contractor’s workers take instructions from the principal, work to the principal’s arrangements, or provide labour in the principal’s name, the Guidelines warn the arrangement may be treated as dispatch, with liability allocated accordingly.

Substantive review: the 2026 cases

On 16 July 2026 the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing briefed the press on model disguised-employment disputes. Spokesperson Ma Yanjia described the pattern: enterprises sign agreements under different names and build multi-layered engagement chains, packaging what is properly an employment relationship as contracting, outsourcing or cooperation. The court applies a substantive review principle, asking whether the enterprise exercises dominant labour management over the worker. Confirming an employment relationship, or imposing employer liability, was the common outcome.

“We manage them, the outsourcer pays them.” A courier company’s outsourcing fee comprised commission, a management service fee, taxes and rebates — with the service fee set at zero. Its station manager ran attendance in a WeChat group, pay flowed from the courier company’s own funds, and the app showed riders as its staff. The consideration was implausibly low and the structure suggested avoidance of employment status and transfer of commercial risk: the employment relationship lay with the courier company.

A contracting agreement over real employment. Another agreement cast riders as individual business operators paid by a platform — yet the company set shifts, controlled order volume and could assign orders individually. However an agreement is dressed, where the substance matches employment, a de facto relationship is recognised.

Outsourcing in name, dispatch in fact. Company A employed a worker and placed him in sales at Company B under a “labour outsourcing cooperation agreement” by which A would second personnel to B. He worked on B’s premises under B’s direction, with pay and benefits confirmed, settled and paid by B — a textbook “fake outsourcing, real dispatch”. After B returned him, A terminated him for serious misconduct; because B could not evidence that the return followed the agreed procedure, A paid damages for unlawful termination. After a return, the agency must independently verify a statutory ground for termination.

Why FIEs sit closer to the line

Article 25 grants an exemption most FIEs do not have. Representative offices of foreign enterprises and of foreign financial institutions — and employers of international seafarers — are not subject to the three-nature restriction or the dispatch ratio. That is structural, not a privilege: an RO cannot employ Chinese staff directly and can only staff itself through dispatch. WFOEs and joint ventures get nothing of the kind. Fully bound by Articles 3 and 4, they are the ones reaching for outsourcing — and the ones exposed to piercing.

Multi-city footprints add a second trap: under Articles 18 and 19, cross-region dispatch requires social insurance enrolment in the client’s locality, and where the agency has no branch there, the client enrols and pays on its behalf.

What piercing costs

Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law* requires rectification, with a fine of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker if it is not made in time, and Article 92(2) imposes joint and several liability on agency and client for loss caused to a dispatched worker; Shanxi treats them as co-parties in dispatch disputes. Article 22 of the Interim Provisions separately allows rectification orders and warnings where auxiliary posts were set without the democratic procedure — staff or employee-congress discussion, equal consultation with the union, and internal publication. Because Article 57 makes dispatch a licensed business, an “outsourcer” usually holds no licence, so piercing converts the arrangement into unlicensed dispatch. Port operators bound by both red lines are already converting non-compliant dispatch into structured outsourcing.

Rebuilding the arrangement so it survives review

  1. From people to work product. Contract for a defined deliverable, not the labour of named individuals; drop “project personnel” for “service team”.
  2. Manage the task, not the person. Remove the principal’s attendance, appraisal and disciplinary power over individuals; keep work rules in the contractor’s system; equipment should be the contractor’s.
  3. Pay for outcomes. Delete per-head pricing and line items for management fees, social insurance, salary and income tax; tie milestones to delivery and acceptance, not to “payable monthly”.
  4. Harden the liability allocation. The contractor alone bears employment contracting, wages, social insurance and work-injury liability; the principal accepts only the work product, against written confirmation that those obligations have been met.

What to do next

  1. Map the population. Count direct employees, dispatched workers and every outsourced head on your premises. If that group were pierced tomorrow, would you be within 10%, and would the posts be temporary, auxiliary or substitute?
  2. Test each supplier against the six dimensions. Pricing basis and management authority decide most cases.
  3. Do supplier due diligence. Verify the Dispatch Operation Licence and its validity — licensing authorities must publish the licensed-agency list and any change, revocation or cancellation — and the RMB 2 million minimum registered capital under Article 7 of the *Administrative Licensing Measures for Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 19, effective 1 July 2013). Never accept a human resources service licence as a substitute.
  4. Audit the evidence trail, not just the contract. Where the paper says outsourcing and the group chat says supervision, the group chat wins.
  5. Fix the democratic procedure for auxiliary posts, and never assume a group RO’s Article 25 exemption travels to the WFOE.
  6. Plan the return route in advance. Returns are limited to the three Article 12 grounds, and workers protected by Article 42 of the *Labour Contract Law* cannot be returned on objective-change or redundancy grounds before the dispatch term expires.

外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

概览:把雇主推向外包的比例上限

需要弹性用工的外商投资企业会同时撞上两道硬约束。《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源和社会保障部令第22号,2014年3月1日施行)第3条规定,用工单位只能在临时性、辅助性或者替代性岗位上使用被派遣劳动者;第4条规定被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量的10%,用工总量为订立劳动合同人数与使用的被派遣劳动者人数之和。

企业的反应可以预见:不是压减派遣人数,而是改换名称。派遣协议改签为”服务外包”协议,劳动者仍在原岗位、由原主管指挥,10%的计算似乎归零。第27条正是为了打掉这一操作而设。

第27条:反规避条款

第27条只有一句话:用人单位以承揽、外包等名义,按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照本规定处理。

后果是整体性的。被重新贴标签的安排不只是失去外包属性,而是整体落入派遣规则体系——三性岗位、10%比例、供应商许可、同工同酬、第7条协议13项必备条款、第12条仅有的三种退回情形,以及《劳动合同法》第92条的连带责任。为规避一条规则而改名的雇主,往往在数年后一次性承受全部规则,且手中没有任何为满足这些规则而准备的材料。

区分外包与派遣的六个维度

2026年4月印发的《山西省劳务派遣用工指引》从六个维度系统区分二者,可直接用作自查表,因为它对应的正是监察人员或法官实际审查的内容。

维度劳务派遣真实的服务外包
主体资质须取得《劳务派遣经营许可证》无特殊资质要求
岗位限制仅限临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位无岗位限定
法律关系三方:派遣单位、用工单位、劳动者两方:发包方与承包方
管理权限用工单位直接管理劳动者发包方不管理承包方员工
费用结算按人数与工作时间结算按业务完成情况结算
法律适用劳动合同相关法律法规《民法典》

指引提示:承包单位劳动者若接受发包企业指挥管理、按发包企业安排提供劳动,或以发包企业名义提供劳动,该安排可能被认定为劳务派遣,并据此确定发包单位与外包单位的法律责任。

实质审查:2026年的案例

2026年7月16日,北京市房山区人民法院召开涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议纠纷典型案例新闻通报会。新闻发言人马艳佳指出的模式是:企业通过签订不同名目的协议,设计多层用工链条,将本应属于劳动关系的情况包装成承揽、外包、合作等其他法律关系。法院坚持实质审查原则,重点审查企业是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。从审理结果看,最终确认存在劳动关系或判决企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。

“自己管人、外包发钱”。 某快递公司的外包费用由佣金、管理服务费、税费及返费构成,其中管理服务费为0。站长在微信群中监督骑手考勤,报酬资金来自快递公司,APP显示骑手为该公司员工。合同对价明显偏低,结构上存在规避劳动关系、转嫁商业风险之嫌,法院认定劳动关系存在于快递公司与劳动者之间。

以承揽合同行用工之实。 另一份协议约定骑手作为个体工商户承揽配送、由第三方平台付酬,但公司对其排班、控制接单量并可单独派单。即便披上承揽外衣,只要用工实质符合劳动关系,即认定为事实劳动关系。

名为外包实为派遣。 甲公司与劳动者签订劳动合同并安排其至乙公司任销售,甲乙之间的《劳务外包合作协议》约定由甲向乙派驻人员。该劳动者在乙公司场所、受乙公司管理指挥,工资福利由乙公司确认、结算和支付——属典型的“假外包、真派遣”。乙公司退回后,甲公司径行以严重违纪解除劳动合同;因乙公司未能提交充分证据证明退回符合约定的处罚程序,甲公司被判支付违法解除劳动关系赔偿金。退回之后,派遣单位须独立审查是否符合法定解除情形,不能被动接受用工单位的退回决定。

外资企业为何更接近红线

第25条给予的豁免,多数外资企业并不享有。 外国企业常驻代表机构、外国金融机构驻华代表机构,以及以派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的船员用人单位,不受三性岗位和劳务派遣用工比例的限制。这是制度配套而非优惠:代表处本身不能直接与中国员工建立劳动关系,只能通过派遣用工。外商独资企业与合资企业则完全没有该项豁免,须完整遵守第3条与第4条——这正是不少外资雇主转向”外包”的动因,也正是其穿透风险的来源。

多城市布点还带来第二重风险。依第18、19条,跨地区派遣应在用工单位所在地参加社会保险;派遣单位在当地未设分支机构的,由用工单位代为办理参保、缴费。

被穿透的代价

《劳动合同法》第92条规定责令改正,逾期不改的按每人5000元以上1万元以下处以罚款;第92条第2款规定,用工单位给被派遣劳动者造成损害的,派遣单位与用工单位承担连带赔偿责任,山西的指引亦明确二者在派遣争议中为共同当事人。《劳务派遣暂行规定》第22条另行规定,辅助性岗位未经民主程序(职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表平等协商、并在单位内公示)确定的,责令改正、给予警告。由于《劳动合同法》第57条将劳务派遣设为许可经营事项,被当作”外包方”引入的供应商通常并无该许可,穿透之后即转化为无证派遣。受双重红线约束的港口企业已开始将违规派遣转为规范化服务外包。

如何重构安排以经得起审查

  1. 从”对人”到”对事”。 约定特定的交付成果而非特定劳动者的劳务;避免”项目人员”等称谓,改用”服务团队””项目小组”。
  2. 管理权”对事不对人”。 删除发包方对劳动者个人的考勤、考核与处分条款;劳动纪律与考核标准独立于发包方制度体系;工作服装、电脑设备等生产资料原则上由承包方配置。
  3. 按成果付费。 删除按人头计价,以及管理费、社保公积金、薪资个税等人身性支出明细;付款节点与交付、验收挂钩,删除”按月支付”等按时间计费规则。
  4. 强化责任边界。 由承包方独立承担劳动合同签订、工资支付、社保缴纳与工伤赔偿等全部法定义务;发包方仅对成果验收,并可要求承包方提供已履行上述义务的书面确认作为验收前提。

下一步建议

  1. 先做人数盘点。 统计直接雇员、被派遣劳动者以及在本单位场所工作的全部外包人员。若外包人员明日被穿透,是否仍在10%以内?相关岗位是否属于三性?
  2. 用六个维度逐一检验供应商。 费用结算方式与管理权限是决定多数案件的两项。
  3. 做好供应商尽调。 核验《劳务派遣经营许可证》的真实性与有效期(许可机关应公示获证单位名单及变更、撤销、注销情况),并核对《劳务派遣行政许可实施办法》(人社部令第19号,2013年7月1日施行)第7条要求的注册资本不少于人民币200万元。切勿以”人力资源服务许可”替代劳务派遣经营许可。
  4. 审查证据链,而不只是合同。 当书面文件写着外包、微信群里却在下达管理指令时,微信群会胜出。
  5. 补齐辅助性岗位的民主程序,且不要假定集团代表处的第25条豁免可延伸至外商独资企业。
  6. 提前规划退回路径。 退回仅限第12条的三种情形,且属于《劳动合同法》第42条保护情形的劳动者,在派遣期限届满前不得以客观情况重大变化或经济性裁员为由退回。

Sources

Labour Dispatch Compliance for Foreign-Invested Enterprises in China: the “three-nature” rule and the 10% cap

  • Dispatch is only a supplementary form of employment in China and may be used solely on “three-nature” posts: temporary (under 6 months), ancillary (non-core), or substitute (covering an absent employee).
    劳务派遣在中国只是补充用工形式,仅限于”三性”岗位使用:临时性(不超过 6 个月)、辅助性(非主营业务)或替代性(顶替休假员工)。
  • The 10% cap is hard: a user employer’s dispatched-headcount must not exceed 10% of its total workforce (employees on labour contracts plus dispatched workers).
    10% 上限是硬指标:用工单位使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量(订立劳动合同人数与派遣人数之和)的 10%。
  • Ancillary posts require a democratic procedure — discussion by the employee congress or all staff, consultation with the union, and internal public notice — before dispatch may be used there.
    辅助性岗位须履行民主程序——经职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表协商确定,并在单位内公示——方可使用派遣。
  • The dispatch agency must hold a Dispatch Licence, sign a fixed-term written contract of at least two years, and pay no less than local minimum wage during any no-work interval.
    派遣单位须持《劳务派遣经营许可证》,订立 2 年以上固定期限书面劳动合同,并在无工作期间按不低于当地最低工资按月支付报酬。
  • Same pay for same work applies: user employers must provide dispatched workers with job-related welfare benefits and may not discriminate; cross-region dispatch is socially insured at the place of work.
    同工同酬适用:用工单位须向被派遣劳动者提供与岗位相关的福利待遇、不得歧视;跨地区派遣在用工单位所在地参保。
  • “Fake outsourcing, real dispatch” is caught: using contracting or outsourcing in the form of dispatch is treated as dispatch under the rules.
    “假外包、真派遣”被规制:以承揽、外包名义按派遣形式使用劳动者的,按本规定处理。
  • Registration certificates and POAs from the foreign parent still need an Apostille (Hague) or consular authentication when filed for licence or entity setup — China’s Apostille accession (effective 7 Nov 2023) streamlines this.
    外国母公司的注册证书与授权书在办理许可或设立时仍须附加证明书(海牙)或领事认证——中国加入海牙公约(2023 年 11 月 7 日生效)已大幅简化此环节。

Labour Dispatch Compliance for Foreign-Invested Enterprises in China: the “three-nature” rule and the 10% cap | 外资企业劳务派遣合规:三性规则与 10% 上限

Overview

Many foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) in China use labour dispatch to flex headcount for seasonal peaks, administrative support, or niche technical roles. Dispatch can work well, but it sits inside a strict regulatory box. The Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security Order No. 22, effective 1 March 2014) — issued to implement the 2012 amended Labour Contract Law — defines where dispatch may be used, caps the proportion, and splits responsibilities among the dispatch agency, the user employer and the worker. For an FIE, getting this wrong risks administrative penalties, back-pay exposure and “deemed employment” disputes. This article explains the rules that matter, with official sources. It is general information, not legal advice.

Where dispatch is allowed: the “three-nature” posts

Article 3 of the Interim Provisions restricts dispatch to posts that are temporary, ancillary or substitute:

  • Temporary (临时性): a post that lasts no more than six months.
  • Ancillary (辅助性): a non-core post serving the main business.
  • Substitute (替代性): a post where the regular employee is temporarily absent (study leave, vacation, etc.) and can be covered by another worker.

Crucially, for ancillary posts the user employer must follow a democratic procedure: the ancillary post list is discussed by the employee congress or all staff, proposed and consulted with the union or worker representatives, and then publicly announced within the unit. Skipping this procedure is a recognised compliance risk.

A notable carve-out: representative offices of foreign enterprises and representative offices of foreign financial institutions, as well as the use of international ocean crews in dispatch form, are not bound by the three-nature and proportion limits (Article 25) — relevant for foreign bank and insurance representative offices.

The 10% cap

Article 4 is the headline constraint for any sizeable FIE: the number of dispatched workers must not exceed 10% of the user employer’s total workforce, where “total workforce” = employees on labour contracts + dispatched workers. The calculation unit is the employer that can conclude labour contracts under the Labour Contract Law — so a corporate group must calculate per legal entity, not group-wide.

The rules also target evasion: where a company contracts work out but the contractor’s workers use the company’s facilities, follow the company’s arrangements, or work in the company’s name (i.e. “fake outsourcing, real dispatch”), those workers are counted into the company’s proportion (Article 27; see also the compliance guidance issued by local HRSS bureaus).

The dispatch agency’s obligations

A dispatch agency may operate only with a Dispatch Licence (劳务派遣经营许可证). Minimum conditions include registered capital of at least RMB 2 million (paid-in, per the 2014 reform), fixed premises and facilities, and a compliant dispatch management system. The licence is subject to annual reporting and may be revoked for repeated violations.

The agency must:

  • conclude a fixed-term written labour contract of at least two years with each dispatched worker (Article 5);
  • truthfully inform the worker of the rules, the dispatch agreement and relevant matters (Article 8);
  • pay labour remuneration and social insurance in accordance with law and the dispatch agreement (Article 8);
  • apply for work-injury identification where the worker is injured on the job at the user employer — the agency bears work-injury liability, with reimbursement arranged with the user employer (Article 10);
  • pay no less than the local minimum wage monthly during any no-work interval after return (Article 12).

The user employer’s obligations

The user employer engages the worker day to day but does not employ them. Its duties include:

  • using dispatch only on three-nature posts within the 10% cap;
  • providing the same remuneration distribution as comparable in-house staff, plus job-related welfare benefits, with no discrimination (Articles 9, 62 Labour Contract Law);
  • providing labour protection and occupational safety/hygiene conditions;
  • handling occupational-disease diagnosis and appraisal where needed (Article 10);
  • following the return rules: a worker may be returned only on the limited statutory grounds (e.g. the user employer’s bankruptcy, closure, revocation, dissolution, or expiry of the dispatch agreement), and protected workers (medical leave, pregnancy, maternity, nursing) may not be returned before the relevant period lapses (Article 12–13).

Cross-region dispatch and social insurance

Where a dispatch agency sends workers across regions, it must enrol them in social insurance at the place of work, under local rates (Article 18). If the agency has a branch at the place of work, the branch handles enrolment; if not, the user employer handles it on the agency’s behalf (Article 19). This “same insure at place of work” rule implements equal treatment for cross-region dispatched workers.

Penalties and pitfalls

Violations are handled under the Labour Contract Law’s penalty articles: unlawful dispatch operation, exceeding the proportion, abusing ancillary posts, or unlawful return can trigger correction orders, warnings, compensation liability to the worker, and — for unlicensed dispatch operation — fines of one to five times the illegal income (or up to RMB 50,000 where there is none). FIEs should also watch the “fake outsourcing” trap: relabelling a dispatch relationship as a service contract does not escape the rules.

Document authentication for the foreign parent

When an FIE or its dispatch arrangements require filings referencing the foreign parent — e.g. the parent’s incorporation certificate or a power of attorney for licence or entity matters — the foreign document must carry an Apostille if the home state is a Hague Convention party, or Chinese embassy/consulate authentication otherwise. China acceded to the Convention on 8 March 2023 and it took effect on 7 November 2023, so most treaty-member parents now use the one-step Apostille instead of double consular authentication.

What this means for foreign investors and FIEs

  • Audit your dispatch footprint against the 10% cap per legal entity, not group-wide.
  • Map posts to three-nature and complete the ancillary-post democratic procedure with evidence (minutes, consultation, notice).
  • Vet your dispatch agency’s licence and contract terms (2-year minimum, no-work pay, social insurance).
  • Confirm same-pay-for-same-work mechanics and benefits parity in practice.
  • Avoid fake outsourcing — structure genuine services as arm’s-length contracts, not disguised dispatch.
  • Authenticate foreign-parent documents via Apostille where applicable.
  • Confirm specifics with qualified PRC labour counsel before restructuring workforce arrangements.

What to do next

  1. Calculate your dispatched-headcount ratio per entity and identify any exceedance.
  2. Review the post list; complete and document the ancillary-post procedure where used.
  3. Audit dispatch-agency licences and agreements for the 2-year contract and no-work-pay terms.
  4. Check cross-region social-insurance enrolment at the place of work.
  5. Re-label any “outsourcing” that is in substance dispatch before it draws scrutiny.
  6. Brief HR and legal on the return rules and protected-worker carve-outs.

Sources

  • 中国政府网(国务院公报)— 人力资源和社会保障部令第 22 号《劳务派遣暂行规定》:https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • 人力资源社会保障部 — 劳动关系司负责人就《劳务派遣暂行规定》答记者问:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/ldgxs/LDGXhetong/ldht/201401/t20140127_123361.html
  • 宝鸡市人社局 — 劳务派遣合规用工指引(PDF):https://rsj.baoji.gov.cn/col9976/col1294/202405/P020241228629579687817.pdf
  • 外交部 — 《取消外国公文书认证要求的公约》在华生效通知:https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/wjbxw_new/202310/t20231023_11165858.shtml

Related reading

  • 外资企业雇佣管理实务 / Employment management for FIEs
  • 工作签证与居留许可 / Work visas and residence permits
  • 社保与跨境派遣合规 / Social insurance and cross-border dispatch compliance

外资企业劳务派遣合规:三性规则与 10% 上限

概述

许多在华外资企业用劳务派遣来柔化淡旺季、行政支持或稀缺技术岗位的用人需求。派遣本身可用,但被置于一套严格的监管框架内。《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源社会保障部令第 22 号,2014 年 3 月 1 日施行)为落实 2012 年修正的《劳动合同法》而制定,明确了派遣的适用岗位、比例上限,并划分了派遣单位、用工单位与劳动者三方责任。对外资企业而言,踩线将招致行政处罚、补薪敞口与”事实劳动关系”争议。本文结合官方来源说明关键规则,仅为一般性信息,非法律意见。

派遣的适用岗位:三性

《暂行规定》第三条将派遣限制在临时性、辅助性或替代性岗位:

  • 临时性: 存续时间不超过 6 个月的岗位;
  • 辅助性: 为主营业务岗位提供服务的非主营业务岗位;
  • 替代性: 用工单位劳动者因脱产学习、休假等无法工作期间,可由他人替代的岗位。

关键在辅助性岗位须履行民主程序:制定辅助性岗位目录,经职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表协商确定,并在单位内公示。省略该程序是公认的合规风险。

需留意例外:外国企业常驻代表机构、外国金融机构驻华代表机构等使用被派遣劳动者,以及以派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的,不受三性与比例限制(第二十五条)——对外资银行、保险代表处有现实意义。

10% 上限

第四条是任何规模外资企业的核心约束:使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量的 10%,用工总量 = 订立劳动合同人数 + 被派遣劳动者人数。核算单位是在中国可与劳动者订立劳动合同的用人单位,故集团须按法人单位分别核算,而非集团整体打包。

规则亦针对规避:用人单位以承揽、外包名义按派遣形式使用劳动者的,按本规定处理(第二十七条);名为外包、实为派遣的,相关劳动者人数纳入本企业职工比例计算。

派遣单位的义务

派遣单位须持《劳务派遣经营许可证》方可经营。基本条件含注册资本不少于 200 万元(实缴,依 2014 年注册资本登记制度改革)、固定场所设施与合规管理制度。许可证须年度报告,屡次违法可被撤销。

派遣单位须:

  • 与被派遣劳动者订立 2 年以上固定期限书面劳动合同(第五条);
  • 如实告知规章制度、派遣协议内容等(第八条);
  • 依规定与协议支付劳动报酬、缴纳社会保险(第八条);
  • 劳动者在用工单位受伤的,申请工伤认定——派遣单位承担工伤保险责任,可与用工单位约定补偿(第十条);
  • 被退回后无工作期间,按不低于当地最低工资按月支付报酬(第十二条)。

用工单位的义务

用工单位日常指挥劳动者但不与其建立劳动关系,其义务包括:

  • 仅在三性岗位、10% 上限内使用派遣;
  • 实行与同类岗位劳动者相同的劳动报酬分配办法,并提供与岗位相关的福利待遇、不得歧视(第九条、《劳动合同法》第六十二条);
  • 提供劳动保护与劳动安全卫生条件;
  • 必要时负责职业病诊断、鉴定事宜(第十条);
  • 遵守退回规则:仅在法定有限情形(如破产、吊销、撤销、解散、协议期满)方可退回;医疗期、孕期、产期、哺乳期等受保护劳动者在相关情形消失前不得退回(第十二、十三条)。

跨地区派遣与社保

跨地区派遣的,派遣单位应在用工单位所在地为劳动者参加社会保险、按当地规定缴费(第十八条)。在用工单位所在地设分支机构的,由分支机构办理;未设的,由用工单位代为办理(第十九条)。这一”在用工地参保”规则落实了跨地区派遣劳动者的同工同保。

处罚与陷阱

违法依《劳动合同法》处罚条款处理:违法经营派遣、超比例、滥用辅助性岗位或违法退回,可被责令改正、警告、向劳动者承担赔偿责任;未经许可经营派遣业务的,没收违法所得并处一倍以上五倍以下罚款,无违法所得的处 5 万元以下罚款。外资企业还须警惕”假外包”陷阱:把派遣关系改签服务合同并不能逃脱规则。

外国母公司的文书认证

当外资企业或其派遣安排需提交涉及外国母公司的文件——如母公司注册证书、办理许可或设立事项的授权委托书——该外文文件若所属国为海牙公约缔约方,须办理附加证明书;否则须中国使领馆认证。中国于 2023 年 3 月 8 日加入、2023 年 11 月 7 日生效,多数条约成员母公司现采用一步式 Apostille 替代双领事认证。

对外资与外资企业的意义

  • 按法人单位而非集团口径,对照 10% 上限审计派遣规模;
  • 将岗位映射到三性,并完成辅助性岗位的民主程序并存证(纪要、协商、公示);
  • 审查派遣单位许可证与合同条款(2 年起、无工作报酬、社保);
  • 核实同工同酬机制与福利平权的落地;
  • 避免假外包——真实服务应设计为背靠背合同,而非变相派遣;
  • 对外国母公司文件适用 Apostille 认证;
  • 重构用工前,与执业中国劳动法律师确认具体事项。

下一步建议

  1. 按法人单位计算派遣比例,识别是否超限;
  2. 复核岗位清单,使用辅助性岗位的完成并留存民主程序证据;
  3. 审查派遣单位许可证与协议中的 2 年合同、无工作报酬条款;
  4. 核查跨地区社保在用工地的参保;
  5. 将实质为派遣的”外包”在受审查前重新定性;
  6. 就退回规则与受保护劳动者例外,向 HR 与法务做说明。

Sources

  • 中国政府网(国务院公报)— 人力资源和社会保障部令第 22 号《劳务派遣暂行规定》:https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • 人力资源社会保障部 — 劳动关系司负责人就《劳务派遣暂行规定》答记者问:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/ldgxs/LDGXhetong/ldht/201401/t20140127_123361.html
  • 宝鸡市人社局 — 劳务派遣合规用工指引(PDF):https://rsj.baoji.gov.cn/col9976/col1294/202405/P020241228629579687817.pdf
  • 外交部 — 《取消外国公文书认证要求的公约》在华生效通知:https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/wjbxw_new/202310/t20231023_11165858.shtml

相关阅读

  • 外资企业雇佣管理实务 / Employment management for FIEs
  • 工作签证与居留许可 / Work visas and residence permits
  • 社保与跨境派遣合规 / Social insurance and cross-border dispatch compliance