Zhejiang and Anhui Free Trade Zones Publish 2026 Data Export Negative Lists Two Days Apart

  • Zhejiang issued its 2026 Negative List on 9 November 2026 and Anhui followed on 11 November, each replacing an earlier version while preserving filing results already notified.
    浙江于 2026 年 11 月 9 日印发 2026 版负面清单,安徽于 11 月 11 日跟进,两省均废止旧版,已取得备案结果通知书的备案结果继续有效。
  • The list decides which outbound data still needs a security assessment, a standard contract or certification; data outside the list may leave the zone without any of the three.
    清单决定哪些出境数据仍需走安全评估、标准合同或认证;清单之外的数据出境,可以免予申报这三条路径。
  • Zhejiang kept the e-commerce business-to-business and clearing fields and added eleven Commodity Trading entries covering seven scenarios and thirty-eight data items.
    浙江保留电子商务(企业对企业)与清结算两个领域,新增十一条大宗商品条目,覆盖七个场景、三十八个数据项。
  • Zhejiang compressed the sequence into Filing In Two Steps — submit a filing application, then transfer lawfully — and replaced the earlier three-stage route.
    浙江把流程压缩为「提交备案申请—合规开展数据出境」两步办理,取代原先的三段式路径。
  • A clause that is easy to miss permits Cross-Regional Reference to another zone’s list only through a five-stage provincial approval ladder ending in national filing.
    一条容易被忽略的条款规定,参照适用其他自贸区清单须经五级省级审批链条,最终报国家层面备案。
  • A filing result is not a permit to export: notification, separate consent and impact assessment survive the list, and export control or technology export rules apply on top.
    备案结果不是出境许可:告知、单独同意与个人信息保护影响评估并不因清单而免除,出口管制与技术出口管理规定另行叠加。
  • Anhui’s measures, published two days later, keep the same two-list architecture, the same two-step filing route and a ten-working-day first review at the municipal tier.
    安徽两天后出台的办法沿用同样的双层清单结构、同样的两步备案路径,并由市级管理部门在十个工作日内完成初审。

Zhejiang and Anhui Free Trade Zones Publish 2026 Data Export Negative Lists Two Days Apart | 浙江、安徽自贸试验区相隔两日发布 2026 版数据出境负面清单

Two provinces, two days, one architecture

On 9 November 2026 the Cyberspace Administration of Zhejiang Province, the Zhejiang Provincial Department of Commerce and the Zhejiang Provincial Data Bureau jointly issued two documents: trial measures for managing the negative list for outbound data transfers in the China (Zhejiang) Pilot Free Trade Zone, and the negative list itself in its 2026 edition. The pair was published on the Zhejiang cyberspace portal on 10 November at four minutes past four in the afternoon, and it carries the provincial cyberspace office’s 2026 document number three.

Two days later, on 11 November, the Cyberspace Administration of Anhui Province, the Anhui Provincial Department of Commerce and the Anhui Provincial Data Resources Administration issued the mirror-image pair for the China (Anhui) Pilot Free Trade Zone. That notice appeared on the Anhui cyberspace portal at ten minutes to four in the afternoon on the same day it was signed, with both attachments — the trial measures and the list — posted as separate files.

The two provinces are not coordinating for the first time, and the timing is less remarkable than the architecture. Both instruments are built as a pair: a management measure that governs who may use the list, how a filing is made, how the list is revised and how compliance is supervised, plus a list that names the data. Both rest on Article 6 of the Provisions on Promoting and Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows, the March 2024 regulation that authorised pilot free trade zones to draw up their own lists of data requiring a security assessment, a standard contract or certification, subject to approval by the provincial cyberspace committee and filing with the national cyberspace and data authorities. Both cite the same political mandate: the fourth plenary session of the twentieth Central Committee and its call to promote efficient, convenient and secure cross-border data flows.

Where they differ is in economic content and in administrative detail, and those differences are what a company actually has to work with.

Two provinces publishing within a week is a reminder of how this layer of the regime is built. The national provisions set the frame and the thresholds; the zones set the sector lists. There is no national negative list for outbound data, and there is not going to be one, because the instrument was designed to be local. That has a consequence for how a group should staff the question: the person who can answer it sits close to the zone, not at the centre. A head office that maintains one China data export position is maintaining a position that is, in a strict sense, not true of any particular entity.

The Zhejiang notice contains a transitional provision that is easy to read past. The 2024 negative list and the original management measures are repealed from the date of the notice, but filing results for which a notification has already been issued remain valid. The repeal is therefore not retroactive in effect. A company holding a 2024 filing result does not have to re-file on 10 November; it holds a valid result until something changes in its own data flows. Anhui’s notice does not carry an equivalent sentence, which is consistent with the fact that this is its first list rather than a replacement.

What the list decides, and what it does not

The most common misreading of a free trade zone negative list is that it is a permission to export. It is not. It is a routing instrument, and the routing has only two outcomes.

Under Article 6 of the national provisions, a processor inside a pilot free trade zone that transfers data outside the list may be exempted from filing a security assessment, from concluding a standard contract and from obtaining certification. That is the exemption. A processor transferring data that is on the list falls back into the ordinary regime: the assessment route for the categories the list assigns to assessment, and the standard contract or certification route for the categories it assigns to those. The list is therefore drawn as two sub-lists, and both provinces say so explicitly. Zhejiang’s list is organised as a list requiring assessment and a list requiring a standard contract or certification. Anhui’s measures state that the list shall contain at least those two parts, and describe what each part covers.

The second common misreading is that the list settles the question of important data. It partly does, and only inside the zone. Article 2 of the national provisions already provides that a processor need not declare data as important data if no department or region has notified it or published it as such. The zone list adds a local determination: within the named industries and the named scenarios, data of the kind described is treated as requiring the stated route. Outside those industries and scenarios, the national rules apply unchanged. Zhejiang’s list says this in a note — that each entry is limited to specified scenarios, and that data outside them follows the ordinary rules.

The mechanics of the split deserve a paragraph of their own, because the two sub-lists are not two degrees of the same test. The assessment sub-list describes data whose transfer requires the national security assessment: important data in the named fields, and personal information above the volume band that the list sets for that field. The standard contract and certification sub-list describes personal information in the band below. Read together, the two sub-lists form a staircase. At the top sits assessment; in the middle, contract or certification; at the bottom, a band in which data may move after filing, and only within the named scenarios. The staircase is the facilitation. It does not lower the obligation that attaches at each step. It fixes where each step begins, which is precisely what a company could not previously determine for a commodity flow or for business-to-business e-commerce data. A trader arguing from analogy had to guess where the first step started; a trader reading the list can see the riser.

That has a corollary that companies tend to resist. Because the staircase is drawn by scenario and by data item, a flow that sits one field outside a described scenario does not inherit the band. It falls to the national thresholds, which are set by volume alone, take no account of the commercial context and may sit higher or lower than the band the list draws for that field. Purpose, not data type, is what moves a flow between one route and another, and purpose is documented in the contract and in the system design rather than in the data itself.

The third misreading concerns what survives. A filing result confirms which route applies. It does not discharge the obligations that attach to the transfer itself. Notification, separate consent for sensitive personal information, a personal information impact assessment and the record-keeping that goes with them are obligations under the Personal Information Protection Law and the Regulations on the Administration of Network Data Security, and nothing in either provincial instrument touches them. Nor does the list displace export control or technology export administration: both provinces provide that where a transfer involves controlled items or technology export matters, those regimes apply on their own terms. Zhejiang’s list carries the point as a note; Anhui’s measures carry it as a substantive article.

There is a fourth point, smaller but practically important. A zone list applies to processors registered in the zone. Anhui defines the processor as an enterprise, public institution, organisation, group or other entity, or an individual, registered in the Anhui pilot free trade zone and carrying out cross-border data activities. A group that operates in the province but is registered outside the zone is not covered by the zone’s list, and must use the national pathways. Registration address, not operational footprint, is the test.

Zhejiang: a commodity chapter and a shorter sequence

Zhejiang’s 2026 edition keeps the frame of the 2024 edition. The two original fields remain: e-commerce between businesses, and clearing and settlement. On top of that, the province added a commodity trading chapter of eleven entries covering seven scenarios and thirty-eight data items, and the provincial question-and-answer describes this as filling a gap — before the addition, commodity traders had no directly applicable list and had to reason by analogy from the e-commerce or clearing entries.

The scenarios named in the published text are specific rather than generic: raw material procurement, equipment maintenance and technical support, commodity sales, digital services for bulk trade, bunkering, offshore transit trade, and insurance claims. Each entry is confined to its scenario, which means a commodity trading company has to match its actual flow to a named scenario rather than to the industry as a whole. A company that moves contract and settlement data for a transaction that is none of the seven is outside the list and falls back on the national rules.

Thirty-eight data items across eleven entries is a ratio worth pausing on. Roughly three and a half items per entry means the entries are not broad categories; they are enumerated fields. That granularity is what allows the list to be used as a checklist rather than as an occasion for judgement, and it is also what makes it brittle. A field that is not enumerated is not covered, and reading an entry by its title rather than by its items is the most reliable way to reach the wrong answer. The provincial text says as much in a note: each entry is limited to the scenarios listed, and the scenarios are described by the fields they contain.

The commercial consequence is a change in who does the work. Under an analogical regime, the analysis sat with the company’s lawyers and produced a memorandum that argued a position. Under an enumerated list, the analysis sits with whoever owns the data dictionary, and it produces a mapping. A company that has not maintained a field-level inventory of its outbound feeds cannot use the list well, because the list asks a question — is this field in this scenario — that only the inventory can answer. The list has therefore made data governance, in a fairly literal sense, a precondition for using a compliance channel.

The commodity chapter matters for a reason that is easy to miss in a summary of entry counts. Zhejiang’s free trade zone is built around a commodity resource allocation hub, and the data that moves with a cargo of oil, iron ore or grain is not consumer data. It is price data, inventory data, counterparty data and logistics data, and much of it sits close to the definition of important data without ever being named as such. Putting it into a list with named scenarios gives a trader something it did not have: a documented answer to the question of whether a particular feed needs an assessment, rather than an argument from analogy conducted during an inspection.

The procedural change is the other half. The question-and-answer states that the filing sequence has been compressed from three stages — submit an application, submit a filing, transfer lawfully — into two: submit a filing application, then transfer lawfully. The province describes the resulting regime as a closed loop of filing in advance, monitoring during the activity and assessment afterwards, and it says the list is subject to dynamic management, with revisions carried out as implementation and risk are tracked.

Two things follow for a company already operating under the 2024 regime. First, the shorter sequence changes the internal approval path, not the evidentiary standard. A filing application still has to be supported by a description of the data, the scenario and the volume, and the provincial text is explicit that implementing guidelines and detailed rules are still to be issued. Until those appear, the practical content of the two steps is the same as before, with one gate removed. Second, the service channel named in the question-and-answer is the data cross-border service centre in the Binjiang district of the Hangzhou zone, which handles receipt of materials, feedback of results, inspection and filing coaching. For a company in another zone — Ningbo, Jinyi or Zhoushan — the centre is a template rather than a counter.

The reference clause

Buried in the ninth article of Zhejiang’s measures, and in the eighth article of Anhui’s, is a provision that no summary of the lists tends to mention, and that will decide a number of real cases.

Both provinces allow reference to a negative list formally published by another pilot free trade zone, free trade port, reform and opening-up pioneer area or national pilot for comprehensive opening-up of the services sector. Both then attach conditions that turn an apparent shortcut into an administrative process. The reference must be for a specific field in which the province genuinely needs it. It must sit inside the national framework for classified and graded data protection. The provincial departments must carry out a needs analysis and a risk assessment for each list proposed for reference, one by one. The result must pass review by the provincial data security coordination mechanism, then be approved by the provincial cyberspace and informatisation committee, and then be filed jointly by the provincial cyberspace office and the provincial data authority with the national cyberspace department and the national data department.

Five stages, two of them at committee level, and a national filing at the end. The design is not obstruction for its own sake. A zone list is an exercise of a delegated power, and a decision to adopt another province’s exercise of the same power has to be traceable to the body that holds the delegation. The ladder is the trace. It also explains why the clause is written as a permission for the province rather than as a right for the company: what is being approved is the province’s adoption of a standard, not the company’s choice of a forum.

The clause is best understood as an answer to a question that would otherwise be answered informally. A company in Zhejiang whose sector is covered by Shanghai’s list, or a company in Anhui whose sector is covered by Zhejiang’s new commodity chapter, cannot simply adopt the other province’s entries. It can ask its provincial authorities to consider reference, and the authorities have a defined route for doing so, but the route has no published timetable and no obligation to reach a positive conclusion.

For planning purposes the clause has a clear implication. A group with operations in several zones should not assume that a list obtained in one zone travels to another. It should map, zone by zone, which list covers which entity and which flow, and treat a gap as a gap until a reference decision is actually published. The alternative — building a compliance position on an assumed reference — is the kind of assumption that survives until the first inspection.

Anhui: same skeleton, different municipal tier

Anhui’s package is structurally identical and administratively more explicit in places, which makes it a useful comparison.

The measures define the provincial tier as five bodies: the cyberspace office, the data resources administration, the commerce department acting as the office of the free trade zone, the public security department and the state security department. The municipal tier is defined by geography: the management bodies of the Hefei, Wuhu and Bengbu zones, together with the relevant functional departments at the same level. That two-tier split is where the practical work sits, because the municipal tier receives the filing, organises the review and issues the initial opinion.

The published text gives the municipal tier ten working days from receipt of the filing materials to organise the review and produce an initial opinion on whether the outbound data falls within the list. That opinion goes to the provincial tier for confirmation, and the result is then fed back to the processor. The outcome has three branches, and they are worth separating because companies tend to collapse them. Where the data is on the list, the municipal tier directs the processor to file a security assessment, conclude a standard contract or obtain certification. Where the data is off the list, the municipal tier tells the processor in terms that the data may flow safely and in an orderly manner. Where the list does not apply at all — because the entity or the activity falls outside its scope — the ordinary law applies.

A first list behaves differently from a revision, and the difference is not only transitional. A revision inherits a body of decided cases: filings granted, questions answered, edge cases settled between the zone and its processors over a year of operation. A first list starts without that sediment, and the published text compensates by writing procedure at a finer grain — five provincial bodies named, three municipal zones named, ten working days fixed, three outcomes enumerated, two supervisory mechanisms described. Anhui has written a manual where Zhejiang could write a revision note. For a company, the practical reading is that Anhui’s answers are likely to be more predictable at the first encounter and less settled at the margin, because there is no accumulated practice to consult when a case does not fit the enumerated outcome.

Anhui also writes down two mechanisms that Zhejiang handles more briefly. The first is consistency sampling: during the validity of a filing, the municipal tier compares the data actually transferred against the filed materials, and where a processor has concealed or misreported, or has deliberately caused the actual flow to diverge from the filing, the consequences run from suspension and a deadline for rectification, through a fresh filing after rectification, to termination of the outbound activity and enhanced supervision. The second is a credit-and-risk approach to supervision, under which processors with stronger data security capability, a better credit record and lower-risk outbound flows may face reduced inspection frequency.

Two boundaries are stated as substantive rules rather than notes. Data concerning national security, the lifelines of the national economy, important livelihood matters or major public interest is core data, is subject to a stricter regime and is not brought within the negative list at all. And where an international treaty or agreement to which China is a party provides otherwise, the treaty applies, except for provisions on which China has entered a reservation. The second is unusual enough to be worth flagging: it does not create an exemption, but it does mean that a transfer covered by a treaty is analysed under the treaty first.

Anhui’s list content is published as an attachment, and the notice itself does not summarise the fields or the entry count. That is a difference in drafting habit rather than in substance, and it has one practical consequence: a company working on Anhui has to open the attachment, whereas a company working on Zhejiang can begin from the question-and-answer. Anhui’s measures also attach a reference rule for classifying and grading data, which is used to identify important data where a national sectoral authority has not published its own standard. The rule works from the scale of personal information held, from personal information held by operators of critical information infrastructure, and from high-value sensitive data generated in research, design and production.

Four steps for a company

The two lists reward a sequence, and the sequence is the same in both provinces.

The first step is to locate the entity, not the business. The question is which legal person is registered in which zone, because the list attaches to the registered processor. A group with a trading company in Ningbo, a manufacturing company in Hefei and a regional headquarters in Shanghai has three different answers to the same question, and the answer for one entity says nothing about the others.

The second step is to read the list for that zone, in its attachment form, and to read the field definitions rather than the field names. Zhejiang’s e-commerce chapter is expressly confined to business-to-business e-commerce and lists the scenarios it covers; a business-to-consumer flow is not inside it merely because the words e-commerce appear in the title. The same discipline applies to the commodity chapter’s seven scenarios.

The third step is to characterise the flow. A single business process usually produces several flows with different characters: order data, payment data, logistics data, after-sales data, employee data on secondment, and system telemetry sent to a group platform. Each has to be tested against the list separately, because the list is written by scenario and by data item, not by business unit. The most frequent error at this stage is to characterise the whole relationship instead of each flow, and to conclude either that everything is covered or that nothing is.

The fourth step is to choose the route and document the choice. If the flow is on the list, the route is the one the list assigns, and the work is an assessment, a standard contract or a certification, with the timelines those processes carry. If the flow is off the list, the route is a filing in the zone, and the deliverable is a filing result. If the entity is outside the zone, neither applies and the national thresholds govern. Whichever branch is taken, the file should record the reasoning, because the consistency sampling described in Anhui’s measures and the inspection practice in both provinces test the record against the actual flow, not against the conclusion.

An example makes the third step concrete. A European manufacturer seconds three engineers to its Chinese subsidiary for eighteen months. Payroll data, performance reviews and expense records for those engineers flow back to the group’s human resources platform in the home country. Three characterisations are available. The flow may be human resources management under the national provisions, which carry their own exemption. It may be personal information inside an e-commerce or clearing scenario, which it plainly is not. Or it may be employee data outside every listed scenario, in which case the list does not apply and the national thresholds decide. The third reading is correct in most cases, and it is the reading a company reaches only if it has separated the secondment flow from the commercial flows around it. Groups that characterise by relationship rather than by flow usually miss the secondment entirely, because no one in the commercial organisation owns it.

One sequencing point deserves emphasis. A filing is not a substitute for the substantive route, and the substantive route is not a substitute for the transfer-level obligations. Companies that treat the three as alternatives tend to arrive at an inspection with a filing result, no impact assessment and an unresolved question about whether the receiving entity is a separate controller. The list does not answer that question and does not pretend to.

What to watch next

Three things will determine how much these lists change in practice.

The first is the implementing guidance. Zhejiang’s question-and-answer states that implementation guidelines and management rules are to be issued, covering filing review, changes and termination of filings, supervision and inspection, with time limits for each stage. Until those appear, the two-step sequence is a direction rather than a procedure, and companies should expect the material requirements to be restated in the guidance.

The second is the reference decisions. The clause exists in both provinces, and the first published reference decision will show how the five-stage ladder works in practice: how long it takes, what a needs analysis looks like, and whether a reference is granted field by field or in a block. A group with a sector that is listed in one zone and unlisted in another has a direct interest in that answer.

The third is the revision cycle. Both provinces describe dynamic management, and Anhui adds that where the content of a list changes, a fresh filing is required. That is a reasonable rule and a demanding one: it means the filing is tied to a version of the list, and a revision reopens the file. Companies should keep the version they filed against, and should expect that the 2026 editions are not the last.

A fourth question sits behind those three, and it is the one a group with several Chinese entities will ask first: whether the lists converge. There is reason to expect convergence in architecture and divergence in content. The architecture is fixed by Article 6 and by a common drafting template — a management measure, two sub-lists, a filing route, a reference clause. The content is fixed by local industry, and local industry differs. A commodity chapter in Zhejiang, a first list in Anhui and a medical device cluster in Beijing will produce lists that do not resemble one another, and a group operating across all three will hold three compliance positions rather than one. That is not a defect in the design. It is what a sector-based instrument does when it is applied province by province, and the reference clause is the mechanism the drafters left for closing the gaps that result.

None of this changes the underlying structure, which is now visible across the two provinces and is likely to hold: a pair of documents, a two-part list, a filing route inside the zone, the national pathways outside it, and a provincial approval ladder for borrowing a neighbour’s list. For a foreign-invested company, the value of the arrangement is not that the obligations are lighter. It is that the question of which route applies now has a documentary answer, and a documentary answer is something a compliance function can audit.

Sources

  • 浙江省互联网信息办公室、浙江省商务厅、浙江省数据局·《关于印发〈中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)〉〈中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单(2026版)〉的通知》(浙网办〔2026〕3 号,2026-11-09):https://www.zjwx.gov.cn/col/col1673564/art/2026/art_b4db8400a4064cf2ba76d47935cd2836.html
  • 浙江网信网·《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)》和《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单(2026版)》政策问答(2026-11-10):https://www.zjwx.gov.cn/col/col1673564/art/2026/art_a5f9bb9ee9fa4437bce8f1dda49cbb37.html
  • 安徽省互联网信息办公室、安徽省商务厅、安徽省数据资源管理局·《关于印发中国(安徽)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法及负面清单(2026版)的通知》(2026-11-11,含两份附件):https://www.ahwx.gov.cn/gzzc/bbdt/202611/t20261105_9720746.html
  • 中国政府网·《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(国家互联网信息办公室令第 16 号,2024-03-22 公布施行):https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/2024/issue_11366/202405/content_6954192.html

浙江、安徽自贸试验区相隔两日发布 2026 版数据出境负面清单

两省、两天、一套结构

2026 年 11 月 9 日,浙江省互联网信息办公室、浙江省商务厅、浙江省数据局联合印发两份文件:《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)》与《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境管理清单(负面清单)(2026 版)》。两份文件于 11 月 10 日 16 时 04 分在浙江网信网公布,文号为浙网办〔2026〕3 号。

两天之后,11 月 11 日,安徽省互联网信息办公室、安徽省商务厅、安徽省数据资源管理局印发了安徽自贸试验区的对应文件。该通知于签署当日 15 时 50 分在安徽网信网发布,管理办法与负面清单分别以两份附件形式挂出。

两省并非首次协同,时点也不是最值得注意的部分,值得注意的是一套结构。两省都是「一对文件」:一份管理办法,管谁能用清单、怎么备案、清单怎么修订、怎么监督;一份清单,点名哪些数据。两份文件都建立在《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》第六条之上——这条 2024 年 3 月的规章授权自贸试验区自行制定需要纳入安全评估、标准合同或认证管理范围的数据清单,经省级网络安全和信息化委员会批准后,报国家网信部门、国家数据管理部门备案。两份文件援引的政治依据也相同:党的二十届四中全会关于「推进数据高效便利安全跨境流动」的部署。

差别在经济内容与行政细节,而这两处差别才是企业真正要用的东西。

两省一周之内相继发文,也提醒人这套制度是怎么搭起来的。国家规定给框架、给门槛,片区给行业清单。出境数据没有全国统一负面清单,也不会有,因为这件工具从设计上就是本地的。这对集团如何配置这个问题有影响:能回答它的人坐在片区附近,不在中心。一个只维护一套「中国数据出境立场」的总部,维护的是一套严格说来对任何一个具体主体都不成立的立场。

浙江的通知里有一条容易被读过去的过渡条款:2024 版负面清单及原管理办法自本通知印发之日起废止,但已取得备案结果通知书的,其备案结果继续有效。也就是说,废止不溯及既往。持有 2024 版备案结果的企业,不必在 11 月 10 日重新备案;只要自身数据流没有变化,那份结果就是有效的。安徽的通知没有对应表述,这与安徽此次是首份清单而非替换版这一事实相符。

清单决定什么,不决定什么

对自贸试验区负面清单最常见的误读,是把它当成一张出境许可证。它不是。它是一套分流装置,而分流只有两个出口。

按国家规定第六条,自贸试验区内数据处理者向境外提供清单之外的数据,可以免予申报安全评估、订立标准合同、通过认证——这是豁免的一侧。向境外提供落在清单之内的数据,则回到常规制度:清单指派给安全评估的类别走评估,指派给标准合同或认证的类别走那两条路。因此清单本身被画成两张子清单,两省都明确写了出来。浙江的清单按「需要通过数据出境安全评估的数据清单」与「需要通过个人信息出境标准合同备案、个人信息保护认证出境的数据清单」两部分编排;安徽的管理办法则规定,负面清单至少应当包含这两方面,并分别说明各自覆盖什么。

第二种常见误读,是以为清单把重要数据的问题一并解决了。它只解决了一部分,而且只在区内解决。国家规定第二条本来就已经写明:未被相关部门、地区告知或者公开发布为重要数据的,数据处理者不需要作为重要数据申报安全评估。区内清单在此之上加了一层本地判断:在所列行业、所列场景之内,符合描述的数据按清单指派的路径办理。出了这些行业与场景,国家规则原样适用。浙江清单用注释把这一点写明——每一条都限定于特定场景,场景之外按现行规定执行。

两张子清单的分工值得单独说一句,因为它们不是同一道门槛的两档严厉程度,而是一道阶梯。评估清单一侧,描述的是必须走国家层面安全评估的数据:所列领域中的重要数据,以及超过该领域量级档位的个人信息。标准合同与认证清单一侧,描述的是档位之下的个人信息。合起来读,就是一道阶梯:顶上是评估,中间是合同或认证,底下是经备案即可在所列场景内流动的一段。阶梯本身就是便利化所在。它不降低任何一级上的义务,它做的是把每一级从哪里起步钉死——而这恰恰是企业此前对一条大宗商品数据流、一条企业对企业电子商务数据流无法自行确定的。靠类推论证的贸易商只能猜第一级台阶在哪;读清单的贸易商看得见那块竖板。

由此有一个企业往往不愿接受的推论。既然阶梯是按场景、按数据项画的,落在被描述场景之外一格的数据流并不继承那个档位,而是回到国家门槛——那套门槛只看量级,不看商业语境,且可能高于也可能低于清单为该领域划出的档位。决定一条流落在哪一级的变量是目的,不是数据类型;而目的写在合同与系统设计里,不写在数据本身。

第三种误读关乎「什么被保留了下来」。备案结果确认的是走哪条路,它并不免除数据出境行为本身的义务。告知、处理敏感个人信息取得单独同意、个人信息保护影响评估,以及与之配套的记录留存,都是《个人信息保护法》与《网络数据安全管理条例》下的义务,两省文件对此一字未动。清单也不取代出口管制与技术出口管理:两省都规定,出境数据涉及管制物项相关技术资料或技术出口管理事项的,按相关法律法规另行执行。浙江把这一点写成清单注释,安徽写成实体条款。

还有第四点,较小但很实际。区内清单适用于在区内登记注册的数据处理者。安徽把数据处理者定义为在安徽自贸试验区内登记注册并开展数据跨境流动等相关活动的企业、事业单位、机构、团体、其他组织或个人。一家在安徽经营但注册在区外的集团,不适用区内清单,仍须走国家路径。判断标准是注册地址,不是经营足迹。

浙江:一个大宗商品章节,一段更短的流程

浙江 2026 版保留了 2024 版的框架。原有的两个领域仍在:电子商务(企业对企业)与清结算。在此之上,浙江新增了大宗商品领域十一条负面清单条目,覆盖七个具体场景、三十八个数据项。省里的政策问答把这一定位为「填补空白」——在增补之前,大宗商品企业没有直接对应的清单,只能从电子商务或清结算的条目类推。

公开文本点名的场景很具体,而不是笼统的行业名:原材料采购、设备维护与技术支持、大宗商品销售、大宗贸易数字化服务、燃油加注、离岸转口贸易、保险理赔。每一条都限定在自己的场景里,这意味着大宗商品贸易企业必须把实际数据流对上某个被点名的场景,而不是对上「大宗商品」这个行业。一笔交易若七个场景都不落,就在清单之外,回到国家规则。

大宗商品章节之所以要紧,原因在一份条目数摘要里看不出来。浙江自贸试验区围绕大宗商品资源配置枢纽建设,而随一船油、一船铁矿或一船粮食流动的数据并不是消费者数据。它是价格数据、库存数据、交易对手数据与物流数据,其中相当一部分贴着重要数据的边界,却从未被点名。把这些数据放进一份点名场景的清单,给贸易商的是一件此前没有的东西:对「某条数据流要不要评估」这个问题的书面答案,而不是一次检查中临场展开的类推论证。

程序变化是另一半。政策问答写明,企业申报流程已由「提交申请—提交备案—合规出境」三段,压缩为「提交备案申请—合规开展数据出境」两步。省里把由此形成的机制描述为事前备案、事中监测、事后评估的全链条闭环,并说明负面清单实行动态管理,跟踪评估实施情况和安全风险,统筹开展修订。

对已在 2024 版制度下运行的企业,有两点随之而来。第一,更短的流程改变的是内部审批路径,不是证据标准。备案申请仍要说明数据类型、场景与量级,而省级文本明确表示实施指南和管理细则仍待出台。在那些文件面世之前,两步的实际内容与从前相同,只是少了一道闸门。第二,政策问答点名的服务通道是杭州片区滨江区的数据跨境服务中心,承担资料接收、结果反馈、监督检查与申报辅导。对宁波、金义、舟山片区的企业而言,这个中心是模板,不是柜台。

参照条款

浙江管理办法第九条、安徽管理办法第八条里,藏着一条清单摘要通常不会提到的规定,而它将决定相当一批真实案例。

两省都允许参照适用全国其他省市自由贸易试验区、自由贸易港、改革开放先行区、国家服务业扩大开放综合试点示范地区正式发布的数据出境负面清单。紧接着,两省都附上了把这条看似捷径变成行政流程的条件。参照必须针对本省确有需要的特定领域;必须在国家数据分类分级保护制度框架下进行;省级管理部门须对拟参照的清单逐一开展需求分析和风险评估;结果须经省数据安全工作协调机制审核通过,报省委网络安全和信息化委员会批准,再由省网信办与省数据局联合报国家网信部门、国家数据管理部门备案。

五道环节,其中两道在委员会层级,末尾还有一次国家层面备案。这么设计不是为了刁难。区内清单是一项被授予的权力,而决定采纳另一个省对同一项权力的行使,必须能追溯到持有授权的机关。这条阶梯就是那条追溯线。它也解释了为什么条款被写成省里的许可,而不是企业的权利:被批准的是省里采纳一套标准,不是企业选择一个管辖地。

这条款最好被理解为对一个本来会被非正式回答的问题的正式回答。一家浙江企业所处的行业被上海清单覆盖,或一家安徽企业所处的行业被浙江新出的大宗商品章节覆盖,它都不能直接把别省的条目拿来用。它可以请本省主管部门考虑参照,主管部门也有既定路径可走,但这条路径没有公布时限,也没有必须给出肯定结论的义务。

从规划角度看,这条款的含义很清楚。在多片区布局的集团,不应假定在一个片区取得的清单可以平移到另一个片区。它应当按片区逐一梳理:哪份清单覆盖哪个主体、哪条数据流,并把空白当作空白,直到参照决定真正公布。反其道而行——把合规立场建立在一个假定的参照之上——是那种能撑到第一次检查之前的假定。

安徽:同一骨架,不同市级层级

安徽的文件在结构上完全一致,在若干处行政表述上更细,因此是个有用的对照。

管理办法把省级层面定义为五个部门:省互联网信息办公室、省数据资源管理局、省商务厅(省自贸办)、省公安厅、省国家安全厅。市级层面按地理定义:合肥、芜湖、蚌埠片区管理机构及属地相关职能部门。两级分工正是实际工作的落点,因为受理备案、组织审核、出具初审意见都在市级。

公开文本给出市级管理部门的时限:收到数据处理者提交的备案材料后,于十个工作日内组织审核,提出出境数据是否适用负面清单的初审意见。初审意见报省级管理部门确认后,向数据处理者反馈备案审核结果。结果分三支,值得分开看,因为企业往往把它们揉成一团。数据在清单内的,市级指导企业申报安全评估、订立标准合同或通过认证;数据在清单外的,市级明确告知企业可以安全有序流动;清单不适用的——因为主体或活动不在其范围内——按现行法律法规执行。

首份清单与修订版的行为方式不同,而这种不同不只是过渡性的。修订版继承一批既成案例:批过的备案、答过的问题、片区与企业之间在过去一年里磨出来的边缘情形。首份清单没有这层沉积,公开文本便以更细的程序颗粒度来补偿——五个省级部门点名、三个片区点名、十个工作日钉死、三种结果枚举、两套监督机制写明。安徽写的是一本手册,浙江可以只写一份修订说明。对企业而言,实际读法是:安徽的答案在第一次接触时更可预期,在边缘处则更不确定,因为当个案不落入被枚举的结果时,没有累积的做法可查。

安徽还写下了两套浙江处理得较简的机制。一是备案有效期内的一致性抽验:市级就数据实际出境情况与备案材料进行比对;对未严格履行承诺、瞒报虚报、故意造成实际出境数据与备案数据不一致的,处理从责令暂停出境、限期整改、整改后重新履行备案程序,到终止出境活动并采取重点监管措施。二是「信用+风险」分类分级监管:数据安全保障能力较强、信用较好、出境数据风险较低的数据处理者,可合理降低监督检查频次。

两条边界被写成实体规则,而不是注释。关系国家安全、国民经济命脉、重要民生、重大公共利益等数据属于国家核心数据,实行更严格的管理制度,不纳入负面清单管理。我国缔结或者参加的国际条约、协定与国内法律法规有不同约定的,适用该国际条约、协定,但我国声明保留的条款除外。后一条足够少见,值得标出:它不创设豁免,但确实意味着受条约覆盖的出境,先按条约分析。

安徽的清单内容以附件形式发布,通知本身没有概述领域或条目数。这是起草习惯的差异,而非实质差异,但它有一个实际后果:做安徽的企业必须打开附件,做浙江的企业可以从政策问答起步。安徽的管理办法还附了一份数据分类分级参考规则,用于在国家行业主管部门未发布本行业标准时识别重要数据。该规则从所持个人信息的规模、关键信息基础设施运营者掌握的个人信息,以及研发设计与生产制造过程中产生的高价值敏感数据入手。

企业侧四步

两份清单都奖励一种次序,而两省的次序相同。

第一步,定位主体,而不是定位业务。要问的是哪个法律主体在哪个片区注册,因为清单附着于注册的数据处理者。一家在宁波设有贸易公司、在合肥设有制造公司、在上海设有区域总部的集团,对同一个问题有三个不同答案,而其中一个主体的答案对另外两个什么也说明不了。

第二步,读那个片区的清单,读附件形态的清单,并且读领域定义而不是领域名称。浙江的电子商务章节明确限于企业对企业电子商务,并列出所覆盖的场景;一条企业对消费者的数据流,不会仅仅因为标题里有「电子商务」四个字就落进去。同样的纪律适用于大宗商品章节的七个场景。

第三步,给数据流定性。一个业务流程通常产出若干性质不同的流:订单数据、支付数据、物流数据、售后数据、外派员工数据,以及发往集团平台的系统遥测。每一条都要单独对照清单,因为清单是按场景、按数据项写的,不是按事业部写的。这一步最常见的错误,是给整段关系定性而不是给每条流定性,于是要么得出「全都在内」,要么得出「全都不在」。

第四步,选路径并留下选择的记录。数据流在清单内,路径就是清单指派的那条,工作是评估、标准合同或认证,附带各自的时间成本。数据流在清单外,路径是区内备案,交付物是一份备案结果。主体在区外,两者都不适用,由国家门槛管辖。无论走哪一支,卷宗都应当记录推理过程,因为安徽办法里的一致性抽验与两省的检查实践,比对的是记录与实际数据流,而不是与结论。

有一个例子可以把第三步讲实。一家欧洲制造商把三名工程师派驻中国子公司十八个月。这三人的薪酬数据、绩效评价与报销记录回流到母国集团的人力资源平台。三种定性都可能被提出:这可能属于国家规定下的跨境人力资源管理,那有它自己的豁免;可能属于电子商务或清结算场景内的个人信息,而它显然不是;也可能属于落在所有被列场景之外的员工数据,此时清单不适用,由国家门槛决定。多数情况下正确的读法是第三种,而只有把派驻数据流与周围的商业数据流分开的企业才会得到这个读法。按关系定性而不是按数据流定性的集团,通常会整个漏掉派驻这一块,因为商业组织里没有人负责它。

有一个次序问题值得强调。备案不是实体路径的替代品,实体路径也不是出境层面义务的替代品。把三者当成可选项的企业,往往在检查时手里有一份备案结果、没有影响评估,还悬着一个「境外接收方是不是独立控制者」的未决问题。清单不回答这个问题,也不假装回答。

接下来看什么

有三件事将决定这两份清单在实践中改变多少。

第一是实施指引。浙江的政策问答写明将加快出台实施指南和管理细则,细化各责任部门职责,梳理备案审核、备案变更终止、监督检查等内部流程,明确各环节办结时限。在这些文件面世之前,两步办理是方向而不是程序,企业应当预期实质要求会在指引里被重新表述一遍。

第二是参照决定。条款在两省都存在,而第一份公开的参照决定会显示五道环节在实践中如何运转:要多久、需求分析长什么样、参照是按领域逐项批准还是整块批准。行业在一个片区被列入、在另一个片区未被列入的集团,对这个问题有直接利益。

第三是修订周期。两省都写了动态管理,安徽还加了一句:负面清单内容发生变化的,应当重新申请备案。这是一条合理而苛刻的规则——它意味着备案绑定在清单的某个版本上,一次修订就重新打开卷宗。企业应当留存自己备案时所依据的版本,并预期 2026 版不是最后一版。

这三件事背后还有第四个问题,也是在中国设有多个实体的集团会最先问的:各省清单会不会趋同。有理由预期结构趋同、内容分化。结构由国家规定第六条与一套共同的起草模板固定下来——一份管理办法、两张子清单、一条备案路径、一条参照条款。内容由本地产业决定,而本地产业各不相同。浙江写出了大宗商品章节,安徽拿出了首份清单,北京经开区把医疗器械纳入清单,三者不会彼此相像;跨三地经营的集团,手里会是三套合规立场而不是一套。这不是设计缺陷。以行业为基础的工具,一旦按省适用,结果就是这样;而参照条款,正是起草者留给填补由此产生的空白的机制。

以上都不改变底层结构,而这个结构在两省之间已经显现,且很可能延续:一对文件、两张清单、区内一条备案路径、区外国家路径,以及一条借用邻省清单的省级审批阶梯。对外资企业而言,这套安排的价值不在于义务变轻了。它在于「走哪条路」这个问题现在有了书面答案,而书面答案,是合规职能可以审计的东西。

来源

  • 浙江省互联网信息办公室、浙江省商务厅、浙江省数据局·《关于印发〈中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)〉〈中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单(2026版)〉的通知》(浙网办〔2026〕3 号,2026-11-09):https://www.zjwx.gov.cn/col/col1673564/art/2026/art_b4db8400a4064cf2ba76d47935cd2836.html
  • 浙江网信网·《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)》和《中国(浙江)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单(2026版)》政策问答(2026-11-10):https://www.zjwx.gov.cn/col/col1673564/art/2026/art_a5f9bb9ee9fa4437bce8f1dda49cbb37.html
  • 安徽省互联网信息办公室、安徽省商务厅、安徽省数据资源管理局·《关于印发中国(安徽)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法及负面清单(2026版)的通知》(2026-11-11,含两份附件):https://www.ahwx.gov.cn/gzzc/bbdt/202611/t20261105_9720746.html
  • 中国政府网·《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(国家互联网信息办公室令第 16 号,2024-03-22 公布施行):https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/2024/issue_11366/202405/content_6954192.html