Category Archives: Data Export / 数据出境

Guangdong’s Data-Export Negative List and the First National Data Pilot: Compliance Relief for FIEs

  • In August 2026 Guangzhou, Shenzhen and the Guangdong-Macao In-Depth Cooperation Zone in Hengqin were selected as the first batch of national pilot zones for international cooperation in the data sector, supported by the National Data Administration.
    2026年8月,在国家数据局支持下,广州、深圳及横琴粤澳深度合作区入选国家数据领域国际合作首批试点。
  • The pilot designates Hengqin to build an international data hub focused on Portuguese- and Spanish-speaking countries via Brazil, leveraging the “Macao + Hengqin” combination.
    试点方案赋予横琴立足”澳门+横琴”独特优势,以巴西为突破口、重点面向葡语、西语系国家打造数据领域国际合作新枢纽、新通道。
  • Hengqin completed its first filing case under the data-export negative list in mid-2026: Macao International Airport reported a cross-border data transmission under the “use first, report later” mechanism.
    2026年年中,横琴完成首单数据出境负面清单报告案例:澳门国际机场依据”先用后报”机制申报跨境数据传输。
  • Guangdong’s FTZ data-export negative list (2025 version), covering intelligent equipment manufacturing and personal-credit services, was registered with the CAC and the National Data Administration in May 2026.
    广东自贸试验区数据出境负面清单(2025版)聚焦智能装备制造和个人征信服务业两大领域,2026年5月经国家网信办、国家数据局审核备案发布。
  • Under the “use first, report later” mechanism, enterprises self-assess against the list, transmit data promptly, and file a report within 15 working days; qualified transmissions are exempt from security assessment and standard-contract filing.
    “先用后报”机制下,企业对照清单自主研判、便捷出境,事后15个工作日内报告;符合清单条件的数据免于安全评估、免于标准合同备案。
  • For foreign-invested enterprises in Guangdong, the pilot and negative list reduce the compliance cost of cross-border data flows for manufacturing, logistics, finance and R&D operations.
    对广东外资企业而言,该试点与负面清单降低了制造、物流、金融与研发运营跨境数据流动的合规成本。

Guangdong’s Data-Export Negative List and the First National Data Pilot: Compliance Relief for FIEs | 广东数据出境负面清单与首批国家数据试点:外资企业的合规减负

Why this matters now

Cross-border data flows have been one of the hardest compliance areas for foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) in China, caught between data-security rules and genuine business needs to transmit HR, manufacturing, logistics and financial data overseas. Two developments in 2026 materially ease that pressure in the country’s most trade-intensive province. First, in May 2026, Guangdong published the data-export management list (negative list, 2025 version) for its pilot free-trade zones, after registration with the Cyberspace Administration of China and the National Data Administration. Second, in August 2026, Guangzhou, Shenzhen and the Hengqin cooperation zone were selected as the first batch of national pilot zones for international cooperation in the data sector. The combination gives FIEs in Guangdong a compliance channel that is substantially cheaper than the default security-assessment route.

How the negative list works

The negative-list approach inverts the default. Under the cross-border data rules, data transfers generally require one of three routes: a data-export security assessment, a standard contract, or certification. A negative list changes the equation: data within the listed scope — as determined by the enterprise’s own assessment against clear data categories — can flow abroad without the assessment or standard-contract burden, subject to filing. Guangdong’s list covers two focus areas, intelligent equipment manufacturing and personal-credit services, spanning important data and personal information across 7 business scenarios and 67 data items. The Hengqin implementing guide issued on 5 June 2026 codifies the “use first, report later” mechanics: an enterprise evaluates its data against the list, transmits compliant data promptly, and files a report within 15 working days. At a policy briefing in Hengqin on 2 July 2026, officials confirmed that data within the list is exempt from security assessment and standard-contract filing.

The international cooperation pilot

The August 2026 selection of Guangzhou, Shenzhen and Hengqin as national data international-cooperation pilots deepens the infrastructure behind the list. The pilot scheme assigns differentiated roles: Guangzhou builds a “facilities-rules-carriers-ecosystem” system; Shenzhen leverages Qianhai to expand cooperation with Singapore, ASEAN and Belt-and-Road countries; Hengqin focuses on the “Macao + Hengqin” advantage and, via Brazil, the Portuguese- and Spanish-speaking world. For FIEs, the pilot matters because it signals sustained official investment in the enabling layer — cross-border data verification platforms, research data networks and a data cross-border service centre that has already advised more than 70 companies — making the negative-list channel more usable over time.

Practical steps for FIEs in Guangdong

  1. Determine whether your data falls in the list. Map the data your entity transmits overseas — production parameters, equipment data, credit data, HR records — and check each category against the Guangdong negative list.
  2. Choose the compliant route. Where data is within the list, use the “use first, report later” mechanism with the 15-working-day filing; where it is outside, fall back to security assessment, standard contract or certification as applicable.
  3. Build self-assessment capacity. Document how your team classifies data and reaches its conclusion, because the mechanism is self-assessment-based and subject to ex-post supervision.
  4. Leverage the Hengqin/Nansha service layer. Use the data cross-border service centre and the implementing guides (Hengqin and Nansha have both issued them) for questions and procedural support.
  5. Watch for industry lists. Other FTZs and pilot areas are issuing negative lists across industries; if your group operates in automotive, healthcare, aviation or other covered sectors, track the applicable provincial list.
  6. Coordinate data, legal and IT. Negative-list compliance touches data classification, security, contracts and systems; run it as a cross-functional programme rather than a compliance checkbox.

Risks and compliance notes

The negative list is a narrowing of obligations, not an exemption from the data-security legal framework. Data outside the list still requires the full route; misclassification by the enterprise can create real liability. The “report later” obligation must be met within 15 working days, and the authorities retain ex-post supervision. FIEs should also remember that personal information crosses the border under the PIPL framework as well — the negative list does not override the PIPL’s consent and minimisation principles, it addresses the administrative route. Finally, because the list is Guangdong-specific, an FIE with operations in multiple provinces should verify the applicable list for each location rather than assuming national application.


广东数据出境负面清单与首批国家数据试点:外资企业的合规减负

为什么当下重要

跨境数据流动一直是在华外资企业最难处理的合规领域之一——一边是数据安全规则,一边是向境外传输人力资源、制造、物流与财务数据的真实业务需求。2026年的两项进展在中国贸易最密集的省份实质性地缓解了这一压力。第一,2026年5月,广东在其自贸试验区发布数据出境管理清单(负面清单,2025版),经国家网信办与国家数据局审核备案。第二,2026年8月,广州、深圳及横琴合作区入选国家数据领域国际合作首批试点。二者结合,为广东外资企业提供了一条在成本上远低于默认安全评估路径的合规通道。

负面清单如何运作

负面清单方法反转了默认逻辑。在跨境数据规则下,数据传输通常需要三条路径之一:数据出境安全评估、标准合同或认证。负面清单改变了等式:清单范围内的数据——由企业对照清晰的数据类别自行判定——可以在不承担安全评估或标准合同负担的情况下出境,仅需备案。广东清单覆盖两大重点领域,智能装备制造与个人征信服务,涵盖重要数据与个人信息,涉及7个业务场景、67个数据项。2026年6月5日发布的横琴实施指南将”先用后报”机制成文化:企业对照清单研判数据、合规数据及时出境、事后15个工作日内报告。2026年7月2日横琴政策宣讲会上,官方确认清单内数据免于安全评估与标准合同备案。

国际合作试点

2026年8月广州、深圳与横琴入选国家数据领域国际合作首批试点,为清单背后的基础设施再添砖瓦。试点方案赋予差异化角色:广州构建”设施—规则—载体—生态”四位一体体系;深圳依托前海拓展与新加坡、东盟及共建”一带一路”国家合作;横琴立足”澳门+横琴”优势、经巴西面向葡语西语世界。对外资企业而言,该试点意味着官方对该使能层的持续投入——跨境数据验证平台、跨境科研数据网络,以及已服务超70家企业的数据跨境服务中心——使负面清单通道随时间推移更可用。

广东外资企业的操作步骤

  1. 判定数据是否落入清单。 梳理本实体向境外传输的数据——生产参数、设备数据、征信数据、HR记录——并逐类对照广东负面清单。
  2. 选择合规路径。 清单内数据走”先用后报”机制、15个工作日备案;清单外数据按适用情形走安全评估、标准合同或认证。
  3. 建设自评估能力。 文件化团队如何分类数据并得出结论,因为该机制以自评估为基础、接受事后监管。
  4. 利用横琴/南沙服务层。 就疑问与程序支持,使用数据跨境服务中心及实施指南(横琴、南沙均已发布)。
  5. 关注行业清单。 其他自贸试验区与试点地区正跨行业发布负面清单;若贵集团涉足汽车、医药、民航等覆盖行业,跟踪适用的省级清单。
  6. 协同数据、法务与IT。 负面清单合规涉及数据分类、安全、合同与系统;作为跨职能项目运行,而非合规勾选项。

风险与合规提示

负面清单收窄的是义务范围,不是豁免数据安全法律框架。清单外数据仍须走完整路径;企业分类错误可能产生真实责任。”事后报告”义务必须在15个工作日内履行,监管部门保留事后监督。外资企业还应记住,个人信息依PIPL框架出境——负面清单不替代PIPL的同意与最小化原则,它处理的是行政路径。最后,由于清单为广东专属,在多省运营的外资企业应核验各地适用清单,而非假设全国统一适用。

Sources

FTZ Data-Export Negative Lists Accelerate: Beijing, Hengqin, Chongqing and Nansha Go Live

  • China’s free-trade-zone (FTZ) data-export negative-list mechanism is moving from policy design to live, enforceable cases. 自贸试验区数据出境负面清单机制正从制度设计走向可落地的实际案例。
  • Beijing, Hengqin (Guangdong), Chongqing and Nansha (Guangzhou) have each recorded its first negative-list data-export case. 北京、横琴(广东)、重庆、南沙(广州)均已出现首单负面清单数据出境案例。
  • Beijing’s “Two Zones” negative list (May 2026) adopts a “1+9” design covering 67 business scenarios and 612 data fields across the whole municipality. 北京市”两区”数据出境负面清单(2026年5月)采用”1+9″制度设计,覆盖全市域 67 个业务场景、612 个字段。
  • NongHyup Bank Beijing Branch became China’s first banking institution to achieve compliant data export under the negative-list framework on 2026-08-03. 韩国农协银行北京分行于 2026-08-03 成为全国首家通过负面清单实现数据合规出境的银行业机构。
  • Hengqin’s list centers on a “use-first, report-later” model with a 15-working-day post-hoc reporting window for qualifying data. 横琴清单核心为”先用后报”,符合条件的企业可便捷出境,并于事后 15 个工作日内报告。
  • All published lists are filed and reviewed by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) and the National Data Administration (NDA). 上述清单均经国家网信办、国家数据局审核备案。

FTZ Data-Export Negative Lists Accelerate: Beijing, Hengqin, Chongqing and Nansha Go Live | 自贸试验区数据出境负面清单加速落地:北京、横琴、重庆、南沙首单齐发

Overview

China’s cross-border data governance has entered a new phase in which free-trade zones (FTZs) are permitted to define “negative lists” of data that may NOT be freely exported, while everything else outside the list flows under a lighter, more predictable regime. Throughout 2026 this mechanism shifted decisively from design documents to real, booked cases. Four jurisdictions — Beijing, Hengqin (in Guangdong), Chongqing and Nansha (in Guangzhou) — have each announced a first negative-list data-export case, signalling that the framework is operational rather than aspirational. The confirming authority for the underlying regime, the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC), together with the National Data Administration (NDA), reviews and files every published list.

Negative-list mechanism

The negative-list approach inverts the traditional burden. Under the older standard-contract filing model, many routine transfers required case-by-case assessment. Under the negative-list model, an enterprise first checks whether its data falls within a listed sensitive category. If it does not, the data can leave in an orderly, secure and freer flow; if it does, the stricter pathways still apply. Each FTZ tailors its list to its local industrial strengths, so the same national principle produces different sector coverage across the country. Lists published so far have appeared in Tianjin, Beijing, Hainan, Shanghai, Zhejiang and Guangdong, among others.

Beijing

Beijing’s “Two Zones” (the integrated national demonstration zone for opening up the service sector and the FTZ) negative list, released in May 2026, follows a “1+9” architecture: one management measure plus nine sector lists, applicable citywide. Building on five previously covered domains, it adds four new ones — medical devices, autonomous driving (intelligent connected vehicles), trade logistics and banking — to reach 67 business scenarios and 612 data fields. The milestone banking case came on 2026-08-03, when NongHyup Bank Beijing Branch (Korea’s NongHyup Bank) became the first banking institution in China to achieve compliant data export under the negative-list framework. Its management mode shifted from standard-contract filing to the secure, orderly free flow enabled by the negative list — a template now watched closely by foreign-invested banks in the Beijing CBD.

Hengqin

Guangdong’s Hengqin FTZ negative list was issued as Yue Wang Ban Fa [2026] No.1 on 2026-05-15, focusing on two sectors: intelligent equipment manufacturing and personal credit reporting services. Its signature feature is “use-first, report-later” (先用后报). An enterprise self-assesses against the list; if its data qualifies, it may export conveniently, then files a report within 15 working days afterward. This reduces upfront friction for manufacturers and credit-service firms while preserving a clear audit trail.

Chongqing

Chongqing’s list — the China (Chongqing) Pilot FTZ Data Export Management List (Negative List) (2025 Edition) — delivered its first beneficiary on 2026-08-11, when Changan Automobile became the first enterprise in the Chongqing FTZ to enjoy the dividends of the negative-list regime. For an automotive exporter, the ability to move R&D and operational data under a predictable negative-list pathway is material to global product development cycles.

Nansha

Nansha, within the Guangzhou portion of the Guangdong FTZ, issued its implementation guide for the data-export negative list on 2026-08-18. The Nansha guide extends coverage to personal credit reporting services and intelligent equipment manufacturing, aligning with the Guangdong provincial direction while providing local implementation detail for enterprises in the Nansha New Area.

Practical steps

For an FDI enterprise weighing the mechanism, the practical sequence is: (1) map your data inventory to the relevant FTZ list by sector and field; (2) confirm whether the data sits outside the listed sensitive categories; (3) if it does, adopt the negative-list pathway and document your self-assessment; (4) where the local rule requires it, complete post-hoc reporting within the statutory window (e.g., 15 working days in Hengqin); (5) keep records defensible, because CAC and NDA review and file every list. Foreign banks, automakers, device makers, logistics and credit-service firms are the earliest movers.

Related reading

The mechanism is part of a broader opening of FTZs and “Two Zones” to foreign investment, with data mobility treated as infrastructure for trade and FDI rather than a pure compliance cost. Enterprises should monitor further list releases from Tianjin, Hainan, Shanghai and Zhejiang, and track CAC guidance for procedural updates.

Legal backbone

The negative-list model is one pillar of China’s three-track cross-border data regime. The backbone instrument is the CAC Provisions on Promoting and Regulating the Cross-Border Data Flows (promulgated in 2024), which, together with the earlier Measures for Data Exit Security Assessment and the Standard Contract Measures, forms a tiered system. The first track is a security assessment for important data and large-volume personal information. The second track is standard-contract filing or certification for routine transfers below the statutory thresholds. The third track is the FTZ negative list, which frees intra-list data from the heavier assessment and filing pathways. For an FDI enterprise, the practical upside is that siting data operations inside an FTZ can convert a transfer that would otherwise require assessment or filing into a self-assessed, list-based flow — provided the data stays outside the listed sensitive categories. The lists themselves remain filed and reviewed by CAC and the NDA, so the lighter pathway is a delegated, not abolished, control. Enterprises should therefore keep both the negative list and the national thresholds in view when designing a cross-border transfer architecture.


自贸试验区数据出境负面清单加速落地:北京、横琴、重庆、南沙首单齐发

概述

我国跨境数据治理已进入新阶段:自贸试验区被允许界定”数据出境负面清单”——即不得自由出境的数据类别,清单之外则适用更轻量、更可预期的管理路径。2026 年以来,这一机制从制度文本走向真实落地的案例。北京、横琴(广东)、重庆、南沙(广州)四个片区均已公布首单负面清单数据出境案例,表明该框架已实际运行而非停留在纸面。作为底层规制的主管部门,国家互联网信息办公室(网信办)与国家数据局对每一份发布的清单进行审核备案。

负面清单机制

负面清单思路颠覆了传统的合规负担逻辑。在过去的标准合同备案模式下,大量常规数据传输需逐案评估;而在负面清单模式下,企业先判断其数据是否落入清单所列的敏感类别。若未落入,数据即可在”安全有序自由流动”的框架下出境;若落入,则仍适用更严格的路径。各自贸试验区结合自身产业优势定制清单,因此同一国家原则在全国呈现不同的行业覆盖。目前天津、北京、海南、上海、浙江、广东等地已相继发布清单。

北京

北京市”两区”(国家服务业扩大开放综合示范区与自贸试验区)数据出境负面清单于 2026 年 5 月发布,采用”1+9″制度设计:1 套管理办法加 9 个领域清单,全市域覆盖。在原有 5 个领域基础上,新增医疗器械、自动驾驶(智能网联汽车)、贸易物流、银行业 4 大领域,覆盖 67 个业务场景、612 个字段。标志性银行业案例出现在 2026-08-03:韩国农协银行北京分行(NongHyup Bank Beijing Branch)成为全国首家通过负面清单实现数据合规出境的银行业机构,其管理模式由标准合同备案转为负面清单框架下的安全有序自由流动,已成为北京 CBD 外资银行重点关注的范本。

横琴

广东自贸试验区横琴片区数据出境负面清单以粤网办发〔2026〕1号于 2026-05-15 发布,聚焦智能装备制造业和个人征信服务业两大领域。其核心特色是”先用后报”:企业对照清单自主研判,符合条件即可便捷出境,并于事后 15 个工作日内报告。这一设计在降低制造企业及征信服务机构前期合规摩擦的同时,保留了清晰的审计痕迹。

重庆

重庆的清单——《中国(重庆)自由贸易试验区数据出境管理清单(负面清单)(2025版)》——于 2026-08-11 迎来首家受益企业:长安汽车成为重庆自贸区首家享负面清单红利企业。对汽车出口企业而言,能在可预期的负面清单路径下移动研发与运营数据,对其全球产品开发周期具有实质意义。

南沙

南沙(中国(广东)自由贸易试验区广州南沙新区片区)于 2026-08-18 发布数据出境负面清单实施指南,将覆盖拓展至个人征信服务业和智能装备制造业,既与广东省方向一致,又为南沙新区企业提供了本地化落地细则。

实务步骤

对于打算运用该机制的外商投资企业,实务顺序为:(1)按行业与字段将数据资产映射到所在片区清单;(2)确认数据是否落在清单所列敏感类别之外;(3)若未落入,即采用负面清单路径并留存自查记录;(4)若当地规则要求,在法定时限内完成事后报告(如横琴为 15 个工作日);(5)保持记录可抗辩,因为网信办与国家数据局对每份清单实施审核备案。外资银行、车企、设备制造商、物流及征信服务机构是最早的先行者。

延伸阅读

该机制是自贸试验区与”两区”更大范围对外开放的一部分,数据流动被视为贸易与外资的”基础设施”而非单纯的合规成本。企业应关注天津、海南、上海、浙江等地后续清单发布,并跟踪网信办的程序性指引更新。

规制基础

负面清单模式是我国跨境数据”三轨”治理框架的一根支柱。其底层文件是网信办《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(2024 年公布),与更早的《数据出境安全评估办法》《个人信息出境标准合同办法》共同构成分层体系。第一轨针对重要数据与大体量个人信息走安全评估;第二轨针对低于法定阈值的常规传输走标准合同备案或认证;第三轨即自贸试验区负面清单,把清单内数据从更重的安全评估与备案路径中解放出来。对外商投资企业而言,务实红利在于:把数据运营布局在自贸试验区内,可使原本需评估或备案的传输转为”清单自检、自由流动”——前提是数据落在清单所列敏感类别之外。清单本身仍由网信办与国家数据局审核备案,因此更轻的路径是”下放”而非”取消”的管控。企业在设计跨境传输架构时,应同时关注负面清单与国家统一阈值两条线。

Sources

  • https://com.gd.gov.cn/gkmlpt/content/4/4897/post_4897452.html (广东省商务厅等:《中国(广东)自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单管理办法(试行)》及管理清单(负面清单)(2025版),粤网办发〔2026〕1号)
  • https://english.beijing.gov.cn/latest/news/202608/t20260813_4821506.html (北京市政府:全国首个银行业数据出境负面清单备案落地北京 CBD,2026-08-13)
  • https://big5.china.com.cn/gate/big5/zw.china.com.cn/2026-08/07/content_118637480.shtml (新华社/中国网:我国首个银行业数据出境负面清单备案落地北京,2026-08-07)
  • https://www.cac.gov.cn/ (国家互联网信息办公室,数据出境相关规制主管部门)

FTZ Data Export Negative List and Facilitated Cross-Border Channels

  • The CAC “Provisions on Promoting and Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows” (CAC Decree No. 16, 22 March 2024) let free-trade zones formulate their own data-export negative lists under the national data classification framework.
    国家网信办《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(2024年3月22日,第16号令)授权自由贸易试验区在国家数据分类分级保护制度框架下自行制定数据出境负面清单。
  • A free-trade zone’s negative list identifies the data whose outbound provision still requires security assessment, standard contract or certification; data outside the list may flow out freely without those filings.
    自贸试验区负面清单列明仍须申报安全评估、订立标准合同或通过认证方可出境的数据;清单外数据可免予申报、自由出境。
  • Tianjin released China’s first FTZ data-export negative list (May 2024), dividing outbound data into 13 categories and 46 sub-categories with concrete examples.
    天津于2024年5月发布全国首份自贸试验区数据出境负面清单,将出境数据分为13大类46子类并辅以具体示例。
  • Shanghai (Lin-gang) published its negative list (February 2024) covering finance (reinsurance), shipping and commerce across 6 scenarios and 84 data items, with field-level detail and a “use-first, file-later” approach.
    上海(临港)于2024年2月发布负面清单,覆盖金融(再保险)、航运、商贸3个领域6个场景84个数据项,细化至字段级并实行”先用后报”。
  • Beijing’s FTZ negative list (August 2024) is the first scenario- and field-level list, spanning autos, pharma, civil aviation, retail and AI training data across five industries.
    北京自贸试验区负面清单(2024年8月)为首个场景化、字段级清单,涵盖汽车、医药、民航、零售与现代服务业、人工智能训练数据5个行业。
  • Foreign-invested enterprises in FTZs should map outbound data to the applicable negative list, use the one-stop data centre service, and rely on the list’s free-flow carve-out to cut compliance cost.
    区内外商投资企业应将出境数据对照适用负面清单,利用一站式数据跨境服务中心,并借助清单”清单外自由流动”豁免降低合规成本。

FTZ Data Export Negative List and Facilitated Cross-Border Channels | 自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单与便利化通道

Why this matters now

For a foreign-invested enterprise moving R&D, manufacturing, sales or HR data across borders, China’s data-export rules have long been criticised as uncertain — particularly the vague definition of “important data.” The 2024 reform changed the geometry of that problem. By empowering each free-trade zone (FTZ) to publish its own data-export negative list, Beijing created a field-level, scenario-based map that tells companies, with far greater precision, which data can leave freely and which still triggers a security assessment, standard contract or certification. For multinationals clustered in FTZs, the negative list is now the single most practical compliance instrument for cross-border data.

The enabling rule

The Provisions on Promoting and Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows (Cyberspace Administration of China Decree No. 16, effective 22 March 2024) is the legal foundation. Article 6 authorises an FTZ, within the national data classification and grading protection system, to formulate its own list of data that must enter the security-assessment / standard-contract / certification regime, subject to provincial cyberspace-authority approval and filing with the national cyberspace and data authorities. Critically, data exported by an FTZ entity that falls outside the negative list is exempt from the security assessment, standard contract and certification obligations. The Provisions also carve out routine cross-border scenarios — international trade, cross-border transport, academic cooperation, multinational manufacturing and marketing, and certain HR-management and low-volume personal-information transfers — from filing requirements altogether.

Tianjin: the first negative list

In May 2024, the China (Tianjin) Pilot Free Trade Zone became the first to issue a data-export negative list under the new rule — now filed with the national authorities. It organises outbound data into 13 major categories and 46 sub-categories spanning biomedicine, services outsourcing, finance, internet platforms, automotive, integrated circuits, meteorology and international trade, with detailed feature descriptions and concrete examples for each. The list makes “important data” identifiable rather than abstract: a chemical firm’s hazardous-materials transport-route planning, for instance, is explicitly mapped to a sub-category requiring security assessment. Together with Tianjin’s earlier data classification standard, it forms a “double first” policy system for cross-border data.

Shanghai (Lin-gang): field-level and “use-first”

Shanghai published its negative list (February 2024, with a management measure and implementation guide) covering finance (reinsurance), shipping (international shipping) and commerce (retail, food and beverage, accommodation) — six scenarios and 84 data items. Its distinguishing features:

  • Scenario names are listed first, so companies can match their activity directly.
  • Important-data features are refined in finance and shipping to aid identification.
  • Thresholds are eased where risk is controllable — for example, the sensitive personal-information assessment threshold in commerce membership management rises from 10,000 to 1,000,000, sharply lowering compliance cost.
  • A “use-first, file-later” principle applies: no entry barrier — a company simply submits its negative-list usage materials within 15 working days of starting the export.
  • Five district service centres plus a Lin-gang centre provide one-stop policy consultation and pre-check.

Beijing: scenario- and field-level pioneer

Beijing’s FTZ negative list (August 2024) was the first scenario- and field-level list, proposing a 13-category / 41-sub-category reference framework and enumerating compliance measures for five industries — automotive, pharmaceutical, civil aviation, retail and modern services, and AI training data — across 48 data categories. It added a provincial pre-review and pre-assessment mechanism and a green-channel service covering more than 100 enterprises in five sectors.

The compliance upside

The negative-list model turns data-export compliance from a national guess into a local, field-level answer. For an FIE, three gains stand out: first, certainty — once a dataset is mapped out-of-list, the assessment/contract/certification filings drop away; second, speed — Shanghai’s “use-first, file-later” removes the pre-clearance wait for in-list routine flows; third, cost — eased thresholds (such as Tianjin and Shanghai raising sensitive-PI triggers) materially lower the volume of filings. The trade-off is geography: the list is FTZ-specific, so an entity outside a pilot zone cannot rely on it and must fall back to the national thresholds in the CAC Provisions. Multinationals should therefore weigh FTZ location as a data-governance variable, not merely a tax or logistics one.

Practical steps for foreign-invested enterprises

  1. Locate your FTZ and list. Determine which FTZ your entity sits in (Tianjin, Shanghai/Lin-gang, Beijing, or others referencing them) and pull the applicable negative list.
  2. Map data to scenarios and fields. Use the scenario-first, field-level structure to classify each outbound dataset as in-list or out-of-list.
  3. Claim the free-flow carve-out. For out-of-list data, document the basis and export without the assessment/contract/certification filings.
  4. Use the one-stop centre. Submit materials within the prescribed window and use pre-check to de-risk.
  5. Watch interoperability. Shanghai and others mutually recognise negative lists; a list published by another FTZ may be referenced, so monitor second-batch lists in your sector.

Related reading

The negative list is one lane of China’s three-track data-export system — alongside the security assessment, the standard contract and certification. FIEs should read the FTZ list together with the national thresholds in the CAC Provisions and the general data-security and personal-information rules.


自由贸易试验区数据出境负面清单与便利化通道

为何当下值得关注

对跨境传输研发、制造、销售或人力资源数据的外商投资企业而言,中国的数据出境规则长期因”重要数据”界定模糊而被视为不确定。2024年的改革改变了这一问题的几何结构。通过授权每个自由贸易试验区(FTZ)发布各自的数据出境负面清单,决策层创建了一张字段级、场景化的地图,以更高精度告知企业:哪些数据可自由出境,哪些仍须触发安全评估、标准合同或认证。对聚集在自贸区的跨国企业而言,负面清单已成为跨境数据合规最务实的单一工具。

授权规则

《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(国家互联网信息办公室令第16号,2024年3月22日施行)是法律基础。第六条授权自由贸易试验区在国家数据分类分级保护制度框架下,自行制定区内须纳入数据出境安全评估、个人信息出境标准合同、个人信息保护认证管理范围的数据清单,经省级网信委员会批准并报国家网信部门、国家数据管理部门备案。关键在于,自贸试验区内数据处理者向境外提供负面清单外的数据,可免予申报安全评估、订立标准合同、通过认证。该规定还将国际贸易、跨境运输、学术合作、跨国生产制造与市场营销,以及特定人力资源管理与低量级个人信息传输等常规场景,整体排除出申报要求。

天津:首份负面清单

2024年5月,中国(天津)自由贸易试验区率先发布新规下的数据出境负面清单(已完成国家备案)。其将出境数据分为13大类46子类,覆盖生物医药、服务外包、金融、互联网平台、汽车、集成电路、气象、国际贸易等领域,并对每一类给出详细特征描述与具体示例。清单使”重要数据”从抽象变为可识别:例如某化工企业的危化品运输路线规划,被明确映射至须申报安全评估的子类。叠加天津此前的数据分类分级标准,形成自贸试验区”双首个”数据跨境政策体系。

上海(临港):字段级与”先用后报”

上海于2024年2月发布负面清单(配套管理办法与实施指南),覆盖金融(再保险)、航运(国际航运)、商贸(零售与餐饮、住宿)三大领域,涉及6个场景84个数据项。其突出特征:

  • 场景名称前置单列,便于企业直接对应适用。
  • 在金融、航运领域对重要数据进一步细化,辅助识别。
  • 风险可控前提下放宽阈值——例如商贸会员管理场景的敏感个人信息安全评估阈值由1万提升至100万,显著降低合规成本。
  • 实行“先用后报”原则:不设准入门槛,企业自开展数据出境活动之日起15个工作日内提交使用材料即可。
  • 五大片区服务中心加临港中心提供一站式政策咨询与材料初核。

北京:场景化、字段级先锋

北京自贸试验区负面清单(2024年8月)为首个场景化、字段级清单,提出13大类41子类参考规则,并列举汽车、医药、民航、零售与现代服务业、人工智能训练数据5个行业48类数据的出境合规措施。其增设省级预审核、预评估机制,并建立覆盖5个行业100余家企业的绿色通道服务。

合规红利

负面清单模式将数据出境合规从”全国猜谜”转变为”本地、字段级作答”。对外资企业而言,三重收益突出:其一,确定性——数据集一旦被归入清单外,评估/合同/认证申报即告免除;其二,速度——上海”先用后报”免除了清单内常规流程的事前审批等待;其三,成本——放宽后的阈值(如天津、上海上调敏感个人信息触发线)大幅减少申报量。代价是地域性:清单以自贸区为界,区外实体无法依赖,须回退至《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》的全国统一阈值。因此,跨国企业应将自贸区选址视为数据治理变量,而非仅关乎税收或物流。

外商投资企业实务步骤

  1. 定位所在自贸区与清单。 确定实体所属自贸区(天津、上海/临港、北京或参照它们的其他区),调取适用负面清单。
  2. 将数据映射到场景与字段。 利用”场景前置、字段级”结构,将每个出境数据集归类为清单内或清单外。
  3. 主张自由流动豁免。 对清单外数据,留存依据并免予评估/合同/认证申报即可出境。
  4. 使用一站式中心。 在规定时限内提交材料,借助初核降低风险。
  5. 关注互认与扩围。 上海等地可参照执行其他自贸区清单;密切跟踪本行业第二批清单。

延伸阅读

负面清单是中国数据出境”三轨”(安全评估、标准合同、认证)中的一条快捷通道。外资企业应将自贸区清单与《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》中的全国统一阈值及数据安全、个人信息保护一般规则一并研读。

Sources

  • 国家互联网信息办公室令第16号:《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(2024-03-22)— https://big5.www.gov.cn/gate/big5/www.gov.cn/gongbao/2024/issue_11366/202405/content_6954192.html
  • 天津自贸试验区数据出境管理清单(负面清单)(2024版)— https://big5.www.gov.cn/gate/big5/www.gov.cn/lianbo/difang/202405/content_6950083.htm
  • 中国(上海)自由贸易试验区及临港新片区数据出境管理清单(负面清单)(2024版)答记者问(临港新片区管委会)— https://www.lingang.gov.cn/upload/1/cms/content/editor/ac2a296d-70a3-47fc-9008-fe5d887eaf73.pdf

China’s Data Export Security Assessment Route (2026): a Field Guide for Foreign-Invested Enterprises

  • The security assessment is the highest-threshold of China’s three data-export routes and is mandatory when a Critical Information Infrastructure Operator (CIIO) exports personal information, or when any processor exports important data or large volumes of personal information.
    安全评估是中国数据出境三条通道中门槛最高的一条,当关键信息基础设施运营者(CIIO)出境个人信息,或任何处理者出境重要数据、或大规模出境个人信息时,必须申报安全评估。
  • The statutory triggers are: CIIO exporting PI; any exporter of important data; exporters of over 1 million individuals’ personal information; and those who since 1 January of the current year have cumulatively exported over 100,000 individuals’ PI or over 10,000 individuals’ sensitive PI.
    法定触发情形为:关键信息基础设施运营者出境个人信息;任何重要数据出境方;累计出境个人信息超过 100 万人的处理者;以及自当年 1 月 1 日起累计出境个人信息超过 10 万人或敏感个人信息超过 1 万人的处理者。
  • The 2024 Provisions exempt a long tail of low-risk flows — notably general cross-border HR management, contract-performance necessity, and sub-100k non-sensitive PI — so many FIEs fall outside the assessment entirely.
    2024 年《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》豁免了大量低风险出境情形——尤其是常规跨境人力资源管理、履行合同必需,以及 10 万人以下的非敏感个人信息出境,因此许多外资企业实际上不落入安全评估范围。
  • The assessment runs through a provincial网信 office to the national CAC, with a 7-working-day acceptance decision, a 45-working-day review (extendable), a 2-year validity, and a built-in renewal path introduced by the 2024 rules.
    评估由省级网信部门报送国家网信部门,7 个工作日内决定是否受理,45 个工作日内完成评估(可延长),结果有效期 2 年,2024 年规定新增了有效期延长申请机制。
  • FIEs should map their data, identify whether they are a CIIO or a large-volume exporter, and use the third-edition filing guide (2025) and the online system at sjcj.cac.gov.cn to prepare materials before submitting.
    外资企业应先梳理数据资产、判断是否构成 CIIO 或大规模出境方,并依据 2025 年第三版申报指南与”数据出境申报系统”(sjcj.cac.gov.cn)提前备齐材料再申报。
  • The 2026 stabilising-foreign-investment action plan explicitly supports FTZs and service-opening pilot cities in exploring scenario-based, field-level data-export negative lists, which can further narrow what needs assessment.
    2026 年《利用外资固稳促优行动方案》明确支持自贸试验区和服务业扩大开放试点城市探索场景化、字段级数据出境负面清单,可进一步收窄需评估的范围。

China’s Data Export Security Assessment Route (2026): a Field Guide for Foreign-Invested Enterprises | 中国数据出境安全评估通道(2026):外资企业实操指南

Which route, and why this one

China regulates outbound transfer of data through three parallel mechanisms established under the PIPL, the Data Security Law and the Cybersecurity Law: security assessment (administrative review), the standard contract (filed), and certification (third-party). This article focuses on the first and highest-threshold mechanism — the security assessment administered by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) — because it is the one foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) most often ask about and most often mis-classify. If your group exports only limited employee or customer data, the standard contract (covered separately) or certification may apply instead; but if you are a CIIO, export important data, or move large volumes of personal information, security assessment is mandatory.

The legal stack

The assessment rests on a layered rule set:

  • The Data Export Security Assessment Measures (CAC Decree No. 11, effective 1 September 2022) set the thresholds, procedures and the two-year validity.
  • The Provisions on Promoting and Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows (CAC Decree No. 16, effective 22 March 2024) relaxed thresholds, created broad exemptions, and introduced the FTZ negative-list system and a renewal path for assessment results.
  • The third-edition Filing Guide for Data Export Security Assessment (released 27 June 2025) simplified and optimised the materials required, and clarified how to apply to extend a valid result.

Together these three instruments define who must file, what to submit, and how long a cleared pathway stays valid.

Who must apply — the triggers

A processor must apply for a security assessment when any of the following applies:

  1. A Critical Information Infrastructure Operator (CIIO) exports personal information.
  2. The processor exports important data.
  3. The processor exports personal information of more than 1,000,000 individuals.
  4. Since 1 January of the current year, the processor has cumulatively exported personal information of more than 100,000 individuals, or sensitive personal information of more than 10,000 individuals.

Items 3 and 4 are the ones that catch multinational groups: a sizeable e-commerce, automotive, healthcare or education business can cross the 100,000-person line in a single year through CRM, loyalty, telematics or learning records.

What the 2024 Provisions took out of scope

Just as important as the triggers is what the 2024 Provisions exempt. The following outbound flows do not require assessment, standard contract or certification:

  • Data generated in international trade, cross-border transport, academic cooperation, multinational manufacturing or marketing that contains no personal information or important data.
  • Personal information collected overseas, processed in China, and returned overseas without introducing domestic PI or important data.
  • Data needed to conclude or perform a contract to which the individual is a party (cross-border shopping, shipping, remittance, payment, account opening, ticketing, visa, exam services).
  • Cross-border human-resources management carried out under lawfully formulated labour rules and collective contracts.
  • Emergency protection of life, health or property.
  • Non-CIIO processors exporting fewer than 100,000 individuals’ non-sensitive PI in a year.

For many FIEs, a careful mapping shows the bulk of routine flows fall into these exemptions, leaving only the high-volume or important-data streams for assessment.

The FTZ negative-list carve-out

Under the 2024 Provisions, a Free Trade Zone may, within the national data classification and grading framework, draw up its own negative list of data that still requires assessment, standard contract or certification. Once the list is approved by the provincial cyberspace affairs commission and filed with the national CAC and data authority, data outside that list may be exported from within the FTZ without any of the three mechanisms. The 2026 stabilising-foreign-investment action plan encourages FTZs and service-opening pilot cities to expand scenario-based, field-level negative lists, so the practical carve-out is widening.

The procedure, step by step

  1. Self-assessment. Before filing, the processor must perform and document a data-export risk self-assessment covering purpose, scope and necessity; the scale, type and sensitivity of the data; the overseas recipient’s safeguards; post-transfer risks; and the contractual protections agreed with the recipient.
  2. File with the provincial office. Submit the application, the self-assessment report, the legal document with the overseas recipient, and supporting materials to the provincial cyberspace administration, which checks completeness within 5 working days and forwards a complete package to the national CAC.
  3. Acceptance. CAC decides whether to accept within 7 working days of receiving a complete package.
  4. Review. CAC organises the assessment within 45 working days (extendable for complexity or supplementary materials). It weighs national-security and public-interest risk, the recipient country’s legal environment, the volume and sensitivity of data, and the adequacy of safeguards.
  5. Result and validity. The written result is valid for 2 years from issuance. The 2024 Provisions added an explicit path to apply to extend validity before expiry when business continues. Major changes to purpose, scope, type, recipient or legal environment require re-assessment.

Practical steps for an FIE

  • Inventory and classify. Build a data map: what you hold, where it came from, who receives it overseas, and whether any of it is “important data” (note: absent a published important-data catalogue for your sector, you are generally not presumed to hold it).
  • Test against thresholds. Tally personal-information subjects per calendar year and flag any CIIO status (often determined by your industry regulator).
  • Prefer exemptions. Route routine HR, contract-performance and sub-threshold flows through the exemptions so they never enter the assessment pipeline.
  • Prepare the legal instrument. The contract or binding document with the recipient must spell out purpose, scope, storage period, re-transfer limits, security measures and breach remedies.
  • Use the online system. File and track through the national data-export system at sjcj.cac.gov.cn, and follow the third-edition guide’s material checklist.
  • Plan for renewal. Set a calendar reminder well before the two-year expiry if the export continues.

Boundaries to keep in mind

Security assessment is not a fast-track; build 2–3 months of lead time. The result is tied to the specific data scope and recipient described — a new use case or a material change in the recipient’s control triggers re-assessment. And the three routes are alternatives, not cumulative: pick the one your facts require rather than layering them.

See also our articles on the standard contract route, the personal-information export certification route, and field-level data-export negative lists.


中国数据出境安全评估通道(2026):外资企业实操指南

选哪条通道,为什么是这一条

中国依据《个人信息保护法》《数据安全法》《网络安全法》,建立了三条并行的数据出境机制:安全评估(行政审批)、标准合同(备案)与个人信息保护认证(第三方认证)。本文聚焦门槛最高、也是外资企业最常咨询却又最易误判的第一条——由国家网信办(CAC)实施的数据出境安全评估。若贵集团仅出境少量员工或客户数据,标准合同(另有专文)或认证可能更适用;但若属于关键信息基础设施运营者(CIIO)、出境重要数据或大规模出境个人信息,则安全评估为强制性要求。

规则体系

安全评估建立在分层规则之上:

  • 《数据出境安全评估办法》(国家网信办令第 11 号,2022 年 9 月 1 日施行)划定了触发阈值、申报程序与 2 年有效期。
  • 《促进和规范数据跨境流动规定》(国家网信办令第 16 号,2024 年 3 月 22 日施行)下调了阈值、创设了广泛的豁免,并引入自贸试验区负面清单制度与评估结果延长机制。
  • 《数据出境安全评估申报指南(第三版)》(2025 年 6 月 27 日发布)优化简化了申报材料,并明确了如何申请延长有效评估结果。

这三部规则共同界定了”谁必须申报、申报什么、 cleared 路径维持多久”。

谁必须申报——触发情形

处理者在任一下列情形出现时,必须申报安全评估:

  1. 关键信息基础设施运营者(CIIO)出境个人信息。
  2. 处理者出境重要数据。
  3. 处理者出境个人信息超过 100 万人。
  4. 自当年 1 月 1 日起,累计出境个人信息超过 10 万人,或敏感个人信息超过 1 万人。

其中第 3、4 项最易”踩线”:一家颇具规模的电商、汽车、医疗或教育企业,仅凭 CRM、会员体系、车联网或学习记录,一年内就可能突破 10 万人的门槛。

2024 年规定划出的豁免范围

与触发情形同样重要的是 2024 年规定的豁免清单。下列出境活动无需申报评估、订立标准合同或通过认证:

  • 国际贸易、跨境运输、学术合作、跨国生产制造和营销中收集和产生、不含个人信息或重要数据的数据出境。
  • 境外收集产生的个人信息传至境内处理后向境外提供,且处理过程未引入境内个人信息或重要数据。
  • 为订立、履行个人作为一方当事人的合同所必需(跨境购物、寄递、汇款、支付、开户、票务、签证、考试等)。
  • 依照依法制定的劳动规章制度和集体合同实施的跨境人力资源管理。
  • 紧急情况下为保护自然人生命健康和财产安全所必需。
  • 非 CIIO 处理者一年内累计出境不满 10 万人非敏感个人信息。

对许多外资企业而言,经仔细梳理后,多数常规出境流都落入这些豁免,只有高体量与重要数据流需要走评估。

自贸试验区负面清单的”切口”

依 2024 年规定,自由贸易试验区可在国家数据分类分级保护框架下,自行制定区内仍需纳入评估、标准合同或认证管理的数据清单(负面清单)。清单经省级网信委批准并报国家网信部门、数据管理部门备案后,清单之外的数据在区内出境即可免予三种机制。2026 年《利用外资固稳促优行动方案》鼓励自贸试验区与服务业扩大开放试点城市扩大场景化、字段级负面清单,因此这一实际”切口”正在拓宽。

程序分步

  1. 风险自评估。 申报前,处理者须开展并记录数据出境风险自评估,涵盖目的、范围与必要性;数据规模、类型与敏感程度;境外接收方保障能力;出境后风险;以及与接收方法律文件中的保护约定。
  2. 向省级网信部门申报。 提交申报书、自评估报告、与境外接收方的法律文件及支撑材料;省级网信部门 5 个工作日内完成完备性查验,材料齐全则报送国家网信部门。
  3. 受理。 国家网信部门收到齐全材料后 7 个工作日内决定是否受理。
  4. 评估。 国家网信部门在 45 个工作日内组织评估(情况复杂或需补正的,可延长),综合研判国家安全与公共利益风险、接收方所在国法律环境、数据规模与敏感程度及保障措施充分性。
  5. 结果及有效期。 书面结果自出具之日起有效期 2 年。2024 年规定新增了有效期届满前申请延长的明确路径;若目的、范围、类型、接收方或法律环境发生重大变化,须重新申报。

外资企业的实操要点

  • 盘点与分类。 建立数据地图:持有何种数据、来源、境外接收方是谁、是否构成”重要数据”(注意:在所属行业未公布重要数据目录前,一般不推定持有)。
  • 对照阈值。 按自然年统计个人信息主体数量,并确认是否具 CIIO 身份(通常由行业主管部门认定)。
  • 优先适用豁免。 将常规人力资源、合同履行及阈值以下流通过豁免处理,使其不进入评估管道。
  • 备好法律文件。 与接收方的合同或具有法律效力的文件须明确目的、范围、保存期限、再转移限制、安全措施与违约救济。
  • 走线上系统。 通过国家数据出境系统 sjcj.cac.gov.cn 申报与跟踪,并按第三版指南的材料清单准备。
  • 规划续期。 若出境业务持续,务必在 2 年届满前提前设置提醒,申请延长。

须把握的边界

安全评估并非快速通道,应预留 2–3 个月前置时间。结果绑定于所申报的数据范围与接收方——新的使用场景或接收方控制权重大变化将触发重新评估。三条通道是”择一适用”而非叠加:按事实选择所需通道,而非层层叠加。

相关阅读可参见本站的”标准合同出境””个人信息出境认证”与”字段级数据出境负面清单”等文章。

Sources

Cross-Border Transfer of Personal Information via the China Standard Contract: Thresholds, Filing and Model Clauses

  • The standard contract is the second of PIPL’s three export routes: sign with the overseas recipient, then file with the provincial cyberspace administration.
    标准合同是《个保法》三条出境路径中的第二条:与境外接收方签约,再向省级网信部门备案。
  • Eligibility is fixed by volume bands: non-CIIO, 100k–under 1m non-sensitive or under 10k sensitive individuals, and no important data.
    适用以数量区间为界:非CIIO、10万至不满100万人非敏感或不满1万人敏感个人信息,且不含重要数据。
  • Splitting volumes to dodge the security assessment is expressly prohibited and is judged at group level.
    明令禁止以数量拆分规避安全评估,且按集团合并口径认定。
  • Separate consent and a five-point PIPIA are mandatory prerequisites before the contract takes effect.
    合同生效前须取得单独同意并完成涵盖五项重点的个人信息保护影响评估。
  • Filing is within 10 working days of the contract taking effect, with the PIPIA report and a cross-border description attached.
    备案须在合同生效之日起10个工作日内完成,附影响评估报告与出境说明。
  • The contract runs for its term and lapses if the handler no longer meets the bands or the data drift outside scope.
    合同随期限有效,若处理者不再符合区间或数据超出范围即失效。

Cross-Border Transfer of Personal Information via the China Standard Contract: Thresholds, Filing and Model Clauses | 通过标准合同出境个人信息:阈值、备案与合同范本实务

The Second Route and Where It Sits

Article 38 of the Personal Information Protection Law (PIPL) sets out three lawful routes to export personal information: (1) a security assessment organised by the national cyberspace administration (CAC); (2) personal information protection certification; and (3) concluding and filing a standard contract with the overseas recipient. The *Measures for the Standard Contract for Outbound Provision of Personal Information* (CAC Order No. 13, effective 1 June 2023) operationalise route (3). The standard contract is the lightest of the three in terms of upfront gatekeeping—no CAC declaration, no accredited body—but it is available only within tight volume bands and still demands a real compliance file.

Who Qualifies: the Volume Bands

A handler may use the standard contract only if all of the following hold at once:

  • it is not a critical information infrastructure operator (CIIO);
  • counting cumulatively from 1 January of the current year, it provides abroad the personal information of 100,000 or more but fewer than 1,000,000 individuals, excluding sensitive personal information, or the sensitive personal information of fewer than 10,000 individuals;
  • the exported personal information does not include important data.

The count resets each 1 January. A fast-growing platform, SaaS or e-commerce business can fall out of the band mid-year, at which point the security assessment route becomes mandatory.

The Anti-Splitting Rule

Handlers may not use quantity-splitting or similar devices to route, via the standard contract, personal information that should lawfully undergo a security assessment. A group with several China entities feeding one overseas parent should assume the aggregate flow is what the regulator counts. Structuring entities or contracts to stay “just under” a threshold is precisely the conduct the rule targets.

Before You Sign: Consent and the Five-Point PIPIA

Before the standard contract takes effect, the handler must have given the statutory notification, obtained separate consent from the individuals, and carried out a personal information protection impact assessment (PIPIA) examining:

  1. Whether the handler’s and recipient’s processing purposes, scope and methods are lawful, legitimate and necessary.
  2. The scale, scope, type and sensitivity of the exported information and the risks to national security, the public interest and individual rights.
  3. Whether the obligations the recipient undertakes and its management and technical measures can safeguard security.
  4. The risk of the information being altered, destroyed, leaked, lost or unlawfully used after export, and whether rights-upholding channels remain open.
  5. The effect of the recipient’s country or region’s personal-information policies and laws on security and individual rights.

The PIPIA report must be kept for at least three years.

Filing: Timing and Materials

The standard contract must follow the annexed model strictly; the parties may add terms that do not conflict with it. The contract takes effect before any export begins. Within 10 working days of the contract taking effect, the handler files with the provincial cyberspace administration where it is located, submitting: (1) the signed standard contract; (2) the PIPIA report; and (3) a description of the outbound provision. The CAC’s filing guide (first edition) sets out the method, process and materials in detail. Where circumstances change—new recipient, new purpose, new sensitive categories—the handler must re-run the PIPIA, supplement or re-execute the contract, and re-file.

What the Model Clauses Actually Require

The annexed model allocates obligations: the handler must inform individuals of the recipient’s name, contacts, purposes, types of personal information, methods, individual rights and the complaint channel; the overseas recipient must perform the contract, accept individual rights requests, and cooperate with supervision. It also fixes the governing-law and dispute-resolution expectations and includes appendices—a description of the outbound provision and any separately agreed terms. The contract is the evidentiary core of the route: if the file is thin, the export is exposed even when the volume band is satisfied.

Standard Contract Against the Other Two Routes

RouteTriggerGatekeeping stepValidityUsers
Security assessmentCIIO exports, important data, or volumes above the bandCAC declaration and assessmentPer that regimeAny handler triggering it
CertificationNon-CIIO; 100k–<1m non-sensitive or <10k sensitive; no important dataAccredited body audit plus supervision3 yearsVoluntary, non-CIIO
Standard contractSame bands as certificationContract signed, filed with provincial CACContract termNon-CIIO

Practical Steps for a Foreign-Invested Enterprise

  1. Count first, tracking cumulative exports from 1 January and separating sensitive from non-sensitive data.
  2. Rule out important data and CIIO status before assuming the contract is available.
  3. Consolidate group flows; the anti-splitting rule bites at group level.
  4. Fix the consent stack and run the PIPIA against the five points, especially the recipient jurisdiction’s legal regime.
  5. Sign, then file within 10 working days, keeping the PIPIA report for three years and re-filing on material change.

Related Reading

See our PIPL cross-border transfer overview (No. 35), the field-level data export negative list (No. 57) and the third route—PI export certification (No. 174).


通过标准合同出境个人信息:阈值、备案与合同范本实务

第二条路径及其定位

《个人信息保护法》第三十八条列出三条合法出境路径:(1)国家网信部门组织的出境安全评估;(2)个人信息保护认证;(3)与境外接收方订立标准合同并备案。《个人信息出境标准合同办法》(国家网信办令第13号,2023年6月1日施行)落地第(3)项。标准合同是三条路径中事前门槛最轻的——无需向网信部门申报评估,也无需有资质机构——但仅在严格数量区间内可用,且仍须具备真实合规档案。

适用条件:数量区间

处理者使用标准合同须同时满足以下全部条件:

  • 属于非关键信息基础设施运营者(非CIIO);
  • 自当年1月1日起累计向境外提供10万人以上、不满100万人个人信息(不含敏感个人信息),或者不满1万人敏感个人信息;
  • 出境个人信息不包括重要数据。

累计数每年1月1日重新起算。快速增长的平台、SaaS或电商业务可能年中越出区间,届时须改走安全评估路径。

反规避条款

处理者不得采取数量拆分等手段,将依法应当通过出境安全评估的个人信息经标准合同出境。多家中国主体向同一境外母公司回传数据的集团,应默认监管看合并总量。为”压线”而拆分主体或合同,正是该条款所针对的行为。

签约前:同意与五项重点影响评估

标准合同生效前,处理者必须已依法履行告知义务、取得个人单独同意,并开展个人信息保护影响评估(PIPIA),重点评估:

  1. 处理者与境外接收方处理目的、范围、方式的合法性、正当性、必要性;
  2. 出境信息的规模、范围、种类、敏感程度及其对国家安全、公共利益、个人信息权益的风险;
  3. 境外接收方承诺承担的义务及其管理和技术措施能否保障安全;
  4. 出境后信息遭篡改、破坏、泄露、丢失、非法利用的风险,以及权益维护渠道是否通畅;
  5. 境外接收方所在国家或地区个人信息保护政策法规对安全与权益的影响。

影响评估报告须至少保存三年。

备案:时限与材料

标准合同须严格按附件范本订立,双方可约定不与范本冲突的其他条款。合同生效后方可开展出境。合同生效之日起10个工作日内,处理者向所在地省级网信部门备案,提交:(1)已签署的标准合同;(2)影响评估报告;(3)出境说明。网信办《备案指南(第一版)》对方式、流程与材料作出具体说明。情形变更——新接收方、新目的、新增敏感类别——须重新评估、补充或重订合同并重新备案。

范本条款究竟要求什么

附件范本分配了双方义务:处理者须告知个人接收方名称、联系方式、目的、个人信息种类、方式、个人权利及投诉渠道;境外接收方须履行合同、响应个人权利请求并配合监管。范本还约定了准据法与争议解决预期,并含两份附录——出境说明与另行约定条款。合同是本条路径的证据核心:即便数量区间满足,档案单薄仍会使出境暴露风险。

标准合同与另两条路径对比

路径触发阈值主管环节有效期适用主体
出境安全评估CIIO出境、含重要数据或超出合同区间向网信部门申报评估依该制度触发任一条件者
个人信息保护认证非CIIO;10万至不满100万人非敏感或不满1万人敏感;不含重要数据有资质机构认证并持续监督3年自愿的非CIIO
标准合同备案与认证相同区间签约并向省级网信部门备案合同期限非CIIO

外资企业的实操步骤

  1. 先做计数:自1月1日起跟踪累计出境量,区分敏感与非敏感数据。
  2. 先排除重要数据与CIIO身份,再判断标准合同是否可用。
  3. 合并集团数据流,反规避条款在集团层面生效。
  4. 修好同意链路并开展影响评估,尤其是接收方所在法域的法律制度评估。
  5. 签约后10个工作日内备案,影响评估报告保存三年,重大变更重新备案。

延伸阅读

可参阅本站PIPL跨境传输总览(编号35)、字段级数据出境负面清单(编号57)与第三条路径——个人信息出境认证(编号174)。

Sources

China’s Personal Information Export Certification: The Third Route Opens on 1 January 2026

  • China’s third data-export route opened on 1 January 2026 under CAC and SAMR Order No. 20.
    第20号令使个人信息保护认证成为可用通道,2026年1月1日起施行。
  • Eligibility is narrow: non-CIIO handlers, 100,000 to under 1m individuals’ non-sensitive data or under 10,000 individuals’ sensitive data, and no important data.
    适用面窄:非CIIO主体,10万至不满100万人非敏感或不满1万人敏感个人信息,且不含重要数据。
  • Splitting volumes to dodge the security assessment is expressly prohibited.
    明令禁止以数量拆分等手段规避应当进行的出境安全评估。
  • Notification, separate consent and a five-point impact assessment must be completed before applying.
    申请前须完成告知、取得单独同意,并开展涵盖五项法定重点的个人信息保护影响评估。
  • Certificates run three years and may be suspended or revoked if exports drift outside the certified scope.
    证书有效期三年;出境情况与认证范围不一致的,可被暂停直至撤销。
  • The route is voluntary and market-based: an extra compliance option, not a new obligation.
    该路径自愿、市场化,是增加的合规选择而非新增义务。

China’s Personal Information Export Certification: The Third Route Opens on 1 January 2026 | 个人信息出境认证办法:2026年1月1日起启用的第三条数据出境通道

Three Routes Out, and What Order No. 20 Changes

Article 38(1) of the Personal Information Protection Law (PIPL) gives three lawful export routes: (1) a security assessment organised by the national cyberspace administration (CAC); (2) personal information protection certification; and (3) concluding and filing the standard contract with the overseas recipient. Route (2) long existed mainly at the level of the rule — no accredited bodies, no clear criteria — so it was almost never used. The *Measures for Personal Information Export Certification*, Order No. 20 of the CAC and the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR), promulgated on 14 October 2025 and effective 1 January 2026, change that. Drawing on the PIPL, the Regulations on Network Data Security Management and the Regulations on Certification and Accreditation, they supply the missing institutions, thresholds, application path, certificate and supervision cycle.

Who Qualifies: Eligibility and Volume Bands

A handler must satisfy all of the following at once:

  • it is not a critical information infrastructure operator (CIIO);
  • counting cumulatively from 1 January of the current year, it has provided abroad the personal information of 100,000 or more but fewer than 1,000,000 individuals, excluding sensitive personal information, or the sensitive personal information of fewer than 10,000 individuals;
  • the exported personal information does not include important data.

The count resets each 1 January, so a fast-growing business can exit the band mid-year; watch the running total.

The Anti-Splitting Rule

Handlers may not use quantity-splitting or similar devices to route through certification personal information that should lawfully undergo the security assessment. Groups with several Chinese entities feeding one overseas parent should assume the aggregate flow is what counts.

Before You Apply: Consent and the Five-Point PIPIA

Before filing, the handler must have given the statutory notification, obtained separate consent, and carried out a personal information protection impact assessment (PIPIA), which must examine:

  1. Whether the handler’s and the recipient’s processing purposes, scope and methods are lawful, legitimate and necessary.
  2. The scale, scope, type and sensitivity of the exported information and the risks to national security, the public interest and individual rights.
  3. Whether the obligations the recipient undertakes to bear, and its management and technical measures and capabilities, can safeguard security.
  4. The risk of the information being altered, destroyed, leaked, lost or unlawfully used after export, and whether channels for upholding individual rights remain unobstructed.
  5. The effect of the personal information protection policies and laws of the recipient’s country or region on information security and individual rights.

Who Certifies, and What the Certificate Is Worth

Certification is carried out by professional certification bodies holding personal information protection certification accreditation, applying the certification basic norms and the certification rules. A certificate is valid for three years and must be reported to the National Certification and Accreditation Information Public Service Platform. Supervision continues: where exports are inconsistent with the certified scope, or the handler no longer meets the requirements, the body must suspend the certificate until revocation; where exports breach the law, it must report promptly to the CAC and other competent authorities.

Who Regulates Whom

The CAC, with the national data administration and other departments, sets the standards and technical specifications. The market regulation department, with the CAC, sets the certification rules and the unified certificate and mark. A body must file with the CAC within 10 working days of accreditation. Departments at provincial level or above may summon a certified handler whose exports present significant risk or that suffers a personal information security incident.

Certification Against the Other Two Routes

RouteTriggerGatekeeping stepValidityUsers
Security assessmentCIIO exports, important data, or volumes above the bandCAC declaration and assessmentPer that regimeAny handler triggering it
CertificationNon-CIIO; 100k–<1m non-sensitive or <10k sensitive; no important dataAccredited body audit plus supervision3 yearsVoluntary, non-CIIO
Standard contractSame bands as certificationContract signed, filed with provincial CACContract termNon-CIIO

Tsinghua law professor Shen Weixing explains why a private audit can be a lawful basis: certification packages the required safeguards as third-party review, continuing supervision, and remedies enforceable by data subjects. Wang Zhicheng of the CAC’s Data and Technology Support Centre notes the voluntary, market-based design lightens regulators’ load and widens compliance choices; Ding Xiaodong of Renmin University’s Law School sees the Measures as completing China’s export system. (Expert views.)

The Wider 2026 Data-Flow Liberalisation

The *Action Plan for Stabilising and Optimising the Use of Foreign Investment* (Shang Zi Fa [2026] No. 97), issued by MOFCOM, the NDRC and the Ministry of Finance on 16 June 2026, supports free trade zones and services-opening pilot cities in exploring scenario-based, field-level data export negative lists, and pushes for national standards for important-data identification catalogues in industry, telecommunications, geographic information, automotive, pharmaceuticals, seed industry, aerospace and civil aviation. Beijing and Guangdong have already issued FTZ negative lists through joint three-department notices.

Practical Steps for a Foreign-Invested Enterprise

  1. Count first, tracking cumulative exports from 1 January and separating sensitive from non-sensitive data.
  2. Rule out important data and CIIO status before assuming certification is available.
  3. Consolidate group flows; the anti-splitting rule bites at group level.
  4. Fix the consent stack and run the PIPIA against the five points, especially the recipient jurisdiction’s legal regime.
  5. Select an accredited body, verify its CAC filing, and monitor scope drift.

Related Reading

See our PIPL cross-border transfer overview and our field-level data export negative list article.


个人信息出境认证办法:2026年1月1日起启用的第三条数据出境通道

三条出境通道与第20号令的改变

《个人信息保护法》第三十八条第一款规定三条合法出境路径:(1)国家网信部门组织的出境安全评估;(2)个人信息保护认证;(3)与境外接收方按标准合同签约并备案。第(2)项长期停留在规定层面——机构资质稀缺、细则不明,企业极少采用。《个人信息出境认证办法》由国家互联网信息办公室、国家市场监督管理总局以第20号令于2025年10月14日公布,自2026年1月1日起施行,上位法为《个人信息保护法》《网络数据安全管理条例》《认证认可条例》,补齐了机构、门槛、申请路径、证书与持续监督等缺失环节。

适用条件与数量区间

处理者须同时满足以下全部条件:

  • 属于非关键信息基础设施运营者(非CIIO);
  • 自当年1月1日起累计向境外提供10万人以上、不满100万人个人信息(不含敏感个人信息),或者不满1万人敏感个人信息;
  • 出境个人信息不包括重要数据。

累计数每年1月1日重新起算,快速增长的电商或SaaS业务可能年中越出区间,应盯住滚动累计值。

反规避条款

处理者不得采取数量拆分等手段,将依法应当通过出境安全评估的个人信息通过认证方式出境。多家中国主体向同一境外母公司回传数据的集团,应默认监管看合并总量。

申请前:同意与五项重点影响评估

申请前,处理者必须已依法履行告知义务、取得单独同意,并开展个人信息保护影响评估(PIPIA),重点评估:

  1. 处理者与境外接收方处理个人信息的目的、范围、方式的合法性、正当性、必要性;
  2. 出境个人信息的规模、范围、种类、敏感程度,及其对国家安全、公共利益、个人信息权益的风险;
  3. 境外接收方承诺承担的义务及其管理和技术措施、能力能否保障安全;
  4. 个人信息出境后遭篡改、破坏、泄露、丢失、非法利用的风险,以及权益维护渠道是否通畅;
  5. 境外接收方所在国家或地区的个人信息保护政策法规对出境信息安全与个人权益的影响。

由谁认证,证书意味着什么

认证由依法取得个人信息保护认证资质的专业认证机构实施,依据认证基本规范、个人信息保护认证规则开展。证书有效期3年,机构应向全国认证认可信息公共服务平台报送证书信息。监督持续:获证处理者出境情况与认证范围不一致或不再符合认证要求的,机构应暂停其使用直至撤销证书;出境活动违反法律法规的,应及时向国家网信部门和有关部门报告。

监管架构

国家网信部门会同国家数据管理部门等制定认证相关标准、技术规范;国家市场监督管理部门会同国家网信部门制定个人信息保护认证规则、统一认证证书及标志。专业认证机构自取得资质之日起10个工作日内向国家网信部门备案。省级以上网信部门等发现获证处理者出境活动存在较大风险或发生个人信息安全事件的,可依法约谈。

三条路径对比

路径触发阈值主管环节有效期适用主体
出境安全评估CIIO出境、含重要数据或超出认证区间向网信部门申报评估依该制度触发任一条件者
个人信息保护认证非CIIO;10万至不满100万人非敏感或不满1万人敏感;不含重要数据有资质机构认证并持续监督3年自愿的非CIIO
标准合同备案与认证相同区间签约并向省级网信部门备案合同期限非CIIO

清华大学法学院教授申卫星解释第三方审核何以构成合法依据:认证把适当保障具体化为”经第三方审核+持续监督+对数据主体可执行的承诺与救济”。国家网信办数据与技术保障中心副主任王志成指出,自愿性、市场化、社会化服务设计既减轻监管负担,也赋予企业更多合规选择权;中国人民大学法学院副院长丁晓东认为,《办法》标志我国个人信息出境制度体系已构建完成。(专家观点。)

2026年更广的数据流动松绑

商务部、国家发展改革委、财政部《利用外资固稳促优行动方案》(商资发〔2026〕97号,2026年6月16日印发)明确:支持自由贸易试验区、国家服务业扩大开放试点城市探索在更多领域制定场景化、字段级数据出境负面清单,推动制定工业、电信、地理信息、汽车、医药、种业、航天、民航等行业领域重要数据识别目录国家标准。北京、广东已由地方三部门联合印发自贸试验区数据出境负面清单及管理办法。

外资企业的实操步骤

  1. 先做计数:自1月1日起跟踪累计出境量,区分敏感与非敏感数据。
  2. 先排除重要数据与CIIO身份,再判断认证是否可用。
  3. 合并集团数据流,反规避条款在集团层面生效。
  4. 修好同意链路并开展影响评估,尤其是接收方所在法域的法律制度评估。
  5. 选择有资质机构并核验其网信备案,同时监控认证范围漂移。

延伸阅读

可参阅本站PIPL跨境传输总览,以及字段级数据出境负面清单一文。

Sources