Tag Archives: FDI

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China

  • Article 27 of the Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch treats workers used in the form of dispatch under the name of contracting or outsourcing as dispatched workers, and applies the dispatch rules to them.
    《劳务派遣暂行规定》第27条规定,用人单位以承揽、外包等名义、按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照该规定处理。
  • Once an outsourcing arrangement is pierced, the client is pulled back under the very “three-nature” post restriction and 10% headcount cap it was trying to avoid.
    外包一旦被穿透,发包方将重新落入其试图规避的三性岗位限制与10%用工比例上限。
  • Chinese courts apply substantive review and ask one question first: does the client exercise dominant labour management over the workers?
    中国法院坚持实质审查原则,首要审查发包方是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。
  • At its 16 July 2026 briefing on disguised-employment disputes, the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing reported that confirming an employment relationship, or holding the enterprise liable as employer, is the common outcome.
    北京市房山区人民法院2026年7月16日涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议通报指出,最终确认劳动关系或判令企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。
  • Representative offices of foreign enterprises are exempt from the three-nature and 10% limits under Article 25; WFOEs and joint ventures are not.
    依第25条,外国企业常驻代表机构使用被派遣劳动者不受三性岗位与10%比例限制;外商独资企业与合资企业并无此项豁免。
  • Piercing carries joint and several liability, plus fines of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker where a breach is not remedied within the ordered period.
    穿透后产生连带赔偿责任,逾期不改正的还将按每人5000元以上1万元以下的标准处以罚款。
  • The cure lies in substance, not the title: price by deliverable, manage the task rather than the person, and let the contractor supply tools, discipline and payroll.
    整改的关键在实质而非名称:按成果计价、”对事不对人”地行使管理权、由承包方配置生产资料并独立承担用工义务。

Outsourcing or dispatch? The “fake outsourcing, real dispatch” trap for foreign-invested employers in China | 外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

Overview: the cap that pushes employers into outsourcing

A foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) needing flexible headcount meets two hard limits at once. Article 3 of the *Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 22, effective 1 March 2014) confines dispatched workers to temporary, auxiliary or substitute posts; Article 4 caps them at 10% of total headcount, counting direct-contract employees plus dispatched workers.

The response is predictable: rather than shrink the dispatched population, rename it. The dispatch agreement becomes a “service outsourcing” agreement, the workers stay at the same desks under the same supervisors, and the 10% calculation appears to reset to zero. That is what Article 27 exists to defeat.

Article 27: the anti-circumvention clause

Article 27 is one sentence: where an employing entity uses workers in the form of labour dispatch under the name of contracting, outsourcing or the like, the matter shall be handled in accordance with these Provisions.

The consequence is total. A relabelled arrangement does not merely lose its outsourcing character; it falls under the entire dispatch regime — three-nature posts, the 10% cap, the licence requirement, equal pay for equal work, the thirteen mandatory terms of Article 7, the three return grounds of Article 12, and joint liability under Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law*. An employer that changed the label to escape one rule inherits all of them, years later, with no records built to satisfy them.

Six dimensions that separate outsourcing from dispatch

The *Shanxi Province Guidelines on Labour Dispatch* (April 2026) draw the distinction across six dimensions — a useful audit grid, because it tracks what an inspector or judge tests.

DimensionLabour dispatchGenuine service outsourcing
Supplier qualificationDispatch Operation Licence requiredNo special licence
Post restrictionTemporary, auxiliary or substitute onlyNone
PartiesThree: agency, client, workerTwo: principal and contractor
Management authorityClient manages the workers directlyPrincipal does not manage them
PricingBy headcount and working timeBy completion of the work
Governing lawLabour contract legislationThe Civil Code

Where the contractor’s workers take instructions from the principal, work to the principal’s arrangements, or provide labour in the principal’s name, the Guidelines warn the arrangement may be treated as dispatch, with liability allocated accordingly.

Substantive review: the 2026 cases

On 16 July 2026 the Fangshan District People’s Court of Beijing briefed the press on model disguised-employment disputes. Spokesperson Ma Yanjia described the pattern: enterprises sign agreements under different names and build multi-layered engagement chains, packaging what is properly an employment relationship as contracting, outsourcing or cooperation. The court applies a substantive review principle, asking whether the enterprise exercises dominant labour management over the worker. Confirming an employment relationship, or imposing employer liability, was the common outcome.

“We manage them, the outsourcer pays them.” A courier company’s outsourcing fee comprised commission, a management service fee, taxes and rebates — with the service fee set at zero. Its station manager ran attendance in a WeChat group, pay flowed from the courier company’s own funds, and the app showed riders as its staff. The consideration was implausibly low and the structure suggested avoidance of employment status and transfer of commercial risk: the employment relationship lay with the courier company.

A contracting agreement over real employment. Another agreement cast riders as individual business operators paid by a platform — yet the company set shifts, controlled order volume and could assign orders individually. However an agreement is dressed, where the substance matches employment, a de facto relationship is recognised.

Outsourcing in name, dispatch in fact. Company A employed a worker and placed him in sales at Company B under a “labour outsourcing cooperation agreement” by which A would second personnel to B. He worked on B’s premises under B’s direction, with pay and benefits confirmed, settled and paid by B — a textbook “fake outsourcing, real dispatch”. After B returned him, A terminated him for serious misconduct; because B could not evidence that the return followed the agreed procedure, A paid damages for unlawful termination. After a return, the agency must independently verify a statutory ground for termination.

Why FIEs sit closer to the line

Article 25 grants an exemption most FIEs do not have. Representative offices of foreign enterprises and of foreign financial institutions — and employers of international seafarers — are not subject to the three-nature restriction or the dispatch ratio. That is structural, not a privilege: an RO cannot employ Chinese staff directly and can only staff itself through dispatch. WFOEs and joint ventures get nothing of the kind. Fully bound by Articles 3 and 4, they are the ones reaching for outsourcing — and the ones exposed to piercing.

Multi-city footprints add a second trap: under Articles 18 and 19, cross-region dispatch requires social insurance enrolment in the client’s locality, and where the agency has no branch there, the client enrols and pays on its behalf.

What piercing costs

Article 92 of the *Labour Contract Law* requires rectification, with a fine of RMB 5,000 to 10,000 per worker if it is not made in time, and Article 92(2) imposes joint and several liability on agency and client for loss caused to a dispatched worker; Shanxi treats them as co-parties in dispatch disputes. Article 22 of the Interim Provisions separately allows rectification orders and warnings where auxiliary posts were set without the democratic procedure — staff or employee-congress discussion, equal consultation with the union, and internal publication. Because Article 57 makes dispatch a licensed business, an “outsourcer” usually holds no licence, so piercing converts the arrangement into unlicensed dispatch. Port operators bound by both red lines are already converting non-compliant dispatch into structured outsourcing.

Rebuilding the arrangement so it survives review

  1. From people to work product. Contract for a defined deliverable, not the labour of named individuals; drop “project personnel” for “service team”.
  2. Manage the task, not the person. Remove the principal’s attendance, appraisal and disciplinary power over individuals; keep work rules in the contractor’s system; equipment should be the contractor’s.
  3. Pay for outcomes. Delete per-head pricing and line items for management fees, social insurance, salary and income tax; tie milestones to delivery and acceptance, not to “payable monthly”.
  4. Harden the liability allocation. The contractor alone bears employment contracting, wages, social insurance and work-injury liability; the principal accepts only the work product, against written confirmation that those obligations have been met.

What to do next

  1. Map the population. Count direct employees, dispatched workers and every outsourced head on your premises. If that group were pierced tomorrow, would you be within 10%, and would the posts be temporary, auxiliary or substitute?
  2. Test each supplier against the six dimensions. Pricing basis and management authority decide most cases.
  3. Do supplier due diligence. Verify the Dispatch Operation Licence and its validity — licensing authorities must publish the licensed-agency list and any change, revocation or cancellation — and the RMB 2 million minimum registered capital under Article 7 of the *Administrative Licensing Measures for Labour Dispatch* (MOHRSS Order No. 19, effective 1 July 2013). Never accept a human resources service licence as a substitute.
  4. Audit the evidence trail, not just the contract. Where the paper says outsourcing and the group chat says supervision, the group chat wins.
  5. Fix the democratic procedure for auxiliary posts, and never assume a group RO’s Article 25 exemption travels to the WFOE.
  6. Plan the return route in advance. Returns are limited to the three Article 12 grounds, and workers protected by Article 42 of the *Labour Contract Law* cannot be returned on objective-change or redundancy grounds before the dispatch term expires.

外包还是派遣?外资企业在华用工的”假外包、真派遣”穿透风险

概览:把雇主推向外包的比例上限

需要弹性用工的外商投资企业会同时撞上两道硬约束。《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源和社会保障部令第22号,2014年3月1日施行)第3条规定,用工单位只能在临时性、辅助性或者替代性岗位上使用被派遣劳动者;第4条规定被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量的10%,用工总量为订立劳动合同人数与使用的被派遣劳动者人数之和。

企业的反应可以预见:不是压减派遣人数,而是改换名称。派遣协议改签为”服务外包”协议,劳动者仍在原岗位、由原主管指挥,10%的计算似乎归零。第27条正是为了打掉这一操作而设。

第27条:反规避条款

第27条只有一句话:用人单位以承揽、外包等名义,按劳务派遣用工形式使用劳动者的,按照本规定处理。

后果是整体性的。被重新贴标签的安排不只是失去外包属性,而是整体落入派遣规则体系——三性岗位、10%比例、供应商许可、同工同酬、第7条协议13项必备条款、第12条仅有的三种退回情形,以及《劳动合同法》第92条的连带责任。为规避一条规则而改名的雇主,往往在数年后一次性承受全部规则,且手中没有任何为满足这些规则而准备的材料。

区分外包与派遣的六个维度

2026年4月印发的《山西省劳务派遣用工指引》从六个维度系统区分二者,可直接用作自查表,因为它对应的正是监察人员或法官实际审查的内容。

维度劳务派遣真实的服务外包
主体资质须取得《劳务派遣经营许可证》无特殊资质要求
岗位限制仅限临时性、辅助性、替代性岗位无岗位限定
法律关系三方:派遣单位、用工单位、劳动者两方:发包方与承包方
管理权限用工单位直接管理劳动者发包方不管理承包方员工
费用结算按人数与工作时间结算按业务完成情况结算
法律适用劳动合同相关法律法规《民法典》

指引提示:承包单位劳动者若接受发包企业指挥管理、按发包企业安排提供劳动,或以发包企业名义提供劳动,该安排可能被认定为劳务派遣,并据此确定发包单位与外包单位的法律责任。

实质审查:2026年的案例

2026年7月16日,北京市房山区人民法院召开涉隐蔽用工类劳动争议纠纷典型案例新闻通报会。新闻发言人马艳佳指出的模式是:企业通过签订不同名目的协议,设计多层用工链条,将本应属于劳动关系的情况包装成承揽、外包、合作等其他法律关系。法院坚持实质审查原则,重点审查企业是否对劳动者实施支配性劳动管理。从审理结果看,最终确认存在劳动关系或判决企业承担用工主体责任的情形较为普遍。

“自己管人、外包发钱”。 某快递公司的外包费用由佣金、管理服务费、税费及返费构成,其中管理服务费为0。站长在微信群中监督骑手考勤,报酬资金来自快递公司,APP显示骑手为该公司员工。合同对价明显偏低,结构上存在规避劳动关系、转嫁商业风险之嫌,法院认定劳动关系存在于快递公司与劳动者之间。

以承揽合同行用工之实。 另一份协议约定骑手作为个体工商户承揽配送、由第三方平台付酬,但公司对其排班、控制接单量并可单独派单。即便披上承揽外衣,只要用工实质符合劳动关系,即认定为事实劳动关系。

名为外包实为派遣。 甲公司与劳动者签订劳动合同并安排其至乙公司任销售,甲乙之间的《劳务外包合作协议》约定由甲向乙派驻人员。该劳动者在乙公司场所、受乙公司管理指挥,工资福利由乙公司确认、结算和支付——属典型的“假外包、真派遣”。乙公司退回后,甲公司径行以严重违纪解除劳动合同;因乙公司未能提交充分证据证明退回符合约定的处罚程序,甲公司被判支付违法解除劳动关系赔偿金。退回之后,派遣单位须独立审查是否符合法定解除情形,不能被动接受用工单位的退回决定。

外资企业为何更接近红线

第25条给予的豁免,多数外资企业并不享有。 外国企业常驻代表机构、外国金融机构驻华代表机构,以及以派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的船员用人单位,不受三性岗位和劳务派遣用工比例的限制。这是制度配套而非优惠:代表处本身不能直接与中国员工建立劳动关系,只能通过派遣用工。外商独资企业与合资企业则完全没有该项豁免,须完整遵守第3条与第4条——这正是不少外资雇主转向”外包”的动因,也正是其穿透风险的来源。

多城市布点还带来第二重风险。依第18、19条,跨地区派遣应在用工单位所在地参加社会保险;派遣单位在当地未设分支机构的,由用工单位代为办理参保、缴费。

被穿透的代价

《劳动合同法》第92条规定责令改正,逾期不改的按每人5000元以上1万元以下处以罚款;第92条第2款规定,用工单位给被派遣劳动者造成损害的,派遣单位与用工单位承担连带赔偿责任,山西的指引亦明确二者在派遣争议中为共同当事人。《劳务派遣暂行规定》第22条另行规定,辅助性岗位未经民主程序(职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表平等协商、并在单位内公示)确定的,责令改正、给予警告。由于《劳动合同法》第57条将劳务派遣设为许可经营事项,被当作”外包方”引入的供应商通常并无该许可,穿透之后即转化为无证派遣。受双重红线约束的港口企业已开始将违规派遣转为规范化服务外包。

如何重构安排以经得起审查

  1. 从”对人”到”对事”。 约定特定的交付成果而非特定劳动者的劳务;避免”项目人员”等称谓,改用”服务团队””项目小组”。
  2. 管理权”对事不对人”。 删除发包方对劳动者个人的考勤、考核与处分条款;劳动纪律与考核标准独立于发包方制度体系;工作服装、电脑设备等生产资料原则上由承包方配置。
  3. 按成果付费。 删除按人头计价,以及管理费、社保公积金、薪资个税等人身性支出明细;付款节点与交付、验收挂钩,删除”按月支付”等按时间计费规则。
  4. 强化责任边界。 由承包方独立承担劳动合同签订、工资支付、社保缴纳与工伤赔偿等全部法定义务;发包方仅对成果验收,并可要求承包方提供已履行上述义务的书面确认作为验收前提。

下一步建议

  1. 先做人数盘点。 统计直接雇员、被派遣劳动者以及在本单位场所工作的全部外包人员。若外包人员明日被穿透,是否仍在10%以内?相关岗位是否属于三性?
  2. 用六个维度逐一检验供应商。 费用结算方式与管理权限是决定多数案件的两项。
  3. 做好供应商尽调。 核验《劳务派遣经营许可证》的真实性与有效期(许可机关应公示获证单位名单及变更、撤销、注销情况),并核对《劳务派遣行政许可实施办法》(人社部令第19号,2013年7月1日施行)第7条要求的注册资本不少于人民币200万元。切勿以”人力资源服务许可”替代劳务派遣经营许可。
  4. 审查证据链,而不只是合同。 当书面文件写着外包、微信群里却在下达管理指令时,微信群会胜出。
  5. 补齐辅助性岗位的民主程序,且不要假定集团代表处的第25条豁免可延伸至外商独资企业。
  6. 提前规划退回路径。 退回仅限第12条的三种情形,且属于《劳动合同法》第42条保护情形的劳动者,在派遣期限届满前不得以客观情况重大变化或经济性裁员为由退回。

Sources

Labour Dispatch Compliance for Foreign-Invested Enterprises in China: the “three-nature” rule and the 10% cap

  • Dispatch is only a supplementary form of employment in China and may be used solely on “three-nature” posts: temporary (under 6 months), ancillary (non-core), or substitute (covering an absent employee).
    劳务派遣在中国只是补充用工形式,仅限于”三性”岗位使用:临时性(不超过 6 个月)、辅助性(非主营业务)或替代性(顶替休假员工)。
  • The 10% cap is hard: a user employer’s dispatched-headcount must not exceed 10% of its total workforce (employees on labour contracts plus dispatched workers).
    10% 上限是硬指标:用工单位使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过其用工总量(订立劳动合同人数与派遣人数之和)的 10%。
  • Ancillary posts require a democratic procedure — discussion by the employee congress or all staff, consultation with the union, and internal public notice — before dispatch may be used there.
    辅助性岗位须履行民主程序——经职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表协商确定,并在单位内公示——方可使用派遣。
  • The dispatch agency must hold a Dispatch Licence, sign a fixed-term written contract of at least two years, and pay no less than local minimum wage during any no-work interval.
    派遣单位须持《劳务派遣经营许可证》,订立 2 年以上固定期限书面劳动合同,并在无工作期间按不低于当地最低工资按月支付报酬。
  • Same pay for same work applies: user employers must provide dispatched workers with job-related welfare benefits and may not discriminate; cross-region dispatch is socially insured at the place of work.
    同工同酬适用:用工单位须向被派遣劳动者提供与岗位相关的福利待遇、不得歧视;跨地区派遣在用工单位所在地参保。
  • “Fake outsourcing, real dispatch” is caught: using contracting or outsourcing in the form of dispatch is treated as dispatch under the rules.
    “假外包、真派遣”被规制:以承揽、外包名义按派遣形式使用劳动者的,按本规定处理。
  • Registration certificates and POAs from the foreign parent still need an Apostille (Hague) or consular authentication when filed for licence or entity setup — China’s Apostille accession (effective 7 Nov 2023) streamlines this.
    外国母公司的注册证书与授权书在办理许可或设立时仍须附加证明书(海牙)或领事认证——中国加入海牙公约(2023 年 11 月 7 日生效)已大幅简化此环节。

Labour Dispatch Compliance for Foreign-Invested Enterprises in China: the “three-nature” rule and the 10% cap | 外资企业劳务派遣合规:三性规则与 10% 上限

Overview

Many foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) in China use labour dispatch to flex headcount for seasonal peaks, administrative support, or niche technical roles. Dispatch can work well, but it sits inside a strict regulatory box. The Interim Provisions on Labour Dispatch (Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security Order No. 22, effective 1 March 2014) — issued to implement the 2012 amended Labour Contract Law — defines where dispatch may be used, caps the proportion, and splits responsibilities among the dispatch agency, the user employer and the worker. For an FIE, getting this wrong risks administrative penalties, back-pay exposure and “deemed employment” disputes. This article explains the rules that matter, with official sources. It is general information, not legal advice.

Where dispatch is allowed: the “three-nature” posts

Article 3 of the Interim Provisions restricts dispatch to posts that are temporary, ancillary or substitute:

  • Temporary (临时性): a post that lasts no more than six months.
  • Ancillary (辅助性): a non-core post serving the main business.
  • Substitute (替代性): a post where the regular employee is temporarily absent (study leave, vacation, etc.) and can be covered by another worker.

Crucially, for ancillary posts the user employer must follow a democratic procedure: the ancillary post list is discussed by the employee congress or all staff, proposed and consulted with the union or worker representatives, and then publicly announced within the unit. Skipping this procedure is a recognised compliance risk.

A notable carve-out: representative offices of foreign enterprises and representative offices of foreign financial institutions, as well as the use of international ocean crews in dispatch form, are not bound by the three-nature and proportion limits (Article 25) — relevant for foreign bank and insurance representative offices.

The 10% cap

Article 4 is the headline constraint for any sizeable FIE: the number of dispatched workers must not exceed 10% of the user employer’s total workforce, where “total workforce” = employees on labour contracts + dispatched workers. The calculation unit is the employer that can conclude labour contracts under the Labour Contract Law — so a corporate group must calculate per legal entity, not group-wide.

The rules also target evasion: where a company contracts work out but the contractor’s workers use the company’s facilities, follow the company’s arrangements, or work in the company’s name (i.e. “fake outsourcing, real dispatch”), those workers are counted into the company’s proportion (Article 27; see also the compliance guidance issued by local HRSS bureaus).

The dispatch agency’s obligations

A dispatch agency may operate only with a Dispatch Licence (劳务派遣经营许可证). Minimum conditions include registered capital of at least RMB 2 million (paid-in, per the 2014 reform), fixed premises and facilities, and a compliant dispatch management system. The licence is subject to annual reporting and may be revoked for repeated violations.

The agency must:

  • conclude a fixed-term written labour contract of at least two years with each dispatched worker (Article 5);
  • truthfully inform the worker of the rules, the dispatch agreement and relevant matters (Article 8);
  • pay labour remuneration and social insurance in accordance with law and the dispatch agreement (Article 8);
  • apply for work-injury identification where the worker is injured on the job at the user employer — the agency bears work-injury liability, with reimbursement arranged with the user employer (Article 10);
  • pay no less than the local minimum wage monthly during any no-work interval after return (Article 12).

The user employer’s obligations

The user employer engages the worker day to day but does not employ them. Its duties include:

  • using dispatch only on three-nature posts within the 10% cap;
  • providing the same remuneration distribution as comparable in-house staff, plus job-related welfare benefits, with no discrimination (Articles 9, 62 Labour Contract Law);
  • providing labour protection and occupational safety/hygiene conditions;
  • handling occupational-disease diagnosis and appraisal where needed (Article 10);
  • following the return rules: a worker may be returned only on the limited statutory grounds (e.g. the user employer’s bankruptcy, closure, revocation, dissolution, or expiry of the dispatch agreement), and protected workers (medical leave, pregnancy, maternity, nursing) may not be returned before the relevant period lapses (Article 12–13).

Cross-region dispatch and social insurance

Where a dispatch agency sends workers across regions, it must enrol them in social insurance at the place of work, under local rates (Article 18). If the agency has a branch at the place of work, the branch handles enrolment; if not, the user employer handles it on the agency’s behalf (Article 19). This “same insure at place of work” rule implements equal treatment for cross-region dispatched workers.

Penalties and pitfalls

Violations are handled under the Labour Contract Law’s penalty articles: unlawful dispatch operation, exceeding the proportion, abusing ancillary posts, or unlawful return can trigger correction orders, warnings, compensation liability to the worker, and — for unlicensed dispatch operation — fines of one to five times the illegal income (or up to RMB 50,000 where there is none). FIEs should also watch the “fake outsourcing” trap: relabelling a dispatch relationship as a service contract does not escape the rules.

Document authentication for the foreign parent

When an FIE or its dispatch arrangements require filings referencing the foreign parent — e.g. the parent’s incorporation certificate or a power of attorney for licence or entity matters — the foreign document must carry an Apostille if the home state is a Hague Convention party, or Chinese embassy/consulate authentication otherwise. China acceded to the Convention on 8 March 2023 and it took effect on 7 November 2023, so most treaty-member parents now use the one-step Apostille instead of double consular authentication.

What this means for foreign investors and FIEs

  • Audit your dispatch footprint against the 10% cap per legal entity, not group-wide.
  • Map posts to three-nature and complete the ancillary-post democratic procedure with evidence (minutes, consultation, notice).
  • Vet your dispatch agency’s licence and contract terms (2-year minimum, no-work pay, social insurance).
  • Confirm same-pay-for-same-work mechanics and benefits parity in practice.
  • Avoid fake outsourcing — structure genuine services as arm’s-length contracts, not disguised dispatch.
  • Authenticate foreign-parent documents via Apostille where applicable.
  • Confirm specifics with qualified PRC labour counsel before restructuring workforce arrangements.

What to do next

  1. Calculate your dispatched-headcount ratio per entity and identify any exceedance.
  2. Review the post list; complete and document the ancillary-post procedure where used.
  3. Audit dispatch-agency licences and agreements for the 2-year contract and no-work-pay terms.
  4. Check cross-region social-insurance enrolment at the place of work.
  5. Re-label any “outsourcing” that is in substance dispatch before it draws scrutiny.
  6. Brief HR and legal on the return rules and protected-worker carve-outs.

Sources

  • 中国政府网(国务院公报)— 人力资源和社会保障部令第 22 号《劳务派遣暂行规定》:https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • 人力资源社会保障部 — 劳动关系司负责人就《劳务派遣暂行规定》答记者问:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/ldgxs/LDGXhetong/ldht/201401/t20140127_123361.html
  • 宝鸡市人社局 — 劳务派遣合规用工指引(PDF):https://rsj.baoji.gov.cn/col9976/col1294/202405/P020241228629579687817.pdf
  • 外交部 — 《取消外国公文书认证要求的公约》在华生效通知:https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/wjbxw_new/202310/t20231023_11165858.shtml

Related reading

  • 外资企业雇佣管理实务 / Employment management for FIEs
  • 工作签证与居留许可 / Work visas and residence permits
  • 社保与跨境派遣合规 / Social insurance and cross-border dispatch compliance

外资企业劳务派遣合规:三性规则与 10% 上限

概述

许多在华外资企业用劳务派遣来柔化淡旺季、行政支持或稀缺技术岗位的用人需求。派遣本身可用,但被置于一套严格的监管框架内。《劳务派遣暂行规定》(人力资源社会保障部令第 22 号,2014 年 3 月 1 日施行)为落实 2012 年修正的《劳动合同法》而制定,明确了派遣的适用岗位、比例上限,并划分了派遣单位、用工单位与劳动者三方责任。对外资企业而言,踩线将招致行政处罚、补薪敞口与”事实劳动关系”争议。本文结合官方来源说明关键规则,仅为一般性信息,非法律意见。

派遣的适用岗位:三性

《暂行规定》第三条将派遣限制在临时性、辅助性或替代性岗位:

  • 临时性: 存续时间不超过 6 个月的岗位;
  • 辅助性: 为主营业务岗位提供服务的非主营业务岗位;
  • 替代性: 用工单位劳动者因脱产学习、休假等无法工作期间,可由他人替代的岗位。

关键在辅助性岗位须履行民主程序:制定辅助性岗位目录,经职工代表大会或全体职工讨论、与工会或职工代表协商确定,并在单位内公示。省略该程序是公认的合规风险。

需留意例外:外国企业常驻代表机构、外国金融机构驻华代表机构等使用被派遣劳动者,以及以派遣形式使用国际远洋海员的,不受三性与比例限制(第二十五条)——对外资银行、保险代表处有现实意义。

10% 上限

第四条是任何规模外资企业的核心约束:使用的被派遣劳动者数量不得超过用工总量的 10%,用工总量 = 订立劳动合同人数 + 被派遣劳动者人数。核算单位是在中国可与劳动者订立劳动合同的用人单位,故集团须按法人单位分别核算,而非集团整体打包。

规则亦针对规避:用人单位以承揽、外包名义按派遣形式使用劳动者的,按本规定处理(第二十七条);名为外包、实为派遣的,相关劳动者人数纳入本企业职工比例计算。

派遣单位的义务

派遣单位须持《劳务派遣经营许可证》方可经营。基本条件含注册资本不少于 200 万元(实缴,依 2014 年注册资本登记制度改革)、固定场所设施与合规管理制度。许可证须年度报告,屡次违法可被撤销。

派遣单位须:

  • 与被派遣劳动者订立 2 年以上固定期限书面劳动合同(第五条);
  • 如实告知规章制度、派遣协议内容等(第八条);
  • 依规定与协议支付劳动报酬、缴纳社会保险(第八条);
  • 劳动者在用工单位受伤的,申请工伤认定——派遣单位承担工伤保险责任,可与用工单位约定补偿(第十条);
  • 被退回后无工作期间,按不低于当地最低工资按月支付报酬(第十二条)。

用工单位的义务

用工单位日常指挥劳动者但不与其建立劳动关系,其义务包括:

  • 仅在三性岗位、10% 上限内使用派遣;
  • 实行与同类岗位劳动者相同的劳动报酬分配办法,并提供与岗位相关的福利待遇、不得歧视(第九条、《劳动合同法》第六十二条);
  • 提供劳动保护与劳动安全卫生条件;
  • 必要时负责职业病诊断、鉴定事宜(第十条);
  • 遵守退回规则:仅在法定有限情形(如破产、吊销、撤销、解散、协议期满)方可退回;医疗期、孕期、产期、哺乳期等受保护劳动者在相关情形消失前不得退回(第十二、十三条)。

跨地区派遣与社保

跨地区派遣的,派遣单位应在用工单位所在地为劳动者参加社会保险、按当地规定缴费(第十八条)。在用工单位所在地设分支机构的,由分支机构办理;未设的,由用工单位代为办理(第十九条)。这一”在用工地参保”规则落实了跨地区派遣劳动者的同工同保。

处罚与陷阱

违法依《劳动合同法》处罚条款处理:违法经营派遣、超比例、滥用辅助性岗位或违法退回,可被责令改正、警告、向劳动者承担赔偿责任;未经许可经营派遣业务的,没收违法所得并处一倍以上五倍以下罚款,无违法所得的处 5 万元以下罚款。外资企业还须警惕”假外包”陷阱:把派遣关系改签服务合同并不能逃脱规则。

外国母公司的文书认证

当外资企业或其派遣安排需提交涉及外国母公司的文件——如母公司注册证书、办理许可或设立事项的授权委托书——该外文文件若所属国为海牙公约缔约方,须办理附加证明书;否则须中国使领馆认证。中国于 2023 年 3 月 8 日加入、2023 年 11 月 7 日生效,多数条约成员母公司现采用一步式 Apostille 替代双领事认证。

对外资与外资企业的意义

  • 按法人单位而非集团口径,对照 10% 上限审计派遣规模;
  • 将岗位映射到三性,并完成辅助性岗位的民主程序并存证(纪要、协商、公示);
  • 审查派遣单位许可证与合同条款(2 年起、无工作报酬、社保);
  • 核实同工同酬机制与福利平权的落地;
  • 避免假外包——真实服务应设计为背靠背合同,而非变相派遣;
  • 对外国母公司文件适用 Apostille 认证;
  • 重构用工前,与执业中国劳动法律师确认具体事项。

下一步建议

  1. 按法人单位计算派遣比例,识别是否超限;
  2. 复核岗位清单,使用辅助性岗位的完成并留存民主程序证据;
  3. 审查派遣单位许可证与协议中的 2 年合同、无工作报酬条款;
  4. 核查跨地区社保在用工地的参保;
  5. 将实质为派遣的”外包”在受审查前重新定性;
  6. 就退回规则与受保护劳动者例外,向 HR 与法务做说明。

Sources

  • 中国政府网(国务院公报)— 人力资源和社会保障部令第 22 号《劳务派遣暂行规定》:https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2014/content_2667613.htm
  • 人力资源社会保障部 — 劳动关系司负责人就《劳务派遣暂行规定》答记者问:https://www.mohrss.gov.cn/ldgxs/LDGXhetong/ldht/201401/t20140127_123361.html
  • 宝鸡市人社局 — 劳务派遣合规用工指引(PDF):https://rsj.baoji.gov.cn/col9976/col1294/202405/P020241228629579687817.pdf
  • 外交部 — 《取消外国公文书认证要求的公约》在华生效通知:https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/wjbxw_new/202310/t20231023_11165858.shtml

相关阅读

  • 外资企业雇佣管理实务 / Employment management for FIEs
  • 工作签证与居留许可 / Work visas and residence permits
  • 社保与跨境派遣合规 / Social insurance and cross-border dispatch compliance